Positive and Negative Consequences of Diet - Case Study Example

«The Effects of Dieting on British Adolescents» 16 year old Sabrina was my neighbour a couple of years ago. Though initially she was a bubbly girl with very positive attitude, she became a changed girl after she went to college. She was often concerned about her looks and went to beauty parlors frequently. She always felt that she could have looked much better with less number of pimples and more thin structure. She said that her friends fitted into any clothes because of their figure and that even her sister and mother were better looking than her. Because of such feelings, she resorted to dieting several times. She also involved in purging and taking dieting pills. Though she did lose some significant weight and appeared thinner, she looked less happy, less healthy and always in low mood. On one day, it came as a shocking news to all of us that she attempted suicide. The doctor told that it was mainly because of severe dieting and that suicidal tendencies are common among dieters. This event instigated me to conduct further research on the effects of dieting on adolescents and this essay will discuss about the impact of dieting on British Adolescents. Evidence Currently, dieting is wide spread in most parts of the world including UK for two reasons. One is because of ideals of thinness circulating among the adolescents (Daee et al, 2002). The other is because of soaring incidence and prevalence of adolescent obesity. According to studies, more than 16 percent of adolescents in the current generation are mildly overweight and 9.9 percent are severely overweight (Daee et al, 2002). Adolescent obesity is a major public health challenge because of increased risk of certain diseases like gout, colorectal cancer, atherosclerosis, cardiac ischemia and stroke. Besides, those who are obese in adolescence have 70 percent risk of turning into obese adults. Obesity in adolescence is associated with several diseases like hypertension, obstructive sleep apnea, adverse lipoprotein levels, coronary artery disease, diabetes mellitus, colorectal cancer, stroke and death due to several causes (Nemet et al, 2005; Daee et al, 2002). Other than these disease states, obesity is also associated with discontinuation of education, poverty and lower marriage rate (Daee et al, 2002). Considering the prevalence of obesity and the need to refer to this disease as early as possible in life, prevention and management of obesity must be initiated in early adolescence, or even childhood (Reilly et al, 2006). However, quick strategies of fixing has become a common mode to tackle this problem which is actually unhealthy. Unhealthy dieting practices among adolescents can lead to several physiologic and psychologic effects many of which are detrimental in nature (Daee et al, 2002). Comparison with official documents Approximately 60 percent of girls and 25 percent of boys of the adolescent age diet at some point of time during adolescence. A significant percentage of those individuals resort to unhealthy or even dangerous methods of dieting like intake of pills, use of very low calorie diets and fasting. Adolescents are often concerned about their weight and shape (Gruber et al, 2001). In addition to the real health risks of obesity and poor eating habits, these youngsters are also exposed to thin beauty ideals that are unrealistic. It is very unfortunate that there is overemphasis of thinness among youngsters, because of which they equate thinness and beauty with success and health. The media provides ideas for various means of losing weight in order to achieve the thin ideal (Morris and Katzman, 2003). Information delivered by media thus are often based on fad trends, with financial incentive and without any scientific backing. The net result is that several adolescents feel the cultural pressure for becoming thinner, more than that required for optimum health and they attempt to fit into this through nutritional choices that are either poor or dangerous or both (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). Comparison with headlines of news papers According to BBC News (2006), "Teenagers often choose food in response to peer pressure or as an act of defiance against parents." Dr Andrew McCulloch, chief executive of the Mental Health Foundation, said: "We are well aware of the effect of diet upon our physical health. But we are only just beginning to understand how the brain as an organ is influenced by the nutrients it derives from the foods we eat and how diets have an impact on our mental health." And he added that addressing mental health problems with changes in diet was showing better results in some cases than using drugs or counseling. Assumptions While the reasons for dieting among adolescents are varied, in majority of teenagers, the motivating factors are dissatisfaction with body image and desire to appear thinner. Losing weight attempts are often associated with different behavioral changes like alterations in the regular eating habits and change in the frequency of exercising. There is no clear cut definition for dieting. Most professionals define dieting as "an intentional, often temporary, change in eating to achieve weight loss" (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). Extreme dieting has been defined as "self-induced emesis, laxative