Nobody downloaded yet

The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The Millian Principle Course Institution Date The Millian Principle “There are some harms, which even though would not transpire but for some acts of expression, however, cannot be included in the justifications for legal limitations on these acts…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.2% of users find it useful
The Criticisms of Scalons Millan Principle
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle"

Download file to see previous pages The Millian principle on Liberty simply means that certain harms may have had no probability of occurring if, not for some expressed actions. However, once these harms occur, the perpetrators may not justify their actions by legally restricting the actions. These harms include; those that originate from certain acts of expression, which include deceiving the individuals into having false beliefs and acts of expressions, which lead people into acting in ways that may lead to harmful consequences, especially in situations where there is a correlation between the act of expression and the succeeding harmful consequences. This correlation simply includes a mere fact that the act of expression facilitated the agents’ belief or led them to believe that it would be worthy performing the acts. Scanlon defended this principle by illustrating that it was a consequence of a certain idea regarding limits of justifiable political authority. That the government’s legitimate powers are restricted to people that can be protected on incompatibility grounds, with the citizen’s authority Scanlon (1979, p. 529). However, Scanlon does not fully agree with this principle. In his criticism, Scanlon argues that the Millian principle aimed at ruling out censorship arguments to which Mill was responding. The principle did this by declaring that the harmful consequences appealed by this argument cannot count as prospective justification for lawful restrictions of expression. However, Scanlon argues that there are supplementary ways of arriving at policies that would seem incompatible with freedom of expression. Freedom of expression refers to the participant’s right not to be prohibited from expressing themselves Bosmajian (1988 p. 122). Scanlon argues that the principle obtains what seems to be an implausible consequence in certain instances. He says that it would be difficult to see how this principle squares laws against misleading advertising on television. In this respect, Scanlon articulates that probably the regulation policies violate the freedom of expression Scanlon (1979, p.534). However, if the policies are acceptable, then they could be paradigms of paternalism. In Scanlon’s view, if anyone could take the first clause of the Millian principle as a restriction set aside in instances where rational capacities are rigorously diminished, it would constitute a dismissal of paternalism. An adequate justification doctrine of paternalism must consider certain factors such as the value associated with the ability for an individual to make their own decisions, the costs of making these decisions and the risks associated with empowering the government to make decisions on people’s behalf. These factors are unique to every case, and may be applicable even in cases where there is no common loss of rational capabilities. However, Scanlon argues that the problems associated with the Millian principle are not only limited to justification of paternalism. The principle also protects the interests of important audiences. These interests include the interest of choosing their beliefs and reasons to act on their beliefs. These interests rely not only on the freedom of expression, but also on means of accessing information, education and other issues critical to decision making. Sometimes, supplementary information is ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle Essay”, n.d.)
The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle Essay. Retrieved from
(The Criticisms of Scalon'S Millan Principle Essay)
The Criticisms of Scalon'S Millan Principle Essay.
“The Criticisms of Scalon'S Millan Principle Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle

Microeconomy principle

... + 3Qa 400= 3Qb + Qa (-3) 250 = Qb + 3Qa -1200= -9Qb -3Qa -950= -8Qb Qb= 118.75 400= 3(118.75) + Qa Qa= 43.75 Price A 250- 43.75= 206.25 Price B 400-118.75= 281.25 Total revenue PaQa+PbQb 206.25*43.75 + 281.25*118.75= 42421.9 The Quantity for each country: Qa= 250 – Pa Qb= 400-Pb References Chakravarty, SR 2009, Microeconomics, Allied Publishers, Mumbai. Mukherjee, S 2007, Modern Economic Theory, New Age International, New Delhi. Schmalensee, R, Armstrong, M & Porter, RH 2007, Handbook of industrial organization, Volume 3, Elsevier, Amsterdam.... Answers: a) First degree price discrimination refers to the type of price discrimination in which the buyer isable to pay the price the seller demands. The buyers are willing to pay the price fixed...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Account principle

...? Accounting Principles Answer (A) Budget in any corporate entity serves several purposes and those can be described as per the following. a) It is an instrument to plan and deploy the resources to achieve the short-term and long-term goals of any organization. b) It is a tool to control the activities of different subunits within the organisation. c) Budget exercise is used as a tool for forecasting and it can be used to motivate employees towards the set goals. Budgetary activity facilitates the planning process of the firm in a systematised manner keeping in view the organizational goals. Budget not only helps allocate resources and set the direction of the firm but also helps determine priorities to act in a manner...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Economic principle

