StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Are the constructive trust rules affecting co-owned housing based on the common intention of the parties - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
While there are several principles and methods for the imposition of the constructive trust the common intentions of the parties is specifically applicable to co-owned housing disputes. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.8% of users find it useful
Are the constructive trust rules affecting co-owned housing based on the common intention of the parties
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Are the constructive trust rules affecting co-owned housing based on the common intention of the parties"

Download file to see previous pages First and foremost, intimate relations are based on trusts and this is particularly important where “individual autonomy” is ceded in reliance and trust on the perpetuation of shared goals and objectives.3 Secondly, the rules applicable to constructive trusts recognize that the intimate bond can be broken and equity will intervene to ensure that one party is not unjustly enriched to the detriment of the other.4 Thus the rules of constructive trust are designed to interpret and affect co-owned housing in circumstances where factual evidence contradicts the legally documented ownership of the house in question. The courts do not automatically interpret the mere existence of a relationship at time the house is acquired as evidence of co-ownership. The courts are guided by the concept of unconscionability and refer to the common intentions of the parties in determining what is conscionable or unconscionable. The main idea is to determine whether the common intentions of the parties are sufficiently made out to justify a claim to co-ownership against the legal title to real property.5 Thus it is argued that the rules of constructive trusts affecting co-owned housing are based on identifying the common intentions of the parties. This paper demonstrates how the courts have relied on the identification of the common intentions of the parties to determine whether or not it would be unconscionable to enforce ownership by reference only to the legal title. The first part of this paper therefore examines and analyses the doctrinal basis of constructive trusts and the second part of this paper demonstrates how the common intentions of the parties forms the basis by which co-owned housing is interpreted under the rules of constructive trusts. The Doctrinal Basis of Constructive Trusts The result of a court finding the existence of a constructive trust is twofold. First the court may order that one party compensate another or that one party “convey a particular right” to another.6 It is this characterization of the constructive trust that has given way to criticisms that the constructive trust is no more than a fiction created by the courts and is not comparable to an express trust. More specifically it is argued that the constructive trust is confusing and with an unclear doctrinal basis because it interprets entirely personal matters relative to property and thus does not follow a clear and concise doctrine.7 Despite the criticisms about the nature and doctrinal basis of the constructive trust, it is based on a sound doctrine: the equitable distribution of property.8 As Hudson explains, the constructive trust serves a practical purpose. It provides a means by which the courts may imply a trust so that “justice is done on the facts before” the courts “on the basis of preventing unconscionable conduct”.9 It therefore follows that constructive trusts are not based on a doctrine that facilitates random distribution of property. Rather, the constructive trust is applied “to ensure that an ethical notion of good conscience is maintained in English law.”10 The House of Lords puts the doctrinal basis of the constructive trusts in its proper perspective by noting the equity has always focused on the conscience.11 Hudson argues that constructive trusts are imposed: ...on the basis of the defendant knowing of some factor which affects her conscience in ...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Are the constructive trust rules affecting co-owned housing based on Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1394530-land-law-essay
(Are the Constructive Trust Rules Affecting Co-Owned Housing Based on Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1394530-land-law-essay.
“Are the Constructive Trust Rules Affecting Co-Owned Housing Based on Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1394530-land-law-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
ra
rabernathy added comment 1 year ago
Student rated this paper as
This essay was always my weak point. I could never finish it on time. Still, after I found this particular document, I understood how it should be completed. So, I performed my research afterward and completed the essay in several hours, instead of days as it was previously.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Are the constructive trust rules affecting co-owned housing based on the common intention of the parties

Moffetts Concept of Trust

Several formalities have been associated with the development of the trust, most of which have been formulated with the intent to prevent fraud and misappropriation in the transfer of property, especially from the point of view of payment of taxes, stamp duties and such related fees for the capital wealth. While trust law is said to be administered based on principles of equity, the reality has been quite different and the results of adjudication in trust disputes have been primarily ad hoc, conditioned from a financial perspective rather than to establish any distinct equitable principles. In fact, the law of formalities has created inflexibility in some cases and there have been instances where the interests of beneficiaries hav...
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Sanctification that Based on Calvins Theology

The first part will try to define morality while the succeeding section will tackle the different meanings attributed to sanctification, giving emphasis on what is taught by Calvinism. In light of this, the issue that links sanctification with morality will be examined through a discussion on the definition of morality. This paper will conclude with its findings.
In the strictest sense, morality refers to “which is innately regarded as right or wrong (Morality 2006).” There isn’t a concise meaning associated with morality as it often refers to set of judgments and principles shared by individuals in within the same culture, religion, and philosophical concepts which separate and identifies actions which are...
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

Comparison of Constructive Trust with the Remedy of Restitution under the Common Law

When trying to locate the property loss because of a transfer made under a breach of trust, there are certain issues that need to be taken into account. At the first level, the remedies available by the relevant legal texts tend to differentiate not only regarding their requirements but also their level of protection provided. On the other hand, the application of the rules of common law instead of the ones of equity has to be considered thoroughly and the party that suffered the damage has to evaluate all the parameters regarding his choice as each of the above legal paths has its own advantages. From a general point of view, it has been stated that ‘a person who confers a benefit, normally a money payment, under a mistake,...
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

