Nobody downloaded yet

Questions on Law - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
LAW Name i) The name of the court is Belgian Conseil d'Etat, the administrative supreme court in Belgium. (ii) The President during these proceedings was G.C. Rodriguez Iglesias (iii) The Court of Justice construed that the first question required a determination of whether Articles 5 and 189 of the EEC Treaty prevented the Member State so that they could not approve measures which were contrary to Directive 91/156 during the time which had been given for its transposition…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Questions on Law
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Questions on Law"

Download file to see previous pages The Court reasoned that there was a binding obligation on the Member State to take measure so as to achieve the desired result in the directive and this was clearly stipulated within Article 189 of the Treaty. Furthermore, the duty was on all authorities which included courts of the Member States. The Court also relied upon Article 191 and stated that directives had legal effect from the time of notification to the Member State. As for directive 91/156 the court stated that the time provided was to allow Member States to take measures to achieve the prescribed result. The Court cited that according to Article 5, Article 189 and the directive measures which would seriously compromise upon the prescribed result should be refrained from. The Court finally went on to give what the national court had to consider, for example the implementation of the directive in stages, certain provisions not transposed and its effect on the overall result. b)i) The name of the Advocate General was J.Kokott (ii) The employer was Ellinikos Organismos Galaktos  (iii) The Court in this question considered what would happen if a directive is transposed belatedly and the relevant provisions do not have direct effect. The first reasoning that was provided was that when the national courts were interpreting domestic law they should take into account the directive and its conformity exclusive of the adoption of the directive. The courts did consides the rules of legal certainty and non retroactivity but went on to say that that interpretation should be in a manner so as to give effect to objectives of the directive. The court cited authorities which included Frankovich wherein the requirement of making good damage to individuals and the criteria within was dealt with. The Court considered Article 10 and 249 EC and stated when it applies that is lack of direct effect. The court went on to consider the fact that expiry of time allows the interpretation and conformity requirements. The Court reasoned that after expiry of time limit if transposition had not been done then the courts of Member States should refrain from interpreting domestic law so as to compromise on the prescribed objective. Thus the court stated that belated transposition means that the domestic court are bound to interpret domestic law in line with the directive so as to achieve the results prescribed therein. (iv) The Court in respect of the case at hand went at length about the details of indirect effect. Furthermore the conditions of non retroactivity and legal certainty were also discussed. The important aspect in respect of this case was the fact that even though in indirect effect there has been the long standing phenomena that case that came under its head were where the time limit for bringing such an action had passed, in the case it was stated that the national courts were under a duty to take into account of the directive even when the time for the directive had not passed and the time limit had not expired. Thus the courts took a new approach in respect of indirect effect whereupon the courts of the member states have been placed under and obligation to interpret ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Questions on Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Questions on Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
“Questions on Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document


Law questions

...? Assignment Law Order Issue Whether Barkley can enter into Contractual Obligations on his own Barkley is the son of Knarles and he is aged 17. When the father had gone for the Green Facilties Management Trade Show, Barkley was responsible for handling the issues of the firm. The question which arises here is whether Barkley is legally tenable to enter into contracts on behalf of the firm. One of the most fundamental principles of Contract Law is that an individual who is below the age of 18 cannot enter into contracts with other parties. This law also applies to situations which consist of an individual entering into contracts to represent a firm which has been established under law. Applying the law to the facts, we understand... the...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Questions on Law

...? ESSAY QUESTIONS 12 February ESSAY QUESTIONS Question How the prosecution is likely to respond to the motion and how the judge is likely to rule The suspects were booked after the police followed a tip of their involvement in a crime. The police officer who witnessed their act together with his back up team issued citation for the suspects. The gang moved a motion for dismissal of their cases on the ground that their citations were issued by officers who lacked probable cause. Legal principle: Prosecution’s reasoning The case is based on the principle of probable cause for making an arrest. Under the principle, a police officer can make a warrantless arrest, and citation, if there is a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

Law Problem Questions

...? Law Problem Questions Word Count: 1500 Evidence Problem Question ???? Max is charged with several counts of being concerned in the supply of Class A controlled drugs. ????The prosecution believe he is very important in the supply chain and have been watching him for some time. They have evidence of a very extravagant, expensive lifestyle with no other clear source of income to fund it, association with known dealers and suppliers and they have found a small quantity of drugs in his possession. He also has a very large number of text messages on his cell phones saying things such as: ????“Can you bring a bag for ?20 and meet me?” ??“Any chance of my usual, Friday 8 pm?” ??“Are you ‘big Max’? Any chance bag ?50 Thursday... before, the new...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Law Questions

