StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Nobody downloaded yet

The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
This paper "The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women" discusses the following issue: a number of defective children are born annually, while practice shows that there are certain risk groups of women with the increased probability of giving birth to a child with congenital defects…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women"

Download file to see previous pages  These are, of course, HIV-positive women, for they can transmit HIV to their children, marginalized groups such as drug and alcohol addicts, and prostitutes engaging in multiple unsafe sexual contacts and face rather frequent cases of an unplanned pregnancy. Birth of defective children imposes numerous difficulties of the society: 1) these children are often abandoned by their mothers (especially when they are heavily disabled), 2) responsibility for care falls on the government, i.e. the state that, in its turn, collects taxes from the population to provide financial aid to orphanages for disturbed children. Moreover, congenital defects often lead to the life-long disability with the individual being unable to be useful for society and being permanently supported by the state. The suggested solution to be discussed is sterilizing women belonging to the groups of risk, making the procedure either obligatory or optional and presupposing certain financial encouragement, as it was described in the book of Michael Sandel.

Firstly, it would be reasonable to clarify the aspects of morality in decisions Kant and Mills imply in their theoretical frameworks. Involving many participants, effects and outcomes, the suggestion of sterilization is complex and requires careful analysis of both of its rationality and of moral acceptance in order to be confirmed as of right or wrong. Kant and Mill have differing views on the definition of moral actions. Kant’s categorical imperative based on the permissibility of action regardless of the results in case it is dictated to an individual by their innate morality (Swartzell). Thereby, Kant’s ethical argument implies that the decision on the moral acceptability of action should depend on the agent’s self-imposed moral laws that rely on rationality, yet are rather subjective.  ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women Case Study, n.d.)
The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women Case Study. https://studentshare.org/ethics/1881632-interesting-topic
(The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women Case Study)
The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women Case Study. https://studentshare.org/ethics/1881632-interesting-topic.
“The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women Case Study”. https://studentshare.org/ethics/1881632-interesting-topic.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women

The unbearable lightness of being

The book The Unbearable Lightness of Being by Milan Kundera is a philosophical study that examines the nature of love and sex, as well as the nature of life through the experiences of a man and his wife, the man’s lover, his lover’s lover, and a dog.In a voyeuristic view of the life that Tomas, the main character lives, the lives of the other characters revolve and grow around the concepts with which Tomas has framed his life. As in all relationships, the pasts help emerging dynamics that reflect the moments within the experiences that each of them have within the events that occur.The nature of the situation is such that Tomas must go through a transformation in order to find a space in which he can truly exist as someone who lov...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

The Power of Suggestion

... 2nd December The Power of Suggestion Suggestion is defined as a psychological process in which one individual guides or dictates the thoughts or behaviours of another individual (Smyth & McGinty, 2003). Hypnosis is one of the more well-known forms of suggestion, but there are also techniques such as neuro-linguistic programming, autosuggestion and indirect suggestion. These techniques have all been shown to be effective to varying degrees, and may be used to persuade an individual to confess a wrongdoing, tell the truth or confess to improper behavior. All of these elements of suggestion are linked in some way, but can be examined separately to show their use in perpetrating honesty in an individual. The purpose of this paper...
4 Pages(1000 words)Article

Preservation of Justice as the Power to Rightness

In the fall off the devil, Anselm says the angels that did not fall are free, and yet cannot sin. This proves that to Anselm, freedom construes the right, and ability to act in the right reason, or meaning having the right intention that cannot lead to sin. In this paper I will review the validity of Anselm’s argument in the statement that “after Satan fell, the angels that did not fall are free and yet cannot sin.” First I will evaluate Anselm’s view relating to the nature of God, secondly, I will review Anselm’s argument concerning, being and the essence of being. This will then lead to the relation between ‘being,’ and preservation of good and evil, evaluating how a being is regarded to be good or evil as related to act and in...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning

