StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Damages to Bonita and Ben - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Damages to Bonita and Ben" highlights that the employee, Maria, was clearly negligent.  She was on the job at the time of the accident. And, even though she was warned about her specific act prior to her committing the act, this would not defeat liability.  …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.3% of users find it useful
The Damages to Bonita and Ben
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Damages to Bonita and Ben"

?Introduction The relevant facts in this scenario are that Maria works for the New Horizon activity centre; that she knows the protocol regarding employees and trained staff, in that employees are never to work in isolation from trained staff; that she defied this protocol in picking up the children without a trained staff member, as her trained staff member, Katie, was sick that day; that, as the consequence of her defying the order, the children suffered damages from being trapped in the bus for 20 minutes; that the twins, Bonita and Ben, suffered mental damages, but no physical damages; and that Bonita and Ben now require therapy before they can return to the centre. Analysis First, the elements of negligence should be established. They are duty, breach, causation, damages. According to Caparo v. Dickman [1990] UKHL 2, if the harm that occurs is reasonably foreseeable, there is a degree of proximity between the tortfeasor and the victim, and if it would be just, reasonable and fair to impose liability, then the duty prong of the negligence analysis is satisfied. In this case the harm was reasonably foreseeable – Maria could foresee that something could go wrong if she defied orders, in that she might be incapacitated, which would leave the children essentially unattended. This is exactly the harm that happened, so this harm is reasonably foreseeable. Proximity is also established, in that the children were in Maria’s care. Because of this, the third prong is also satisfied, in that it would be just, reasonable and fair to impose liability. Therefore, the duty element is established. The next element of negligence is a breach of the duty. According to Bolton v. Stone [1951] A.C. 850, the injury must be foreseeable, and, if the injury is no foreseeable, there would not be a breach of duty. Also, breach of duty is established by examining whether the tortfeasor acts in the way that a reasonable person would act (Blyth v. Company Proprietors of the Birmingham Water Works (1856) 11 Ex. Ch 781). The injury was definitely foreseeable – there were icy roads that day, therefore the accident was foreseeable. Moreover, since there was only Maria on the bus, it would be foreseeable that she would be incapacitated in the event of an accident, and that the kids, who are disabled, would be traumatized by this. Maria did not act as a reasonable person, as a reasonable person would have obeyed the rules set forth by the New Horizons regarding employees acting only with trained support staff. Therefore, breach is established. Causation is the next element. The court’s typically use the “but-for” test – would the damages have occurred but-for the tortfeasor’s actions? (Barnett v. Kensington & Chelsea NHS Trust [1968] 1 All ER 1068). In this case, the actions of Maria were the cause, because but-for her choosing to drive without supervised help, the damages would not have occurred, because there would have been a trained person to help the children on the bus. Damages are next – do Bonita and Ben have compensable damages? After all, they were physically unhurt, but apparently suffered some type of emotional damage from the incident. In this case, the court would look to the case of Page v. Smith [1995] UKHL 7. In Page, the plaintiff was physically unhurt in a minor traffic accident. However, he suffered other damages, which was that he had myalgic encephalomyelitis, and this disease recurred, although it was previous in remission. The court found that Page was a primary victim, which means that the primary victim must only show that personal injury would have been a foreseeable consequence of the tortfeasor’s actions. If this is established, that the victim was unhurt would not preclude the victim from collecting from some kind of nervous shock or psychiatric injury. Further, another case that establishes that primary victims may recover for nervous shock, if they are in danger of being injured, is Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] 1 AC 310. Therefore, even though the two children were not hurt physically, they may recover damages for their nervous shock. The basic elements of negligence thus established, the next part of the analysis will center upon the liability of the New Horizons, who would be vicariously liable if it is established that there is a master-servant relationship between Maria and them, and if it can be shown that Maria was carrying out her duties as a servant at the time of the negligence (Yewens v. Noakes (1880) 6 QBD 530). Maria was an employee of the Consortium, and she was carrying out her duties, which is driving the bus, at the time of the accident, so the master-servant relationship and vicarious liability are definitively established. However, Maria defied the rules of the New Horizons – New Horizons has a rule that employees must be accompanied by trained staff, and that every employee must sign a document outlining this. Plus, the New Horizons has disciplinary measures for the employees who defy this code of conduct. Might this be enough to defeat liability? Two English cases – Limpus v. London General Omnibus Co. (1862) 1 H&C 526, and Rose v. Plenty [1976] 1 WLR 141 – would indicate that the warning given to the employees would not be enough to defeat liability for the Consortium. In both of these cases, employees were warned about specific conduct, the employee did that conduct anyhow, and injury resulted. In Limpus, the employer warned the employee specifically not to pull in front of a rival omnibus, the employee went ahead and did it, and the employer was liable. In Rose, the employee was specifically warned not to have small children in in milk vans. The employee had a small child help him deliver milk and the child was injured. Therefore, even though the New Horizons have specifically warned employees against the very conduct that Maria engaged in, they would still be liable. Conclusion The Consortium would be liable for the damages to Bonita and Ben. The employee, Maria, was clearly negligent. She was on the job at the time of the accident. And, even though she was warned about her specific act prior to her committing the act, this would not defeat liability. The parents may bring an action for nervous shock, and, since the kids were the primary victims, as opposed to secondary victims, in that they were actually in the accident, the parents will probably be successful in their suit. Sources Used Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] 1 AC 310 Caparo v. Dickman [1990] UKHL 2 Bolton v. Stone [1951] A.C. 850 Blyth v. Company Proprietors of the Birmingham Water Works (1856) 11 Ex. Ch 781 Barnett v. Kensington & Chelsea NHS Trust [1968] 1 All ER 1068 Limpus v. London General Omnibus Co. (1862) 1 H&C 526 Rose v. Plenty [1976] 1 WLR 141 Page v. Smith [1995] UKHL 7 Yewens v. Noakes (1880) 6 QBD 530 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Mental Damages Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Mental Damages Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1462449-a-case-study
(Mental Damages Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Mental Damages Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1462449-a-case-study.
“Mental Damages Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1462449-a-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Damages to Bonita and Ben

