Nobody downloaded yet

Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System? For those that stand accused of a crime, either in a civil or criminal court, there are two options available to them: a trial by jury, or a bench trial, in which a judge confers a verdict. In the United States of America, the right to a trial by jury in either a criminal or a civil court was considered so important by the Founding Fathers that it was written into the Bill of Rights, stating that “In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by an impartial jury of the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed.” (U.S…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System"

Download file to see previous pages Const., amend. VII). Many states have considered the right to a trial by jury so important that it is written into state constitutions as well (Saks). It is, therefore, not an exaggeration to say that the right to a trial by jury is considered a fundamental right of the American legal and judicial system. A trial by jury has its roots in Great Britain, where juries were used to provide protection against the harsh judgments of those that were in the favor of the King, and therefore handed down relatively harsh judgments for relatively small crimes (Graham, 2009). That system has grown, from Britain, to the United States, where in 2006 an estimated 154,000 jury trials were held nationwide (Mize, Hannaford-Agor & Waters, 2007). However, this does not mean that the system itself is perfect; indeed, if incarcerated criminals were questioned, most would likely say that the judicial system had not done what they hoped it would do. Trials by jury take time to put together, and can be expensive to everyone involved (VanKoppen, 2009). Trials by jury also have the benefits, however, of fairness and impartiality, the bigger availability of resources, and because juries do not have the same concerns over image or power as a judge does. For these reasons, a trial by jury is an efficient and just system in proving guilt or innocence. One reason that trial by jury is an efficient and just system is that juries are chosen based on their ability to be impartial and fair towards the one who stands accused. This is proven during the jury selection, when both lawyers ask questions and ensure that each person impaneled on the jury can be fair and impartial during the trial (Saks). Potential jurors that have a problem with certain sets of circumstances, such as racism or even possibly voting for the death penalty in capital cases are dismissed (Saks). In this way, fairness towards the accused is ensured. In contrast, a judge must go through no such procedure. The role of a judge was created for the very reason of protecting an accused (Graham, 2009). It is taken for granted that a judge will be impartial; even though the Constitution does not say that a judge must be, it is the right of every American to enjoy such a privilege at trial (Siegel, 2010). However, this is not always the way that the judicial system works. Corruption is not unknown, and judges have, in the past, been bought or bribed to render decisions. Consider Operation Greylord, a Federal probe that exposed widespread corruption in the Cook County, Illinois court system in 1983 (Bogira, 2005). Judges had been found to be extorting money from prosecution and defense lawyers, as well as taking money directly in exchange for certain verdicts (Bogira, 2005). Had a jury trial been the route taken, instead of the judge being able to be bribed, twelve people would have had to be bribed or replaced. While it is true that jury tampering can certainly occur, it stands to reason that it is much harder to tamper with and convince twelve people to vote a certain way, as opposed to one judge. Juries, whether they are made up of six ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System Essay”, n.d.)
Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1441778-is-trial-by-jury-an-efficient-and-just-system
(Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System Essay)
Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1441778-is-trial-by-jury-an-efficient-and-just-system.
“Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1441778-is-trial-by-jury-an-efficient-and-just-system.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System

Society and its Attraction to Jury Trial

...to what is the ordinary man’s idea of what is just.”18 Since the legal system is generally seen as an elitist social institution with a general opaque way of functioning, public confidence in the system tends to be low as regards meting out social justice and the trial by jury system is the right mechanism to bring the aspect of common man’s viewpoint into criminal laws. This allows the society to form its own accepted norms of equity and justice, and makes it the ethical arbiter of crime.19 Thus allowing the citizens to enter the legal processes as jurors with formidable powers to even act against the Judges (a part of the ‘British...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Why Trial by Jury Should Be Retained

.... 2011] Lees, S.,1995. ‘The media reporting of rape: the 1993 British ‘‘date rape’’ controversy’, in D. Kidd-Hewitt and R. Osborne (eds), Crime and the Media: The Post-Modern Spectacle. London: Pluto Press. Lieberman, J., & Krauss, D., 2009. Jury psychology: Social aspects of the trial process. Burlington, VT: Ashgate. Newburn, T., McLaughlin E., 2010. The sage handbook of criminological theory. London: SAGE. NZLC, 1998. Juries in Criminal Trials: Part One, Preliminary Paper 32 Obilo, B.E., 2009. Reason curve, jury competence in English criminal justice system. FL. Universal Publishers. Travis A., 2010. The verdict on...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Energy Efficient Food System

