StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Different Respects in Which Freemen Were Treated during Reconstruction by the Cherokee Nation - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "The Different Respects in Which Freemen Were Treated during Reconstruction by the Cherokee Nation" it is clear that discrepancies still exist regarding equal treatment of the Cherokee groups, though they all remain citizens of the Cherokee nation, with valid citizenship…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
The Different Respects in Which Freemen Were Treated during Reconstruction by the Cherokee Nation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Different Respects in Which Freemen Were Treated during Reconstruction by the Cherokee Nation"

? Essay History and Political Science Inserts Insert Grade Insert 20th April, Essay History and Political Science The Cherokee freedmen constituted of various individuals of African origin who were offered citizenship into the Cherokee nation during the nineteenth century. These people originated for continental Africa and came into the Cherokee nation, mainly as slaves, working for the Cherokees. These individuals became citizens of the Cherokee nation through being offered citizenship (Miller and Purvis). Though the Cherokee nation offered them citizenship in the 19th century, their treatment as slaves never changed during that period. Following an establishment of a working treaty with the United States of America, these individuals gained Cherokee citizenship in 1866. Numerous rights of the freedmen remained limited with some being available only to Cherokees and not freedmen Cherokees. During the reconstruction of the Cherokee nation, freedmen were only granted citizenship into the Cherokee nation. Numerous human rights, however, were not granted to the freedmen Cherokees following citizenship. Controversies continued through the 20th century concerning the rights granted to freedmen Cherokees. These individuals felt they were being accorded second grade citizenship with limited rights. Though the Cherokee citizenship offered freedmen with citizenship based on possession of Cherokee blood, amendments into the constitution later involved acceptance based on historical presence. The Cherokee nation presented controversial regulation regarding citizenship of freedmen Cherokees. This controversy continues to yield continuous court battle as freedmen seek acceptance into the citizenship of Cherokee nation. Various Cherokee constitutional laws declare that qualification to Cherokee citizenship should be based on having Cherokee blood relationships and not merely historical presence within the Cherokee nation. The Cherokee nation requires registration and enrolment of citizens through lineal blood descendants. This element is however, controversial as it defines membership and not citizenship. As a tribal nation however, membership was utilized in establishing and offering citizenship. Utilizing modern-day translation of the law, on might fail to be a member of the tribe, yet become a citizen of the nation containing particular tribe. Within the context of Cherokee nation, however, separation of these parameters remains difficult. The integration of the Cherokee nation as part of the United States of America brought significant impact and clarification of the pending citizenship issues. Freedmen Cherokees continued to be accorded limited right by the Cherokee nation. These included limitation into intermarriages with native Cherokees; hence freedmen Cherokees could not intermarry with native Cherokees according to the Cherokees’ regulations. This mainly remained so because these freedmen continued to be viewed as slaves of the Cherokees. There exists an unwritten slavery law where masters cannot intermarry with slaves. This theoretical believe continued to be commonly practiced within the Cherokee nation. The freedmen were also accorded second-class citizenship, with limited rights, like those of intermarriages. Adaptation into the constitution of the United States of America included access to various rights, previously unavailable. These included the right for freedmen Cherokees to vote and elect leaders. Though the united states governments seeks to empower the freedmen Cherokees through giving them human right accorded to other marginalized communities, controversy continues to cloud the issues of freedmen Cherokees. These individuals were offered citizenship into Cherokee nation before integration into the United States of America. The standing order, therefore, remains that they are still bound by the regulations which gave them Cherokee citizenship. These people, therefore, completely remain bound by the constitution of the Cherokee nation whose authority over their citizenship supersedes that on the United States government. Following their initial acceptance of Cherokee citizenship, changing the status remains a difficult task. Under the United States of America constitution, these individuals are offered constitutional rights equal to other citizens. In contrast with the existing Cherokee regulations, freedmen can be accorded a free court hearing. This has seen the freedmen presenting numerous cases within the US jurisdiction seeking to clarify their citizenship rights (Monet). Most of these cases are presented in United States courtrooms where the freedmen have equal rights as citizens of the United States of America. The rulings delivered by court within the United States of America, however, remain bound by the Cherokee nation constitution and must not violate the constitution of Cherokee. The freedmen Cherokees continue to get favorable rulings within these courtrooms. Appeals following these cases, however, must be presented into the Cherokee courts and not the United States Supreme Court (Murphy). The process of legally seeking independence from limited human right therefore continues for the freedmen Cherokee. The United States government offers comprehensive citizenship as contrasted with Cherokee citizenship which comes with limited roles. Freedmen within the jurisdiction of Cherokee were offered citizenship with limited rights. One instant saw freedmen Cherokees being denied the right to participate in a general election. The Cherokee nation denied freedmen constitutional rights provided by the United States of America government. The treatment of Cherokees under the US jurisdiction therefore contains significant differences with treatment under Cherokee national constitution. These discrepancies are caused by the mere definition of Cherokee citizenship under the different constitutional orders. The Cherokee constitution attaches importance to membership, therefore, having citizenship does not guarantee similar treatment as members. Within the US jurisdiction, however, once a citizen all individuals have access to exclusive rights provided within the constitution. The Cherokee government discriminates citizens through introduction of a membership element to the citizenship. This continues to present freedmen as second-class citizens within the Cherokee nation. The United States constitution, however, grants complete citizenship to individuals fitting their requirements. This citizenship grants access to all rights provided by the constitution and even illegalizes different forms of discrimination present among citizens. While discriminative actions still exist within the United States of America boundaries, the constitution offers protection for people targeted by various forms of discrimination. One can seek constitutional protection if faced with incidents of discrimination while within the United States. This right equally applies to non-citizens living within the geographical boundaries of the United States. While citizenship could guarantee provision of basic human right within the context of US jurisdiction, the Cherokee nation citizenship does not guarantee equal right for native and freedmen Cherokees. Discrepancies still exist regarding equal treatment of these Cherokee groups, though they all remain citizens of the Cherokee nation, with valid citizenship. Works Cited Miller, Melinda and Rachel Smith Purvis. "The Cherokees Free Their Slaves." The New York times 17 February 2013. Monet, Jenni. " Cherokee Freedmen Case Returns to Capitol Hill; US Circuit Court of Appeals Will Re-Hear Vann v. Salazar." Indian Country 16 October 2012. Murphy, Sean. "Cherokee Freedmen Controversy: Court Lets Slaves' Descendants Sue Cherokee Chief ." The Huffing post 14 12 2012. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare and contrast the different respects in which Freemen were Essay”, n.d.)
Compare and contrast the different respects in which Freemen were Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1474661-compare-and-contrast-the-different-respects-in
(Compare and Contrast the Different Respects in Which Freemen Were Essay)
Compare and Contrast the Different Respects in Which Freemen Were Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1474661-compare-and-contrast-the-different-respects-in.
“Compare and Contrast the Different Respects in Which Freemen Were Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1474661-compare-and-contrast-the-different-respects-in.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Different Respects in Which Freemen Were Treated during Reconstruction by the Cherokee Nation

