Nobody downloaded yet

Duty of care: An evaluation of its fitness for the purpose - Assignment Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Duty of Care: An Evaluation of its Fitness for the Purpose Introduction The law of persons has developed over many years. As a result, various elements have been being introduced while others have undergone appropriate amendments to meet the intended purpose…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Duty of care: An evaluation of its fitness for the purpose
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Duty of care: An evaluation of its fitness for the purpose"

Download file to see previous pages Thus, the idea of negligence or unreasonable behaviour was introduced in the practice of tort law in order to control foreseeable misdeeds and related mishaps whose occurrence might be injurious to other parties in the society. Despite the fact that the law of tort has significantly contributed to the maintenance of law and justice, some scholars argue that the duty of care imposes a generalized responsibility of people. In Anns v Merton London Borough Council [1978] AC 728, Lord Wilberforce argued that there ought to be some element of foreseeable harm and reasonable proximity between the events of the parties involved in order to ascertain the existence of duty of care. However, Brenan J intellectually overruled Lord Wilberforce’s approach in distinguishing the conceptual duty of care in Sutherland Shire Council v Hayman [1985] 60 ALR 1. 2 With that in mind, this paper evaluates the essence of duty of care to determine whether it is fit for the purpose in line with the propositions of Brenan J. Particularly, the paper provides a succinct discussion on the various components of negligence that define the need for a broad consideration of facts beyond the mere existence of prima facie duty of care. Thus, the paper culminates with a rational perspective of the duty of care and its relevance in contemporary law. Duty of Skill and Care The duty of skill and care is a matter of rational judgment based on practicable reasoning that other persons in the same situation would ordinarily resort to a similar judgment. In the case of tort, there is need to consider the possibility of foreseeable harm from unreasonable commission or omission of an act from which a person may suffer personal injury or injury to their property. On the other hand, the duty of care is defined as the obvious expectation of diligence to ensure that one’s actions are not injurious to other people or their property as postulated by Abraham Kenneth.3 In defining the legal context of the duty of care, Lord Aitken stated that the duty of care can be proven when one’s act of omission or commission might result in foreseeable injury to another person. This definition was well illustrated in Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562 House of Lords.4 It was held that the defendant owed Mrs Donoghue the due of care to ensure that the content of their product was safe from any offensive materials. Accordingly, the duty of care is often recognized by law as the relationship to situations that would otherwise require one to take reasonable care to avoid mishaps resulting in reasonably foreseen injuries. Breach of such relationship would attract legal redress for purposes of serving justices and restoring order. Ideally, there are three essential components in determining the duty of care. The first one relates to reasonable foresee-ability. It is practically expected that a driver in his performance of the activity will be careful enough not to run over other road users including fellow motorist and pedestrians, or cause damage to the adjacent property. Consequently, a reasonable person would not resort to commit or omit such acts that might otherwise cause personal injury to people or damage of property. In Ande v Gabriel [1975] 12 CCHCJ, 2143, the Nigerian court held that the defendant owed his fellow road users the duty of care. For that reason, the plaintiff succeeded in his claim for damages on grounds of breach of duty owed to him by the defendant. This was however distinguished in Topp v London Country Bus [1993] 1 ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Duty of care: An evaluation of its fitness for the purpose Assignment”, n.d.)
Duty of care: An evaluation of its fitness for the purpose Assignment. Retrieved from
(Duty of Care: An Evaluation of Its Fitness for the Purpose Assignment)
Duty of Care: An Evaluation of Its Fitness for the Purpose Assignment.
“Duty of Care: An Evaluation of Its Fitness for the Purpose Assignment”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Duty of care: An evaluation of its fitness for the purpose

Fitness for Duty Evaluation

...? Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation Introduction The following paper attempts to create a comprehensive, well-researched fitness-for-duty evaluation. The fitness-for-duty evaluation relies on a Midwestern state police department who recently responded to a barricaded active shooter incident, where the shooter had confined himself and his family in their home. During the scenario, the negotiator was able to persuade the shooter to release all his four young children but was unable to persuade the shooter to release his wife or surrender. The scenario resulted in the suicide of the active shooter...
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment

Employers Duty of Care

...Employer’s Duty of Care 1. Explain whether Jake’s actions are in or out of “his scope of employment.” First and foremost, Jake was clearly identified as the service manager. As service manager, therefore, the scope of responsibilities include governing the functions of the department including planning, directing, organizing and controlling service activities that need to be attended to. The video did not disclose any information on the number of service personnel under his jurisdiction. One could simply assume that he was alone attending to all the service requirements of all the cars that were offered for free change oil service because when he opted to have his injured thumb checked, it was Herman,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation: Ethical and Legal Implications

...that both the police officers and their employers have legal responsibilities for actions of police officers on duty. The attachment of legal responsibilities for police officers makes them to become more careful on how they conduct their duties (Heilbrun, Grisso, & Goldstein, 2009). On the other hand, police employers are cautious about the mental and psychological health of their employees. This has made them to have a more intensive and extensive training and recruitment programs. Despite being monitored by the law, police misconducts are usual occurrence that affects the life of law enforcement officers. The legal obligations attached to...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Company Director's Duty of Care

..." -But not expected to give continuous attention to the affairs -Should maintain sufficient knowledge of business 3) Reliance on Others -A director is not liable for the acts of co-directors or Company officers solely by virtue of his position. -A director is entitled to rely on a subordinate "put in a position of charge for the express purpose of attending to the detail of management" -Directors cannot absolve themselves entirely of their responsibility by delegation to others. "In fixing the director's duty of care and skill in the process of supervising the activities of management, UK law has sought to avoid the pitfalls of a purely objective and a purely subjective test,...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Negligence and Duty of Care

...Abstract With the modern penchant for litigation, joined with the increased recognition of responsibility, the tort of negligence has become one of the most widely used areas of litigation. This paper examines the development of this phenomenon, providing a study of its principle and paying particular attention to the development of the core elements on which this litigation rests, namely the legal definition of duty and care. Our research shows that, in some areas, the current situation in tort of negligence can be argued to be unreasonable. However, it is concluded that, although there is some evidence of attempts to curb the effects of such litigation, the key intention of tort of...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Duty of Care

... In order to be able to advise the parties in the above situations it is necessary to examine the potential claims against each. This will involve looking at the rules on general negligence as well as professional negligence. The starting point in proving all claims for tort is establishing whether a duty of care was owed and by whom, whether there has been a breach of that duty and whether as a result of that breach the party has suffered harm. In all three cases there needs to be a discussion as to whether the party causing the damage owed the victim a greater degree of care as they were supposedly professionals in their field of work. As none of the parties have suffered physical harm as a result of the tort all three case... will...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Employers Duty of Care take Jake’s place and do the change oil service himself. In this regard, Jake’s actions are actually within his scope of employment. According to Damewood (2012), the duties and responsibilities of an auto shop service manager is “normally focused on satisfying the customers through correctly determining the problems with their vehicles and repairing them in a timely and cost-effective manner” (par. 3). Although Herman identified that he should just focus on providing the free change oil service, the extra service provided by Jake ensures that the customers would be satisfied with his work. Further, any additional costs needed from checking the basics: the brakes, tires and transmission would be revenue for the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Developing a Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation

...Task: Developing a Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation Those man d with the recruitment of law enforcers are required by law to ensure that officers under their watch are mentally fit to discharge their mandate competently. From time to time, employer may call into question the emotional soundness of an employee, which may impair not only their ability to discharge their duties effectively, but also render them a danger to both themselves and the general public. Such dangers may include lapses in concentration, excessive use of force and such kind of idle tendencies. It is the right and duty of the employer to administer...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment


...Fitness Introduction This paper is about the importance or the significance of fitness and healthy living. It also goes ahead to discuss how fitness and healthy living can affect the performance of students. The first section discusses the general background of the topic healthy living and fitness, its problems and issues associated with it, which is followed by a section on comments regarding the UAE in particular. General background Fitness and good health is associated with a number of positive outcomes in the lives of both students and other people. It has a great impact on the general performance of the students and other members...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay


...Fitness Fitness Chad Evermore requires improving his golf game, despite the fact that he has regularly been exercising for the last eight years. He has done a lot of aerobics and just a little of resistance training. At his age, Mr. Chad is a healthy man and is highly motivated to start a training program. Before the exercise program can begin, an assessment has to be carried out. This assessment involves checking for physical fitness in terms of how much their muscles and cardiovascular organs can endure. These fitness tests are, however, preceded by discussions on medical or chronic conditions that Mr. Chad may be having. This initial formality is quite crucial for any...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Assignment on topic Duty of care: An evaluation of its fitness for the purpose for FREE!

Contact Us