Is Public Safety Assured or Threatened

Public safety is often the greatest concern, when deciding whether incarceration or alternative sentencing programs are suitable.... “National statistics indicate that roughly 50% of those imprisoned every year are there for non-violent crime” (Petersilia & Sherman).... .... ... ... There are many alternatives to prison, for most offenses....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Implement and Monitor Nursing Care for Clients with Acute Health Problems

The paper contains a nursing care plan for clients with acute health problems.... The patient has third-degree burns seen in Harold.... The skin on his anterior lower leg and superior of his left foot appear pearly white and leathery.... He does not feel anything at all on his lower leg.... ... ... ...
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Usefulness of the Concept of Pain

This paper "Usefulness of the Concept of Pain" determines the questions patients are asked by medical experts, the tests to be conducted and treatment to be offered.... The paper seeks to benefit nurses and other providers of health care by providing a better understanding of the concept of pain....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Maritime Law: Nature and Advantages of Proceeding in Rem

"Maritime Law: Nature and Advantages of Proceeding in Rem" paper argues that the controversy over the idea of liability of ownership in my opinion renders maritime liens an ineffective force because they invoke liability on the vessel and its equipment.... .... ... ... A maritime lien refers to a secured claim against a sea vessel for a service done to it or damage done by the vessel or a maritime lien can also refer to 'a non-possessory right to property in a vessel' (Raia, 2010)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Interpretation of Multiracial Status

The purpose of this assignment "Interpretation of Multiracial Status" is to review a journal based on impact of multiracial status.... This assignment shall interpret the concept of multiracial status in context of psychological well-being and social engagement.... ... ... ... In this journal, there would be certain concepts, which shall be analyzed in accordance to four frames of colorblind racism demonstrated by Bonilla-Silva....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Dynamics of Managing a Visitor Destination

This paper "Dynamics of Managing a Visitor Destination" covers the growth of tourism in a place by taking steps to increase the number of visitors.... It has been seen that Sound tourism management is the most vital part and it is the process of appropriate visitor management.... .... ... ... In this paper, the growth of tourism visitors will be taken in such a way that the environment will not be damaged but will be harnessed....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Risk Factors of Stroke

The paper "Risk Factors of Stroke" is a perfect example of a case study on nursing.... Greta, a 77-year-old female, has been living independently for 38 years.... In the last two years.... Greta felt it become harder to live independently.... ... ... ... The paper "Risk Factors of Stroke" is a perfect example of a case study on nursing....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Osteoporosis and Orthopedic Surgery

The paper "Osteoporosis and Orthopedic Surgery" highlights that with the drastic global increase of osteoporosis and its related complications there is a need for an elaborate system for its monitoring and surveillance in order to improve its control and management.... .... ... ... Compartment syndrome can either be chronic or acute which is caused by the raising of tissue pressure within the fascial space; this pressure is abnormally high and leads to lowering of blood flowing into the extremity (Pollak, and Ficke, 2008)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us