StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

The Historical Extension of the Federal Government's Power Over the States - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The fourteenth amendment, to the United States Constitution, revered for containing the Bill of Rights and imposing limitations upon the state…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93% of users find it useful
The Historical Extension of the Federal Governments Power Over the States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Historical Extension of the Federal Government's Power Over the States"

Download file to see previous pages It attained this by prohibiting the states from infringing upon the rights and protection of the American populace. It also prevents the state from arbitral denial of the right to life and property without the due course of the decrees, and affords every individual within the jurisdiction of the state equal protection of the law. Over the years, the Supreme Court and the federal courts have adopted different interpretations of the fourteenth amendment. It is this reinterpretation, of the amendment, that has gradually changed the law of on the fourteenth amendment. This reinterpretation was reflected in various case laws that have been decided over the years. Barron v. Baltimore, 32 U.S. 243 (1833) This was the first judicial interpretation on whether the Bill of rights could limit sate powers. In this case, Baron had argued that the Constitution limited powers of both the state and federal governments, and proceeded to give the limitations on state power specified under Article 1 Section 5 (Phelan, 2008). Marshal J, in a dissenting opinion, held that the Bill of Rights in any way did not limit state power, and if it was intended to limit sate power, it could have expressly stated so (Phelan, 2008). In his judgment, Marshal J applied the law as it was as opposed to what it ought to have been. He directly and strictly interpreted the fourteenth amendment to hold that it did not apply in limiting state power, but rather acted only to limit the power of the federal government. In informing his decision, Marshal J noted that the provisions that were sought to be relied upon were in the passive voice, as opposed to direct language, and the provisions under Article 1 could not be applied to limit state power. The use of passive voice, could not answer the question ‘by whom’ and it was thus incapable of determining whether the provisions of Article 1 were binding upon the states as well (Rosenkranz, 2011, 1010). Article 1, on which Barrron sought to rely on, was framed in general terms, read passive voice, and could thus not be directly linked to limiting the state power because it could not answer the question; limited by whom? Had such provision been intended to limit state power, it could have taken a more direct tone. This, for example, could have been evidenced by the use of direct terminology such as ‘the state shall....’ or ‘No state shall....’ Although convectional wisdom may have dictated the fact that the use of the passive voice is ambiguous, Marshal J was undeterred in his stance as he applied the constitutional interpretation rule that the constitution ought to be read as a whole (Rosenkranz, 2011, 1012). In light of this therefore, if Article 1 section 9 were meant to limit state powers, then it would not have been framed in general terms. It should thus have been framed in a manner that answered the ‘by whom’ question. The logic applied in Barron is that when the Constitution seeks to limit power in passive voice, it is then limiting the authority of the government that it established. This logic is not necessarily correct because there is the horizontal dimension to separation of state power (Rosenkranz, 2011, 1015). If an interpretation were sought using this concept, then the court would have found that the Bill of rights could also limit state power horizontally. In other words, the strict application of the canon of grammatical consistency need not be construed so rigidly as to rule out flexibility in interpretation (Rosenkranz, 2011, 1016). Weeks v. U.S., 232 U.S. 383 (1914) This case sought to give an interpretation ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Historical Extension of the Federal Government's Power Over the Research Paper”, n.d.)
The Historical Extension of the Federal Government's Power Over the Research Paper. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1435869-the-historical-extension-of-the-federal-government
(The Historical Extension of the Federal Government'S Power Over the Research Paper)
The Historical Extension of the Federal Government'S Power Over the Research Paper. https://studentshare.org/law/1435869-the-historical-extension-of-the-federal-government.
“The Historical Extension of the Federal Government'S Power Over the Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1435869-the-historical-extension-of-the-federal-government.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Historical Extension of the Federal Government's Power Over the States

The Constitutions of the United States of America and the United Kingdom

The principal characteristic of a functioning democracy is the separation of powers. The concept of separation of powers is complex, although it may seem to be simple. This is because it consists of expressive and rigid components. The US Constitution represents the operational capability of the notion of separation of powers. It operates on three functions of the government. First, the executive implements legislation and supervises the administration over the state. Secondly, the legislature enacts the legislation and monitors the work of the executive and lastly, the judiciary interprets the legislations to apply land laws3.

