Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Doctor Assisted Suicide - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Doctor Assisted Suicide Introduction and Claim The controversy has always gone on as to whether or not doctor assisted suicide is an act of mercy or murder. The issue has attracted even more controversy because of the fact that there has been legal backing for the issue of doctor assisted suicide…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.5% of users find it useful
Doctor Assisted Suicide
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Doctor Assisted Suicide"

Doctor Assisted Suicide Introduction and Claim The controversy has always gone on as to whether or not doctor assisted suicide is an act of mercy ormurder. The issue has attracted even more controversy because of the fact that there has been legal backing for the issue of doctor assisted suicide. Indeed, death remains a very sensitive issue in different cultures and socio-cultural backgrounds around the world. Death may be considered a very sad phenomenon or a necessary evil for rest depending on circumstances under which the death occurs. It is this bi-dimensional feeling on death that makes doctor-assisted suicide highly controversial. In the sight of the law however, doctor-assisted suicide may be necessary to end the suffering of dying patient Background The issue of doctor-assisted suicide in the United States was more or less started by Dr. Jack Kevorkian who remained a vocal campaign for doctor-assisted suicide for over three decades. It is reported that “Kevorkian helped an estimated 130 terminally or chronically ill individuals kill themselves between 1990 and 1999” (Gwaltney, 2010). The doctor was not found guilty of any of those acts, in which he virtually provided a means and served as a witness; but in 1998 he was found guilty of the law of homicide when he personally undertook the injection that ended the life of his ailing patient. As of the time, the need to give the subject of doctor-assisted suicide gained much prominence in the American media with views being very divergent. As of the year 2009, Montana had become the third state in the United States to legalize doctor-assisted suicide. All in all, the law envisions that “most deaths by physician-assisted suicide are likely to occur for the illness of cancer and in the elderly and that physicians will deal with most requests for assisted suicide” (Hicks, 2012). Whether Autonomy Decision can rightly be taken by the seriously sick A very central theme of the issue of physician assisted suicide is the topic of autonomy decision by the sick. The law provides that the decision to admit to the suicide should come only by consent from the sick. The point of discussion however remains as to whether or not the sick person may be in his or her right sense to take such a decision. It would be appreciated that most people are highly at fear to pain and discomfort. To such people who may see death as a last resort and a means for eternal rest, there is the greater possibility that they may not be in a position to take very ethically informed decision on the need for them to accept medical suicide. This therefore calls for the need for the law to be critically reviewed regarding who should have the final say to death consent. More so, most sick people may not understand the medical alternatives available to them and so may opt for medical suicide wrongly. Indeed, it may not always be right that a sick person who opts for medical suicide or even a doctor who suggests it may be perfectly right that there remained no hope for recovery. The decision for opting for medical suicide should therefore be made more difficult and binding to take. Even if the law will stay, it should come only as a last resort. Alternatives for survival and relief There could also be the debate of what medical experts and other health professionals could do as alternatives for survival and relief. Without any doubt, for us to continue believing that medical cases could get to such a situation where medical experts and professionals could do nothing about is tantamount to saying that our medical system is the least developed. With the advancement of technology and its use to solve several globally prevailing phenomena, it should be possible to have medical alternatives of giving relief to sick people without necessarily causing their deaths. To this end, artificial life support technologies that can sustain human life for longer periods are suggested. These artificial life supports should also be provided while meeting other health responsibilities of the sick person in giving such person total healing (Curlin, 2008). Conclusion The act of living is a fundamental human right and so must be protected to the later. It is however important that the need to live must be done in a state of good health and sound life. To this end, doctor assisted suicide should be accepted as right only under a circumstance, that health practitioners find that continuous existence would be the worse choice of the patient. It is also important that decision to commit medical suicide be left in the hands of experts who can be the sole decision makers as whether or not there remains any hope for sick people (Hodge, 2009). REFERENCE LIST Bernstein, Sid. Doctor-Assisted Suicide. 1999. Aish Journals. Web. April 11, 2012 Curlin, Farr A et al. To Die, to Sleep: US Physicians’ Religious and Other Objections to Physician-Assisted Suicide, Terminal Sedation, and Withdrawal of Life Support. 2010. Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2008 Apr–May; 25(2): 112–120. Gardener, Helana. Some Good News To End The Year With. 2009. Associated Press. Web. 11, April, 2012. Gwaltney, Mike. Kevorkian Physician Assisted Suicide. 2010. APUS Database. Web. April 12, 2012 Hicks, Hsiao-Rei M. Physician-assisted suicide: a review of the literature concerning practical and clinical implications for UK doctors. 2006. BioMed Central Ltd. Web. April 11, 2012 Hodge, Richards. Motivated to Live. Ultimate Press Limited: New York. 2009. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
“Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
bayerena added comment 2 years ago
Student rated this paper as
Wonderful work done on the "Doctor Assisted Suicide". I think it is the best example I have seen so far.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Doctor Assisted Suicide

Assisted Suicide

... a certain quality of life, against those who are pro-life and believe in maintaining it under any circumstances. An intangible situation, comprising of socio-religious and ethical dilemma, and legal hurdles for the patient and the family members, and a question mark on the medical ethics of the doctor involved in the case. Now a look at the term ‘assisted suicide,’ will show us that the word is self revealing. A suicide where there is the presence and involvement of a third person. Now, the term suicide is one of the most intriguing, terrifying and difficult concepts for us to understand. Scientists have carried out extensive researches on whether suicide is linked to inheritable madness or has some connection to various other...
66 Pages(16500 words)Research Proposal