Jeep Grand Cherokees Crash tests

Jeep Grand cherokee Crash Tests - By Harish Das A review by an auto safety group states that the Jeep Grand cherokee(1993-2004) was susceptible to fires if involved in a rear collision, This has been corroborated by the Center for Auto Safety which suggests that the Grand cherokee's fuel system is more dangerous in rear impact collisions than other competing vehicles of the time.... Chrysler changed the placement of the fuel tank in the Grand cherokee in 2005, where it was moved from next to the rear bumper to a position ahead of the rear axle....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Government impact on the Cherokee nation

The Story of Self Interest: Federal and Local Government Effect on the cherokee nation the cherokee nation has had a long and troubled relationship with the various offices of the US government they have had to deal with since the founding of the United States in 1776.... the cherokee nation and the US government have had every imaginable form of relationship, from trading partners to colonizers to warring bodies violently seeking to eradicate each other....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

History of the Removal of Cherokees

[Professor Name] [Course Number] [Professor Name] [Date] Cherokee removal The Cherokee removal refers to the forces relocation of the cherokee nation from their lands as a result of Indian Removal efforts.... the cherokee nation resisted against the removal efforts and also hired some lawyers to combat with this forces relocation but eventually they had to leave their homes in South and were forcefully moved towards North America.... negotiated with some tribes and convinced them to leave their lands and move towards the other territory however, the cherokee nation refused and condemn the policy of U....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

What do the freedman's bureau papers tell about african american life in the reconstruction era

The bureau helped the freedmen and women during reconstruction in the following ways: 1.... What do the freedman's bureau papers tell about african american life in the reconstruction era?... This bureau was established in the year 1865 after a debate was raised against its establishment and it took care of all matters concerning the refugees who lived in the southern states which were mainly under reconstruction following the destruction of property and land after the civil war....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Many Nations Native Americans

The land lottery that was enacted in 1830 is being implemented, where citizens of Georgia are the beneficiaries of the cherokee's land.... However, a rift among the people created instability to the cherokee government.... Firstly, under the Principal Chief John Ross they had a control of the cherokee government.... The government has been There is a group of cherokee people that want to stay in their homelands spearheaded by Principal Chief John Ross....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Profile Speech about Trail of Tears- Removal of the Cherokee

his deadly trek, during the course of which thousands of Cherokees perished, loved ones died in front of the eyes while others stood helpless.... A central idea of the speech is the Native Americans, considered uncivilized and unfit for a 'white' America were forced to leave their homeland and settle in Oklahoma.... Next, I will tell you how tribes such as Cherokees were affected following which I shall take you back to the fateful 'Trail of Tears....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Cherokee - Native American Indians

In effect, the cherokee nation now resembles the larger US; but in some ways, they have also improved on the modern American influence.... The social influences of the cherokee have been based on a blending of their Cherokee teachings, as well as their modern interactions with their white counterparts.... This paper presents the social, genetic, and psychological effects of the modern cherokee Indians, infants and teens.... Social influences of the modern cherokee Indians are already largely based on the whites or the American The author....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Cherokee Tribe, Southeast Native Americans

The best-known episode in Cherokee history was the worst: the Trail of Tears, the forced relocation of the cherokee Indians from their ancestral home in the southeast to Oklahoma.... Southeast - The largest Native American tribe, the cherokee, lived in the Southeast.... The paper "cherokee Tribe, Southeast Native Americans" states that 'cherokee' is Creek for 'people with another language'.... Woodland Indians were knowledgeable about herbs and natural medicines....
23 Pages (5750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us