Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
[Instructor Name] Case Solutions 1. The action taken by animal rights group is a fully-protected action and the court of law may intervene into this matter only if there are compelling reasons to do it or there is a chance of anarchy that will spread out due to the open expression committed by the animal rights group…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.6% of users find it useful
Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts"

Case Solutions The action taken by animal rights group is a fully-protected action and the court of law may intervene into this matter only if there are compelling reasons to do it or there is a chance of anarchy that will spread out due to the open expression committed by the animal rights group. The Time, Place and Manner doctrine of the court would compel the court of law to take reasonable action against the animal rights group but another doctrine of the court, i.e. Public Forum” would encourage the court to take no harsh actions. This is because Public Forum doctrine provides a levy to the animal rights group as they organized their protest on sidewalks and in the parks (McClory). 2. No, the news director is not right because the reporter and news team has not heard the opinion of Assistant Principal Johnson on student’s claim. Since the news team has decided to go on-air with the report, there are chances that either the students or the news team is committing would be seen by the Assistant Principal as slander and thus implying that the speech is partially protected. These types of scenarios are considered to be coming under the heavy regulations by the official authorities as this would damage the reputation of the Assistant Principal and he might file a case against the reporter and the News Director. Moreover, the newspaper has the liability that it communicates correct information and news to the audience without biasness and investigating the whole scenario. The on-airing of the report in prime time show would violate the basic rules of journalism, i.e. to communicate at neutral place and manner so that no one is hurt by the news or the person who is convicted is not humiliated, unless there are solid evidences to prove claims. 3. The care of duty requires a professional to fulfill his professional duties at best and do not present lame excuses for the mistakes he or she makes while performing the duty. In the current scenario, the reporter is punishable by the court as he published the story without even asking Judge Jameson about his opinion or listening to his side of story. It was the duty of the newspaper in general and reporter in particular to complete their investigation of the matter before publishing the story in the newspaper. This act of the newspaper is a slander which would require government or the court to intervene and interrogate the reporter why did he publish the story without investigating the whole matter. Moreover, the Judge would be righteous to question the commitment of the reporter with his or her profession and might put charges of damaging his personal reputation. In this scenario, the reporter will have to compensate financially or morally by asking for public excuse to the judge. Even if he has solid proof against the Judge that he is involved in drug trafficking and child abuse, the reporter should have completed the investigations first. 4. Pica should tell her publisher that she will not replace her ace reporter Ivanna Noe or take her out of the investigation. This is because this act of Pica might de-motivate the reporter or the reporter might hit back on Pica by saying that she actually violated the workplace ethics or the employment contract. If the mayor thinks that the reporter might neutralize the investigation report according to her perception, that he should approach Pica and ask her to follow on the investigation on her own and see if there are unproven or dishonest content going to be published in the investigation report. Another argument that Pica might use in order to support her reporter’s reputation and her involvement in the series is that the if she stops Noe from participating into the series investigation under the pressure of a Government figure, this would be seen as the violation of Freedom of Press. It should b the utmost priority of the journalists that they remain neutral in investigative reports and does not take particular sides or favor any party. Pica should tell her publisher that when the report will be published, the conclusion would be provided keeping in view the facts and figures. Then if the mayor thinks that his personal reputation is being damaged on the basis of weak evidences, he is welcomed to challenge the report and take Pica and Noe to the court of law for resolution. Work Cited McClory, Toni. "The Free Speech Clause." 09 June 2006. 16 September 2013 . Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Explaining How Each of the Following Situations Would Be Resolved by Essay)
“Explaining How Each of the Following Situations Would Be Resolved by Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts


...the, primarily abuse of office. With such vile practices also, the judges are able to employ the use of original intent or judicial activism in their interpretation and application of the law in the entire court processes. Courthouse violence Courthouse violence is a prevalent issue nowadays in the courts. We have two main types of courthouse violence in a way that we observe premeditated or opportunistic and unpremeditated violence in courtrooms. The latter applies to the case \where individuals on opposite sides of the dispute resolve to vent their anger on their counterparts. This is an extremely perilous and detrimental to the safety of the people in the courtrooms (Jones, 2003)....
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Civilian courts and military courts

