Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This essay discusses some delicate legal and ethical issues related to their intention of starting their own business and leaving their current employers.: Mason and Shepherd. It analyses agreements that somehow limited their possibilities of starting a new business in the future…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.8% of users find it useful
Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues"

Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues
Mason and Shepherd are facing some delicate legal and ethical issues related to their intention of starting their own business and leaving their current employers. Both of them have signed agreements that somehow limited their possibilities of starting a new business in the future. The situation of each of them will be further analyzed:
a) Sheila Mason:
Sheila’s leaving ATS raises both legal and ethical issues concerning her employment at ATS.
Mason was planning to start a business which involved the development and sale of a product that, at a first sight did not compete with ATS’ products, but did facilitate the creation of products which would compete with those developed by ATS in the future. Although Sheila claims that while working for ATS, the company’s policy regarded the products that furthered UNIX-based systems as a good thing for ATS no matter where it came from, this is not an official statement of ATS and it does not prevent ATS from taking legal action against such situations. Sheila’s starting a business with this kind of products circumvents the Non-competition clause, and, inevitably, leads to the circumvention of the Non-solicitation of customers clause. This is normal, as such a product needs to be sold to the same range of customers with whom ATS works with. Moreover, a lot of the work that Sheila had done on developing the concept of Intelisoft was done by her using ATS’s property: her working laptop was connected to her home computer and her Palm, which, additionally to the above-mentioned, violates the clause referring to the company property usage. Another clause which is violated by Sheila is the Assignment of Developments clause, which stipulates that any development that “(i) relates to the business of the Company or any customer of or supplier to the Company or any of the products or services being developed, manufactured or sold by the Company or which may be used in relation therewith; or (ii) results from tasks assigned to me by the Company; or (iii) results from the use of premises or personal property (whether tangible or intangible) owned, leased or contracted for by the Company, then all such Developments and the benefits thereof are and shall immediately become the sole and absolute property of the Company and its assigns, as works made for hire or otherwise.” Her further actions may involuntarily lead to her violating the non-disclosure clause, too.
Sheila has signed with ATS an Employee Noncompetition, Nonsolicitation, Nondisclosure and Developments Agreement, by which she was bound to a Non-competition, Non-solicitation of Customers Clauses and some additional clauses related to usage of company property and assignment of developments. She should terminate her employment at ATS according to the law requirements and be prepared to face serious legal litigations. Therefore, Mason should give an official notice to her employer and hire a good attorney in order to protect her in the future.
b) Craig Shepherd:
Craig finds himself in a legally awkward position, too. He has signed with Nova an Agreement Regarding Assignment of Inventions and Non-Disclosure, by which he is bound to “…communicate to an officer of the Company promptly and fully all inventions …
made or conceived by me … from the time of entering the Company's employ until I leave, … which result from or are suggested by any work which I may do for or on behalf of the Company.” The translator software was developed by Craig during his employment at Nova. However, Craig may use in his defense the fact that the idea of conceiving such a program came to him during his work at Riverhead, being inspired by the problems of Riverhead’s software. This may be hard to prove, but it is not impossible. Craig should also terminate his employment at Nova in proper manner, through an official notice and be prepared to be sued by Nova for refusing to hand them his invention. As in Mason’s case, a good attorney is needed here.
2. The non-disclosure agreement considerably limits the possibility of expansion of a venture capitalist. I believe it is reasonable for the companies to ask employees to sign non-disclosure agreements, in order to protect all the information concerning the company’s activity. I also find it reasonable, considering the fact that companies are hiring people whose experience and knowledge is enriched due to working in that specific company, as in Mason’s and Shepherd’s case. The company is investing in its employees and is entrusting to them serious confidential information related to its activity, including know-how, techniques, systems, processes, engineering data, software programs, software code, works of authorship, customer lists, customer information, supplier lists, supplier information, marketing or sales information, financial information, financial projections, pricing information, business plans, projects, plans and proposals – all of this information being collected and accumulated by the company during years of activity and hard work and at the same time, being vital information for a venture capitalist willing to invest. Under these circumstances, I believe that non-disclosure agreements are reasonable, but it is imperative to avoid them being applied excessively and abusively. A venture capitalist should comply with such kind of clauses, but this should not limit or prevent one from starting a new business.
3. It is certain that if Sheila and Craig are willing to pursue with their plans of starting their own business, a lawyer should be hired. I completely disagree with them hiring an attorney who has worked with ATS, as a conflict of interest may occur and it would not be in Mason’s and Shepherd’s favor. She should also avoid hiring an attorney who is working with the Venture capitalists, as his activity depends on the VC and another conflict of interests might occur in this case. The possibility of hiring the intellectual property boutique firm recommended by Shepherd’s friend is the most reasonable of all, as it does avoid the situation of conflicts of interests. It is certain that an independent attorney or law firm, that does not depend in any way of the parties involved, should be hired. It is also preferable that the attorney is specialized in intellectual property issues and a good defense for Mason and Shepherd is proposed by him. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues Case Study”, n.d.)
Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues Case Study. Retrieved from
(Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues Case Study)
Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues Case Study.
“Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues Case Study”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues

