Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Constitution The Mandate that Individuals buy Health Insurance - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
There have been divisions on whether the Patient Protection and Affordable Act of 2010 is constitutional. It has been contested with divisions emerging between Democrats and Republicans. There have been…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Constitution The Mandate that Individuals buy Health Insurance
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Constitution The Mandate that Individuals buy Health Insurance"

Download file to see previous pages s lacked the authority under the Constitution’s Commerce Clause to force Americans to buy health insurance or pay a penalty for the failure (Rourke, 2012, p.3).
According to the proponents of the issue, the mandate modifies the internal Revenue Code and thus constitutes a tax. It, therefore, offers Americans a choice to either purchase health insurance cover or pay a tax equal to the cost of purchasing health insurance. However, people exempted from the tax include the poor, dependents, military personnel, citizens living overseas, or individuals with a religious objection (Bluestein, 2011, p.27). This subsidizes the government’s health care program hence making it cheaper both to the government and health insurance companies as well as to families wishing to buy a health insurance.
However, the introduction of the penalty for those with no health care insurance is unconstitutional since it makes Americans pay taxes. The central issue relates to the Commerce Clause. Congress argues that the Commerce Clause empowers it to compel private citizens not currently involved in commercial activity, to buy insurance from private dealers or pay a penalty to the national government. However, the Congress has no powers through the Commerce Clause to enact laws imposing such penalty (The Editors, 2010, p. 2). By passing the individual mandate and penalty as components of the Patient Protection and Affordable Act of 2010 (PPAA), Congress exceeded the powers granted by the constitution. This is because resolving such a suit remains the role of the federal courts as noted by O Conor in New York v United States (1992). This is the traditional and foundational function of the federal courts (Barnett, Stewart & Gaziano, 2009, p. 1).
However, since no Congress has ever tried to apply the Commercial Clause in the issue of APPA casts great doubt as to whether Congress has the authority to do the same. The Supreme Court in Printz v United States (1997) noted the same; the reality ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Constitution The Mandate that Individuals buy Health Insurance Research Paper”, n.d.)
Constitution The Mandate that Individuals buy Health Insurance Research Paper. Retrieved from
(Constitution The Mandate That Individuals Buy Health Insurance Research Paper)
Constitution The Mandate That Individuals Buy Health Insurance Research Paper.
“Constitution The Mandate That Individuals Buy Health Insurance Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Constitution The Mandate that Individuals buy Health Insurance

The wrongs of Obama Care

...“their non-participation in the health insurance industry” could likewise affect those who buy insurance in a seemingly complicated method than those with other industries.38 Therefore, the author believed that within the limited scope introduced in the health care industry the individual mandate should be constitutional as a means of controlling the price and increasing the access to health care.39 As a reaction to the author’s argument, there are some points in the discussion that can support the constitutionality of the individual mandate such as...
16 Pages(4000 words)Research Paper

An Act to Protect the Freedom to Choose Health Care and Health Insurance NCGS 58:49A

...that all Americans buy health coverage or pay a fine (or tax). The insurance mandate is core to mission of covering more than 30 million uninsured. Meanwhile, federal government is trying to roll out early provisions. In September 2010, a number of important provisions took effect. Insurers were banned from dropping sick and costly customers after discovering technical mistakes on applications and required to offer coverage to children under 26 on their parents’ policies. The very affirmative obligation on individuals to purchase health insurance beginning in 2014 or face the payment of a penalty is the...
11 Pages(2750 words)Research Paper

Policy-making in the Federal System

...of this metric reveals that health care costs have been increasing at a faster rate after enacting the ACA. As such, Obamacare as failed as far as care costs are concerned. Critics argue that Obamacare increases care cost by encouraging doctors to increase care quantity rather than quality (Tate, 2012). Therefore, to this extent, it can be concluded that Obamacare is ineffective in its bid to reduce health care cost. The policy’s consistency with the constitutional framework of federalism has been questioned. Obamacare has been criticized for its inconsistency with constitutional framework of federalism. The Obamacare compels individual Americans to...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

National Health Insurance System deal (Goodmann & National centre for policy analysis 2004). This insurance deal ensures these individuals are well catered for health wise in the best coverage deal subsidised by the federal government that fits their needs and budgets. The open enrolment in the online national health care system is a non-discriminative operation aiming at the improvement of the citizen’s health status without consideration of either class or status. One of the major disadvantages of the national insurance system is that the countries with this type of insurance scheme often attempt to use more finances...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Workers Without Health Insurance

.... They include, AIDS, cancer, psychological dysfunction, etc The American government invests in health service provisions for those who have health insurance covers through publicly sponsored coverage and other incentives4. A certain percentage of the people also benefit from health services especially those workers who are uninsured and the aging population. In fact, public spending on health services for the insured workers are becoming increasingly good but compared those workers who are uninsured; they do not get enough benefits. The dollars alone do not have satisfactory benefits for an individual who is not...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Health insurance

...Health Insurance The employer contends that the union had filed for grievance after three months whereas it has to file the grievances within five days of communication about the change in the insurance policy. The employer had indicated about the change in insurance policy before it independently changed the insurance company on January 1, 2003. Therefore the grievance is not timely. The union had to file grievances in five days from January 1, 2003. The union negotiated with the employer regarding the financial difficulties and health insurance program in good faith and cooperation. The negotiations came to an end...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Negative Letter (Health-Insurance)

...3840 Sandusky St. Delaware, OH 43015 (800) 123-4567 ext 890 4 March, 2009 Ronald Reineke Production Officer The Company 85 W. Winter St Delaware OH, 43015 Dear Mr. Reineke, I have received your correspondence regarding your pending surgery costs. Unfortunately the company is unable to pay for the surgery because it is not covered under your elected health insurance policy. All new employees are given a choice between three health maintenance organizations (HMOs) upon employment. With this choice, employees are given a list of doctors and hospitals that are in cooperation with each respective HMO. These lists are included in the packet of...
2 Pages(500 words)Personal Statement

Health Insurance

...that of doctors and medical practitioners. Conclusion The importance of organizational culture along with the well defined vision and the mission statement is instrumental in the success of any organization. It is same for any health insurance company too. The vision and the mission help to identify the reason of existence and the long term goal of the organization. The other important aspects include the organizational culture and the well defined organizational hierarchy through the organizational chart. Along with these factors, the effective risk management and involvement of leading professional experts would ensure the success of the health insurance...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Health insurance

... Health Insurance Advertisements Advertisements are important aspects of a business or any organization with intentions and objectives of widening their client base. It is through advertisements that companies, organizations or any businesses get to access a larger and more expansive population. The messages passed through advertisements are more often than not intended to persuade the target population into using more of the product or service being advertised. These advertisements must be prepared and presented in such a way that they are captivating and caries most of the information in a short, precise, but clear way. Therefore, this paper will look into a health advertisement and discuss it in its fullness. Health and health... ...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Health Insurance

...of Phoenix Material Health Insurance Matrix As you learn about health care delivery in the United s, it is important to understand the various models of health insurance to develop a working knowledge as you progress through the course. The following matrix is designed to help you develop that knowledge and assist you in understanding how health care is financed and how health insurance influences patients and providers as important foundational information for your role as a future health care worker. Fill in the following matrix. Each box must contain responses between 50 and 100 words...
5 Pages(1250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Constitution The Mandate that Individuals buy Health Insurance for FREE!

Contact Us