Nobody downloaded yet

Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or not - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Drug testing of employees and applicants remains the issue of hot public debate. Lawsuits and suggestions concerning drug testing in the workplace are flooding U.S. courts and governing bodies. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or not
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or not"

Download file to see previous pages The issue of drug testing in the workplace exposes the ongoing tension between employee rights for privacy and the employer’s right to discharge the worker and terminate the at-will employment agreement. On the one hand, drug testing is believed to violate the Fourth Amendment and the basis premises of the U.S. Labor law protection. On the other hand, employers have the legal right to monitor and evaluate employee performance and address illicit drug issues, especially when it directly subjects employees and the community to health dangers (e.g., the use of drugs by policemen, firefighters, pilots, train conductors, etc.). This being said, and taking in consideration employers’ obligation to guarantee safety in the workplace, drug testing can be considered legal and ethical when it is based on reasonable suspicion and has the potential to adversely impact the safety of the employees, other workers, and the rest of community. The prevailing majority of employers in the United States are not required to test their employees and applicants for drug use. Moreover, most states have already enacted laws and regulations limiting the use of drug testing in the workplace (United States Department of Labor, 2010). Even the Drug-Free Workplace Act of 1988 does not make drug testing a mandatory condition of employment (United States Department of Labor, 2010). Nonetheless, the debate surrounding the issue of workplace drug testing continues to persist, because employees struggle for their rights, and of course not all the workers consider that the employer’s right to test them for using drug should exist. ...
e workplace policies, to reduce the costs of illicit drug use in the workplace and prevent the dangers associated with drug abuse in the workplace (Occupational Drug Testing, 2011). Employees, in turn, want to preserve the right to privacy and confidentiality, because testing them for using drugs at the workplace really violates their rights. More often than not, drug testing is considered as illegal, unethical, and similar to unreasonable seizures and searches protected by Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. However, a number of other laws and regulations also apply to the case, and courts do not always accept employee side in drug testing debates. Dozens of employees in the U.S. filed lawsuits against their current or former employers in terms of drug testing in the workplace. More often than not, employees argue that drug testing is illegal and unethical, violates their right to privacy and cannot be considered a valid reason for employment termination. In Luck v. Southern Pacific Transportation Co. (1990). 218 Cal. App. 3d1 [267 Cal. Rptr. 618] the petitioner Barbara A. Luck filed a lawsuit against her employer for terminating her contract after she refused to pass a mandatory drug test. Luck was rewarded almost half million dollars in rewards and compensations, and the U.S. Supreme Court confirmed the decision of the lower circuit court (Luck v. Southern Pacific Transportation Co. (1990). 218 Cal. App. 3d1 [267 Cal. Rptr. 618]). The decision was based on the premise that drug testing violates the Fourth Amendment to the Bill of Rights. Later in 2009, a North Carolina Appellate Court declared mandatory testing of teachers in the state unconstitutional (ACLU, 2010). The decision was based on another statute – the Louisiana constitution – which grants ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or not Research Paper”, n.d.)
Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or not Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1438194-drug-testing-employees-and-applicants-ethical-or
(Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or Not Research Paper)
Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or Not Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/law/1438194-drug-testing-employees-and-applicants-ethical-or.
“Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or Not Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1438194-drug-testing-employees-and-applicants-ethical-or.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or not

Drug testing for employers

...law application and education programs on the drug impacts. Finally, there was introduction of Executive Order No. 12564, which was compulsory for all employees to renounce from drugs and all agencies to cultivate a work place free from drugs (Potter & Orfali 10). Today, drug testing is an increasing and acceptable way of regulating the negative impacts of drug abuse on different work places. Subsequently drug abuse declines the firms’ profitability subsequently increasing accidents that occur in work places. Therefore, employers should have permission to test their...
5 Pages(1250 words)Research Paper

Facebook Effect on College Applicants and Employees

...?Face book Effect on College Applicants and Employees With the growth of the technological advancements in the globe over the recent times, the communication and transport also manifest these advancements with the emergence of more convenient, quick, and social communication media. Indeed, the emergence of the internet has improved communication and draws its application to a wide range of services. Social networking sites like Face book, MySpace, and Twitter are some of the communication aspects that rely on the internet. Launched in 2004, Face book currently enjoys a worldwide crop of active users ranging from 845 Million and above. The users are mostly the young although a significant...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Animals for drug testing

