Nobody downloaded yet

On the debate surrounding legislation for same-sex couples - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
The research will argue that same-sex couples in civil partnership are not given exactly the same rights as married couples, and that the law would need to straighten these discrepancies before considering the extension of civil marriage to same-sex couples. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
On the debate surrounding legislation for same-sex couples
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "On the debate surrounding legislation for same-sex couples"

Download file to see previous pages From the research it can be comprehended that a same-sex partner residing with his/her partner is considered to be a cohabitee. Such an arrangement causes the person to have no rights invested in the property and the risk of homelessness is very real should separation occur. Cohabitants possess no statutory rights to occupation; such rights are only claimable through the use of equitable principles such as trusts or proprietary estoppels. The court indeed has shown a desire to rule in a manner that prevents injustice, though this is a far cry from the positive rights that are granted to married couples. The courts have indeed expressed a need as well as a desire for Parliament to reform the law in cases such as Hammond v Mitchell and Stack v Dowden. Many ask why, if the law is prepared to assign the same rights to same-sex couples and married couples, it does not simply allow the former to enjoy the institutions of marriage. The same need for reform is evident in the law in relation to children. While the Children Act 1989 defines parental responsibility in a gender-neutral manner, it is most often the case that the mother of a child born out of wedlock is given automatic parental rights. How does this fare when applied to same-sex couples who are parents? It is clearly recognised that “the legal definition of families has changed over time”. This is evident in, as has been stated, the change in social attitudes towards the institution of marriage, the birth of children out of wedlock, and the rights of unmarried couples. The law, although it has greatly moved forward in relation to heterosexual partnerships, has been reluctant to codify any such similar approach to same-sex couples. The courts have attempted as far as is possible to interpret the law in a manner that allows unmarried couples (heterosexual and same-sex) to be granted the same, or similar rights to married couples. In other decisions, the court has clearly expressed a desire for legislation which gives them the freedom to positively grant same-sex couples the same rights as married couples, recognising that this needs an extension of the law of civil marriage to same-sex couples. In the case of Fitzpatrick v Sterling Housing Association (2000), the House of Lords recognised that the definition of family has increasingly become a legal concept. While the couple in the case were not married, the court could not class them as family, yet it expressed a need to reform the law to allow ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“On the debate surrounding legislation for same-sex couples Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1393504-family-law-see-instructions-for-full-title-please
(On the Debate Surrounding Legislation for Same-Sex Couples Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1393504-family-law-see-instructions-for-full-title-please.
“On the Debate Surrounding Legislation for Same-Sex Couples Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1393504-family-law-see-instructions-for-full-title-please.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF On the debate surrounding legislation for same-sex couples

The debate over same-sex marriage

...The Debate Over Same-Sex Marriage Introduction Since the 1950s gay people have been speaking out about their rights and by 1969, there became a movement for gay rights. According to Cabaj and Purcell, the conversations about gay rights was the precursor to same-sex marriage (Cabaj). Purcell stated that same-sex marriage first came into the forefront of the news and controversy in mid-199, when three same-sex couples challenged the Hawaiian Supreme Court for their right to marry. The Supreme Court ruled that the decision by the state “might be unconstitutional” (29). This...
20 Pages(5000 words)Research Paper

Same-sex relationships and same-sex families

...% of Americans opposed interracial marriages while 48% believed that this should be a crime. This led to a series of lawsuits through groups such as The American Center for Law and Justice which believed that domestic partnerships of any kind should be recognized, specifically because of equality provisions which were a part of the samesex couples. This basis led to debates such as the Anti – Gay Movement and the belief that those who practiced gay and lesbian identities were considered criminals (Cahill, 2006). The concept of the healthy environment and the psychology of the family is the main political battle that has been used for same –...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Same-Sex Couple Families

