Free

Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims. Section 1: a) What are the most critical or significant issues or topics raised by the author(s) of the piece? Who has the right to invoke the tenth amendment? This is the main question she is raising…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful
Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims"

Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims. Section a) What are the most critical or significant issues or topics raised by the author(s) of the piece? Who has the right to invoke the tenth amendment? This is the main question she is raising. The principle controversy springs from the fact that the law gives both the state and the people the privilege to practice it. Taking a scenario where the opposing parties involve a private party against the state, the state is more likely to be favored. The contentious issue addressed includes whether the courts should unanimously make a decision on the position of private parties against the state in regard to the tenth amendment. The second significant issue this paper discusses is the tenth amendment and its effect on state autonomy in regard to federal interference (Killenbeck 20). (b) What are the credentials/areas of expertise of the author(s) that make them qualified to discuss these issues and topics? The author is a law student at the Boston College. The average law student in America has more than 70% percent grasp on constitutional proceedings within the syllabus covered. The author has also given substantial evidence to support her claims by deriving from the constitutional provisions and past court rulings. Her status as a student and the factual structures of her arguments are an exemplary attempt to combine both ethos and pathos to appeal to the reader and thus support her claims. Section 2: The author makes comments that have blanket assertions. Take for instance, her claim that the Court should side with the minority and ignore the states’ interests in accordance with the Tenth Amendment claims. She supports her argument by saying that the language of the constitution supposes so. In view of all other rules of the constitution, the language used and the manner of presentation is subject to different interpretations by different courts in different states. The subjectivity of language and subsequent interpretations, therefore, renders her argument flimsy. She also argues that the taxpayer cannot present a law suit on behalf of other taxpayers, making the federal government and the states look amateurish, but she does not mention that it is for this reason that the constitution allows them to be unions and civil rights groups to take care of this issue (Killenbeck 56). Section 3: Does the author rely upon, or cite, any empirical data to support the point of view? If so, describe and evaluate this data. The author has used empirical data in the form of years to present her arguments. She has used years and dates to show the developments and deterioration of the Tenth Amendment since its conception. She starts with 1918 when the Amendment first started to gain meaning. She proceeds to 1941, where courts and other litigations stripped the Amendment off its powers and progresses to subsequent years where a series of Supreme Court decisions finally gave it power. The author gives evidence in the form of case studies, for instance Printz v. United States 1997 and Reno v. Condon. Both these cases were in favor of the sovereignty of states (Hashmi 45). Section 4: a) What, if any, unexplained or unanswered questions became left for the reader to ponder, after he or she finishes the piece? She does not answer why even after all the cases that supreme courts have presided over, the TVA case still has a strong hold on modern day cases and that most judges refer to it when making rulings (Killenbeck 32). b) Does the author acknowledge in the piece that some questions remain to be explained or answered? Yes, she acknowledges that there are still some questions left unanswered, for instance the issue in section 4 above. In addition to that, she does not give substantial reason as to why she supports private party standing on the Tenth Amendment. She gives only one reason which has many inconsistencies arising from the subjective nature of the argument. This is to say that the same reasons she has used to support her stand can be used against it (Hashmi 66). Section 5: What has the author said that appears to be most confusing? The question of whether the federal government should be given leeway at the expense of state governments when it comes to the privileges of the Tenth Amendment appears to be most confusing. From the evidence she gives it is clear that most states prefer to remain as autonomous as possible. Finally, she goes on to validate her position on the issue. She does this by examining the standing doctrines, language used in the Tenth Amendment and the different interpretations of the courts on the same. The language factor is confusing because in the clause the state, private parties and the federal government have power but with an undefined extent (Hashmi 83). Section 6: Does one see any contradictions within the piece? There are a few contradictions that can be cited in this peace. The author proclaims the sovereignty of the state and then goes ahead to give suggestions that will undermine its authority. For instance, at page 1542 lines 25-27, she argues that private parties should bring the Tenth Amendment’s claim as long as they can prove that there was personal harm inflicted. She adds that by bringing the Tenth Amendment claim the private party is invoking their constitutional rights. In my opinion, the state and the federal government make jurisdictions. It is not rational for the state to take up a side that disproves of their competence. It is imperative, though unfair, that in a case of private parties against the state that the state should win. In this light, therefore, the Amendment should include a citation that allows the state power over private party claiming to close the argument of private party position in accordance with the Tenth Amendment debate once and for all (Killenbeck 54). Section 7: What has the author said that I most disagree with? I disagree with the author that private parties should have the privilege according to the Tenth Amendment statement. This is because it will undermine the sovereignty of both the state and the federal government (Killenbeck 73). Works Cited Hashmi, Sohail H. State sovereignty: change and persistence in international relations. Penssylvania: Penssylvania state university press, 2001. Killenbeck, Mark Robert. The Tenth Amendment and state sovereignty:constitutional history and contemporary issues. Oxford: Rowan and little fields, inc, 2002. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims Essay”, n.d.)
Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1444894-analysis-of-a-journal-article-who-s-left-standing
(Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims Essay)
Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1444894-analysis-of-a-journal-article-who-s-left-standing.
“Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1444894-analysis-of-a-journal-article-who-s-left-standing.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims

The Tenth Amendment

...the states in times of need. The Federal Government will only act as a manager of these States, and will act as a prime tax collector and infrastructure developer, in order for the United States to become a better nation. The statement “United we stand; Divided we fall” echoes that same sentiment. Should one secede? That is the question. The right to secede is not particularly illegal in the United States under the Tenth Amendment (because it is not specified!). This is supported by the historical fact that the States (then not United) had the right to secede in 1776 but they did not give up that right when they were forming the new Constitution. On the contrary, several states noted...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Claims