...Task Energy efficient food system Fossil resources have been the main form of energy production for the food system for many years, indirectly through utilizing of machinery, pesticides and fertilizers and directly through energy use in crop management both with an aim of increasing food production. Apparently, the increase in food demand in the recent years has seen the food-energy relationship enter a new era which could prove fossil resources as an insufficient mode of energy production in the food system. A food system here refers to all the work, research and processes involved in making sure that a population is well fed incorporating a balanced...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Advantages And Disadvantages Of The System Of Trial By Jury

...? Number: Topic: Trial by jury has been described in terms ranging from the cornerstone of British justice to amateur justice. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the system of trial by jury. Date: Trial by jury has been described in terms ranging from the cornerstone of British justice to amateur justice.  Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the system of trial by jury. The jury system in UK is a unique feature: as it combines the common sense of a non-legal person with the procedure of the law to ensure that justice is...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Jury Trial Analysis

...to Hornberger, there exists a judicial corruption in court where the judge has the power to influence the jury to ensure conviction. The existence of Hornberger’s point is just a reminder that the employment of constitutional trial rights especially in the selection of a jury can still be manipulated through the strong powerful force of bureaucracy. The trial Each party would be given a chance to share an opening statement. The prosecutor is privileged to tell the court what the trial is all about. The prosecutor would present their specific accusations to the defendant and a summary how they would prove that the accused is culpable. On...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Jury

...jurisdiction processes are caused mainly due to lack of diversity in the configuration of jurors. Thus, maintaining a higher degree of racial diversity amid juries is most likely to contribute towards making effective and racially unbiased judgment in the courtroom. Subsequently, with the involvement of minorities and women as jurors, the judgment process may also obtain an enhanced efficiency in dealing with equality of rights and mitigating biasness to a substantial extent (SAGE Publications, 2013). An opponent’s response to the reform There is need for racial diversity in the jury system so that effective decisions can be made with equality and in an unbiased manner....
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Efficient International Monetary System

...EFFICIENT INTERNATIONAL MONETARY SYSTEM Introduction This paper will aim to enumerate the main criteria for an efficient and effective international monetary system. Furthermore, the role of the supranational organisations in achieving an efficient international monetary system would also be discussed. The international monetary system can be said to be "the institutional framework within which international payments are made, the movement of capital is accommodated and exchange rates among countries' currencies are determined" (International finance in practice). An ideal international monetary...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Jury system of United States

...before time. Jurors are not allowed to make economical reasons for the day off however judges listen to personal problems cause of jury services and allow the juror to take off but to compensate that day afterwards some other day. Judge Stephen Reinhard, Nineth Circuit Court of Appeals mentioned in 1986, "Our constitutional right to trial by jury does not turn on the political mood of the moment, the outcome of cost/benefit analyses or the results of economic or fiscal calculations. There is no price tag on the continued existence of the civil jury system, or any other constitutionally-provided right." Qs. What are common grounds for challenging...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Jury System of UK

...- especially with the advances made in forensic science and the complexity of many civil trials, severe doubts regarding the efficacy of the jury system have been made. First of all, it is correct to consider whether a jury can in fact be "objective", especially when there has been a lot of pretrial publicity. Many studies have documented adverse effects of pre-trial publicity on juror decision making (Linz & Penrod, 1992; Otto, Penrod & Dexter, 1994; Ogloff & Vidmar, 1994; Studebaker & Penrod, 1997). These studies point out that jurors do not exist in a vacuum and are likely to have some opinion of a well-known case before they enter the courtroom....
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Petit (Trial) Jury

...Petit (Trial) Jury PETIT (TRIAL) JURY Sentence Definition A petit jury consists of a group of citizens chosen from a district that is used to question facts in a case. It tests the accusation’s accuracy via standards of proof. They are supervised by the trial judge who gives direction on the evidence to be viewed and the applicable laws, sometimes even directing the verdict. Historically, they consist of twelve members. Expanded Definition for first year student Defendants are guaranteed jury trials by the Sixth Amendment. The jury sitting in a case is technically referred to as a...
2 Pages(500 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Is Trial by Jury an Efficient and Just System for FREE!

Contact Us