...? Economic Principle Table of Data   Australia USA Qatar Total population  23,298,022  313900000  2051000 GDP/capita 23945.72 USD  49965.27 USD  102700 Labour force  11639200  154839000  1320000 % of population working in agriculture  3.3  0.7  2.3% % of population working in industry  21.6  20  51.8% % of population working in service  75.1  79.3  45.7% % of population living below the poverty line  12.5  14.8  0% Exports commodities  coal, crude petroleum, copper, liquefied natural gas, iron ore, meat, gold, wool, wheat, alumina   Industrial Supplies, automotive vehicles, Consumer goods, capital goods Capital Goods and components Food and beverages  Liquefied Natural Gas Petroleum products fertilizers steel Exports in $...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Precautionary Principle

... the exact meaning of the precautionary principle, which in its turn hinders its correct application. As a result, the lack of accurate and clear definition has recently become one of the primary points of criticism levied against the precautionary principle (Marchant and Mossman 2004; Sandin 2004). In order to resolve the controversy with definitions Cooney (2005) proposed to introduce three versions of the precautionary principle: weak, moderate and strong. The Rio definition is classified as weak within this structure. An example of moderate definition is described in the UK Biodiversity Action Plan 1994: "In line with the precautionary principle, where interactions are complex and where the available evidence suggests... in domestic and...
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay

Beneficiary Principle

...intended to give the said shares of stock to Joe. RSCPA is entitled to the shares in Smallco Ltd. This is in accordance with Grant's valid will, giving the rest of his estate to RSPCA, which is a registered charity. Since the state does not recognize the principle of "legitime" or "forced heirship", it is the will of the decedent that should be followed in the distribution of estate. By virtue of this provision in Grant's will which gives effect to the principle of residuary devises, all monies and properties of Grant that did not pass to some particular beneficiaries shall be given to RSPCA. c.) Grant's telephone conversation with Tom during his lifetime regarding the trust has no legal effect...
4 Pages(1000 words)Case Study

Moral Principle sell their children given the circumstances they may be going through. However, on the other hand, such practice may outline the failure of State and society as a whole that people are not been able to support their children and are resultantly selling them as commodities. Second objection that may be raised against this moral principle is the relative definition of good and bad. Viewing actions relatively may underlie that individual may perceive good or bad according to his own understanding and regardless of the well established principles as set by the society. This objection can be critical given the fact that it may highlight inherent weaknesses of the principle...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Peter principle

... Here Here Here Here The Peter Principle In the late 1960’s the Canadian psychologist Dr. LaurenceJ. Peter proposed a concept that would come to be known as the Peter Principle (Peter and Hull). The principle states that promotions within an organization of hierarchical structure will lead to employees being incompetent in their positions. Another way to explain the effect would be to say that we tend to believe that a person who is competent at one position will bring said competence with them as they rise through the company. Unfortunately, their competence can only be judged in relation to the skills required for a specific position of employment, and this idea was not taken into account in the supposedly common sense beliefs... of...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Rhetoric Principle

...Rhetoric Principle: Invest To Avoid Dying Poor If you demand a desperate person in life from me, I will avail two; a person who is unemployed and has not ventured into business and a person who is retired and never invested when he or she was earning. It all goes without saying that employment does not solve future needs if the earned salary is not put into a system than can replicate the resources (Hassett, 2008). It does not matter how much one earns, it matters how much one saves and ploughs back after paying bills. The wisdom of saving lies in the parable of a grain of wheat where one has to willingly allow the best seed to rot underground so as to get more in harvest. It is, therefore, wise for employed people to...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Marketing principle

...-based messages that are carried through social media, they have become a huge factor in most of the features of the behaviours associated with consumers like knowledge, collection of information as well as attitudes and opinions. International marketers are required to acknowledge the power and nature of the interaction that is held by customers who use social media. Accordingly, the capability to inspire the people effectively is the key quality that is required by the team responsible for marketing. Another critical factor associated with social media marketing is that the person responsible for marketing will be able to listen and evaluate the information that has been shared on the social media sites so that they may...
10 Pages(2500 words)Assignment

Management principle

...Management Principles SECTION A Question ONE: Leadership and its Importance in Effective Management. Effective management of any organisation that has goals requires a visionary, focused and effective leadership. Leadership is act of being in a position of bringing different heads together and guiding them towards a particular way in order to achieve a given goal. It involves the leader stepping up to a higher position and setting up a common objective, convincing the followers to follow and structuring strategies of achieving that set vision. This is a very key component in effective management as good leadership unites the diverse members and contradicting interests can be brought at a common level ground so that the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic The Criticisms of Scalon's Millan Principle for FREE!

Contact Us