StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Leadership - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Leadership" states that most agencies are against the creation of oversight because they feel that the oversight procedure lacks the experience and understanding of the police work made them feel it is unfair to them…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.4% of users find it useful
Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Leadership
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Leadership"

? INTRODUCTION In any part of the world, public depends on the criminal justice system to protect them and to provide solutions regarding the crime. Nevertheless, the said system also shapes the direction of the crime policy. The criminal justice systems as well as agencies related to them are accountable among other matters such as protecting the public, enforcing the law, identifying the transgressors, treating criminal behaviour, bringing the guilty to justice, and in the implementation of the peace and order. The public relies on this vast system to protect them from evil doers and promoting justice to their lives (Siege, J. S. 2010). As the criminal justice system expands, civilians are entitled to their role in determining the standards by which they are treated and being policed by authority being in powers particularly those who use the lethal force. Moreover, civilians are given the rights to form an independent civilian review board that would serves as the venue in engaging with their grievances, concerns, and voice out their recommendations. It is important to consider that the civilian review board to be truly effective must be independent. Nevertheless, it must conduct an independent investigation regarding the complaints and not a review of an investigation conducted by the police internal affairs bureau, or otherwise, the investigation may result to the illusion of the oversight without the element of truth and reality. The veracity or truthfulness of the civilian review board will be derived directly from the civilian review of the police conduct and not vice versa. OVERSIGHT MODEL Compliance on the part of the police has been the subject in the creations of oversight in the criminal justice system in almost all the communities around the world. To drop a few, there are four oversight models to be considered in the implementation of justice in the communities. 1. Political Oversight- This is usually appointed by the mayor of a certain town. Critics of this oversight model claim that the political panels is not independent and do not hold on to the interest of the minority communities. 2. Citizen Oversight – Critics of this oversight claims that the members of the panels lack resources, and is not authorized to adopt changes in the agency policies and procedures. 3. Judicial Oversight – In this model, DOJ has the mandate to review, monitor, and evaluate the compliance of the agencies concern. Furthermore, these includes force policy revisions, and protocols. 4. The Police or Corrections Compliance Office However, in a democratic society, police holds accountable with many things. Furthermore, some of the responsibilities they are accounted for are dealing with crime and disorder, professionalism, and respect when it comes to dealing and treating people. It is therefore relevant to recommend citizen oversight among the models above to be discussed in this paper and to scrutinize the accountability of the police to the public about the treatment they render to the people. CITIZEN OVERSIGHT The creation of oversight system among the communities is rarely identical and most of the time is different. However, most of the reviews in the citizen oversight fall into four main types. 1. Citizen Review Board - Citizens are investigating on the allegations of the police misconduct and give a recommendation on the finding to the head of the agency. This is considered to be the most independent citizen review model. 2. Police Review/Citizen Oversight - Officers do the investigations on the allegations and findings were developed. After, the citizens review and recommend by which the head of the agency approves or not. Under this model, steps and process of the complaints are handled by the police. A board of citizen’s reviewer reviews those actions. Nevertheless, this model is considered to be less independent compared to Citizen Review Board. 3. Police Review/Citizen-police Appeal Board - Complainants may appeal to the citizen’s review about the findings established by the agency and make recommendations to the head of the agency. In this model, the process in the complaint is being handled by the police. Moreover, if the result of the investigation is not satisfactory on the part of the complainant, an appeal could be made to the board about how the first investigation was done. In this model, there is a limited participation on the part of the citizen. 4. Independent Citizen Auditor - Auditor will be investigating the thoroughness and the fairness of the process done by the agency in the acceptance and investigation of the complaints. In this model, the process in the complaint is totally in the jurisdiction of the police. However, the audit team has the access in the process and in the review for the accuracy of the findings. All the policemen belong to one huge and national organization and they hold on to the protection of the organizations integrity. In view of this, this agency has a big tendency of protecting themselves against the involvement of some policemen in the crimes committed to the ordinary people. The citizen’s oversight is considered to be the people’s protector against abusive police in the authority. However, law enforcement agencies shows to be reluctant in the creation of oversight Along with the implementation of such system in the communities, this agency found to be troublesome. Most of the agencies are against the creation of the oversight because they feel that the oversight procedure lack the experience and understanding of the police work that made them feel it is unfair for them. LEGAL ISSUES OF THE OVERSIGHT Some of the legal issues in the creation of the oversight are as follows: Civilian oversight must reach even farther into policing Constitutional structure to enforce the oversight is incomplete. To strengthen the expertise, resources, and independence of the oversight, there must be a creation of the permanent structure such as police ombudsman, civilian complaint review board, monitors, inspector general and independent complaint directorate. Other issues include: Size and Composition Nature and Degree of Civilian Involvement Case by Case Review vs. Policy Review Type of Complaints Reviewed Scope of Authority PROS AND CONS OF THE OVERSIGHT PROS: Increase or reinforce public trust? Enhance police accountability? Create a more ethical police culture? Increase the number of legitimate complaints? Diffuse hostility toward the department? Reduce or prevent officer misconduct? Improve fairness and thoroughness of misconduct review? Ensure that misconduct will be dealt with effectively? CONS: How satisfied are current police personnel with the internal affairs process? Do they feel the current internal affairs approach is sufficient and fair? Do they want to see a change, such as utilizing a form of citizen oversight? Do they have concerns about citizen review authority/powers? How will consideration or adoption of a form of citizen review impact officer/civilian employee morale? Is the institutional culture of the department strongly inclined toward ethical behaviour? CONCLUSION Across the globe, it is relevant to conclude that law enforcement leadership serves as the primary key to police officer accountability. The chief of the agency plays vital role in the influence of good moral among the officers behaviour by setting standards in recruitment and in developing intelligent and responsible officers that would look after the welfare of the ordinary people. Nevertheless, the use of objective review such as the creation of oversight is just one of the several tools that can be applied to help law enforcement to be responsible with their duties towards ordinary people. REFERENCES Siegel, J. S. (2010). Introduction to Criminal Justice. Wadsworth Califronia: USA. The International Association of Chiefs of Police, (2000). Police Accountability and Citizen Review. Retrieved on August 11, 2011 at http://www.theiacp.org/PoliceServices/ExecutiveServices/ProfessionalAssistance/Ethics/ReportsResources/PoliceAccountabilityandCitizenReview/tabid/193/Default.aspx#sec6 Stone, C. And Bobb, B. (2002). CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT OF THE POLICE IN DEMOCRATIC SOCIETIES. Retrieved on August 11, 2011 at http://www.vera.org/download?file=95/Civilian%2Boversight%2B2.pdf Farrow, J. And Pham, T. (2003). Citizen Oversight of Law Enforcement: Challenge and Opprtunity. Retrieved on August 11, 2011 at http://www.policechiefmagazine.org/magazine/index.cfm?fuseaction=display_arch&article_id=111&issue_id=102003 Schmidt, W.W. (2004). Criminal Justice Compliance Officer: A new title and duties for self-governance responsibilities within law enforcement and corrections agencies. Retrieved on August 11, 2011 at http://www.aele.org/compliance.pdf Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Criminal justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1390799-criminal-justice
(Criminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1390799-criminal-justice.
“Criminal Justice Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1390799-criminal-justice.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Leadership

