StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Summit vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985) - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Question 1 Facts In the case of Summitt v. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985), Summitt sought to reverse a previous jury conviction from two counts of sexual assault. In the previous case, Summitt was indicted for three counts of sexual assault, but because of the state’s failure to preserve evidence, one charge of sexual intercourse was dropped, and he was convicted for cunnilingus and fellatio…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Summit vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985)
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Summit vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985)"

Download file to see previous pages This testimony was offered by the appellant by stating that the victim had previous knowledge of similar acts that formed a foundation for the current case. Summitt was convicted by the grand jury, and the current case is an appeal on grounds of the rape shield law under FRE 412. Issue The issue before the court in the current case is whether the rape shield law allowed the admission of prior sexual experience of the victim as evidence in the case. The court had to determine whether Summitt could introduce the prior sexual experience of his victim as a basis for his defense in the appeal of his conviction. Rule The rule in this case is defined by the Nevada Revised Statute Section 50.090.1, which limits the inquiry into the sexual history of a victim in a rape or sexual assault case. This rule reversed the common law statute of rape cases, where the morality of the victim could have led the assailant to infer consent for sexual acts. Analysis The rape shield law was designed to prevent the introduction of irrelevant evidence in sexual assault cases, evidence that had the potential to prejudice a jury against a victim in the case. The evidence that is usually barred includes opinions or apparent previous reputations of the victim and prior sexual experience. In the case of Summitt v. The State Supreme Court of Nevada, the rape shield law was used to prevent the appellant from introducing a previous sexual assault on the victim as basis for defense. The appellant tried to claim that since the victim had been subjected to the same assault previously, the victim had prior independent knowledge of the present case. According to common law, a defendant has the right to present witnesses in a case, cross examine them and introduce any history that pertains to the case. But in the case of sexual assault, this history might have no bearing on the case and just prejudice the jury. Therefore, the rape shield law is used to shield the victim from unfair testimony. In this case, the defendant tried to prove that the prior sexual experience of the child could have been used to formulate the evidence in the current case, indicating that the rape shield law should not have been applied. In dissenting, Steffen, a judge, stated that the previous sexual experience of the victim could have been used to make up statements in the current case, and that the lesser court was wrong in excluding reference to the previous assault. Conclusion The decision in the case to reverse the prior ruling and remand the case for a new trial was based on the error by the district court in not admitting the prior sexual experience of the victim in the case. This means that the rape shield law can sometimes act unfavorably for the defendant, since the victim could have prior knowledge that might have bearing in the current case. Discussion The rule in this case impacts different rape and sexual cases. From the decision, it is seen that the rape shield law can be circumvented by a jury if it is evident that the defendant needs the prior sexual experience of the victim in his case. Question 2 Facts Martin Weil unexpectedly passed away, and on investigation, his doctors could not explain the cause of death or the cause of several medical complications that he experienced before his death. One ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Summit vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985) Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1399702-midterm-essay
(Summit Vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985) Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1399702-midterm-essay.
“Summit Vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985) Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1399702-midterm-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Summit vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985)

Tragic Hero Supreme of Shakespeare and Sophocles

In analyzing Sophocles’ play Antigone and Shakespeare’s play Othello, we find at least two such tragic heroes in the title characters. Although both characters exhibit characteristics of the tragic hero, it is my contention that Othello proves the stronger representation.
At the opening of each play, both Othello and Antigone display a noble stature in their relationships to the powers that be. Antigone is a princess of Thebes as the play opens following the death of her father and the subsequent deaths of her brothers at each other’s hands (194-95). Being ordered not to bury the brother who brought war to the gates of Thebes by the new king Creon, Antigone decides to risk the king’s wrath in favor of...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Has Government by States Given Way to Inter and Non-State Governance

The application of theories related to the state and its governance can be proved very helpful towards the creation of an effective and well-structured state. However, the phenomenon of a ‘subjective’ interpretation of the above theories is common especially when there are specific targets that need to be achieved by the interested parties (usual participants in a state’s political or social life). For this reason, it is necessary that specific rules and guidelines are followed when studying and interpreting the views of theorists regarding the position, the role and the power of the state.

Within the state, there are many ‘political’ and ‘social’ forces that try to impose their...
10 Pages(2500 words)Report

The State and the Impact That Homelessness Has on Children in Miami-Dade

Miami-Dade County has the highest homeless rate in the State of Florida. It ranks first in ‘families living in poverty’ among 25 major US cities (JLM, n.d.). Poverty and high rate of rentals have been considered the two main causes of homelessness. As much as 83% of people experience homelessness for a short period and usually require assistance in finding housing or rent subsidy. About 17% of the people in Miami-Dade are homeless for longer periods and require permanent supportive housing. The total number of homeless persons on the street in January 2006 was 4709 (Camillus.org). Fluctuations in the homeless count can occur depending upon the weather, time of the year and the methodology.

