StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Postmodernism and History of Modern Historiography - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The review "Postmodernism and History of Modern Historiography " discusses literary experimentations in historical writing between 1970 and 1990 following cultural, economic, and political changes. The paper concerns innovative writings that led to postmodernism and post-structuralism in history…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Postmodernism and History of Modern Historiography
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Postmodernism and History of Modern Historiography"

Revolution in writing history has consequently changed the genealogy of traditional cultures and resulted in present study topics. It is vital that revolution in interpreting the discipline has led to doubts over the existence of factual history.

Summary of Global History of Modern Historiography-Chapter 6 (Pgs. 281-306)
Chapter 6 of the book entails a discussion of postmodernism and linguistic turn, development of contemporary historiography in sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America history, subaltern studies, and post-colonialism. The authors of the book relate the aforementioned discussion topics to current historical challenges in the post-war period. The authors use concepts of post-colonialism and postmodernism in discussing modernism in historical writing. Postcolonialism led to a revolution in non-western countries' systems including education, politics, and culture.

Africa, for example, experienced the postmodernism era when they adopted western culture after the attainment of independence. Subaltern studies remained imperative in explaining the historical effects of post-colonialism and war on both East and western countries. For instance, subaltern studies elucidated the dominance of Indian historiography. The authors also compare historiography emergence periods in different continents and factors that influenced its revolution. For example, Sub-Saharan Africa historiography started towards the end of the colonial period after that of India had begun. Historiography in Africa faced various challenges including racism. It is essential that the language had a fundamental role in historical writing, and it influenced the postmodern era.

Summary of John Edward Philips-Chapter 1
Chapter one of the book elaborates the meaning of history, how to write it, its relation to social sciences, and the differences between history and other disciplines. Moreover, the chapter develops potential factors that make history a real discipline and misconceptions about the fascinating subject. In explaining the definition and relation of history to other disciplines, the chapter focuses on African history. The book explains misconceptions that history is explicitly about society winners such as wars. Philips discusses that history entails an account of events recorded by winners, losers, and witnesses. It is imperative that historians have a significant role in creating and making coherent interpretations of the past based on present evidence .

History forms the central source of information for all disciplines including social sciences. Accounts of history make up theories and facts discussed in various disciplines such as science. It is imperative that historians conduct proper research to help enrich history as a source of information.

Summary of Postmodernism for Historians by Callum Brown
The book discusses postmodernism theory in relation to contemporary history research and applications. According to Brown, 2005 postmodernism has impacted positively on the development of history as a subject and other disciplines such as Journalism. Historians should embrace postmodernism theory in the research and teaching of history. Postmodern theory is imperative in modern history based on its seven main significant themes which include empiricist inheritance, sign, discourse, text, self, morality, and post-structuralism. The aforementioned themes explain the development of postmodernism and how historians use it in research and teaching unknowingly though they doubt its importance. Despite adverse critics by scholars on the relevance of postmodernism, the theory has vast influential applications in social research and teaching history as a discipline. Moreover, postmodernism has widened history by introducing new disciplines including popular culture, gay history, women's history, and postcolonial history.

Part 2
Two Discussion Questions in relation to Subject

Question 1
Has postmodernism led to the emergence of fiction in history?

Question 2
How important was linguistic diversity in the development of modern history?

Need to clarify the questions
Question 1 seeks to establish if the contemporary interpretation of ancient events has resulted in non-factual history and research. The question aims at eliminating misconceptions about historical development. Question 2 would address the relevance of languages in understanding modern history. Languages remained imperative in the historical writing of events from diverse cultures. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“1- is history fiction, ch. 9, 2- Global History of Modern Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
1- is history fiction, ch. 9, 2- Global History of Modern Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1661298-1-is-history-fiction-ch-9-2-global-history-of-modern-historiography-ch-6-pp-281-306-3-phillipsch1-4-brown-excerpts
(1- Is History Fiction, Ch. 9, 2- Global History of Modern Book Report/Review)
1- Is History Fiction, Ch. 9, 2- Global History of Modern Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/history/1661298-1-is-history-fiction-ch-9-2-global-history-of-modern-historiography-ch-6-pp-281-306-3-phillipsch1-4-brown-excerpts.
“1- Is History Fiction, Ch. 9, 2- Global History of Modern Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1661298-1-is-history-fiction-ch-9-2-global-history-of-modern-historiography-ch-6-pp-281-306-3-phillipsch1-4-brown-excerpts.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Postmodernism and History of Modern Historiography

