StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Insufficient Strength to Support Present Pregnancy - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Insufficient Strength to Support Present Pregnancy" it is clear that carers and volunteers could help the patient in looking after her children. Secure housing, financial benefit, a good job, and help with baby care will all help her to explore other possibilities. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
Insufficient Strength to Support Present Pregnancy
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Insufficient Strength to Support Present Pregnancy"

149488 REPORT FROM DR. CROOMBER PATIENT: Ms. White Age: 19 HISTORY: Third Trimester, First Pregnancy terminated when she was 15. Second pregnancy resulted in 10 month old child. PROBLEM: Insufficient strength to support present pregnancy. Hospitalised and is put on intravenous support. PRESENT: Wants to terminate 26 week pregnancy. It is almost impossible to allow Ms. White to have premature baby, precipitating life long damage to the infant. There is very little chance of baby's survival in a delivery during 26th week gestation period. It is a non-viable foetus with minimum chances of survival. Even if it survives1, it can have intra-uterine heart arrhythmia, postpartal respiratory insufficiency and bradycardia and cometimes, hypoglycaemia. The harm to the unborn child could be immense. The child might lose its life as a result of mother's decision. Or child could be crippled for life and doctor would be responsible for its continuous agony throughout life2. It will be either like an abortion, or like permitting a child to be born without proper health, even though alternatives exist. Many ethical and moral issues are connected with abortion like the rights of foetus,3 and mother's self-determination that should not be questioned. I am also well aware of the fact that the foetus is already very weak and might not survive the entire gestation period without hospitalisation and continuous monitoring, or even might be born after that with certain milder chronic problem. I could try to find another physician and transfer the case to him as it is. This would be risky too, because physician might not be willing to take the burden. It could work well in another way, because the mother will get a cooling-off period to reconsider her hasty decision so that she could be sure that she could live with such a decision for the rest of her life4. If I don't make her understand all implications and alternatives, I could be charged of post-conception harm, for not only informing the mother the risks of discontinuing the pregnancy (which I have already done), but also the harm that could come to the foetus by indefinitely prolonging the pregnancy without proper treatment for foetus. Professional duty and ethical confusion will plague this issue as this is an ethical as well as medical dilemma for me to be torn between the two. I can also refuse to abide by her wishes and try to obtain a court order to force her to undergo treatment. No doubt, this is perhaps a semi-legal way to do it, because foetal rights are not yet fully recognised as against the rights of mother, and this course of action would never work properly5. A resentful mother cannot be forced to have the baby, or to look after it with genuine affection after it is born. It will also jeopardise baby-mother bonding and an awfully strained relationship will develop between the two. It is also doubtful if I would be able to get the court order forcing Ms. White to undergo treatment and retain her pregnancy. There exists an unending argument whether the foetus right is more important or the mother's health. There had been no solution till now, even though as it is today, mother's right is recognised more than that of the foetus. I can go for Five step process of ethical decision making after taking into consideration all existing issues that have caused ethical distress and dilemma to medical fraternity by being forced to choose between woman's right to self-determination and right to life of the child. I have to consider Ms. White's psychological and physical wellbeing too before making a decision. Usually the child's right is rather suppressed. But to some extent, ethical consideration of women's right too is rationalized. Here foetal disability does not exist, though pointers towards it are present; but there is reasonable assumption that with the continuation of treatment, the child should be benefited and normal. Ethics is an essential dimension of clinical practice and we cannot totally ignore it. Ethical issues get complicated if, along with the mother, foetus too is treated as a patient, as it is already under treatment6. Also there is no indication that child could be born with a genetic disorder. Ethical and moral aspects of human reproduction have always been knotty7. Ms. White definitely has a right on her unborn baby and can take decisions keeping in mind her wellbeing, as she finds foetus 'painful and uncomfortable'. She had gone through the trauma of an abortion when she was only fifteen (this might even lead to the thought that she had been irresponsible even as a teenager); but now she is the single mother of ten month old child, and she is only nineteen and is expecting another baby. Naturally she has the right to say no, to another financial and emotional burden. Ms. White should have used contraceptives as they are very easily available and the present unwanted pregnancy could have been avoided. Also she has a duty towards her ten month old child. This does not wipe out her duty towards unborn child and she has very little right to inflict permanent suffering on her future child. But she has a right to consider her own health. Abortion is negated by Pope and the Catholic Church and there are Human Right Organisations which would argue on behalf of the child. There are also feminine organisations and ordinary women's organisations who would uphold the right of the mother8. This is an issue raging all over the world with widely divided opinions. Different countries have different issues that force mothers to terminate pregnancies. In traditional countries it is done for the fear of society and stigma of being an unwedded mother9 and in advanced countries, it is done to avoid additional responsibilities and problems. The moral status of foetus is a contentious issue10 that has human rights and legal aspects. ACTION TO BE TAKEN: Weighing all pros and cons, I am of the opinion that convincing Ms. White about the abnormal and difficult results of terminating a pregnancy at such an early period is of paramount importance. If she is totally against bringing up this child, she will be advised to give away the child in adoption and this might ease her tensions to some extent. She might even reconsider her decision. She shall go through psychological counselling that would help her to regain control. She might be running away from responsibility and reality again, by having a premature child with disastrous consequences, and this should be prevented. Father of her earlier child is not mentioned in her records. He could be traced and made to look after her child while she could go through pregnancy and birth of another child. With Care help, this need not be impossible and after the birth, she might be able to care for both children. Another practical solution is look for the father of unborn child and make him equally responsible. Perhaps Ms. White wants to terminate pregnancy because she does not feel capable of looking after 2 children being so young and vulnerable. She could be provided with a good, but easy job and that would make her financially sound. Carers and volunteers could help her in looking after her children. Secure housing, financial benefit, good job, help with baby care will all help her to explore other possibilities. Being in the hospital she must have been worrying about her other child's welfare. This problem could be solved by making suitable arrangement for looking after the child. While pursuing these alternatives, I would advice Ms. White to continue her treatment in hospital till she could deliver a normally monitored and healthy child. BIBLIOGRAPHY: 1. Cook, Rebecca, Bernard Dickens and Mahmoud F. Fathalla (2003), Reproductive Health and Human Rights, Clarendon Press, Oxford. 2. Hayry, Heta (1998), Individual Liberty and Medical Control, Ashgate, Aldershot. 3. Mulburn, Marj (2001), Informed Choice of Medical Service: Is the Law Just Ashgate, Aldershot. 4. Trohler, Ulrich and Stella Reiter-Theil (1998), Ethics Codes in Medicine, Ashgate, Aldershot. ONLINE SOURCES: 1. http://www.libertarian.co.uk/lapubs/philn/philn047.pdf 2. http://politics.scienceboard.net/archives/2005/04/02/33/ 3. http://www.owen.org/blog/528 4. http://conservativehome.blogs.com/torydiary/2006/10/nadine_dorries_.html 5. http://www.obgynsurvey.com/pt/re/obgynsurv/abstract.00006254-200307000-00023.htm;jsessionid=FnGdj1Q7Wt0hh2QHqyF07NkhJvFDk7Msn2LS3SrfWgw1Tm6TPNZx!990059801!-949856144!8091!-1 6. http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstractfromPage=online&aid=113787 7. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Medical Ethics Master Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1499723-medical-ethics-master-case-study
(Medical Ethics Master Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1499723-medical-ethics-master-case-study.
“Medical Ethics Master Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1499723-medical-ethics-master-case-study.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Insufficient Strength to Support Present Pregnancy

