StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Ethical and Legal Constructs of a Contract - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The study "Ethical and Legal Constructs of a Contract" focuses on the critical analysis of the major issues in the ethical and legal constructs of a contract. Contract law defines elements of a valid contract and provides for the termination of contracts in various cases…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Ethical and Legal Constructs of a Contract
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethical and Legal Constructs of a Contract"

Pertinent to the case is the determination of whether parties should rescind a contract because of a mutual mistake of fact, ethics in the parties’ actions in the case, provisions of the Uniform Commercial Code on the case, and possible winners or losers in a rescinded contract due to mutual mistake.

The parties should be able to rescind the contract under mediated caution. Rescission of a contract, based on mutual mistake, involves both legal and ethical considerations that should be made in justifying it. A legal approach to the issues identifies termination of a contract under mutual mistake because this makes a contract void per se. Such positions have been held in judicial decisions such as in the case of Bell v Lever in which an agreement to terminate employees under compensation was rescinded because the employees had, at the time of the agreement, breached their contract and neither party was informed of the breach (Wishart, 247). The breach established a mutual mistake in the employment condition. Equitable doctrines of equal treatment under the law therefore imply that contracts made under mutual mistakes are void and the parties should be allowed to rescind such contracts (Miller and Cross, 15). Ethical considerations however limit such discretionary right to rescind a contract because of mutual mistake. Utilitarianism doctrine, from Halbert and Ingulli’s perspective of business law and ethics, requires the evaluation of consequences and decisions that maximizes the good of all involved stakeholders in a case (14). The parties should therefore be allowed to rescind a contract under fair terms, because of mutual mistake, on equitable terms that minimize potential loss to each party.

Neither party acted unethically in the case. The scope of the contract, sale of a good contract, provides for obligations and rights after the formation of a contract and the seller did not incur such expenses as purchase cost for demand because the subject matter never existed. Josh’s decision to rescind the contract would therefore present no adverse consequences to the seller but instead relieve the seller of the burden of honouring the contract. Similarly, the sellers’ decision to rescind the contract would facilitate Josh’s economic interest in fuel conservation. Deontology ethics also justify the party's actions because a mutual mistake on the subject matter made the contract void and therefore relieved both parties of any rules and obligations that would compromise deontological morality (Halbert and Ingulli, 14- 17).

The Uniform Commercial Code is silent on the case, as it does not define rescission. Cosson and Mazeaud explain that rescission, under the Code, is only derivable from its related terms such as termination (373). Provisions of the code on rescission are also limited to “misrepresentation and fraud” and do not guide cases of rescission under a mutual mistake of facts (Rossman and Moskin, 9-114).

No party, based on the context of contract law, is a loser or a winner when a contract is rescinded because of a mutual mistake. This is because of the legal definition of rescission that involves legal rights and obligations to a case. Rescission restores involved parties to their original position before the contract with its core provision that all transferred benefits are returned and all established rights and obligations are cancelled. Complete reversal of rights and obligations was held in the case of Car and Universal Finance Co v Caldwell (1965) and on the doctrine of applicability to all forms of mistakes. The courts held that a rescission of the contract reversed the title of sold commodity, a car in the case, and no further rights or obligations existed (Wishart, 230). There may however be winners and losers beyond the context of contract law because the law does not recognize some losses. Personal initiatives towards completion of a subject contract may for example not be considered under provisions for restitution to identify non-legal financial loss.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Contract law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1482543-contract-law
(Contract Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1482543-contract-law.
“Contract Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1482543-contract-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical and Legal Constructs of a Contract

Sheila Mason & Craig Shepherd

Since there is so much illegal business activity going on a contract agreement means nothing.... It is reasonable to expect the signing of such a contract.... The contract was signed and dated when Mason and Shepherd started at their companies.... The contract was signed and dated when Mason and Shepherd started at their companies.... By signing the contract the two of them are not able to engage in any unfair trades or similar business while being employed....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Is Downsizing unethical

Insofar as the actions that managers take are in accordance with their moral and legal obligations toward the firm's owners, any decisions resulting from those actions would not necessarily be perceived by them as unethical.... A discussion of the ethics of downsizing that focuses on contractual claims will therefore necessarily rely on psychological and social contract theory rather than a legal analysis.... n short, the fact that many societal (and for that matter, personal) expectations of employers are neither codified into law nor included in a formalized contract is not necessarily fatal...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Legalizing Marijuana: Ethical Considerations

The essay "Legalizing Marijuana: ethical Considerations" discusses how it is ethically irresponsible for society to continue to support the criminalization of drugs, especially in the case of marijuana.... The most important factor in regard to the crime of drug use is that it is a self-abusive crime, the only victim of the commission of this crime being the person using the drug....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Business Law and the Legal Environment

he fact if it is ethical and legal for the people and parties involved to cancel the contracts if they are not generating any significant financial value from the contracts.... This essay "Business Law and the Legal Environment" presents the actions of canceling a contract that can be justified from both the ethical as well as a legal standpoint.... a contract is considered valid if it comprises the four essential elements.... It can be said that a party by following the act utilitarianism concept, can move forward to withdraw the contract....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Employee Motivation, Working Environment and Productivity

The psychological contract is a metaphorical representation of the various factors that help organizations in emphasising and exploring the key issues affecting their employees.... The fundamental objective of a psychological contract is to ensure that the management places more emphasis on the 'people' i.... Hence various organizations include the element of 'psychological contract' as part of their strategic plans in order to help the organizations grow and prosper....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Reduction of People as a Violation of Contract

Insofar as the actions that managers take are following their moral and legal obligations toward the firm's owners, any decisions resulting from those actions would not necessarily be perceived by them as unethical.... The paper 'Reduction of People as a Violation of contract' analyzes that top management makes the strategic decision to downsize, two ethics-related issues arise....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Legal Directions Various Involved Parties Could Have Adopted

econdly, Article 25 of CISG provides that in the event of a breach of a contract from either Super-Cola Taiwan or Dag-Brucken and such becomes detrimental to either party (in this case Super-Cola Taiwan) and when a such breach is not foreseeable, then Dag-Brucken is likely to lose the case.... The author of the "Legal Directions Various Involved Parties Could Have Adopted" paper examines the ethical and legal actions of the two external contractors, broad legal issues contained in within the case study, and legal steps by SCT to avoid project failure....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Analysis of Contract Law Cases

"Analysis of contract Law Cases" paper states that contracting parties must be careful lest they make contracts that are too vague to be enforceable and which do not have specific performance objectives.... One of the legal issues is the uncertainty, vagueness, or ambiguity of contract terms.... According to McKendrick (2012), uncertainty can lead to the severance of ambiguous terms from the contract or the voiding of the whole contract....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us