use and diet pill use." Self induced emesis has been reported in 5-12 percent of adolescent girls. Crash diets, skipping of meals and fasting have been reported in 22- 46 percent of youngsters in several parts of the World, including Canada, US and UK. Several studies have classified chronic dieting, fasting, fad dieting and skipping meals as unhealthy dieting strategies. Thus, dieting consists of spectrum of behaviors that range from healthy to unhealthy. One surprising unhealthy behavior arising out of urge to become thin is smoking. Smoking for controlling weight is reported in12- 18 percent of young women (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). Model of health According to WHO (1946) "Health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity." However, several researchers have argued the completeness of this definition and thus several other definitions and models of health have come up like the biomedical model, biopsychosocial model, public health model, wellness model, health belief model, etc. (Curtis, 2002). According to the health belief model, it is possible to explain health related behavior if beliefs about health care clear. According to this model, individuals will act to protect or promote their health based on what they believe and this belief is influenced by several factors including media (Turner et al, 2004). There are several determinants of dieting among adolescents and it is often challenging to ascertain as to which group of adolescents resort to dieting. Generally, dieting is more common among girls and increases with age. Adolescent girls who are dissatisfied with their image and are overweight are likely to resort to dieting. The more the degree of overweight, more is the risk of dieting and disordered eating (Neumark-Sztainer et al, 2002). However, there is high prevalence of dieting even in those with normal and underweight. Some studies have determined that dieting is prevalent in 36 percent of normal weight adolescent girls when compared to 50 percent of overweight and 55 percent of obese girls. Thus, perception of over weight is an important factor for dieting among adolescent girls, regardless of the fact that they are actually over weight (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004; Wertheim, 1997). Several cross sectional studies have identified self-esteem as a strong factor for unhealthy dieting practices to control weight (Cameron, 1999). Factors which protect adolescents from unhealthy dieting are "having a sense of control over one's life, family connectedness, having positive adult role models and positive involvement in school" (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). Infact, there are reports that parental criticism of the adolescent's weight, pressure to lose weight and parental role modeling of dieting are associated with increased rate of dieting and increased risk of development of dieting behaviors that are extreme (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). According to French et al (1997), perceived over weight, low body pride and dissatisfaction of body image among adolescent females are consistent correlates of binge eating and dieting and ethnic subculture does not seem to influence the prevalence of these correlates. The study demonstrated that while purging was significantly associated with dissatisfaction of weight, perception of overweight, lower pride of body, increased risk of suicide and increased risk of alcohol abuse; binge eating is associated with dissatisfaction of weight, perceived over weight, decreased body pride, lower family connectedness, emotional stress and increased acceptance of concerns of peers. Another important risk factor is presence of chronic illness like epilepsy, asthma, diabetes and attention deficit disorder. Presence of psychiatric problems like anxiety and depression also leads to extreme dietary practices. Other important factors include weight related teasing, peer group influence, vegetarianism, involvement in sports related to weight like gymnastics and dance, puberty at an early age and engagement in risky behaviors like smoking, substance abuse, illegal activity and unprotected sex (Byely et al, 2000, Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). Discussion Moderate dieting is associated with some positive outcomes. These are decrease in hyperinsulinemia, improvement in insulin resistance and decrease in high cholesterol levels occurring because of weight reduction. In a study by Escobar et al (1999), the researchers found that weight loss in obese children led to improvement in the altered insulin clearance, leading to normalization of serum insulin levels. Weight loss in obese children also causes improvement in sleep function and upper respiratory obstruction (Willi et al, 1998). In a large study (Sothern et al, 2000) on adolescents with obesity, weight reduction strategies involving calorie restriction with moderate grade exercise contributed to sustained growth velocity while at the same time causing decrease in body weight. Positive consequences of dieting are associated with intake of more fruits and vegetable that is a part of dieting. Several negative consequences can occur as a result of dieting among adolescents, the most common of which are delay in the linear growth and delayed pubarche. According to a study that evaluated children