The Various Postural Changes Associated with Pregnancy

The paper "The Various Postural Changes Associated with pregnancy" states that these postural changes adversely affect the health of women, cause damage to their physiology and result in various musculoskeletal issues and musculoskeletal dysfunction during the prenatal and postpartum periods.... The centre of gravity of the body shifts as a result of changes that take place during pregnancy such as a rise in blood volume, an increase in body weight and the growth of the fetus and women lean backwards in order to maintain their body balance and as a result of which the spinal code loses its genuine curvature....
21 Pages (5250 words) Literature review

Postural Changes Associated with Pregnancy

The paper "Postural Changes Associated with pregnancy" suggests that posture is defined as the arrangement of body parts with reference to each other.... Joint discomforts and joint laxity are common features associated with pregnancy.... pregnancy brings about multiple changes in the women's body affecting almost every biological system.... While some of these changes go with pregnancy, others continue to affect for a longer duration....
19 Pages (4750 words) Dissertation

Pelvic Floor Exercises for Mothers during the Antenatal Period

There are various remedies that pregnant mothers can apply in order to manage the difficulties of pregnancy and to assist them in the eventual birthing process.... The study called for the respondents to attend supervised pelvic floor exercises as assisted by a physiotherapist on a monthly basis from 20 weeks of pregnancy.... Risk factors for this condition include pregnancy and vaginal delivery.... Their study set out to establish whether intensive pelvic floor muscle training during pregnancy could prevent urinary incontinence....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review

Vitamin D Supplementation in Pregnancy

The paper "Vitamin D Supplementation in pregnancy" tells that as low levels of vitamin D can have negative implications upon maternal and fetal health, treatment with multivitamins is considered a requirement until the child reaches 12 months of age, even if breastfeeding takes place.... Vitamin D deficiency in pregnancy and in babies of vitamin D deficient mothers has been found in a number of populations, including isolated northern Canadian aboriginal people ( Scroth et al 2004)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Domestic Violence as it Relates to Pregnancy

This research paper "Domestic Violence as it Relates to pregnancy" is aimed at building a relationship between domestic violence and pregnancy.... Domestic Violence as it relates to pregnancy Introduction Women have been experiencing domestic violence since the start of this world and its intensity has been noticed to increase especially during pregnancy.... This leads to pre and post-pregnancy complications which require immediate corrective actions under the supervision of an experienced nurse (Shah PS, 2010)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Nursing Implication for Teenage Pregnancy

This paper talks about the problem of teenage pregnancy in the US which is having the highest incidence of teen pregnancy though the rate is declining everywhere.... The paper "Nursing Implication for Teenage pregnancy" talks about the problem of teenage pregnancy in the US which is having the highest incidence of teen pregnancy though the rate is declining everywhere.... This essay gives detail information regarding statistical facts of teen pregnancy state wise information along with the implication of nursing....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Health Care for Women in the USA

This study will be effective at determining whether the prenatal care can be effective enough at identifying the outcome of pregnancy or not.... Prenatal care is most likely to minimize the risks associated with fatal growth constraints during pregnancy and immediately after the birth of the child for a few weeks.... Even in the case of mothers aged above 20 years, babies are often observed to suffer from various complications mostly due to genetic orders, but also due to the inadequate medical guidance and insufficient care during the pregnancy and in the infancy of the baby....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Top Physical Activity Amongst Pregnant Women

This study 'Top Physical Activity Amongst Pregnant Women' can provide unique insights not available in many pre-existing empirical studies about what might represent the most common and dominant, perceived barriers that defy increased physical activity during pregnancy.... This qualitative study provided results consistent with women perceiving inconsistency of quality and relevant information about the potential benefits and hazards of physical activity during pregnancy....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us