Nobody downloaded yet

How do the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Grafton and Jardine's texts enable imperialism How did rea - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
How do the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Grafton and Jardine’s texts enable imperialism? How did reading practices effect political change? Various factors may influence one’s understanding of a text and one crucial factor influencing the meaning and interpretation of the texts is the quality of reading practice…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
How do the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Grafton and Jardines texts enable imperialism How did rea
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "How do the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Grafton and Jardine's texts enable imperialism How did rea"

Download file to see previous pages A discussion on the various qualities of reading practices helps in a historical understanding of the ways in which humanistic-ally trained readers assimilated and responded to imperialism and political change. For example, the introduction of printed text to the Maori people in New Zealand had a crucial influence on their understanding of the Treaty of Waitangi. In other words, the reading practices of the Maori had a critical influence on the meaning of imperialism and political change in the region. This paper makes a reflective exploration of how the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Grafton and Jardine’s texts enable imperialism. One of the major studies of the principles of bibliography, Bibliography and the Sociology of Texts by D.F. McKenzie establishes that the material form of texts remarkably determines their meanings. According to McKenzie, texts take on different forms and meanings as they are reproduced and re-read. He maintains that a reader in the pursuit of historical meanings moves from “the most minute feature of the material form of the book to questions of authorial, literary, and social context. These all bear in turn on the ways in which texts are then re-read, re-edited, re-designed, re-printed, and re-published. If a history of readings is made possible only by a comparative history of books, it is equally true that a history of books will have no point if it fails to account for the meanings they later come to make.” (McKenzie, 1999, p. 23). The meaning gained in the beginning is completely changed in the reading of the new forms of the text which is re-read, re-edited, re-designed, re-printed, and re-published. Therefore, one’s reading practice is influenced by the material form of the book which, in turn, affects the meaning of the text. Lisa Jardine and Anthony Grafton’s seminal article “‘Studied for Action’: How Gabriel Harvey Read His Livy” is a classic example of how reading practice can influence one’s understanding and meaning of the text. Based on an exploration of how Gabriel Harvey practiced the reading of Livy, Jardine and Grafton establish that Harvey’s interpretation of Livy is considerably changed each time he reads it with different purposes in his mind. The article maintains that the different reading practices carried out by Harvey led to different outcomes. In fact, the different reading practices can lead to different meanings of the same text and this fluctuation in the meaning can affect the overall outcome of the reading practice. “Thus critical reading, skillful annotation and active appropriation emerge as the central skills, not just of the student of history, but of the intellectual tout court. Reading always leads to action – but only proper reading in the manner of a Gabriel Harvey.” (Jardine and Grafton, 1990, p. 76). According to Jardine and Grafton, the early modern readers used to actively reinterpret their texts rather than passively receive it. In this article, the authors provide a convincing illustration of how the ‘reading as intended to give rise to something else’ can influence the meaning of the text and, in turn, affect political changes. To them, scholarly reading has always been goal-oriented and conducted under conditions of strenuous attentiveness. Therefore, “ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How do the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1427050-how-do-the-qualities-of-reading-practices-outlined
(How Do the Qualities of Reading Practices Outlined in McKenzie and Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1427050-how-do-the-qualities-of-reading-practices-outlined.
“How Do the Qualities of Reading Practices Outlined in McKenzie and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1427050-how-do-the-qualities-of-reading-practices-outlined.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How do the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Grafton and Jardine's texts enable imperialism How did rea

How useful is the cultural imperialism thesis

...to the theory of imperialism. Consider that in cultural imperialism "an active role on the part of the dominating country and a damaging effect on the dominated one are assumed".11 A different adage supposes "Third World consumers of [foreign] media products will be influenced by the values inherent in that content, the values of an alien and predominantly capitalist system".12 It is quite a common practice that when you review literature, there is a large number of unfavourable content besides the content supporting the theory. When scholars started to review the work on this theory, these assumptions were tested and shown to be false; now, they do not serve as...
12 Pages(3000 words)Essay

Grafton

...for their intentions and context. The book focuses fully on historical writing. The author chose the history of a particular discipline that made him reach a wider audience. Even though the author sometimes gives overemphasis to historiography, forgetting that the subject is footnoting, the historiography helps the author make a great explanation of the history of footnotes. The book can otherwise be named as historiography and references. Even though the author touches few other fields, he doesn’t cover it sufficiently. Grafton’s work is a quality text on professional-level historiography. The book is sometimes dense as it takes it for granted that the reader is familiar with...
4 Pages(1000 words)Book Report/Review

