The Dilemma That Exists - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Matt’s mother feels that the child should be brought up in the most natural way just like she was brought up during her early age. Her argument is that her seven year old child should take up his responsibilities without necessarily being rewarded for doing what he is supposed to do. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94% of users find it useful
The Dilemma That Exists
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Dilemma That Exists"

Case Scenario College: The Dilemma That Exists In this scenario, Matt’s mother feels that the child should be brought up in the most natural way just like she was brought up during her early age. Her argument is that her seven year old child should take up his responsibilities without necessarily being rewarded for doing what he is supposed to do. On the other hand, the psychological approach is that behaviorism principles be applied to help the child learn to distinguish right and wrong behavior by rewarding the child’s positive behaviors (Bailey and Burch, 2013). While it is right to reward a child’s behavior, it is more appropriate if the child learns to take up their responsibilities without necessarily expecting a reward. The dilemma that exists is that there is a conflict on whether to use the Matt’s mother’s intuition or to apply a psychological approach in helping the child to appreciate their duty of doing homework or even using respectful language. According to McNamara’s decision making model, if there exists a situational dilemma it is important to identify the basis of the conflict while choosing the right path to take on the situation (McNamara, 2008). The Basis of the Conflict A keen look at the scenario shows that there exists a conflict of interest between Matt’s mother and the welfare of the child in the child orientation program. The mothers wish is that the child learns to respect people, do its homework and doing his chores in the same manner that she learnt without necessarily receiving tokens for doing what they are supposed to do. On the other hand, there is an obligation to change the child’s attitude towards their roles and the end objective is to turn them into a responsible person. The mother suggests that the child be punished for the wrong actions rather than be only rewarded for doing what in her opinion should be done by any responsible child. McNamara (2008) provides that the role of a psychologist is to protect the interests of all the parties that are entangled in a dilemma without sacrificing the primary objective of the therapy program. In this scenario, the therapist would require to achieve the objective of transforming the child’s behavior without hurting the feeling of the mother about child appraisal. By upholding the Matt’s mother’s opinion, it would be satisfactory for her but at the end the reform process is likely to be ineffective. Consequently, the psychologist has a role to consider the best course of action that would resolve the dilemma effectively by harmonizing the interests of their client. Available Courses of Action After identifying the basis of conflict resulting to the ethical dilemma, McNamara (2008) recommends that the psychologist be able to plot the possible paths that they could use in resolving the dilemma. One of the possible actions that a therapist in this situation would take is to give the mother a go ahead in withdrawing the rewards that she had used to entice Matt and instead resort to punishment when the child does wrong. Going by this, the child would learn to associate wrong behavior with punishment and may at the end of it drop such behaviors. The danger with this method is that the child might develop a negative attitude towards the parent and to her homework which might affect their academic performance. Another option would be to disclose to the parent the essence of rewarding good behavior in encouraging a child and helping them to improve its relationship with the parent. The danger of this would be that the parent may be more likely to overwhelmed by her feeling to bring up her child naturally and the consequently the risk of withdrawing from the therapy program. This may have a negative impact on the child’s interest given that the priority of a therapist is to solve the primary problem of rehabilitating the child. Lastly, another path to take would be to provide harmonize the mother's idea with the behavioristic approach recommending the application of both punishments for wrong behavior and reward for positive behavior. In this case, Matt’s mother may be satisfied by the partial adopting of her intuition and is likely to respond to positively to such a procedure. Course of Action and Outcome Evaluation The best course of action in this scenario would be to harmonize the two methods of child rehabilitation by allowing the parent to discipline the child for its wrong behaviors and reward them for responsible behavior. The expected outcome of this course of action is that Matt would learn to associate the wrong behavior with punishment and the right behavior with a reward, which is likely to encourage him to be responsible. Consequently, the action would achieve the primary goal of rehabilitating the child through an affirmative reform process. The possible negative impact of this course of action would be the kind of attitude that is likely to be impacted on the child especially if the mother inflicts severe punishment on the child wherever they wrong, which would be a hindrance to the primary objective of therapy plan. To ameliorate the negative impact of this course of action, I would make Matt’s mother aware of the dangers of excessive punishment. Also, like Bailey and Burch (2013) points out, it would be necessary to start a re-evaluation program to check the success of this course of action after every one week by obtaining feedback from Matt’s mother on the progress. Consequently, it would be possible to modify the therapy program depending on the response of the child behavior to the rehabilitation scheme. References Bailey, J. and Burch, M., (2013). Ethics for Behavior Analysts. UK, London: Taylor & Francis. McNamara, K. (2008). Best practices in the application of professional ethics: Best Practices in School Psychology. National Association of School Psychologists. Retrieved from: <>Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“The Dilemma That Exists Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(The Dilemma That Exists Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
“The Dilemma That Exists Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Dilemma That Exists

Freedom as it Exists Today

...? Scholars agree that democracy began around 500 B.C.E. in Athens. Other contributing origins to the current American system of democracy include theMagna Carta, Renaissance humanism, and the Mayflower Compact. The Magna Carta is a document that nobles forced King John to sign limiting his powers and forming a parliament to keep the king in check. The Magna Carta serves as the basis for English citizen's rights and, eventually, for American citizens’ rights (Alchin, 2006). Renaissance humanism looked to classical Greece to generate secularism, advocate personal independence, individual expression, the right of each person to enjoy such freedoms, and also the free market system the U.S. purportedly operates under today. “Expansion... Scholars...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Racism Still Exists in America

