StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Arguments for Commodification - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Arguments for Commodification" states that there has been an increasing discussion about the need for the commodification of body parts. The human body can be marketed in parts; various professions have been at the forefront to perpetuate the commodification of human body parts…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Arguments for Commodification
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Arguments for Commodification"

In support of this view, the article illustrates how biomedicine and bioscience are responsible for the increasing view of the commodification of body parts. Arguments for commodification Commodification of humans is regarded as an important activity applied in medical terms without people viewing it in the contradictory perspectives that the practice seems to generate. For instance, the article outlines the process where people have had to donate blood and various tissues to save the lives of other people. According to this article, an object only becomes a commodity when it gets its use-value; this is when it is subjected to a form of commercial exchange (Tumber 2004, 23).

However, the case of the human body is different; here reification or objectification has to be fulfilled first. In this process, a physical and mental process is needed first to separate the body parts before becoming an object. Mass Media and CommodificationMaas media has been criticized as a force contributing to the commodification of human body parts; this is through the way they treat women; they depict a society that portrays humans like potential exhibits that can bring income. Across various media, human bodies in exhibitions have portrayed evil characters that go against the norms and values of society.

According to this article, it’s still hard for many people to view the media as a significant force in the commodification of body parts despite the examples available. Strengths and weaknesses of the article's research have been carried out with due regard to the scientific and medical contributions to the concept of commodification as it is being applied in different areas of life. It outlines various ways in which people have exchanged body organs and donated blood on various occasions without bringing in the concept of commodification (Waldby, Rosengarten & Fraser 2004, 65-6).

However, the article does not clearly provide scientific evidence to delink the cultural perspectives held against the practice. For instance, other people have continued to hold that selling body parts for diverse purposes is showing is disregarding the value of the life of the concerned people. 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Seale, C., D. Cavers and M. Dixon-Woods, (2006) Commodification of Literature review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1660610-seale-c-d-cavers-and-m-dixon-woods-2006-commodification-of-body-parts-by-medicine-or-by-media-body-and-society-121-25-42
(Seale, C., D. Cavers and M. Dixon-Woods, (2006) Commodification of Literature Review)
https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1660610-seale-c-d-cavers-and-m-dixon-woods-2006-commodification-of-body-parts-by-medicine-or-by-media-body-and-society-121-25-42.
“Seale, C., D. Cavers and M. Dixon-Woods, (2006) Commodification of Literature Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1660610-seale-c-d-cavers-and-m-dixon-woods-2006-commodification-of-body-parts-by-medicine-or-by-media-body-and-society-121-25-42.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Arguments for Commodification

The Commoditization of Human Life and Body Parts

The paper "The Commoditization of Human Life and Body Parts" highlights the main arguments against the commoditization of human life.... Those who support commoditization argue that it helps benefit both the donors and the recipients/infertile couples because both their needs are met in the end....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Overview and Analysis of the Possibilities of Genetic Engineering

The paper "Overview and Analysis of the Possibilities of Genetic Engineering" discuss any alternate views which are relevant to the topic and their ethical basis and evaluates the effectiveness of any methods used to 'guard against' increasing commodification of human life.... ... ...
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Ethics of the Sale of Body Parts

There are also various arguments that have been put forth against the sale of organs and three of those are concerned with commodification of human anatomy, exploitation of the poor and the unjustifiable pressure endured by potential donors.... In regard to commodification, it is often argued that selling one's organs is synonymous with debasing oneself and equating a human's worth to that of ordinary commodities.... The sale of human organs raises various ethical arguments both in support and against such undertaking....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Citizenship and Welfare

The idea of welfare is a dynamic concept, which has been evolving over the years.... The basis of welfare is the freedom of the individual to make choices.... During the days of absolute rulers, whether they were sovereigns or self-proclaimed heads of states, the idea of welfare was rather a Hobson's choice....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Creativity versus Commodification

The paper "Creativity versus commodification" highlights that the commodification of art forms is definitely an issue in today's world.... Yet, both articles are lacking in the basic area of defining the arguments and theories in terms of relevant concepts like globalisation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

The Cultural Industry in Relation to the International Events Industry

The Frankfurt School's key arguments in regard to the culture industry are summarized.... Firstly, the Frankfurt School's key arguments in regard to the culture industry will be summarized.... Secondly, these arguments will be evaluated critically....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Response to Dallas Smythe Today in Terms of Marxism

Also, he takes a peek at the resurgence of interest in the element of the commodification of communication and the media.... Third, he looks at the concept of internet prosumer commodification.... This paper 'Response to Dallas Smythe Today in Terms of Marxism" focuses on the fact that of late, there seems to be an increase of interest in the role of Marxism, especially in the media and communication studies....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Commodification of Human Organs

This paper "commodification of Human Organs" focuses on the fact that Berman argues that although legalizing organ sales is callous and abhorrent, the well-meaning attempts to bar organ sales has created something worse – an illegal market in body parts.... He uses examples, history and facts to back up his claims and arguments....
6 Pages (1500 words) Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us