... system is in place. There is also a participation of the general public, while the defendant has a right to be present at trial, has the right to know all the evidence against him, thus ensuring that there is a fair and effective adversarial proceeding which is being followed before a decision is to be rendered against the enemy combatant. This approach is not achievable in a military tribunal lacks probity and competence compared to the efficiency of federal courts in a trial proceeding. This has been evident in the case of US during the trial of several terrorists involved in the 9/11 attack. “As the military commission system, though it has yet to yield any discernable benefits for the United States, has hampered cooperation... ? MILITARY...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

How Civil War Resolved Slavery Issue

...?Sur Lecturer How Civil War resolved slavery issue According to McLaurin (1991), slavery is the ownership and exploitation of an individual or a group of people by another group of persons or person. This was one of the social relationships traditionally in the human history. The origin of American Civil War can be traced from the bourgeois revolution. Although slavery was instrumental to the first rise of capitalist industry in North America, and in the Atlantic World, it became a major impediment in the mid 19th Century to the continuation of that process. The political power of planter prevented the nation unification under central government with capability of implementing an economic policy that was...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethiscal Situations

...You are promised a raise and it is months overdue. What do you do? Few things are more important to an employee than their salary. When a promise ismade by management regarding the salary, it is imperative that the promise be kept in order to ensure employees’ morale. If morale sinks, so does productivity. If I were in a situation where I had been promised a raise and it was months overdue, I would request to speak to the manager. I would sit down in their office and politely explain my situation to them. I would explain that promises are very important because people rely on them and they are an important part of the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay


.... This shows that the interpretation of the Court may not be consistent in the policies it upholds. However, it is consistent in shaping the understanding of the people of the constitutional provisions. This is how the Court is able to shape policy in a way. Ultimately, judicial review enables the Court to participate in policy-making, even if only indirectly. Some would contend that the Court has no role in policy-making. However, it is more proper to look at the power of judicial review as a necessary element of the checks-and-balances system. Under this system, there is recognition that each of the three branches of...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Resolved collective bargaining rights

...8 November Resolved collective bargaining rights The issue of whether or not to repeal resolved collective bargaining rights for state and local governments in New York has become a subject of debate amongst management professionals in the United States of America. However, the pendulum of this discussion swings towards the side in support of repealing the resolved collective bargaining rights for state and local governments in New York. One of the reasons that, the resolved collective bargaining right should be repealed is that, it costs the state and local taxpayers a huge sum of money. Thus, due to the high costs of running the resolved collective...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

How would you teach the following structures to Young Learners

...TEACHING OF YOUNG LEARNERS by The of the The of the School The and where itis located The Date How to present a new target language to a class? How to teach the meaning of the language (not just practice)? There are different suggestions on how and when to make a child familiar with a foreign language. However, nowadays the teaching is practiced on the early stages of children’s life. To present a foreign language to a class, a teacher must give children a comprehensive explanation that there is a place in the world where people speak different language and it is important for us to have the ability to communicate with these people. This purpose can be achieved only by learning their...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment


...Courts: Book Review Courts: Book Review The book “The introduction to American legal system” offers a detailed and comprehensive description of the complex American legal framework. The book vividly describes the prosecutor, defence attorney and judge’s legal presentations before the American judicial system. The book consequently comments on the wrong doings of the American legal system in relation the civic knowledge as per the system to the overall American society. Additionally, this book provides liberal and legal minds based comments on the public’s criticism and explains why a particular procedure or law is necessary in order to protect individual’s constitutional rights. Utterly,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review

Organizational Situations

.... Most significantly, inauguration of a recognition and reward scheme will be the foundation to success since each employee will strive to remain the best, hence an escalation in productivity. It is a win-win situation for both employees and the company. A conflicts resolution committee should handle any arising issue earliest possible, so that it may not bring divisions. All these activities, on adoption, will increase the moral of the staff, which will in turn heighten their productivity. The firm will regain more profits, and occurrences of layoffs will be past events. I will be very glad to discuss the memo with you on our scheduled meeting next week. I believe strongly that it will bear much fruits...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

Hypothetical situations

...HYPOTHETICAL SITUATIONS Affiliation Q1. Engineering is one of the professions among many others that need high moral standards and virtues. It holds the very sense of human living and exploring natural resources for the better living of the human being. There is a myriad of distinctive set of virtues that need to be adhered to as a way to ensure that in the process of exploration of the natural resources the biodiversity is not threatened. The virtues include the following, which are more of positive rules as opposed to normative one. Primarily, engineering as professional that is considered physical should observe personal honesty in the execution of its mandate. Personal honesty is a moral standard that should guide committed... and...
5 Pages(1250 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts for FREE!

Contact Us