Legal and Ethical Issues

...if it refers to elderly smokers in a care setting. Some elderly people suffer from numerous diseases and it is relevant to inform them about health hazards caused by smoking. It is quite clear that smoking is a trigger of cancer, lung diseases and many other illnesses (Chiva&Stears, 2001). Thus, it is relevant to find a solution to this problem from legal and ethical perspectives. Ethical issues There are four basic ethical principles: respect for person, autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. Elderly people who undergo treatment in health care settings should be treated in accordance with these ethical...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Sheila Mason & Craig Shepherd

...?Sheila Mason &Craig Shepherd Case Study Evaluate the situation in which Mason and Shepherd find themselves with respect to their existing employers. What legal and ethical issues do you see, and how would you advise them to proceed? What should Mason and Shepherd do to terminate their current employment? Mason and Shepherd are faced with some serious decisions regarding their employment. Situations regarding their employment are dependent on making ethical business decisions. Mason and...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Mason and Shepherd' difficulties

...of operation of ATS. As per clause 6, the company has also claim to any new idea that may significantly impact organizational work output and performance. Shepherd’s employment contract also forbids him to share company’s information. At the same time, it also ensures that his employer, Nova Software Company will have claim to any new idea, discovery or development that are conceived during the period of employment and which has direct bearing on the wider ramifications on the operations and performance of the company. Thus, both Mason and Shepherd are in highly precarious ground vis-a-vis their employment conditions. There are huge legal and ethical...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

Ethical Issues Facing Internet Technology

...? Ethical Issues that Arise from the Use of Internet Technology Ethical Issues that Arise from the Use of Internet Technology Internet is the most powerful invention of our times that has made life easier by bringing any information home just at a mouse click. With the advent of internet communication, banking, academic, business, governance and everything has become faster than what we could imagine some years ago. Traditional communication means including letters, telephone, music, film etc have been reshaped by the internet. The print media have undergone a facelift by adapting website technology and blogging. Human interactions have been redefined by...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Legal and Ethical Issues

...Describe the legal issues that are involved in this case Tatiana was killed by Prosenjit Poddar in Oct, 1969. The parents of the victim reported through that Poddar confessed his crime to Dr. Lawrence Moore, a psychologist employed by the Cowell Memorial Hospital at the University of California at Berkeley. The parents also claimed that the psychologist deliberately avoided the revelation of the details to the court and public. Legally, the case was stronger for the parents, and it seemed that it was rational for them to protest and seek punishment against the murderer and the person who deliberately hide the identity of the murderer. Legally Poddar was under...
5 Pages(1250 words)Case Study

Ethical and Legal Issues how the consent is made. In the earlier discussions, consent has to be acquired clearly and the individual has full knowledge of the facts and possible effects and ramifications of his giving his personal information for sale. The supermarket would not have satisfied the legal and ethical requirements, as we simple go there to shop. Indeed, by analyzing our receipts and past purchases and piecing them together with our financial information through our payments, credit card use, etc., the supermarkets have as much information as they or anyone else would need to take advantage of the information we unwittingly give them. There is presumably an element of trust involved when we make purchases at our...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Legal and Ethical Issues

...LEGAL AND ETHICAL ISSUES IN NURSING of Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) is designed toenable the researchers to obtain Protected Health Information in the course of their research. These researchers include those in medical and other health related disciplines. They require access to certain information about heath that people may view as private and intend it to be confidential. The information is contained in disease registries, government archives of important medical records and other databases that contain hospital discharge records. The HIPAA rules are a response to public concern over potential abuses of the privacy of health information. To understand...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Ethical and Legal Issues

...Ethical and Legal Issues A policy restricting employee internet use is ethically sound. Employee monitoring has appeared as a requirement, and it is still a controversial issue because of widespread use and complexity of technology. Employees are apprehensive of Code of Conduct compliance and proper employee behavior relative to their industries and other organizations. This is the reason why more and more employers are utilizing monitoring devices to keep track or check the actions of their employees. Most of the employers feel that too much utilization of internet for activities that are not job related while on the job is not beneficial. It is also...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Legal and Ethical Issues

...operations of solar panel manufacturing (Anderson, 2012). Conclusion This study sought to analyze the Solyndra in the legal and ethical perspectives. It had described the company’s business activities from the time it started up to when it closed the doors. It has evaluated the legal and ethical issues that relate to what the company has gone through. In introducing the company, the study found that the company had a great political influence that made it suffer financially after some time. It faced stiff rivalry from Chinese solar manufacturing enterprises that made the solar prices drop. Even if the production costs...
7 Pages(1750 words)Term Paper

Legal an Ethical Issues Facing IT Managers

... users in the workplace, the public, and even the employers. Therefore, IT managers should develop and create awareness on the importance of legal and ethical values associated with computer use in the workplace (Oswalt & Elliot-Howard, 2003). Other crimes such as cyberbullying may also compromise a person’s individual rights and ethical values. Policies to protect worker’s ethical values should be included in the operational activities in cyber work environments. Otherwise, Reference Oswalt, B., & Elliot-Howard, F. (2003). Cyberslacking - Legal an Ethical Issues facing IT Managers. IACIS, 646.... The issue of computer ethics is a crucial topic in the information systems sector. Though...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Mason and Shepherd Facing Some Delicate Legal and Ethical Issues for FREE!

Contact Us