with either short stature or delayed puberty or both, it was evident that 7 percent of children suffered from growth failure as a result of malnutrition secondary to willful and conscious decreased calorie intake. In these children, while the normal weight gain decreased at 12 years of age followed by decrease in the linear growth velocity, there was also delay in puberty and also delay in bone age. Another major physical impact of adolescent dieting is the increased risk of gaining weight in the long term. This is evident from a prospective cohort study that evaluated high school girls who limited calorie intake and performed moderate exercise for weight loss. Predictors for future weight gain are vomiting, use of appetite suppressants and laxatives and binge eating. Another important predictor for future weight gain is use of significant efforts for weight loss (Daee et al, 2002). One important point worth mentioning at this juncture is that adolescent dieting is associated with decrease in the expenditure of resting energy. This is because, more often that not, diet during dieting is low-energy diet with predominant calorie restriction and this causes significant decrease in the expenditure of energy during resting. Thus, unless physical activity is increased or further calorie intake is reduced, weight loss becomes difficult to achieve (Daee et al, 2002). Other than physical consequences, dieting can also result in psychological consequences in adolescents who are undergoing rapid psychologic, physical and social development. There are several studies which have shown the association between dieting in adolescents and problem behavior. Worst psychological problems have been reported in those who diet frequently and purge. Smoking is one of the behavioral consequences of dieting. When adolescents resort to smoking as a deviation from food intake, they become addicted to smoking and fall prey to the health and financial consequences of smoking (Daee et al, 2002). Smoking and intake of other substances like alcohol and illicit drugs is more likely to occur in dieters who are purgers when compared to dieter who are non purgers. French et al (1995) opined that frequent efforts of dieting in adolescents must be viewed in broader context of heath and behaviours that are risk taking rather than just an isolated issue. Dieters, especially purgers perform poorly at school and they are more likely to be active sexually and frequently get involved in sexual or physical abuse. They are also more likely to attempt suicide. Purging and dieting are both associated with family stress, emotional turmoil, negative body image and lower connectedness with family members (Daee et al, 2002). Dieting is also associated with development of eating disorders like bulimia, disordered eating and binge eating. According to some reports, while 2-3 percent of adolescents suffer from bulimia, 1 percent of them suffer from anorexia nervosa and 3-5 percent suffer from disordered eating. All these disorders are associated with several consequences like estrogen deficiency, amenorrhea, hypophoaphatemia, ostopenia, anemia, renal dysfunction, cardiac abnormalities and leucopenia. On the other hand, bulimia is associated with electrolyte disturbances like hypokalemia and also other problems like cardiac arrhythmias, gastric dilataion, irregularities in menstrual cycle, esophageal rupture and gastric rupture, parotid gland enlargement, erosion of tooth, upper gastrointestinal bleeding and esophagiti (Daee et al, 2002)s. The most common erratic eating disorder is binge eating which is likely to occur in those who diet frequently and resort to purging (Daee et al, 2002). Infact, studies on binge eaters has revealed that these adolescents are not able to control their urge to eat, because of which they eat and then purge out of guilty feeling. According to a population based study, 1 in 40 adolescent females were likely to develop an eating disorder within 6 months of dieting when compared to non-dieting adolescent females who were at risk of developing the disorders at 1 in 500 rates. More than three fourth's of bulimia patients developed the eating disorder when they were on a low-carbohydrate diet which they could not maintain. Keys et al (cited in ) conducted a study on military adolescents who were placed on a diet that was very low in calories. Most of them had developed one or more types of eating disorders like food hoarding, preoccupation with food and emotional instability. According to Butyrn and Wadden (2005), weight loss programs under professional advice minimize the risk of developing eating disorders in children and adolescents. According to American Heart Association, low carbohydrate diet contains too much of protein and saturated heart which is not good for bones, kidneys and heart (Harvard Medical School, 2007). Also, the diet does not include other healthy foods like fruits and vegetables which decrease the risk of stroke, dementia and some types of cancers. Though Atkin's diet has been proven to reduce diet in those who are overweight, recent reports have questioned the health effects of this diet. Lack of fruits and whole cereals and presence of high fat questions the safety of this diet when it comes to cardiovascular aspects. Most of the concerns related to acute effects of dieting are with regard to deaths that have