...Task The key element in proving material support to terrorism is mens rea. The intention of knowingly providing financial or any other form of material support to a terrorist organization has to be sustained by the prosecution in a charge of providing material support to a terrorist organization (Abram Normans, 2002, p.6). These involves the advancement of evidence that the accused, at the time of committing the offence, knew that he/she was providing material support to a terrorist organization and knew the terrorist organization in question. 2 Terrorism has been defined by different kinds of laws including the following: 1. The International Terrorism Act of 1990 2. The Patriots Act 3. The UN...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Business Law - Questions

...?Business Law Element of Contract to UK Online Selling: In order to sell a product to s through online medium, the websites offering the goods or services needs to have an explicit contract, verifiable by the consumers with a specific log, where they can express their agreement to such a contract by endorsing a tick mark thereon. Such a contract or agreement of terms of use is enforceable by law and valid for all the online transactions. It is not necessary for the sales of goods or services in this manner, to have a traditional, written document by endorsing signature in ink for it to be legally valid. Mostly in the case of online business, an advertisement on a site suffices as “a formal offer to...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Business Law Questions

...?First information Business Law Question Eva, the owner of Finest Enterprises, is a sole proprietor. Assuch, she runs and maintains ownership of the business herself. In sole proprietorship, there is no legal distinction between Eva and Finest Enterprises that is, the owner and the business are considered as one under law (Aronoff, Ward and Astrachan 22). The first advantage is that this type of business is easy to form. The business organization is simple with minimal legal formalities that includes the license and permits in special cases. The business is also easy to dissolve if Eva so wishes. The second advantage is that this type of business only needs small startup capital. Apart...
7 Pages(1750 words)Coursework

Hypothetical international law questions

...1. Set forth at least one jurisdictional theory under which each of the three nations may properly prosecute the terrorists under international law. Answer. There are several international conventions against unlawful interference with civil aviation. Among them the following are most important : 1. Tokyo Convention(1963) 2. Hague Convention (1970) 3. Montreal Convention(1971) 4. Protocol for the Suppression of Unlawful Act of Violence at Airports Serving International Civil Aviation, 1988 Principle of universal jurisdiction in respect of the crime of the hijacking : The principle of universal jurisdiction is recognized in respect of the crime of piracy and war crimes. Since hijacking is generally described as aerial piracy... , the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Law Questions

...Law Questions Law questions Q1. The issue is that the people officers were called to respond to an accident and not an investigation into Fred’s life. Did the circumstances and facts provide the police officers a probable or credible cause to consider that Fred had or was going to commit a felony? Can probable cause rely on tips? In addition, the police officers did not have the right to search Fred’s possession because they lacked a valid search warrant from the court. . The “Due Process Clause” had been disobeyed when police officers coerced Fred to take breadth test. The police officers in this matter are supposed to respond to the accident not start searching Fred’s...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment

Business law questions

... Section/# Law Question and Answers 11. With regards to Young bringing suit against Pileggi for nonpayment, it is not a valid defense for Pileggi due to the fact that the promissory note that discussed the amount given is not sufficient to distance Young from the wrong doing that he may have committed in the first place. Simply agreeing to pay is of course not sufficient in order to undue any past wrongdoing. One can understand this by a situation in which an individual would steal something from their employer only to go to the employer at a later time and say that they will pay it back. The employee would still be ultimately responsible for the theft that they committed regardless of the extenuating circumstances of the case... place. ...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Law Questions

...GROCERY, INC. SIMULATIONS Grocery, Inc. is a retail grocery store chain. It has written contracts with many different vendors Does Article 2 of the UCC apply to the contracts between Grocery, Inc. and its vendors? Do common law contracts apply? Explain your answer in detail. Your answer should compare and contrast common law contracts and UCC Article 2 contracts. Article 2 of the UCC applies to the contract because of article’s scope that governs sale of goods in which the grocery stores deal. Common law also applies to the contract because of its scope that includes law of contracts (Cross and Miller, 2011). 2. Grocery Inc. has contracted with Reliable Construction...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Questions on Law for FREE!

Contact Us