...Racism Still Exists in America Introduction For a long time, America has been faced with racism. This form of social discrimination continues to exist despite the many campaigns against it. In fact, it keeps increasing. While the people of America make forward steps in fighting racism, others would pull them back. That is the reason why despite America having achieved much in anti-racism campaigns and elected a black president, the US President Obama has to address the nation behind a bullet proof glass because of racial threats against him. Similarly, there are a lot of racist groups operating in the country. All these exist amidst activities by many anti-racism organizations towards...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...? Ethical Dilemma Create an ethical legal decision-making dilemma involving an advanced practice nurse in the field of education,informatics, administration, or a nurse practitioner with a doctoral degree. “Nancy” is a nurse practitioner in a given family practice clinic. In one of her visits, she manages to see a patient, “Linet Wanyama,” a 28 year-old multigravida woman, who came with a pregnancy 5 weeks old after her last normal menstrual period. Linet Wanyama came to start attending her prenatal care for the first time in that place after moving from another town. Linet came alone to the clinic, though had been married for 7 years and the last born was 3 years of age. At the clinic, she stated that...
3 Pages(750 words)Case Study

A Problem Exists

...? A Problem Exists The discussion conducted in this paper mainly emphasizes towards providing the most effective solutions to mitigate the problems faced by foreign English learners in terms of their perceived variances. This study argues that the perceived discrimination as observed amid the foreign English learners can be mitigated with the application of effective measures based on ethos, pathos, logos and credibility principles. The detailed evaluation thus explains that foreign English learners are needed to be treated sympathetically and that there is a substantial need to enhance awareness among the native English speakers regarding their moral role simultaneously in the context. A Problem Exists...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

A Problem Exists

...? A Problem Exists This paper aims to discuss the various possible disadvantages that may arise resulting from the implementation of the stated solutions to perceived discrimination issues identified amid foreign English learners. In this aspect it has been viewed that the suggestion of establishing collaboration with authoritative bodies and non-governmental organizations to enhance the performance of ESL can be the most effective one apart from establishing groups constituting both native English speakers and ESLs, to eradicate the perceived discrimination amid this group. However, a critical assessment of the solutions revealed that lack of proper funding may result in discontinuation of the program, resulting in...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Mayan Language Exists

...Running Head: Mayan Language Proof Mayan Language Exists of the appears here] of the appears here] Proof Mayan Language Exists World history had a variety οf cultures that contribute to our societies. One οf the cultures is the Maya. Throughout their history the Maya were in contact with other groups οf Indians on all sides, particularly with the nations οf Mexico. For long periods sections οf the Maya were under the political domination οf Mexican rulers. Under such circumstances intermarriages must have been frequent. The Maya are therefore as mixed a race as most European peoples. The Maya country varied in its climate. The greatest developments were the center οf the lowlands and highlands οf northern...
11 Pages(2750 words)Essay

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma An ethical dilemma refers to a complex situation which involves choice between two conflicting s of action. Choice of one alternative mostly results to breach of another. (Reamer 7). The case is that of Alexis Hutchinson a 21 year old mother of a 10 year old son. Alexis was serving in the army and was due to be deployed in Afghanistan on November 5. Alexis however refused to join her colleagues when they were leaving claiming that she had not found someone she could trust to take care of her son while she was away. Her mother who had initially accepted to take care of the baby backed out claiming that she was already overwhelmed as she was taking care of some other ailing relatives. She...
2 Pages(500 words)Term Paper

Does sexual equality exists in our society In answering this question. Consider whether or not cultural equality exists, whether social equality exists, and whether biological equality exists

...Running Head: Sexual Equality in the Society Sexual Equality in the Society Clarisse Kehou HUM 110 Dr Ates March 12, Sexual Equality in the Society Sexual equality in the society can be considered as one of the social concerns. Gender equality is defined as the equality or the state of having equal rights between men and women. This includes the development of abilities, decision making, and freedom from the hindrances such as stereotypes, gender roles and prejudices. In a state of social equality, the behaviors, needs and aspirations of both genders are equally considered (UNESCO, 2000, p.5). But the society is stratified and prejudice, that the existence of social equality in a real and non-perfect world is in...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper


...Dilemma Dilemma The Mayor In the case of the Mayor of the large a possible consequence of his action is that the people or organizations who gave him gifts will expect that if they ask a favor from him in the future, he will grant it because of the favors which he has received in the past. One does not think that the actions of the Mayor are acceptable. Being the Mayor of the city, he is a decision maker with regards to contracts or grants. Accepting gifts from his constituents might result in biased decisions on his part, considering that some of the gifts are very expensive. He should not receive anything of economic value other than those required or allowed by law because it might influence him in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Does God exists

...Does God Exists INTRODUCTION God is conceived by most of the people in the world as supreme-being and primary object of faith. Different peopleliving in this world possess dissimilar views regarding the existence of God. However, no religious or mythological principle provides any actual evidence regarding the subsistence of God (Hughes 1-6). THESIS STATEMENT This paper intends to represent arguments for exploring the answer of the question concerning whether God subsists or not? 2. PROOF FOR GOD-ONTOLOGICAL ARGUMENT The ontological argument represents that God is greater than nothing that any individual can imagine. This argument states that everything in this universe is absolutely perfect. The ontological arguments stress... that...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic The Dilemma That Exists for FREE!

Contact Us