been reported in otherwise healthy dieters. Potential etiologies for such severe outcomes include sudden onset of severe hypertension due to pills, cardiac arrhythmias, acute disturbances in electrolytes especially potassium, that can be fatal, and finally primary effects of the low calorie diets that can affect the contractitlity of the myocardium (Daee et al, 2002). These problems may be due to dieting also, or due to exacerbation of a previously undiagnosed potentially dangerous condition like prolonged QT syndrome. The most common cause of acute adverse effects of dieting are due to pills, which are easily available over the counter. Most of the over the counter and prescription diet pills have hunger suppressing drugs and drugs to increase metabolic rates. More often than not, these drugs are sympathomimetic drugs. Other type of drugs include thyroid supplements. Both category of drugs have side effects like hypertension, arrhythmias, myocardial ischemia, tremulousness, psychosis, insomnia and seizures (Daee et al, 2002). Sympathomimetic drugs can also affect the peripheral vascular resistance and systemic vascular resistance and heart rate, leading to an imbalance in supply and demand, resulting in myocardial ischemia. Other than these acute side effects, the pills also have some chronic side effects. Dexfenfluramine and fenfluramine are known to cause pulmonary hypertension and cardiac valvular lesions and are now removed from the market (Daee et al, 2002). Summarise the model When health belief model is applied for Sabrina's case, it is evident that Sabrina believed that being thin is health and beauty. This was because of the image provided by media and her peers. There are several determinants of dieting among adolescents and it is often challenging to ascertain as to which group of adolescents resort to dieting. Generally, dieting is more common among girls and increases with age. Adolescent girls who are dissatisfied with their image and are overweight are likely to resort to dieting. The more the degree of overweight, more is the risk of dieting and disordered eating (Neumark-Sztainer et al, 2002). However, there is high prevalence of dieting even in those with normal and underweight. Some studies have determined that dieting is prevalent in 36 percent of normal weight adolescent girls when compared to 50 percent of overweight and 55 percent of obese girls. Thus, perception of over weight is an important factor for dieting among adolescent girls, regardless of the fact that they are actually over weight (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004; Wertheim, 1997). Several cross sectional studies have identified self-esteem as a strong factor for unhealthy dieting practices to control weight (Cameron, 1999). Factors which protect adolescents from unhealthy dieting are "having a sense of control over one's life, family connectedness, having positive adult role models and positive involvement in school" (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). Infact, there are reports that parental criticism of the adolescent's weight, pressure to lose weight and parental role modeling of dieting are associated with increased rate of dieting and increased risk of development of dieting behaviors that are extreme (Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). According to French et al (1997), perceived over weight, low body pride and dissatisfaction of body image among adolescent females are consistent correlates of binge eating and dieting and ethnic subculture does not seem to influence the prevalence of these correlates. The study demonstrated that while purging was significantly associated with dissatisfaction of weight, perception of overweight, lower pride of body, increased risk of suicide and increased risk of alcohol abuse; binge eating is associated with dissatisfaction of weight, perceived over weight, decreased body pride, lower family connectedness, emotional stress and increased acceptance of concerns of peers. Another important risk factor is presence of chronic illness like epilepsy, asthma, diabetes and attention deficit disorder. Presence of psychiatric problems like anxiety and depression also leads to extreme dietary practices. Other important factors include weight related teasing, peer group influence, vegetarianism, involvement in sports related to weight like gymnastics and dance, puberty at an early age and engagement in risky behaviors like smoking, substance abuse, illegal activity and unprotected sex (Byely et al, 2000, Adolescent Health Committee, 2004). Thus, Sabrina was concerned more about her looks and beauty because of various factors her and resorted to dieting, because; that is what she believed in.. The health belief model helps understand the behavior of Sabrina as an adolescent dieter desperate to look thin despite adverse consequences. Conclusion Dieting is very common among adolescent sin UK and other parts of the world. A significant proportion of dieters resort to unhealthy and dangerous methods of dieting leading several negative and unexpected outcomes of dieting. Dieting can be associated with positive and negative consequences and this of course depends on the type of dieting. Diets involving intake of pills, very low calories and skipping of meals are dangerous, while those associated with positive consequences are due to increased