...? Same-Sex Couple Families This paper reviews the article d “Same-Sex Couples' Kids Less Likely to Have Private Health Insurance: Study” by Amy Norton, drawing few noteworthy inferences regarding the stressors inhibiting the confidence level of same-sex couples to raise their children. Accordingly, the paper critically evaluates the narrated facts in the article to obtain a thoughtful understanding to the problem exhibited throughout the discussion. Summary The article titled “Same-Sex Couples' Kids Less Likely to Have Private Health...
3 Pages(750 words)Article

Same Sex Marriage

...is an institution traditionally reserved for the heterosexual couples. Given the traditional legal definition of marriage, same sex couples face certain challenges. Same sex marriage is a controversial issue with staunch opposition due to deeply entrenched religious and patriarchal opinions. Those in favor of same-sex marriage have a lot at stake on this particular issue, as many financial and legal benefits are bestowed upon married couples. Pragmatically speaking, marriage ought to be an institution that allows two loving people to legally fulfill their commitment towards each other...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Same Sex Marriage

...With the flourishing same-sex communities in all parts of the world, especially in the developed nations, same-sex relationship issues have come to be discussed in all sorts of local, national and international forums. Those with homosexual preferences, whether gay or lesbian, are trying to gain recognition and acceptance. While an acceptance of the sexual preferences of this community by the heterosexual community at large has been slow in coming, a large number of countries now recognize the rights of homosexuals to education, employment and lifestyle at par with the rest of the society. In some countries like Netherlands, Denmark and so on, same-sex unions are now legally acceptable. Urgent debates have now arisen between... commitment...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Same sex couples adoting children

...-parent but he or she does not have formal or legal rights as far as the child is concerned. Different states follow different legislation as far as parenting rights by the partner is concerned. Recent studies have demonstrated that there were 1,400 same-sex couples raising children in Alameda County and close to 700 in San Francisco (Hendricks). The study further stated that a large number of these couples were nonwhites. Sixty-nine percent of the same sex couples were lesbians. It also said that the income of such families was 17% lower than an average family. With lesbians families adopting more than...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Should Same-Sex Couples Be Allowed to Adopt

...Debate: Should Same Sex Couples Be Allowed to Adopt Same sex couples should not be allowed to adopt due to the many different negative outcomes which children inside these relationships experience. The homosexual couple is one which statistically is more likely to break up than their heterosexual counterparts (post-gazette.com, 2002) which poses a risk to the developmental health of the child. Children tend to develop a form of attachment to their caregivers in any kind of parental relationship. When there is a constant risk of break-up within the relationship, or fighting which ensues over...
4 Pages(1000 words)Assignment

Should same sex couples be allowed to adopt

..., it will create severe social problems and the traditional beliefs and the natural laws will undergo changes. Any attempt to change the nature’s laws is a dangerous act. Stability is the key to raising an emotionally and mentally healthy child; unmarried and homosexual partners simply cannot provide the stability that married heterosexual couples can give. "Children need a role model, both male and female (Gay Adoption Debate and Poll: Should Gays and Lesbians be allowed to Adopt Children?, n. d). The cohesion and strength of the same sex couple family life would be less compared to the normal couple family lives. It is possible that...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Same Sex Couples Raising Children

...The study is focused on the same-sex couples raising children. The main objective of the paper is to present the different perspectives of the media regarding the issue. The issue has been analyzed through the presentation of the different factors affecting same-sex couples and their capability to adopt and raise children. The media representations on the issue and the effects of being raised by same-sex parents were also presented. Lastly, the issue had been analyzed through the social perspective of the queer theory and the postmodern theory. The issues related to...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

The Marriage (Same Sex Couples)

...amid the first decade of the 21st century. In May 2013, thirteen nations (as Netherlands and Argentina), and a few sub-national administrations (parts of Mexico and the United States), permit same-sex couples to wed. Uruguay and New Zealand have both sanctioned laws to legitimize same-sex marriage, which has come into energy in August 2013. Same-sex marriage laws have differed by jurisdiction, being differently treated through anauthoritative change to marriage laws, a court decision focused around protected certifications of fairness, or by immediate prominent vote. The acknowledgement of...
17 Pages(4250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic On the debate surrounding legislation for same-sex couples for FREE!

Contact Us