... Module Skill discovery In management, there are extremely many management skills and competences that have been pinpointed by different scholar. Different managers have strengths and weaknesses in various skills and competences. The most common competences and skills required of managers include the following: motivating people so that they can produce maximum by compensating their efforts; delegating authority effectively in all levels of management to ensure communication and commands follow scalar chain unless where the chain is creating delay; decisions making to enable the organization achieve set goals and objectives; understanding team dynamics, to ensure cooperation of all personnel in the organization; selecting... Module Skill...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Raise or Lower Tuition

...? Raise or Lower Tuition? al Affiliation Raise Or Lower Tuition? The price elasti of demand assesses the quantity of product responsiveness to a change or variation in its price. The accessibility of substitutes is the key determinant of price elasticity of demand for the product. Demand tends to be elastic when there is availability of good substitutes and a sizable element of the item in the consumers’ budget. On the other hand, demand tends to be inelastic when there is availability of poor substitutes. Generally, a product’s price elasticity increases as the consumers get more time to adjust to the change in the product price (Gwartney, Macpherson, Sobel, and Stroup, 2009). The idea of elasticity...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

PUBLIC/PRIVATE DIVIDE/STANDING IN JUDICIAL REVIEW

...Public/Private Divide/Standing In Judicial Review The citizen when seeking to challenge the powers of the is fundamental principles in the process of judicial review. The essence of judicial review is that an 'inferior body' (other expressions employed include subordinate body; administrative body, or administrative agency) has acted outside the scope of its power. The expressions used are: 'intra vires'- within its powers; and 'ultra vires'- beyond its power. Here the decision made by Architectural Academy would be amenable to claims for judicial review or not. And whether Julia, Arif and the Student Bursaries Foundation would have standing to bring a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Tenth Amendment acts as a limit on Congressional powers

... A Modern Day Analysis of the Tenth Amendment Abstract This paper examines some of the history of the Tenth Amendment as well as the various ways in which it is interpreted and expressed today. By utilizing four sources that address this subject and examining the actual words of the amendment, this paper takes a look at its original intent and then jumps to more current examples of its use. This paper will examine how the Tenth Amendment is viewed in modern times, whether through the U.S. Supreme Court, the threat of increased Congressional authority, state activities and policies and various organizations working to maintain its historical intent. The reader will also find a critical look at the ways in which the Tenth Amendment... is...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Raze-Raise

...Raze Raise The Emmanuel gallery has been mistaken by many for church. However, historically the gallery was a church and was converted in 1973 to a gallery as stated by Emanuel (1). Recently, Jeff page, a Denver native has been holding a fourteen piece exhibit which was showing since August 2nd all through to September 6th. Page’s work in raze-raise symbolizes the gay male subculture of Denver. Most of the pieces in the work are made of human hair, latex and pelts. The major attraction of this piece of art is the Raze, the roof piece that is based on the middle of the gallery. This structure made of human hair, acrylic, wood and latex rubber gives the viewer the opportunity to create individual meaning....
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Claims

...Skill discovery al affiliation In management, there are extremely many management skills and competences that have been pinpointed by different scholar. Different managers have strengths and weaknesses in various skills and competences. The most common competences and skills required of manages include the following; motivating people so that they can produce maximum by compensating their efforts. Delegating authority effectively in all levels of management to ensure communication and commands follow scalar chain unless where the chain is creating delay. Decisions making to enable the organization achieve set goals and objectives. Understanding team dynamics, to ensure cooperation of all personnel in the organization. Selecting... discovery...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Raise interactive scenario

...ARGUMENT al Affiliation ARGUMENT Children are by all means and aspect some of the precious possessions and backbone of thesociety, because the very moment they are born and brought to life, there is joy and happiness across the whole society. This is to say that they are assumed to be the future of the generations present and subsequent ones. Thus, when they are mistreated or treated rightly, it is the whole society that benefits in equal measure. It is worth to note and record that the society depends on them out rightly and directly since they represent the hope of the future and subsequent generations. In Tanzania in the areas of Mererani, children are subjected to deplorable conditions of mining, while they ought... al Affiliation...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Private Search and Seizure and the Fourth Amendment

...property, which may be moved away from the premise and the police jurisdiction if they go in search of a warrant. 3. Searching the Defendant’s Locker The supervisor or I have jurisdiction to search the locker of Mr. Yourprop without the violation of the fourth amendment as it does not apply to private searches. In the case Burdeau v. McDowell, the Supreme Court held that the exclusionary rule was not applicable to searches conducted in the private sector (Burdeau v. McDowell, 1921). The court held that the Fourth Amendment could not invade any search or seizure conducted by private entities to repossess what had been wrongfully taken from them by...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Tenth Amendment and Constitutional Interpretation

...the federal government have the right to regulate private industries or firms, mandate safety standards, mandate a certain wage or interest rate, require the payment of overtime, require benefits, etc.? Some people on the extreme free-market side of the spectrum argue that the government has no such power. They claim that the free market should be allowed to run untampered with by anything but the most cursory federal government interference. Sometimes, their argument is aconstitutional (that is, they are talking more philosophically about what governments should do, not what they legally can do), but many interpret the Tenth Amendment very broadly and the interstate...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Private Party Standing to Raise Tenth Amendment Claims for FREE!

Contact Us