Nobody downloaded yet

Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Introduction Professor HLA Hart upended the legal world with his treatise about the nature of law. In doing so, he critiqued the legal philosophies of Bentham and Austin, stating that they were naive, especially Austin, in stating that laws are based upon coercion and just the fact that these laws are in existence, without taking into account the standards by which these laws should be based…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER99% of users find it useful
Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin"

Download file to see previous pages Positivism and the Tradition of Austin In H.L.A. Hart’s critique of the legal philosophies of Bentham and Austin, Hart explains that these two men saw that laws as they are should be distinguished from laws as they should be. In other words, there is a distinction between law and morality, and a separation between the two. That said, Hart declares that Austin and Bentham also engage in legal positivism, in that the law as it is (law), and law as it ought to be (Law), is separated.1 Austin sees that there are laws which are based upon morality, such as those based upon God’s laws, and then there are man-made laws, which might, or might not, be based upon morality. Man-made laws which are not based upon reality might be benign, such as a so-called “silly law” such as the law in California that women may not drive in a house coat (dumblaws.com). That is the kind of law which Bentham would obey, yet censure.2 In other words, the law is on the books, so the citizens must obey, yet the laws are silly, so it also the citizen’s duty to attempt to get the law changed by censure. Alternatively, according to Hart (1958), there might be laws with evil intent, such as those put forth by the Nazis. It was these kinds of laws, Hart (1958) states, that led to Bentham stating that there must be some kind of civil disobedience, in that resistance to these laws must be had, not only through censure but through not obeying these laws (Hart, 1958). Hart explains that Bentham states that there are extremists in positive law, on either side of the coin. There are those extremists who see laws with which they do not agree, and, because they have a personal disagreement with the law, they opt not to follow it. These individuals are anarchists, according to Hart (1958). On the other hand, there are those who see a law, and, no matter how dumb it is, or evil it is, state that the law is the law, therefore it must not only be obeyed, but must not be criticized. This would mean that criticisms of bad laws will be “stifled…at its birth.”3 That said, Hart says that there is often an intersection between law and morality, as each mirrors the other. Laws are often based upon morals, and morals are often a reflection of laws. However, one does not follow the other – just because something is immoral does not mean that there is a law against it, and just because there is a law against something does not mean that it is immoral.4 Bentham and Austin are correct, in that morality cannot be a basis for the law, simply because morality is, often, subjective. For instance, in the United States, in the case of Bowers v. Hardwick, 478 U.S. 186 (1986), the Supreme Court upheld a law against homosexual sodomy, partially on the basis of moral concerns, in that a large portion of society considered, and still considers, homosexuality to be immoral and a violation of God’s law. However, Lawrence v. Texas, 539 U.S. 558 (2003) overturned Bowers, stating that homosexual sodomy cannot be made illegal, individual beliefs about the morality of the act non-withstanding. Indeed, the United States Supreme Court has decided a number of cases in favor of the rights of the individual to engage in certain practices which are deemed immoral by wide swaths of the country – ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin Essay”, n.d.)
Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1449335-jurisprudence-assignment-question-more-fundamental
(Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin Essay)
Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1449335-jurisprudence-assignment-question-more-fundamental.
“Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1449335-jurisprudence-assignment-question-more-fundamental.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin

Jurisprudence

...?JURISPRUDENCE Module Module ID: Q 4 (Answer Freedom of thought and action appears to be one of the most preferred yearnings of all the creatures at large. Consequently, all existing species long for freedom, by demonstrating tremendous resistance to the incarceration; it is equally applied to the humans, which do not allow any type of confinement and captivity that could create an impediment on the way to exercising their free will. On the contrary, they make resistance against all types of bondages inflicted upon them in one way or the other. The individuals and nations, not demonstrating any signs of resistance to the factors and elements imposing bars on them, lose their liberty eventually; as Call (2002)1 argues that...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Positivism

...? The Principles of Positivism: Do they still guide the design of social survey research Background Auguste Compte’s treatise ‘The in PositivePhilosophy’ first introduced the terms ‘positivism’ and ‘positive philosophy’ that are considered symbols of a recognised mode of thought, and which, according to Mill, are better known through the enemies of this mode of thinking, rather than due to its adherents (1882). Compte himself regarded Francis Bacon, Descartes and Galileo as antecedents of his concept of human knowledge; he defined his version of ‘positive philosophy’ stating that the only existing knowledge is the one of phenomena, and that this knowledge is not absolute but relative, hence, what is...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Jurisprudence Law

