Nobody downloaded yet

Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Case C-236/09 Association belge des Conssommateurs Test-Ach - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
CASE ANALYSIS By: name Instructor Institution Date Case Analysis This paper aims at analysing, critically, the European Court of Justice’s judgement in the Case “C-236/09 Association belge des Conssommateurs Test-Achats ASBL & Others v Conseil des ministres”…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Case C-236/09 Association belge des Conssommateurs Test-Ach
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Case C-236/09 Association belge des Conssommateurs Test-Ach"

Download file to see previous pages These proceedings were against the Conseil des ministres (Council of Ministers) for annulment of a section of the law (UK Pensions Update, 2011). According to InfoCuria (n.d), Article 6(2) of the Amsterdam treaty depicts that the Union shall respect all fundamental rights already guaranteed by the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms that were enacted on 4 November 1950 in Rome. Article 6 of the Treaty on European Union bears was founded on principles of democracy, liberty, respect for fundamental freedoms and human rights and the rule of law. These principles are common in the member states’ constitutions as general principles contained in community law. Article 5(2) expressly permits discrimination by reference to existing statistical data (Burling and Lazarus, 2011). Such were the grounds upon which the Belgian consumer group and the two citizens founded their case to find appropriate interpretation from the European Court of Justice. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) was deemed as the appropriate authority in this ruling. Based in Luxembourg, it is composed of 15 judges appointed by the agreement of the Member State governments. Each of the judges serves a six-year renewable term in office. According to Lloyd, Bajwa and Sukhwinder (1997), the court's procedures place greater emphasis on written submissions rather that oral argument. Following the hearing, the advocate-general delivers his or her well-reasoned opinion on the case. The opinion should be highly persuasive, but not binding on the court, which may differ from the advocate-general's propositions. The complainants presented the issue before the Belgian Constitutional Court in an effort to inspire the annulment of the Belgian law that transposed the directive. It if from this perspective that the Belgian Constitutional Court asked the Court of Justice for appropriate assessment on the validity of the derogation with respect to higher-ranking legal rules, and with reference to the principle of equality of genders enshrined in European Union law (Europe Log, 2011). The directive provided that Member States had the authority to permit exemptions from the rule of unisex premiums and benefits for as long as they could prove that underlying actuarial and statistical data were reliable, available to the public and regularly updated. Under Belgian insurance law, the insurance contract must have an element of uncertainty. An insurance contract under Article 1A of the Insurance Contract Law, 1992 states: A contract according to which, in return for the payment of a fixed or variable premium, a party, the insurer, commits itself towards another party, the policyholder, to provide the benefit stipulated in the contract in case an uncertain even emerges, that depending on the circumstances, either the insured or the beneficiary does not wish to emerge. (Keulers and Lydian, 2011 p. 2). In Belgium, there are no special courts for insurance disputes. Insurance disputes are brought before any court although the domicile of the policyholder has jurisdiction. Regulation of the Belgian insurance sector is also under Europe's highest court, the ECJ, which issues directives to member countries. Premiums are usually fixed or variable amounts, annual or any other date that agreed upon ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Essay”, n.d.)
Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Essay. Retrieved from
(Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Essay)
Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Essay.
“Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Case C-236/09 Association belge des Conssommateurs Test-Ach


...? JUDICIAL ACTIVISM BY EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE . Introduction The European Community Courts have played a decisive role in the integration process of the European Union. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has especially assumed key role by constantly pursuing legal assimilation in the EU by offering flesh and substance to an outline Treaty, thereby plugging in loopholes in the European laws, and improving the effective implementation of Community law in the provinces of the member states1. In case of ambiguities in the text of the Treaties, ECJ has to employ its creative talents so as to accomplish an acceptable elucidation and application of Community law. ECJ has filled in the gaps and removed the imprecision in the provinces... ....
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

European Court of Justice

...and local versions. Surely, the affect of the verdicts is not consistent throughout the Member States (Janne Sylvest and Andrew Beale, 2007). References 1. Janne Sylvest and Andrew Beale, The Impact of the European Court of Justice Case Law on National Systems for Cross-Border Health Service Provision 2007, briefing note pp.3-4. 2. Miriam Lenz, Dora Tynes and Lorna Young, "Horizontal What Back to Basics", E.L.Rev, 2000, vol. 25, pp.509-522. 3. Maciej Szpunar, Direct Effect of Community Directives in National Courts - Some Remarks Concerning Recent Developments, Centrum Europejskie Natolin, Warszawa 2003, p.3. 4. Paul, Craig, and...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

EU law (European Court of Justice)