Law Enforcement Information Sharing

This qualitative case study explores ways and means on how law enforcement agencies share information to combat transnational crime and terrorism in the post 9/11 era from the perspective of officials charged to enforce relevant laws and policies.... How do law enforcement agencies share information to combat transnational crime and terrorism in the post 9/11 era?... What human factors contribute to the successful implementation and sustainment of technological systems used to share information in the law enforcement community?...
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

U.S. criminal justice

The 17,500 law enforcement agencies of the country are trying very hard to achieve these objectives (Hudzik, J.... The 17,500 law enforcement agencies of the country are trying very hard to achieve these objectives (Hudzik, J.... The objectives of the criminal justice system ensure safety of the society through justice for individual, personal liberty and the right to due process.... he extent to which the United States criminal justice system has achieved these goals....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Impact of the Broken Window Theory and How It Directly Impacts the Criminal Justice System Today

From the paper "The Impact of the Broken Window Theory and How It Directly Impacts the criminal justice System Today" it is clear that it is evidently clear that the Broken Windows Theory has had far-reaching effects in criminology and the criminal justice system in general.... The criminal justice system has the following main components: Corrections, police and the courts that are responsible for deterring crime by trying, apprehending, and punishing the offenders (Lilly, Cullen, and Richard 7)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Leadership Styles and Ethics for Law Enforcement Administrators

This research paper "Leadership Styles and Ethics for law enforcement Administrators" discusses by way of comparing and contrasting autocratic and democratic leadership styles.... In law enforcement, there are several leadership styles that can be adapted to fit situations, and all have advantages.... No other profession demands high ethical standards than that of law enforcement given the challenges that the officers have to grapple with on the ground....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Leadership Personal Issues and the Rules of Law

The police force has been equipped with the modern security devices to enhance rapid response to emergences and quality service delivery to the American The inclusion of educational requirements and training in the American law enforcement docket has revolutionized the entire practice.... ?Several laws have been enacted to facilitate smooth functionality and implementation of the transformation policies in the American law enforcement system.... resently, the law enforcement in America is perceived as a professional and not just a mere occupation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Law Enforcement in the USA

This study 'law enforcement in the USA' aims at analyzing different aspects of law enforcement in the USA including comparing and contrasting different law enforcement agencies, highlighting eligibility requirements for entry-level positions in the law enforcement agencies.... The author states that law enforcement in the USA requires the concerted efforts of different levels of government to achieve safety.... There are four main law enforcement agencies in the USA including local, state, county, and federal law enforcement agencies providing law enforcement to the American citizens....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Leadership in a Law Enforcement Organization

In the paper 'Leadership in a law enforcement Organization,' the author focuses on the police department, which can be considered as most important and critical to our contemporary democratic and federative system.... The author states that the ways in which leaders in a law enforcement organization seek to manage administration and personnel are very much linked to the functional order and hierarchy of police agencies.... The National Center for Victims of Crime visualizes law enforcement as a key component of the criminal justice system, along with the other components such as 'prosecution, defense attorneys, courts, and corrections' (National Center for Victims of Crime, 2008, p....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Leading, Organizing and Decisions in Criminal Justice

The paper "Leading, Organizing and Decisions in criminal justice" is a good example of a management essay.... The paper "Leading, Organizing and Decisions in criminal justice" is a good example of a management essay.... The paper "Leading, Organizing and Decisions in criminal justice" is a good example of a management essay.... Future leaders in criminal justice face greater and complex issues.... he specific problems in the management of crime and criminal justice within local governments vary across regions....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us