...One of the more controversial issues confronting the medical and pharmaceutical research industries is, without doubt, the use of animals for drug testing. The debate over the ethics of the practices and its practical benefits has raged on for close to three decades now (Speth), with neither opponents nor proponents willing, or able, to understand the opposing viewpoint and position. Proponents of the use of animals for drug and chemical testing have consistently and persistently maintained that medical and pharmaceutical research cannot proceed were live specimens, as in lab animals, removed from the equation. This camp has further maintained that the...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Disparate Impact Drug Testing

.... This understandable method of employment may actually impact blacks or certain racial groups more than others, because those certain groups are statistically less likely to have graduated from high school. (Runkel, 2008). Another example may possibly involve employers drug testing employees' hair strands prior to hiring them. Evidence exists suggesting that black hair may retain traces of drugs longer than lighter-colored hair, which means that this practice would cause groups of people with black hair (African Americans, Asians, etc.) to be less likely to be hired. (Discriminations, 2005). Because cases of disparate impact typically do not involve intentional...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Forced Drug Testing

...June 30 2009 Forced Drug Testing A drug test is an examination of urine, hair, blood, sweat, or oral fluid samples to determine the presence or absence of drugs in an individual's body. Each country has its own set of laws and ethics that focus on the testing of drugs. In 1995, President Clinton developed and implemented a policy that enforced drug testing on every federal arrestee before they were released for trial. The argument was that every criminal was caught in a vicious cycle where they passed through courts, correction facilities and probation hooked onto...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Drug testing

...a need to protect the privacy and rights of the individual that are a part of the American way of life. How do we reconcile public safety against the backdrop of the principle of presumed innocence? For most occupations drug testing is an excessive intrusion into privacy that violates the constitutional principles of self-incrimination and legal search and seizure. The constitutional guarantees that protect our privacy and require probable cause are illegally suspended when employers require mandatory and random drug testing. According to the US Department of Labor guidelines, "The current law in the private sector generally permits non-union companies to require...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Proposal

Workplace Drug Testing Programs

...% of the US workforce in 2007 were users of drugs and almost the same percent were reported heavy users of alcohol (cited in US DOL, 2010, p.2). The bottomline impact of such statistics is that the employee, his/ her co-workers and the business itself sustains losses as a result of a poor performance by a drug dependent. Therefore, there is a compelling reason to do drug testing like urinalysis or blood tests in order to deter and prevent substance abuse in workers, not just in public institutions but in all private and public businesses. Today, the law mandates that all companies dealing with the government should have a...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Drug testing on welfare

...that those who received welfare used it to get drugs (Davidson). The legislation was therefore, introduced to deny them the means of getting drugs, something that was thought to be commendable at the time. However, this assumption was found to be untrue, because of all the welfare applicants tested for drugs, only two percent of them tested positive. This automatically confirmed that this law was ineffective, due to the fact that its intended targets were found to be innocent of what they had been accused. It has now been confirmed that welfare recipients are not the majority drug users in the United States, and this...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Workplace Drug Testing

..., the excretory products such as urine are normally private affairs that must not be revealed. It is therefore apparent that asking employees to take their urine sample is violation of one’s privacy and may be very distressing thus detracting an employee’s dignity and self-esteem. Drug testing may further may further be regarded as unfair because there is violation of ethical standards of fair treatment. Usually, drug testing sees numerous innocent people tested because a presumption of guilt is placed on everyone. Choosing to indiscriminate against testing is not a fair act especially...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Drug Testing

...and moral concerns on invasion of privacy (American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) 2002). I would not advocate for the use of random drug testing in any occupation. Other methods that ensure the privacy of the employee is observed should be used instead. From my classes in psychology and understanding of the employees’ rights I would always support a system that takes concern of the employees’ privacy and address the legal and ethical issues that lay behind such a practice. Conclusion As much as it is important to enhance sobriety and alertness in the workplace, nothing can justify the performance of the random drug...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Drug Testing Employees and Applicants: Ethical or not for FREE!

Contact Us