..., and lawyers are applying positive law. References Austin, J., 1832, The Province of Jurisprudence Determined, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1954. Dorkwin , R. Laws Empire. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 1986 Fuller, L. The Morality of Law, New Haven: Yale University Press, 1964.  Fuller, L. The Principles of Social Order. N.C.: Duke University Press, 1981 Gardner, J. “Legal Positivism: 5 ? Myths.” American Journal of Jurisprudence 46 (2001): 199- 227. Green, L. “Positivism and Conventionalism”, Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence, 12(1999): pp. 35-52. Greene, L., "Legal Positivism" in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Jurisprudence positivism/ Hart, H. The Concept of Law. 2d ed. Oxford: Clarendon... ? Jurisprudence Law Jurisprudence Law Positive law makes a...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Positivism

...? Positivism s s According to Auguste Comte, who is well known for his sociology theories d scientific knowledge as the most appropriate one which comes by following strictly scientific methods through positive approach towards all aspects of work. He further believed that this scientific study should be limited to only those pieces of data which can be objectively observed and explained on the basis of scientific methods because motives, feelings, emotions and other qualitative parameters can never be measured and hence should not be included in Sociology (Positivism, 2012). Positivism is often considered in scientist ideology context and is widely an attractive topic for technocrats who...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Positivism

... upon more authoritarian principles of law obedience that, despite their age, still have relevance today. John Austin, with his The Province of Jurisprudence Determined (1832) suggested the idea of "habitual obedience", that is obedience given to a sovereign (or perhaps elected government) based upon a fear of sanctions. Crudely, people obey the law because they fear the consequences if they do not. On a superficial level Austin's ideas seem self-evident: people do avoid breaking the law because of the consequences if they do on an individual level. However, if a whole system of laws is based solely (or nearly completely) on "habitual obedience" then it is by nature fragile and ripe for change. A frightened people has no loyalty... or...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Jurisprudence

...JURISPRUDENCE There was a time during Palaeolithic and Neolithic eras, when man was leading a wild and an anarchic life. There was neither any code of conduct, nor the concept of a code of law prevailing that time. With the growth of his intelligence and intellectual development as well, man started thinking in respect of devising some specific methods to make his environment peaceful, systematic and organized. Thus, the sets of laws and concept of jurisprudence came into existence. “Society develops”, Katers views, “because of the need for people to use the services of others and insure their own security. In order for a society to gain such a reliable reputation, there needs to be a backbone, which in...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Positivism

...specific to each person, such as brain structure, biological make-up and mental ability. Each of these forces influences human behavior. The second aspect of positivism is solving problems by the scientific method. Positivists rely on the strict use of empirical method to test hypotheses: by actual, first hand observation of conditions and events. The positivist tradition took firm root when Charles Darwin’s (1809-1882) work on the evolution of man strengthened a nineteenth century cult of science that dictated that all human activity could be proved by scientific principles (Siegel, 2007). Burke (2005) supports the view that biological, sociological and psychological factors shape human behavior by all...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Jurisprudence

...Jurisprudence Introduction Locke John’s social contract (construct) has been under several intense discussions to justify its relevance as far as the field of jurisprudence is concerned. Locke states that: “The great and chief end ... of Men’s uniting into Commonwealths, and putting themselves under Government, is the preservation of their Property. To which in the state of Nature there are many things wanting.”1 Considering the main words in his statement, which are: Men, Commonwealths, Government, Property and Nature, it is possible to understand John Locke’s idea. The Concerns about Men’s Quest for Rulership Locke reckons in his Book I chapter II that “Men are not...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Jurisprudence

...as jurisprudence. According to the legal scholars like Roscoe Pound, jurisprudence is actually “the science of law” and they have contradicted opinion of legal philosophers like Austin who suggested that jurisprudence is actually “a philosophy of law” (Pound, 2002, p. 7-11). The historical development of jurisprudence, starting from ancient Greek civilization to modern time is clearly suggestive of the fact that a lot of changes have occurred in the arena of jurisprudential observation regarding society, its transformation and the scope of implementing legal principles within the ever changing scope of social domain. There are several ways that the term...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Jurisprudence

...Jurisprudence Introduction Human rights are universal values and legal guarantees that protect individuals and groups against actions and omissions primarily by state agents that interfere with fundamental freedoms, entitlements and human dignity1. Terrorism refers to the acts of violence that target civilians in the pursuit of political or ideological aims. The issue of terrorism and how to counter it has led to the development of various laws on human rights. There are various Acts of Parliament and regulations that have been developed to counter terrorism in a special way that will ensure terrorism is countered without infringing on the rights of the perpetrators. The people affected in the new legislations include...
24 Pages(6000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Jurisprudence: Positivism and the Tradition of Austin for FREE!

Contact Us