StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
A federal judge, as pertains to article 3 of the US constitution, is one who is appointed by the president after which he or she is vetted and confirmed by the Senate before he can proceed to perform activities as a Judge (Carpenter 23). With regard to this article, these judges are guaranteed life time tenure of office, meaning that they can hold such office until their time of death…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges"

Download file to see previous pages

On the other hand, they can decide on their own to resign or retire whenever they feel the need to do so. The security of tenure provided for by article 3 of the constitution, was informed by the need to ensure that the judiciary is independent and free from political interference (Federal Judicial Center n.d). It goes without saying that if the judges were subjected to a situation whereby the appointing authority has the capacity to terminate their employment at will, it would be extremely difficult for them to dispense justice without favoritism.

This is especially when they are called to make judgment on matters that have a political dimension and where the issues are touching on the party affiliated to the appointing authority. In this context, they would be easily compelled to rule in favor of their boss’s interests so as to avoid being removed from office. The dilemma in making such a decision is that in a democratic society such as the US, the opposition may come to win elections in the future to form the government and if the leaders have had problems with some of the judicial officers, they may take this opportunity to remove them and replace them with friendlier ones.

Security of tenure ensures that these judges are not affected by such a change, which has the capacity to ruin their lives especially from the financial perspective. In addition, it is a well known fact that experience in any field of service is acquired through long time participation. Opponents of lifetime employment of federal judges argue that having a limited term creates opportunity for introducing new members, probably younger, to the judiciary, who have the capacity to bring new and fresh ideas, which would help build more jurisprudence as they would be more conversant with current trends and issues affecting the society (Carpenter 73).

In this context, the opponents insinuate that judges, who have served for a long time, for example 20 years, may tend to take a conservative approach, while interpreting the law, to issues brought before them. On the contrary, being old does not necessarily mean that one loses his or her cognitive abilities and therefore is no reason for one to be discriminated in the work place. They still have the potential to serve the people, who really need their expertise and experience in law. On the other hand, it does not escape the minds of opponents that old age inhibits timely delivery of services as aged people tend to succumb to fatigue at a faster rate than young people.

In the judiciary, the consequence of this fatigue is an impediment to justice as it may result to backlog of cases in the courts. Mental debilitation and dementia also becomes an obstacle for a person to think or remember important aspects of law, which may lead to the making of irrelevant judgments (Federal Judicial Center n.d). For example, Justice William Douglas of the Supreme Court failed to acknowledge his inability to make healthy contributions after he suffered a debilitating stroke and anosognosia in 1975, even after his colleagues on the bench voted to bar him from participating and disqualifying any decisions he made (Carpenter 36).

This shows that life tenure of office by judges gives

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges Essay”, n.d.)
Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1432414-research-lifetime-appointment-of-federal-judges
(Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges Essay)
Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1432414-research-lifetime-appointment-of-federal-judges.
“Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1432414-research-lifetime-appointment-of-federal-judges.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Research Lifetime Appointment of Federal Judges

The Role of Government in Helping Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Veterans

According to Williamson and Mulhall, the repercussion of Vietnam War veterans' psychological issues, showed the federal government how to take care of its future veterans, in particular the state of their mental health after their wartime incident (6).... Furthermore, the former military personnel with PTSD had to wait for long periods, in order to get appointment to be assessed and treated at medical centres run by the veterans' affairs department (Scott 111)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Compare / Contrast IL Courts and Federal Court

Structure of federal and Illinois Courts The federal judiciary of the United States is divided into 94 judicial districts (Structure of the Federal Court, n.... RUNNING HEAD: JURISDICTION AND STRUCTURE OF ILLINOIS COURTS AND federal COURTS Jurisdiction and Structure of Illinois Courts and federal Courts Class School January 00, 2011 Gregory Calvin Robinson Email Address gregory.... il Jurisdiction and Structure of Illinois Courts and federal Courts Introduction The United States has a federal government and a state government....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Texas Parks and Wildlife

This appointment was to ensure that the Act for fish preservation was carefully complied with.... Texas Parks and Wildlife Introduction The Texas Parks and Wildlife Department (TPWD) was created in 1983, but existed since 1897 and is headquartered at 4200 Smith School Road in Austin, Texas....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

The federal budget deficit

Research Report By: 10th Nov, 2013 federal Budget Deficit The budget deficit occurs when government's spending outweighs its outlays.... hellip; ‘The public debt, which is sometimes called the federal or the national debt, is the total amount the federal government owes its creditors.... The current federal deficit for the government went down by 37% from the previous years pictures.... We will conduct an analysis to comprehend the federal budget deficit situation and find answers to the above questions....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

The Legacy of Ruth Ginsburg

Her appointment to the US Supreme Court was the pinnacle of a career that had persistently fought for womens… Labeled as a liberal, she began her career teaching at some of Americas most prestigious law schools, while volunteering her services with organizations such as the American Civil Liberties Union It is not possible to fully cover Ginsburgs contributions to womens rights in a paper of this limited scope....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Legal Basis for Ad Hoc Judges

Party-selected judges and arbitrators in international legal proceedings: their role, independence, desirability, and compatibility with the general principles of law governing procedure before international tribunals. International Law is administered by various entities.... Various international legislations exist that provide for the use of the party – elected judges.... The foremost instance where ad hoc judges are employed is in the International Court of Justice (ICJ)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Implementing an Effective and Judicial System for Puerto Rico

Thus, this paper aims at ploring the island of Puerto Rico in detail to suggest an effective and implementable judicial system after thorough research on the judicial systems prevalent in other similar states, or other states of the U.... Puerto Rico, officially known as the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, is the incorporated territory of the United States, however some of the recent developments indicate that it might get the status of a legal U....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Party-Selected Judges and Arbitrators in International Proceedings

This research will begin with the statement that in international legal proceedings, whether judicial or arbitral, parties may assured an opportunity to select or appoint a judge or arbitrator of their choosing to the judges' or arbitration panel.... hellip; The paper tells that in internal legal and arbitral proceedings, party-selected and party-appointed arbitrators and judges play distinctive useful and practical roles.... In both types of proceedings, party-selected or party-appointed judges and arbitrators are seen as a positive way of encouraging parties to resort to international legal processes in resolving conflicts....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us