Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Should deathrow inmates be required to be organ donors - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Should Death Row Inmates Be Required To Be Organ Donors? Name Number and Name of the Course Instructor Abstract As has been argued in this paper, there are very many patients who die every year for want of organ transplant. These people would be saved through organ donation…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Should deathrow inmates be required to be organ donors
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Should deathrow inmates be required to be organ donors"

Download file to see previous pages Other segment of society must also be targeted. Thus, there should be massive educational and awareness programs and other imitative to let the people appreciate the need for organ donation support. The government could consider giving some kind of allowance, benefits and incentives to those who donate their organs. The issue of family role in matters relating to organ donation and donor decision also need to be addressed. Key Words: Death row inmates, Organ, Organ donation, Organ transplant Should death row inmates be required to be organ donors? There have been proposals among various stakeholders including the legislators and scholars that death row inmates be allowed or worse still, required to donate organs shortly before execution. Others have suggested that the death row prisoners should have their sentences converted to life imprisonment without parole upon donating their kidney, bone marrow or any other organ that may be suitable for transplant. This is seen as a useful way of tapping their organs which would have otherwise been wasted upon execution. However, the issue as to whether the prisoners on the death row should be required to donate organs is a very complex one and involving intricate medical, ethical and legal issues all which needs to be resolved if the most appropriate position is to be reached. While donation of an organ by these prisoners may save some patients in a very desperate situation, it is very vital that their voluntary consent is got and that they are not coerced by legislations and policies to donate the organs. Medical perspectives Organ transplant from the prisoners has a lot of potential health risks. A number of homosexual sex scandals associated with the prison life. 1This implies that the prisoners stand a significantly high risk of being with a transmissible diseases and health conditions, particularly HIV and hepatitis. It is very important that any organ to be transplanted to a recipient must be maximally healthy and this depends on the health of the donor. Whereas there are bloods test that the medics concerned may be able to carry to verify the health of the donor prior to donation, the medics submit that these test methods are not and cannot be a hundred percent effective. As such none of the blood test and screening can be trusted to completely rule out the possibility of a donor being free from these transmissible illnesses. This explains why the doctors have always sought to obtain the history of the donors before making their donation. Even the idea of carryon gouty testing and screening itself raises public issues. Because a very rigorous testing process is to be undertaken, to the extent of clearing any scintilla out doubt as to the health risks posed by the donor to the recipient, lots of public funds will be used in testing the prisoner. This follows from the fact that the government’s department concerned will be interested in knowing the prisoners who are fit to donate and those who are not. In the long run lots of funds may be wasted. This is in contrast with the optional and voluntary donation, where in most cases only those who are at least certain of their health well being will be going to seek testing. The government will therefore be incurring unnecessary expenditure to meet tests and screening which may in the long run end up not being useful. A lot of time will also be wasted carrying out a routine test of those who are lined to provide organ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Should deathrow inmates be required to be organ donors Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Should Deathrow Inmates Be Required to Be Organ Donors Research Paper)
“Should Deathrow Inmates Be Required to Be Organ Donors Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Should deathrow inmates be required to be organ donors

Organ Donation- How recipients are chosen and should donors be compensated

...that payment should be given to the living organ donors and that the amount should go beyond $50, 000. They believed that the organ donors would require money to cover their expenses, such as transport, and indirect expenses such as their time expended and any future medical expenses. However, it is still relative as to the amount of money, which is given out for compensation and how this should be given out. Secondly, there has also been some concerns regarding how it could exploit the poor and result in organ trading, especially, since there have been quite a few cases in recent times,...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Organ Donation

...? Organ Donation in the US Task Introduction Organ donation is a term that refers to the donation of a tissue or organ primarilyof the body, from an existing or lifeless individual to an existing recipient who requires a transplant (Childress & Liverman, 2006). It is a procedure of providing an organ or its constituents purposely for transportation into another individual. For one to qualify as a donor, blood and oxygen should flow within the organs pending recuperation to enhance the success of the procedure. After exhaustion of all efforts to save the patient’s life, carrying out of tests is necessary...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Organ Transplants