Florida accounts f...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

America Vs Let America be America

His poem “Let America be America”
When Claude McKay was just twenty years old, he published his first book of verses titled “Songs of Jamaica” which dealt with his impressions of Black life in America. He wrote on various subjects that included love and romance using very passionate language. Later on, the main themes he wrote on, time and again was about the sufferings and injustice meted out to the blacks in America. In the earlier part of the twentieth century, his literary achievements had a great influence on the Harlem Renaissance. He was greatly respected by the younger generation
Langston Hughes completed his college education at Lincoln University, Pennsylvania. It was at Lincoln, Illinoi...
7 Pages(1750 words)Book Report/Review

Self-Defence against Non-State Actors

Prior to 1945, there was no unified international prohibition on a unilateral resort to force and the UN Charter sought to radicalize international politics through a general prohibition on the use of unilateral force by member states. The prohibition was officially enshrined in Article 2(4) of the Charter, which provides that:
“All member states shall refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations”(UN Charter Article 2(4) 1945).
Despite the purported ban on the unilateral use of force, the parameters of Article 2(4)’s applicabili...
15 Pages(3750 words)Assignment

Cultural Value Orientations: German vs. Turkish

When organizational culture is discussed in the context of national culture, it is based on certain assumptions. According to Schein (2004 qt. Browaeys and Price 2008) culture can be defined as:

"...a set of basic assumptions - shared solutions to universal problems of external adaptation (how to survive) and internal integration (how to stay together) - which have evolved over time and are handed down from one generation to the next".

External adaptation here refers to factors or culture which the management can control while internal integration means the relationship which binds them to the group. In this context management styles and approaches are often influenced by the cultural value orientation - that...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

The British Constitution vs The Human Rights Act 1998

This research essay analyses the above statement and arrives at a conclusion.
Integration of the provisions of ECHR into U.K’s domestic law by way of HRA 1998 can be regarded as revolutionary as it facilitates the majority of the ECHR rights provisions directly applicable in the U.K. Before that integration, a U.K Court has to presume that when there is a clash between U.K’s domestic law and ECHR rights provision, the ECHR rights provision will always prevail. This principle has been laid down in R v Secretary of Home Dept ex parte Brind1 and R v Secretary of Home Dept ex parte Thakrar. 2
Courts have now the power to declare any statue which they find incompatible with ECHR provisions and order for fine-tunin...
9 Pages(2250 words)Case Study

The United States Supreme Court

The Court, consisting of nine lifelong justices, bears complete authority over the Federal courts but has lesser power over those of the states. It has the power of “last word” on decisions made by these Federal courts and makes the rules that these courts have to follow in their procedures (Wagman, 1993). In addition, all Federal courts must abide by the decisions laid down by the Supreme Court, as well as the United States Constitution. With respect to state courts, the interpretations and decisions that the Supreme Court makes apply, but the Court is limited to interpreting and changing Federal laws, not state laws. Thus, the Supreme Court cannot change conditions of state constitutions or interpret laws made by ind...
10 Pages(2500 words)Coursework

Health Needs Assessment among Internally Displaced People in Southern Darfur State

In the recent past, Sudan has gone through a very serious humanitarian crisis, rated by as among the worst in the world. This crisis has led to thousands of Sudanese being displaced from their homes. The crisis was a series of civil wars that have characterized the Southern Sudan regions, and quite recently the Darfur region. The conflict in the Darfur region is among the most recent crises in Sudan and has as a result drawn global attention. According to the UN, the Darfur conflict emerged as the worst crisis in the year 2003 as far as humanitarian aspects are concerned (UNEP/OCHA, 2004 pp 6).

So far, the Darfur crisis has led to the internal displacement of more than two million citizens. In the year 2008, the UN esti...
11 Pages(2750 words)Term Paper

What Are the Most Important Factors in Explaining the Rise of the Modern State

Though the existence of the state can be felt in different walks of everyday life, yet it is an intangible whose nature is impossible to grasp. As a political institution, state embodies the concept of sovereignty. Devetak (2007) describes it as a political unit or a country that possesses sovereignty. State can thus be described as a single, unified whole confined within territorial borders. The state is built in a core geographical area with allowances to a certain extent on the boundaries. According to Strayer (1970), a state exists in the hearts and minds of the people. The collective personality of the state renders it immortal. The state is a multi-faced concept that is fuzzy around its edges. Consequently, we cannot develop...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Summit vs. State Supreme Court of Nevada (1985) for FREE!

Contact Us