Nobody downloaded yet

Comparison of Three Books about Vietnam War - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Name: Instructor: Course: Date: Comparison of Three Books about Vietnam War The Vietnam War was an era characterized by cold war, as well as military conflict in Cambodia, Laos and Vietnam between 1955 and 1975. The warring sides were largely from the Southern part of Vietnam, which encompassed anti-communists and the Northern part that had a high concentration of communists…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
Comparison of Three Books about Vietnam War
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Comparison of Three Books about Vietnam War"

Download file to see previous pages While different authors appreciate the occurrences during the war, they portray the war and the US interference in different ways. This paper will examine three such books, comparing the description of the Vietnam War in all the books. The Vietnam War was a memorable event in the history of the US. A People's History of the United States In the book, A People’s History of the United States, Zinn presents the history of the Vietnam War in a simplistic manner that common people can appreciate. Zinn provides this history through the eyes of the common folk instead of the economic and political elite. For instance, he focuses on the US citizens’ resistance to the Vietnam War, as well as the people of North Vietnam who though deemed insignificant, were able to defeat the US-backed South. Zinn terms the US involvement in the Vietnam War as a mission in futility. He exemplifies that regardless of its military and technology superiority, the US was unable to defeat Northern Vietnamese whose main weapon was human strength and tactical thinking capacity. According to Zinn, US victory in Vietnam was impossible because North Vietnamese dejected colonial imperialism after Japan’s failed attempt to capture Indochina. He argues that the US was fighting a war it could not win. This is because the people of Vietnam favored the government led by Ho Chi Minh and were against Ngo Dinh Diem’s regime. This allowed the people of Vietnam to maintain high morale throughout the war. On the other hand, morale among US military fighters in Vietnam was quite low because most of the American soldiers revolted against the atrocities they inflicted, like the My Lai massacre. Zinn describes the Vietnam War as a war between “the wealthiest and most powerful nation in global history” and “a nationalist, revolutionary movement in a peasant nation”. This description paints the picture of a fight akin to a cat and mouse fight where the insignificant revolutionary people fought against a mighty nation such as the US. Normally, one would expect that the stronger party in the fight wins, but in the Vietnam War, Zinn asserts that it is the small, insignificant humans who won against the technology of the US. In addition, Zinn speaks of the impact the US citizens had on the culmination of the Vietnam War. Zinn talks of the impact of the US movement against the Vietnam War as having, “played a critical part in bringing the war to an end”. Nonetheless, Zinn attempts to dispel the common belief that US opposition to the Vietnam War was amongst college students and intellectuals from the middle class. He uses statistics from the war period to show evidence that considerable opposition also came from the US working class. For instance, poet Robert Lowell refused to attend a luncheon at the White House, while singer Eartha Kitt spoke out against the war in the presence of the first lady. Zinn maintains the stance that it is the common people that brought change in Vietnam. The assertion “the revolutionists fought against the Japanese” and defeated the superior nation speaks of the impact of Vietnamese on the going on within their country. Zinn’s description of the war also holds that the troops also opposed the war, citing refusals and desertions to progress to war, as well as movements like Vietnam Veterans Against the War, which subsequently covered US invasions ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison of Three Books about Vietnam War Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1452478-comparison-of-three-books-about-vietnam-war
(Comparison of Three Books about Vietnam War Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1452478-comparison-of-three-books-about-vietnam-war.
“Comparison of Three Books about Vietnam War Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1452478-comparison-of-three-books-about-vietnam-war.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Vietnam War
...of a communist group known as the Viet Cong. Although the Americans had superior firepower, the Vietnamese, with their knowledge of the terrain and their guerilla tactics, finally forced America to withdraw after two decades of a long drawn and costly war. The cost to America in terms of economic and political losses, as well as loss of lives and humiliation at the hands of an enemy that seemed small and insignificant, was immense. Today, after over three decades, there is still no consensus among scholars and historians about whether America should have ever entered the war. Vietnam War The war in...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Vietnam War
...? In the Vietnam War, the US was unable to understand what a revolutionary war was and that was the reason why US strategies failed painfully in gaining victory (Vickers, 1993, p.126). The people of Vietnam and the country’s leadership were so full of revolutionary fervor that they were mentally unbeatable. That was why they could persevere the prolonged attacks of a very powerful enemy. Another factor that the US rulers failed to understand was that “third world governments seeking US assistance against insurgencies frequently are governed by elites benefiting from social inequality and the exploitation of a majority of the population” (Vickers, 1993, p.125). South...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Vietnam War
...of the Vietnam War was three million enemy soldiers killed as opposed to 58,000 Americas. Despite this overwhelming disparity, the ‘big dog’ in the battle ultimately had to run back home with its tail tucked between its legs, dishonored and soundly beaten. Due to the unprecedented media coverage of the truth of the war, the U.S. quickly lost credibility in the international community including the people in its own country. “The U.S. cannot be involved in a unilateral conflict without operating under the constraints of its limited resources and range or without the support of the people in the region it intends to occupy. In that fictional world, the sole superpower...