The Politics of Doctor Who

...The Politics of Doctor Who Introduction In the television series Doctor Who, there are allegories which correspond to the real world. Some would saythat the show is very political – both Alec Charles and Marc Dipaolo, in their essays listed below, see that the allegories are decidedly liberal and offer a critique for not only the neoconservatives who goaded much of the world into the war wi th Iraq, but also provide critiques for other aspects of conservative politics – such as the corporatism, racism, and pursuit of materialism over the good of the world. However, McKee (2004), who studied fans of the series, found that the series appeals to people in all parts of the political...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

The Positives and the Negative Aspects of Physician Assisted Suicide

The very public death of Terri Schiavo in 2005 alerted Americans to the growing medical, ethical, and social crises accompanying the status of end of life issues and decisions in the USA. Physician-Assisted Suicide (PAS) is legalized in only two USA states, yet there have been numerous requests across the country to perform the operation. As indicated in the 2012 PBS Frontline documentary; there is an underground world that has added new legal and moral complexity to one of the most divisive issues in the United States of America. The practice of Physician-assisted suicide has been legal in Washington and Oregon states since 1997-09.

In Montana State, the Supreme Court ruled in 2009 that physician-assisted suicide was l...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper

Physician Assisted Suicide

... not assist in suicides because to do so in not compatible with the doctor’s function as a healer. Suffering has always been part of human existence. Since the beginning of medicine, requests to end suffering by means of death through physician-assisted suicide. Physician-assisted suicide in most occasions can be confused with euthanasia; however, they have both similarities while at the same time have some differences. Euthanasia is the act of bringing about the death of a hopelessly ill and suffering patient to a relatively and painless death. This research paper focuses on physician-assisted suicide as a medical issue and theories that attempts to explain this issue. In particular, this paper attempts to determine both the positives...
10 Pages(2500 words)Term Paper

Suicide of Megan Meier

... Suicide of Megan Meier Introduction It was on October 15, 2006 that Megan Meier received really unexpected and harsh messages from her boyfriend Josh, who ended the conversation by saying that “The world would be a better place without you”. Megan had been talking to Josh for quite some while. They met on MySpace and Megan instantly fell for this person, who surprisingly enough, did not have a cell phone or landline and had just moved into town. She loved talking to such a handsome boy as she had faced problems of obesity, depression and attention deficit disorder but this friendship was really boosting her self-esteem, something, which promoted her mother from allowing her daughter to spend her time on MySpace (Long, p. 28). When...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Statistics of Offenders to Commit Suicide

A more serious suicide problem in correctional facilities, which has come to the fore in recent times, is the gender disparity in the cases of prisoner self-harm and attempted suicide. It is rather intriguing that while they comprise only about 5% of the prison population, female prisoners are observed to attempt more self-harm and attempt suicide compared to males. Notably, between 20% and 24% of female prisoners self-harm while between 5% and 6% of male inmates self-harm every year. The study also found out that cases of self-harm were 30 times higher in female prisoners compared with the general UK population rates, which were reported to be at 0.6%. Hence, this study seeks to establish whether or not, female prisoners attempt...
17 Pages(4250 words)Research Proposal

Urban Challenges Depicted in Virgin Suicide and Detroit an American Autopsy

There are very many challenges facing the modern urban centers that are compelling the residents to consider relocating to the suburban areas. However, most of these challenges are avoidable because they are caused by the negligence of both the urban authorities as well as the residents. Therefore, it is imperative to decide the best action plan to remedy this phenomenon. The two choices available are either fleeing the urban centers or finding relevant solutions to the challenges facing the urban centers.
This essay addresses the effects of suburbanization as far as urban diversity is concerned. However, it makes reference to two main books mainly the Virgin Suicide and Detroit an American Autopsy.
Numerous factors ca...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

The Effect of Using Computer-Assisted Language Learning

... The effect of using Computer-Assisted Language Learning (CALL) to Assess Listening Skill for ESL Learners INTRODUCTION Computer Assisted Language Learning (CALL) refers to the use of computer in the process of language learning. The objective of CALL is to explain about the process of language learning through the help of computer. It assists in creating an autonomous learner. In this regard, it can be stated that the significance of computers with regard to CALL has changed from being an “Input – control- feedback” to management of communication. In other words, CALL methodology in the initial years was based on the behavioral approach so that the inputs of the students could be checked and than a feedback was to be provided...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Comparison of The Overcoat and The District Doctor

... The Overcoat and The District Doctor The overcoat is a short story written by Nikolai Gogol who was born in Ukraine but is a Russian. The story was published in 1842 and is about the life and death of a counselor known as Akaky Akakievich Bashmachkin. The story is told using a third person narrative describing the activities surrounding the life of Akaky. The District Doctor, on the other hand, is a story by Ivan Turgenev. It is a story about a traveller who becomes ill and is treated by a local physician known as Trifon Ivanitch who shares a strange story with the traveller. The story is told from a first person narrative point of view. This paper will compare The Overcoat and The District Doctor and develop an argument about the issues...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Suicide Prevention Programs

... Suicide These days, suicide is one of the leading causes of death of young people in the United s of America, and every day people engage in self-harm activities to end their lives. Some of them do display red-flag behaviors while others do not show they have problems, and this makes detection and prevention of suicide rather difficult and very often even impossible. This means that existing suicide risk assessment programs are not enough to deal with the problem and that the community is not educated enough to be able to detect and prevent suicide of its members. The research paper is aimed at answering the following question: How serious is the issue of suicide in today’s society, and what is done and can be done to change the state...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Doctor Assisted Suicide for FREE!

Contact Us