We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Nobody downloaded yet

Minow's dilemma critical evaluation - Essay Example

Comments (0)
Summary
Consider Minow's dilemma: "The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic" (Minow, 1998: 46) The recognition of the universality of human rights is perhaps the strongest force that underlies initiatives made towards the struggle for justice after a period of mass atrocity…
Download full paper
GRAB THE BEST PAPER
Minows dilemma critical evaluation
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
Minow's dilemma critical evaluation

Download file to see previous pages... While forgetting may seem an alluring option for some, unwilling as they are to face the disquietude brought about by rousing old skeletons, there is a greater ethical and moral imperative to exhume the past if only to serve as lessons for the future. In her important book entitled “Between Vengeance and Forgiveness: Facing History After Genocide and Mass Violence”, Martha Minow looks at the range of institutional responses that have been crafted with the end in view of seeking justice for the victims of mass atrocities and demanding accountability from the perpetrators. The ethical imperative of incorporating justice into efforts towards peace in a post-conflict context is at the heart of the transitional justice project. Its premise is that war and conflict have brought about a slew of human rights and international humanitarian law violations which demand accountability from its perpetrators and reparation for its victims. Minow uses this framework in her book as she problematizes the difficulties of navigating the complex road to justice, in the complex terrain and conditions of a post-conflict situation. Minow, however, presented a crucial dilemma when she stated that "The central premise of individual responsibility portrays defendants as separate people capable of autonomous choice- when the phenomena of mass atrocities render that assumption at best problematic" (1998: 46). This is a dilemma because it articulates a conflict between the desire to prosecute individual perpetrators for war crimes and crimes against humanity, and the realization that the mass atrocities were taking place amid extraordinary conditions and assigning individual criminal responsibility to the perpetrators – even if they were the leaders or the heads of the military – does not capture the depth and breadth and magnitude of the phenomenon at hand. This paper will explore this dilemma even further, and will demonstrate that while there is persuasive value to individual criminal responsibility, it is an injustice to constrain or limit oneself to the institutional and legal mechanisms that seek accountability for individual criminal behavior without looking at the conditions that gave rise to the atrocity. To quote Franke (2001: 1), “Justice is, of course, a very complex ethical, legal, institutional and emotional problem, and its aspirations are rendered all the more difficult in transitional societies that are struggling with unstable governance, security and economic institutions.”. Certainly, there are cases where individual criminal responsibility may be very clearly gleaned. Historical accounts have it that on April 25, 1987, Slobodan Milosevic, the fallen President of Serbia, went to Kosovo Polje and was met with a crowd of fifteen thousand Serbs, including an old man who suddenly shouted to Milosevic that the ethnic Albanians were beating them. Milosevic responded by calling out to the man, “No one shall dare beat you again.” As if these remarks were not incendiary enough, he proceeded to say, “This is your land, your fields, your gardens; your memories are here”. A decade later, under Milosevic’s watch, in defense of fields, gardens and memories, Serbian forces unleashed ethnic ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Critical Evaluation
McCullin, Don (2012) "Don McCullin's Last War: The Times" 4. McCullin, Don, "Don McCullin in Syria, December 2012" (Hannah Strange) 5. McCullin, Don, "Don McCullin in Aleppo, December 2012" 6. McCullin, Don, "Don McCullin's last war with Anthony Loyd, December 2012" 7.
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
Critical evaluation
76, pp. 285-291 Article 3 - Govindarajan, R., Vijayakumar, P., & Pushpangadan, P., 2005, "Antioxidant approach to disease management and the role of 'Rasayana' herbs of Ayurveda", Journal of Ethonopharmacology, vol. 99, pp. 165-178. Park and Ernst's (2005) "Ayurvedic Medicine for Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Systematic Review," though a qualitative study by design, has many of the scientific rigors associated with quantitative studies.
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
Critical Evaluation
torical period and by its reliance on an unstable discourse of honor” -- made by Pacheco in her essay; however, fails to examine or evaluate the contents of the text in full vis-à-vis her thesis to understand or guide the prospective readers as to how Pacheco fares in
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Critical analysis and evaluation
This approach would be seen throughout her piece. The author’s chain of logic is somewhat internal, but present. One sees this in her discourse of the details:
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Critical evaluation
The credibility of the research, in the first place, lies in the fact that it does not go into any type of interest-conflict. Rather the research topic was intended to find
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Critical review and evaluation
The two major accounting standards setting bodies such as Financial Accounting Standard Board (FASB) and International Accounting Standard Board
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Critical Evaluation of Bureaucracy
British Airways is the national airline of the United Kingdom and also its largest airline. It started operating in 1974 with its center of operations at Terminal 5 at London’s Heathrow Airport. The airline operates flights to 400 destinations around the world and operated 245 aircraft as of 2011. In 1976, the airline started flights to the US.
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
Critical evaluation
health professionals’ interpersonal skills in looking after the patients, and the inappropriate facilities are some of the barriers to the access of people with learning disabilities to the healthcare. Health check programmes, communication aid, walk-in clinics, and a prompt
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Critical Evaluation
For the first time, the work of a British photojournalist is being exhibited in the National Gallery of Canada (NGC) till April 14, 2013. Major newspapers and magazines including The Sunday Times, The Daily Telegraph and The Observer have also printed his
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
CRITICAL REFLECTIVE EVALUATION
Moon (1999), defines reflective practice as “a set of abilities and skills, to indicate the taking of a critical stance, an orientation to problem solving or state of mind”. This encapsulates a wide range of activities associated with
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Let us find you another Essay on topic Minow's dilemma critical evaluation for FREE!
Contact us:
+16312120006
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us