The Anti-Aesthetic of Postmodernism: New Literary Definition or Just Critique

This essay will discuss the similarities between the authors' definitions of postmodernism and the manner in which their definition of anti-aesthetic acts as a critique of both the modern and classical views of art and society.... In his introduction to the book, Foster specifically argued that 'anti-aesthetic' does not mean an emphasis of modernism's principle of aesthetic repudiation, or an anti-art stance, but rather is a critique of the very notion of the aesthetic in its modern manifestations with pseudo-trans-historical and determinate meanings....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Postmodernism in American literature

In the late twentieth-century thought as evident in the postmodern novels of Capote and Spiegelman et al, one discovers some more fundamental questions such as how one memorizes in history and what is rendered as history in the midst of an awareness about the implication of the images in mediating memory and history.... The true value of this great work by Capote is evident in the fact that this ‘nonfiction novel' cannot be ignored in any account of the ‘new' American writing, especially the historiographic meta-fiction, of the 1960s and 70s and one may realize this novel as “a modern rewriting of the realistic novel – universalist in its assumptions and omniscient in its narrative technique....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

History and Historiography

Pocock, 1982)Background The sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth centuries have been roughly related to the history of Great Britain by historians.... They have termed it as the ancient history of early modern Britain.... From the paper "History and historiography" it is clear that the nation as well has been criticized by postcolonial history, whereas, fixed gender individualities have been criticized by feminist history.... The abovementioned old and new forms share different similarities, as well as, differences with each other, which results in the renewal of earlier histories, rather than their expunging from the historiography of the British....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

E.H. Carr and Historical Thought

he American historian and political philosopher Allan Bloom, in his cultural jeremiad on the state of university education in the closing decades of the twentieth century, lamented what he saw as the contemptuous antagonism felt for one another by the aforementioned three main divisions of modern academia.... The history of the question itself is very much intertwined with the development of modernity, the three-tiered epistemology found in the natural sciences, the social sciences, and the humanities, and the supposed loss of objectivity engendered by the onset and dissemination of postmodernist thought....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Is history fiction & a global history of modern Historiography

& a Global history of modern historiography Is History Fiction?... A Global History of Modern HistoriographyThis book provides a global analysis of the history of modern historiography.... A Global history of modern historiography.... Majority of books concentrated on analyzing the history of historiography from western perspective.... The first form is History as the scrutiny of information sources and history as the....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Architectural History, Theory & Criticism

It is considered a loyal opposition rather than a movement that is anti-modern.... Most post-modern concerns of the 1970s and the 1980s have become central to society (Jencks, 2012).... Jencks states that a typical post-modern building is a hybrid and one that dramatizes opposing trend mixtures, of the past, present, and future to create a miniature city.... hus, it is based on numerous codes, combining modern universal technology and local culture, in a double coding that is characteristic....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

What Is the Meaning of Postmodernism

This work called "Postmodernism" describes the meaning of the term post-modern based on Charles Jencks's question-article What Then is Post-Modernism and Jean-Francois Lyotard's Answering the Question: What is Postmodernism.... Jencks (1996, p 14) states that for a contemporary historian, a strong American state having a policeman role is modern but the conglomerate EU acting through soft power is postmodern.... For an economist, a corporation such as General Motors is modern while Amazon is postmodern (Jencks, 1996, p 14)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

What is Postmodernism

Most post-modern concerns of the 1970s and the 1980s have become central to society (Jencks, 2012).... Jencks states that a typical post-modern building is one that is hybrid and one that dramatizes opposing trend mixtures, of the past, present, and future to create a miniature city.... Thus, it is based on numerous codes, combining modern universal technology and local culture, in a double coding that is characteristic.... A typical building that is post-modern speaks at once on several levels to both high and low culture....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us