...I will advise James and Neil that they both have a remedy under European law specifically under the Greyhounds Directive 2005 the Directive to claim for damages and compensation against the British government. The primary issue in the given problem is whether the Directive has a direct vertical effect such that James and Neil can claim rights under it against the State. In the landmark case decided by the European Court of Justice,1 the ECJ stated that EC law "has direct application within the territory of a Member State", or in other words, "nationals of such a state can, on the basis of the Article in question, lay claim to individual rights which the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Case Study

European Free Trade Association (EFTA)

... in aspects other than economic cooperation and trade. References: * Brown, Druscilla K, 1989. “Trade and Welfare effects of the European Schemes of the generalized system of preferences”, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 37(4): 757. * “European Free Trade Association” Retrieved October 27, 2007 from: * Henning, C. Randall, Hochreiter, Eduard and Hufbauer, Gary Clyde, 1994. “Reviving the European Union”, Peterson Institute. Retrieved October 27, 2007 from:,M1... European Free Trade...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The Implicit Association Test

...The Implicit Association Test The Implicit Association Test The Implicit AssociationTest is used for various purposes, such as evaluating unconscious favoritism towards an individual’s own group and prejudice against those outside one’s group. After taking the test, I discovered that I am somewhat racist and fairly sexist. The test was about Arab-Muslim IAT where I sorted Muslim from non-Muslim names. In this case, I was faster at ‘bad’ with Muslim names when the two shared a key and slower when the Muslim name was associated with “good”. The second test proved that I am sexist; I had to...
1 Pages(250 words)Admission/Application Essay

Sony versus Hotz court case and decision

...Sony versus Hotz Court Case and Decision Sony versus Hotz Court Case and Decision The Sony Corporation is a Japanese multinationalcompany, with its headquarters in Konan Minato, Japan. The conglomerate is widely known for its manufacture of a wide variety of electronic products. The PlayStation 3 is one of Sony’s key products. George Francis Hotz, on the other hand, is a hacker of American descent, famous for the unlocking of the iPhone and the PlayStation 3, contrary to the manufacturers intent (Grazzini, 2011). George Hotz announced his plans to hack Sony’s PlayStation 3. He managed to hack the machine and was able to access, read and write the system memory of the PlayStation 3. His hacking also enabled him to have access... and...
1 Pages(250 words)Article

Appraise Qualitative Data - Criminal Justice

...processes. The authors moreover report negative evidence on the analysis of sentencing sentences. The view of the researchers was to demonstrate that the analysis of court decisions where characterized by ethnic and racial disparities. The role of identifying and reporting negative evidence is evident in this research article because the authors based their arguments from empirical research findings on their topic. References Aselin, A. R., Gallucci, M., & DeCoster, J. (2013). Reconciling questions about dichotomizing variables in criminal justice research. Journal of Criminal Justice, 41(6), 386-394. Bottoms, A., & Tankebe, J. (2012). Beyond Procedural...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Court Decision

...Court Decision Court Decision Question I would like to categorically that the result of this case would not be different if Annett’s foster parents were seeking to adopt her. As unanimously agreed upon by the bench, New York law is very clear on the parental rights and its termination should a need arises. Based on the judgment, it was proved beyond no reasonable doubt that Joseph has abandoned his daughter. As a legal requirement, he was supposed to act responsibly by being in a constant contact with his daughter and communicating with her. However, despite doing so in her earlier years, he stopped in 1996 when two events happened-his incarceration and...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Supreme Court Case: Juvenile Justice

...the appeal and also did not explain the judge’s investigation. Furthermore, the court stated the waiver was valid. His attorney argued that his client’s rights were denied because he was a minor and added that his constitutional rights were disregarded. The court’s decision in this case was applied in D. C. courts and has an extensive impact (Taylor et al., 2007). The court’s power was increased as per the constitution and it could contend parens patriae as the foundation of juvenile court. The court had applied equal protection requirement in the 14th amendments to translate to the fact...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Supreme Court Decision

...of the Political Science of the Teacher 14 July Doe v. of Intrusia- Supreme Court Decision As per the wisdom and informed opinion of this Court of Law, the City of Intrusia no way violated the search and seizure protections enshrined in the Fourth Amendment by intercepting the text messages of the accused Joe Doe, and these text messages are aptly admissible in this Court as valid and credible evidence. This Court has ample reasons to set aside the appeal made by the accused, Joe Doe. The Fourth Amendment in its word and spirit intends to protect “The right of the people to be secure”, in the condition that they are subjected to “unreasonable searches”....
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Critically Appraise the Decision of the European Court of Justice in Case C-236/09 Association belge des Conssommateurs Test-Ach for FREE!

Contact Us