The UK Contract Laws and Consent of the Contracting Parties

There is no acceptance yet by Betty as far as Andrew’s offer to sell the car is concerned on November 3, before Andrew sold the car to Colin; hence his offer to sell to Betty who was deemed to be accepted on November 5 was not perfected as of November 3 when Andrew made the sale. This answer is based on English law which adopts the theory that “a contract is not formed unless the acceptance corresponds exactly to the terms of the offer.” (Vergne, François, n.d.). Calling the same as "mirror image rule", it argued that “an acceptance which is not in conformity with the offeror's terms is considered as a rejection of the offer” (Vergne, n.d.) citing (Tinn v. Hoffman & Co., 1873). Because of t...
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Analysis of Trust Law Case

Once the court is satisfied that the “declarant had the requisite intention it will strive to validate it.”3 Certainty of intention will therefore be the most important element for determining whether or not the letter constitutes an enforcable trust.

Assuming that the trust held by the trustees under the father’s will trust in favor of Sally and the trust agreement in respect of the horse are valid trusts the question of cetainties are not valid except to the extent that a new trust is created in favor of Sally’s children and thereby extinguishing the previous trusts. This is particularly so with respect to the will trust. The trust agreement over the horse only involves the disposition of a ben...
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

A Problem with Categorizing the Secret trust and ascertaining its Jurisprudential Basis

The will itself will make no mention of the secret beneficiary and o9n the face of the will it appears that the money has been left to the named person for them to dispose of the funds as they see fit. Anyone reading the will would be likely to assume that the money has been bequeathed for the benefit of the named individual. Only the named person and the testator will know of the identity of the secret beneficiary and the agreement for the money to be held for the secret beneficiary will not be committed to writing anywhere. With half secret trusts, the trustee will appear in the will as holding the money on trust but the names of the beneficiary will be withheld.

Three elements have to be present for the creation of a...
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Critique of Technological Innovations, Activity Based Costing and Satisfaction Article by Davood Askarany

Many of the innovations have been introduced as early as 1980, such as “activity-based costing (ABC); activity management (AM) and activity-based management (ABM); local information system (LS); balanced scorecard (BS); life cycle costing (LCC) and target costing (TC) [and] strategic management accounting (SMA).” (Askarany, Smith and Yazdifar 54). However, few of these have been implemented and utilized to their full potential. The authors propose to find a reason for this.

ABC focuses on costs associated with activities, but also evaluates whether those activities add value, thus providing a means of understanding how to most effectively reduce costs. In addition to cost reduction benefits, applying ABC giv...
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Billing System Upgrade with Web-Based Version Project of Rick Auto Enterprises: A Communication Plan

The project is envisioned to involve changes to existing business processes, changes to existing jobs, and/or the creation of new positions. With the new web-based version, customers and auto brokers will be able to view and pay their bills online, as well as access a billing customer service agent is required. This change will affect the billing, sales, and customer service departments but it is expected to reduce costs, improve customer satisfaction, and reduce the number of days for outstanding accounts receivable.
Ownership of the existing system rests with the Billing Department. However, with the benefits projected to be derived from the upgraded system, especially with the implantation of the web-based version, the Cus...
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study

Esentials of Management: Team-Based Learning

Setting up successful teams is a prerogative of any organization and in the business world of present times; it is very much a need rather than a desire. The businesses have changed so as to create more room for teams than individual working ethos. This has given space to more facilitation within the working environments of teams since they bring combined efforts and usage of more brains than a singular person. The factors that stand important in the wake of successful teams include a commitment towards common goals and a simplistic and solitary objective which must be kept in mind at all times. These factors underline the basis of the teams performing a singular whole than disjointed units within the framework of the organization...
6 Pages (1500 words) Report

Asher B. Durand and the American Landscape

... artist with an amazing love for wilderness, two generations of landscape painters consciously set out to create the first American art movement. Based in New York City they became to be collectively known as The Hudson River School. The founder members were Cole, Thomas Doughty and Asher B. Durand. These artists embraced landscape paintings as a medium of addressing profound philosophical questions of life and human aspiration. The members of this school imagined the natural world as a grand opera. With or without actors the scenery provided all the romance and the drama; lofty mountains, turbulent skies and divinely inspired sunlight. Durand was heavily influenced by Thomas Cole and after his death in 1848, became the leader...
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Macro and Microeconomics Factors in the UK Housing Market

The housing industry is divided into residential, commercial and industrial segments. Economists define supply in terms of service units, that is, a physical unit can be deconstructed into the services that it helps provide. These housing unit services are considered as an unobservable theoretical construct. Housing stock depreciates making it qualitatively different from a brand new constructed building.
The owner, user/owner and renter comprise the demand side of the housing market while the renovators and developers comprise the supply side of the market. In order to implement the simple demand and supply analysis to the housing markets, several modifications have to be made to the standard microeconomic procedures and ass...
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Are the constructive trust rules affecting co-owned housing based on the common intention of the parties for FREE!

Contact Us