...had to be entered in the database and at every time when an organ would be donated, the parameters and specifics of the organ were matched with the database of possible recipients (Nathan,, 2003). Based on the assessment of the transplant center, as supported by a medical professional’s evaluation, an organ would be accepted or rejected in behalf of a potential recipient. Due to the risks which are often placed upon living donors, there is a significant amount of controversy on the use of living organ donors (Nathan,, 2003). Risks relate to the requirement of efficient donor screening...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Paper

Organ Transplants a human being or any other animal) giving the organ to be transplanted is referred to as the donor while the organism who is receiving the new organ is termed as the recipient. The procedure involved in obtaining the organ from the donor and transferring it to the recipient requires high technical knowhow and swift operation with the main goal of saving life of the two parties. With the inception of this science there has been a steady rise in emerging issues that if not looked into is likely to erase its effectiveness and reliability. Discussion A lot of resources were put in research and development to revolutionize...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Organ Transplant

.... Process of Organ Transplantation Organ transplantation calls for therapeutic usage of organs to replace a non-functional organ. However, the medical process is quite complex since organ transplantation comes with its own bag of complications and challenges. Keeping aside the legal issues and paperwork involved, the first step i.e. procurement of a healthy donor is a mammoth task since it care should be taken that the blood types of the recipient as well as the donor matches since “fate of a graft depends not only on excellent surgery with avoidance of damage to the organ in the process,...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Organ donation

...? Organ Donation s Hundreds of people around the world die every single day because of unavailability of organs for organ transplantation. Major illnesses may cause major organs of the body to lose their function while accidents may also severely damage organs inhibiting them from serving the human body and in such cases it becomes immensely important to replace the organ with a new organ through transplantation surgery in order to make sure that the person survives. The organ used as a replacement in the surgery is donated by another human being known as the organ donor. The organ donor may be a cadaver or a live human being. The most important organs that are donated are kidneys, heart, liver, pancreas, lungs, bone marrow, skin... and...
9 Pages(2250 words)Research Paper

Organ donation

...the right of the patient to take action or make a decision without interference or coercion. In the same way, donors have the right to donating their organs and should consent to such action without which it would not be executed. Statistics indicate an increasing gap between the number of organ recipients and organ donors. As observed by Brezina (2010), the number of organs from the dead and living donors falls far below the number of patients waiting for transplant. Because of this high demand, there has been a rise in the black market business for human body organs. Kerridge et al....
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Educating Prison Inmates

...(John Howard Society of Alberta, 2012). Hence, it can be evidently asserted that inmates’ education programs have favorably influenced the American community. In accordance with John Howard Society of Alberta (2012), correctional education needs to address not only the academic and literature knowledge along with thinking skills but also it should reduce recidivism among offenders (John Howard Society of Alberta, 2012). According to a research report, it has be observed that during the year 2004, after getting released from the prison 41% men have remained unemployed and out of these unemployed men 17% were engaged in criminal activities within an one year interval. Thus, it can be asserted that...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Organ Donation

..., or from brain dead patients. In other instances, close relatives, donate their body parts so that their loved ones can survive (Ebadat et al., 2014). In this speech, an argument is made about the positive nature of organ donation, and the need to educate people. Support for organ donation comes from the chance that a dead person has to make a positive difference for the living. A person, who has died in an accident, can give a second chance to another person. Some diseases such as dialysis require expensive treatments, besides placing the patient through trauma and pain. Organ donation can help to remove such issues. The recipient can perhaps rest more easily, if he...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Characteristics of Living Organ Donors among the UK Population

...of the ethical concerns involved in this type of organ donation. Specifically, there is raising concern about the motivations of living organ donors. Directed organ donors may be driven by the family or loved ones’ feeling of obligation to the family member or friend. This can be a form of coercion in such a way that the donors are not fully willing to do the donation, but are only forced to do so because of explicit or implicit pressure arising from the close relationship with the recipient. On the other hand, non-directed living organ donation may have different driving factors, but are equally...
18 Pages(4500 words)Research Proposal
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Should deathrow inmates be required to be organ donors for FREE!

Contact Us