intake of fruits and vegetables, increased exercises and decreased intake of fat. In general however, dieting appears to have more negative consequences than positive consequences. Weight loss among adolescents is mainly associated with poor body image, decreased coping mechanisms and negative psychosocial and family risk factors. There does exist a strong association between dieting and onset of eating disorders like anorexia nervosa, bulimia and erratic eating habits like binge eating. Other psychosocial consequences include involvement in health risky behaviors like smoking, substance abuse and alcoholism, unprotected sex, suicide attempts and delinquency. Besides these negative consequences, alarming effects of dieting include mortality and morbidity related to dieting because of biochemical and physiological consequences like acute electrolyte disturbances in blood and serum, loss of minerals and essential trace elements, changes in the myocardium and adverse effects of free fatty acids on the myocardium. In view of the consequences of dieting, the primary intervention point should be at prevention of dieting. This can be done by education of parents during primary health visits and also education of older children and adolescents about eating patterns, behaviors and physical activity. In case dieting has to be done, the food intake must be taken under physician guidance who can monitor the consequences and detect side effects at an early stage itself and revert them. References Adolescent Health Committee. (2004). Dieting in adolescence. Pediatrics and Health, 9(7), 487- 491. BBC Health. (2001). Healthy eating for teenagers. http://www.bbc.co.uk/health/treatments/healthy_living/nutrition/life_adolescence.shtml BBC News. (2006). Mental health link to diet change. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/4610070.stm Byely, L., Archibald, A.B., Graber, J., Brooks-Gunn, J. (2000). A prospective study of familial and social influences on girls' body image and dieting. Int J Eat Disord., 28, 155-64. Butryn, M.L., and Wadden, T.A. (2005). Treatment of overweight in children and adolescents: does dieting increase the risk of eating disorders? Int J Eat Disord., 37(4), 285-93. Curtis. A.J. (2000). Health Psychology, London: Routledge. Cameron, J.W. (1999). Self-esteem changes in children enrolled in weight management programs. Issues Compr Pediatr Nursing, 22, 75-85. Daee, A., Robinson, P., Lawson, M., et al. (2002). South Med J., 95(9). Available from http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/442892_3 Escobar, O., Mizuma, H., Sothern, M., et al. (1999). Hepatic insulin clearance increases after weight loss in obese children and adolescents. Am J Med Sci ., 13, 282-286. French, S.A., Story, M., Neumark-Sztainer, D., Downes, B., Resnick, M., Blum, R. (1997). Ethnic differences in psychosocial and health behavior correlates of dieting, purging, and binge eating in a population-based sample of adolescent females. Int J Eat Disord., 22(3), 315-22. French, S.A., Story, M., Downes, B., Resnick, M.D., and Blum, R.W. (1995). Frequent dieting among adolescents: psychosocial and health behavior correlates. Am J Public Health, 85(5), 695–701. Gruber, A.J., Pope, H.G. Jr, Lalonde, J.K., Hudson, J.I. (2001). Why do young women diet? The roles of body fat, body perception, and body ideal. J Clin Psychiatry, 62, 609-11. Harvard Medical School (2007). Popular Diets: Obesity. Harvard Health Publications. Available from http://www.aolhealth.com/obesity/learn-about-it/popular-diets Morris, A.M., and Katzman, D.K. (2003). The impact of the media on eating disorders in children and adolescents. Paediatr Child Health, 8, 287-9. Neumark-Sztainer, D., Story, M., Hannan, P.J., Perry, C.L., Irving, L.M. (2002). Weight-related concerns and behaviors among overweight and non-overweight adolescents: Implications for preventing weight-related disorders Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med., 156, 171-8. Nemet, D., Barkan, S., Epstein, Y., Friedland, O., Kowev, G., and Eliakin, A. (2005). Short- and Long-Term Beneficial Effects of a Combined Dietary–Behavioral–Physical Activity Intervention for the Treatment of Childhood Obesity. Pediatrics, 115(4), e443- e449. Reilly, J.J., Kelly, L., Montgomery, C., et al (2006). Physical activity to prevent obesity in young children: cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ, 333(7577), 1041 . Retrieved on 19th Feb, 2010 from http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/333/7577/1041 Sothern, M.S., Udall, J.N., Suskind, R.M., et al. (2000). Weight loss and growth velocity in obese children after very low calorie diet, exercise, and behavior modification. Acta Paediatr., 89, 1036-1043. Turner, L.W., Hunt, S.B., Dibrezzo, R., Jones, C. (2004). Health Belief Model. Jones and Bartlett Publishers: LLC WHO. (1946). WHO definition of Health. Available from http://www.who.int/about/definition/en/print.html Wertheim, E.H,. Paxton, S.J., Schutz, H.K., Muir, S.L. (1997). Why do adolescent girls watch their weight? An interview study examining sociocultural pressures to be thin. J Psychosom Res., 42, 345-55. Willi, S., Oexmann, M.J., Wright, N., et al. (1998). The effects of a high-protein, low-fat, ketogenic diet on adolescents with morbid obesity: body composition, blood chemistries, and sleep abnormalities. Pediatrics, 101, 61-67. Read More