The British Constitution is an unwritten constitution. Therefore, the limitations of the orga...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

S&T Debt Factors

The agreement contains a credit default contracts that include credit default swaps, default index contracts, credit default options, and credit default basket options. One can use these as part of the mechanism that is collateralized by debt obligations. The goal should be to establish a price for a given risk and controlling credit based on risk. The credit can be allowed by minimization of risk. Credit controllers should develop versatile tools that transfer risk away from a lender’s balance sheet.
d) With reference to the proposed debt counseling business, illustrate and explain exactly how you would organize the debt counseling operation, taking particular care to explain how and when you would receive payment for...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Truth and Power at the Coca Cola Company

Needless to say, while some corporations have successfully implemented these recommendations and have substantially expanded their markets and financial returns as a result, others have not. This research looks at one of the corporations which have successfully reaped the rewards of globalization: Coca-Cola. Drawing on international business theory, the study engages in a critical analysis of Coca-Cola’s external and internal environments for the purposes of shedding light on its corporate strategy and uncovering the determinants of its success. The analyses, which utilize Porter’s Five Forces, SWOT and PEST, indicates that Coca Cola’s success is a direct outcome of an internationalisation strategy which is deepl...
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study

United States Foreign Policy from 1945-1991

American Presidents presiding over some key events in history, such as the Cuban Missile Crisis, The Cold War, The Vietnam War, etc., were hindered from acting as public representatives due to pressure from the military-industrial complex. John Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, Ronald Reagan, George Herbert Walker Bush, and George W. Bush – all of them were subject to these opposing interests. But eventually, the corporate-government nexus proved too powerful; and in this sense, American Presidents after the Second World War were largely restricted and powerless to uphold their higher personal values. Most of the strategic moves on part of the United States after the end of the Great War were directly in response to an anticipated th...
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Historical Analysis Long-Term Care

In accordance with a survey published by the U.S. General Services Administration in 2004 ‘the number of elderly people residing alone without living children or siblings is expected to reach 1.2 million in 2020 — up from about 600,000 just a decade ago’ (U.S. General Services Administration, 2004, online article). Apart from the elderly, people with disabilities – as well as those with severe problems of health - also require continuous assistance in all their activities. The care of people belonging in the above categories is likely to last for quite a long (in most cases for the rest of their lives); for this reason, appropriate changes in existing legislation are made periodically in order to meet the n...
7 Pages (1750 words) Report

The Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956

Neither did this act increase the federal share to be borne of the expenses of the construction nor did it provide special funding for the project. The states had already completed about 6,500 miles of the allocated improvements when President Dwight D. Eisenhower took office in January 1953. For a period two years from 1954 to 1956, the congress had faced failure on several occasions in passing a national highway bill which would provide means to fund the interstate system. The focus was on the issue of how the expenses would be shared between the federal government and the states. Eisenhower having been in the army knew the importance of constructing well-designed roads to national security. In his address delivered in the State...
15 Pages (3750 words) Report

Organization and Functions of Federal Law Enforcement Agencies

Threats may either appear in the form of terrorism or from other intelligence groups or from the espionage. It may arise within the country, against the existing government or social systems. Though most of the federal law enforcement groups are investigative groups, they are not only focused on investigations but stand for the people. One can see that the importance of the federal agencies is growing day by day because the threats from militants and others have considerably increased. Such kinds of federal law enforcement agencies include Federal Air Marshalls, Secret Service, FBI, Untouchables, C.I.A and Federal Corrections etc. The organization and functions of these agencies vary in different fields and can be cited in the fol...
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

The United States Supreme Court

The Court, consisting of nine lifelong justices, bears complete authority over the Federal courts but has lesser power over those of the states. It has the power of “last word” on decisions made by these Federal courts and makes the rules that these courts have to follow in their procedures (Wagman, 1993). In addition, all Federal courts must abide by the decisions laid down by the Supreme Court, as well as the United States Constitution. With respect to state courts, the interpretations and decisions that the Supreme Court makes apply, but the Court is limited to interpreting and changing Federal laws, not state laws. Thus, the Supreme Court cannot change conditions of state constitutions or interpret laws made by ind...
10 Pages (2500 words) Coursework

Transatlantic Dispute over GMO Regulations

There has in the past been a row over the regulations of Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO) or Genetically Engineered Organisms (GEO), where different factors have been quoted by different stakeholders. The most notable of the stakeholders have been United States, Canada, and Argentina, which have brought about consultations aimed at straightening the disputes, with the European Community (EU), under the auspices of the World Trade Organization (WTO), and in respect to the “Moratorium for Regulations and Approval of Biotech Products” (Pipe SW 2008, pg 11). Based on the fact that the whole issue of GMOs rotates around a process where an organism has its genetic material altered using genetic techniques is in itself a...
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Effects of the United States of America Troops in South Korea

Despite the few negative incidences of crime committed by the United States of America’s security troops that were deployed in the country on a peacekeeping mission.
Since the war in Korea began in the early nineteen fifties, the United States has stationed tens of thousands of soldiers, mostly the United States’ army personnel, in South Korea. Through the assistance of the South Korean troops and other neighboring governments, the American troops have been able to guard and offer maximum security to South Korean people. In line with the argument of James (2003), ‘most of the military bases in South Korea are relatively isolated’ thus the need for much attention from the troops so as to ensure maximum...
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic The Historical Extension of the Federal Government's Power Over the States for FREE!

Contact Us