8 Pages(2000 words)Term Paper
Vietnam War
...THE VIETNAM WAR INTRODUCTION The dynamics of the Vietnam War make it one of the most complex wars ever fought by the United s. Every element of the war was saturated with complexities beyond the previous conceptions of war. From the critical perspective, for the first half of the twentieth century, Vietnam was of little strategic importance to the United States and, even "after World War II, Vietnam was a very small blip on a very large American radar screen" (Herring, 14). The U.S. knew very little about Vietnam outside of its rice...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Comparison: Iraq war & Vietnam war
.... According to Scott Ritter about 90 to 95% weapons had already been destructed and there were no weapons found after the attack. “When I left Iraq in 1998... The infrastructure and facilities had been 100% eliminated. There’s no doubt about that. All of their instruments and facilities had been destroyed” (“War on Iraq”, p.26, Ritter and William Rivers Pitt, Profile Books, 2002) the critics opines that the main purpose behind this war was America’s interest in the crude oil. And by invading Iraq America was planning to settle its monopoly on the crude oil. The purpose behind Vietnam War was totally different. Growing...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Vietnam War
...Vietnam War Impulsive causes, as well as, starting points can be found in obvious forms in most of the American wars. Some of the examples of wars with obvious causes are North Korean War in the year 1950, Fort Sumter War in the year 1861, and a number of other wars that had understandable causes and reasons behind them. However, for the first time, the Vietnam War commenced with no noticeable or apparent reason or cause. This paper will try to understand different aspects of Vietnam War in light of readings from the given text. **In specific, South...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Vietnam War
...The rules of engagement (ROE) for limited warfare during the Vietnam held different implications for different levels of stakeholders in the conduct of the war, from the President as Commander in Chief down to the foot solider in the field of battle. In this brief essay, some of these major implications for major stakeholders will be summarized. The materials for these summaries were taken from reading Lewy (1978) and The Weider History Group (2006) For the individual soldier in the field, the ROE were often either unknown or unacknowledged. While the soldiers were aware of the general nature of the American involvement in Vietnam and understood that they needed to avoid unnecessary violence, if only to avoid making enemies... the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Vietnam War
...of their military actions on the territory of Vietnam. Actually, the goals of the war are still vague. Soldiers themselves could not understand what they were fighting for. Vietnamese were weaker in terms of military forces, but they were stronger mentally because they knew that they just had to defend. Today everybody knows about the huge military potential of the USA: even a little child every day can see modern American military techniques and bold soldiers on TV, in magazines, movies, computer games. It seems that military forces of the United States can do everything: help other peoples in their struggle with suppressors, neutralize dangerous terrorists, bring peace to dangerous...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Vietnam war
...Vietnam War What were the most important factors, according to Johnson, that led to the withdrawal? The first factor was the poor leadership and decision making techniques exhibited by the two presidents who fore so the war: Kennedy and Lyndon. They both put in more money and soldiers into the war that the Americans were clearly losing. The most important factor that led to the withdrawal was the immense deaths of the American soldiers. These deaths saw complaints and disgruntlement from the American people and so of the future leaders in the US and the pressure led to the withdrawal and end of the war. There was also the fact that millions of dollars...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Vietnam war
... Vietnam War Introduction The United s of America for the first time from 1964 to 1972 made an all-out military effort in the fight as it took sides in the conflict in Vietnam. With all the technological and human capabilities, America was favored to win that war. The Government of America was very determined to end that war in the shortest possible period that never came to be. So, what really transpired in the Vietnam War? Did America emerge the “obvious winner? Many questions about the Vietnam War lay unanswered to date. This paper discusses and compares the views of different authors about the war in Vietnam. Evidently, the issue has been viewed differently as the books that will be discussed highlight. Some authors attribute... the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Comparison of Three Books about Vietnam War for FREE!
Contact Us