How Did the 1960's Change America

...Luther King’s efforts came to a stop in the year 1968 because he was murdered in this year during a protest in Tennessee. However, his dreams did not die with him. Another very important revolutionary political factor of the 1960s was John F Kennedy’s presidential term. He said, “Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do or your country” (Kennedy cited in “Ask not what”). This quote served as a potential drive for the youngsters to join the armed forces. John F Kennedy was among the four presidents in the history of the USA who were murdered. However, it was not until the assassination of John F Kennedy that the American presidents were provided with a police force...
3 Pages(750 words)Term Paper

Reading and Comprehension of Texts / Discursive writing

...be easily discarded by the masses because of religious faith. All attempts of the headmaster to give a facelift to the school by decorating the compound variously, his hard work of years comes to the ground when villagers, strictly forbidden by him not to use the path for taking the dead, take violent action by destroying all that is beautiful, “the flowers trampled to death...”, leading the supervisor to remark negatively about ‘the misguided zeal of the new headmaster’. This is a literary writing, which the students of literature or English subject would be given in their text books to read. Otherwise, magazines can also print such literary works. Achebe has been more than successful in getting his...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Theodore McKenzie

...PLOT SUMMARY Theodore McKenzie had chances to leave San Vicente. His father, an engineer, with other railroad workers, was one of the white settlers who resided in the island after the railway was constructed. The only white settler left, Theodore had to make a choice - to leave and expunge memories of his childhood, or stay and face his demons. CHAPTER 1 The smell of the cornfields near the foot of Dos Padres Mountains was a stench familiar to Theodore. There were times that the odour of the burnt field and the hot humid weather created an unbearable mix - the reek and the dampness sticking onto his clothes. His shirt, damp from the humidity, outlining his lean built and his broad...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Mens Rea

...Mens Rea Its funny how a simple thought can be one's own undoing. I have viewed plenty of true crime shows and listened to various experts pontificate about the intent level of a crime having a substantial impact on the degree of the crime charged. It all sounded like a bunch of mumbo jumbo to me and frankly, compelled me to turn the channel. I always thought that an "intent level" applied to measuring the difference between the death penalty and life without parole. How wrong I was indeed I was sitting in a caf sipping on my latte' on a summer morning in mid June, when I observed a gentlemen. He was perhaps in his early thirties medium height and bearded face. What stood out to me at...
4 Pages(1000 words)Personal Statement

Discuss how curatorial practices shape an exhibition

...Foister states that during the Renaissance, “great painters burst upon the scene with a fascination for the human likeness. They not only acquired the technique to do it, but also the intellectual liberation required to think about what it meant to an individual” (Higgins, 2008). After the dark ages, humanism greatly focused on the individual. The purpose of this paper is to discuss how curatorial practices shape this exhibition of Renaissance portraits and to critically evaluate the location, type of event and related factors. Discussion The exhibition Renaissance Faces: Van Eyck to Titian at the National Gallery, London provides a rare opportunity to explore over...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

How its made

...Running Head: How it’s Made How it’s Made [Institute’s How it’s Made Sandpaper belongs to the family of abrasive materials, asit is a piece of paper made into a substrate, which has adhesives attached on its top surface, which gives it the abrasive property. This special composition of the paper makes it ideal as a repairing material, acting as a tool which smoothes surfaces or roughens them in order to encourage gluing. It also helps to remove materials from a surface (paint from walls) or removing oil stains. Other than the usage of sandpaper on domestic grounds, its different types and qualities are now widely used industrially, such as in plating of metals, polishing...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

How does information technology enable strategy in travel

...Sate Information Technology Enables Strategy in Air Travel Companies within the air travel business such as Southwest Airlines and united Airlines have in the recent past increasingly adopted and implemented information technology as a strategy for competitive advantage. Through the use of technological applications, air travel companies have efficiently met their goals and objectives. Computer reservation systems (CRS) have for example allowed these companies and travel agents to efficiently allow their customers to book in advance for travel and accommodation. Customers for the travel companies are attracted to technologically compliant services because of the efficiency and quality associated with...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Reading and Comprehension of texts

...Reading and Comprehension of Texts Reading and Comprehension of Texts Different styles of text on the of children The paperpresents a succinct analysis of three chosen texts that include a poem, novel, and newspaper report. Task 1 entails the reading and comprehension of the texts including an analysis of its meaning. It includes an explanation of the purpose of the text. Finally, it outlines a summary of the main points in the text. Task 2 incorporates the authors’ ideas in the development of the text. Task 3 involves choosing a...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic How do the qualities of reading practices outlined in McKenzie and Grafton and Jardine's texts enable imperialism How did rea for FREE!

Contact Us