... Moral Dilemmas and Moral Reasoning Morality is an aspect that deals with behaviors, ifying them as either good or bad. There are various moral development theories that have been put across to explain individual’s behaviors. Moral development entails children learning to differentiate between what is right and what is wrong (Blasi, 1983). Individuals will then apply such knowledge when faced with complex issues of decision-making. Individuals will have the independence and the strength to do the right thing, even though it might not be the most convenient (Markus& Kitayama, 1991). In children, morality is shaped by various factors, such as their interpersonal experiences they obtain from interacting with their families, peers and other...
3 Pages(750 words)Assignment

Moral Rightness over Legal Rightness: Womens Justice in Glaspells Trifles

... 14 May Moral Rightness over Legal Rightness: Women’s Justice in Glaspell’s Trifles The law is not right, if the conscience says it is wrong. Susan Glaspell’s Trifles problematizes the conflict between what is morally right and what is legally right. The County Attorney, Mr. Hale, and Mr. Peters search the Wright’s house for potential motive on John’s death. Unknown to their husbands, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters discover the motive for Minnie’s crime. The decision of silence shows their struggle against the traditional notion of justice. They realize that legal rightness does not give justice to Minnie’s dehumanized conditions. The play uses setting, choices of staging, characters, symbolism, and irony to argue that when a complex...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Many forms of Grief or your suggestion

...? Many forms of Grief Grief and suffering can indeed break a man. In the book of Job, it was used as a test of how faithful was Job to his Lord. He was wealthy, upright and served the Lord God well. He had everything any man could ask for. His faith was however tested when Satan challenged God that Job was only faithful to Him because he is blessed. He made a challenge to God to take everything from Job that he may suffer and grieve and will hate God. God agreed with one condition that Job will not be killed. So the devil carried on his task and took everything from Job. First his wealth that includes his cattle, his camels, and other possessions. Then his servants and finally his own family that his own son and daughters were... Many forms...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

The Scarlet Letter

...The Scarlet Letter Outline Introduction Social Morality a. puritan tradition and false morals; b. social blindness as a cause of low morals; c. individual choice vs social choice; d. confrontation of morality and traditions e. treatment of women 2. Personal Morality a. Hester b Dimmesdale c. the crowd 3. The Symbol of "A" Letter and its Moral Meaning Conclusion The Scarlet Letter The novel 'The Scarlet Letter" represents moral wisdom and reflects values and morals typical for the Puritans. Social and personal morals of people are depicted through emotional sufferings and experience of the main heroes of the novel: Hester Prynne, her husband Roger Chillingworth and Hester's lover, Dimmesdale. Hawthorne depicts morals of people...
250 Pages(62500 words)Essay

Moral

...The desperate need to be moral within society contributes to the motivations, choices, and actions made by people everyday. It is society which defines what morality is and applies the necessary pressure to force individuals to conform. Often, failing under these societal pressures, individuals are forced to use deception to escape the oppressive nature of their society. Oscar Wilde, in The Importance of Being Earnest and William Shakespeare, in Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, venture into nature of society and how it effects the individuals within that society. Shakespeare and Wilde assert that deception is a symptom of a corrupt society not a character flaw. The plot of The Importance of Being Earnest centers around deception. Algernon...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Moral relativism and Moral absolutism

... require utilizing cultural standards which the critics say that moral relativism does not provide. The critics additionally argue that the concept of moral relativism suggests that we cannot make rightful ethical comparisons between different cultures. They also argue that the concept argues that we cannot perform rightful ethical comparisons in individual cultures over a period of time. This implies that judgments cannot be made concerning changes being experienced in different societies as either being good or being bad. The critics suggest that the concept of moral relativism is not able to make any sense of the changes or comparisons required before a decision is reached (Hammerlinck). The critics additionally perceive the actions...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Moral

... to the invasion of privacy. In addition, if Jane decides to tell the truth about Sue’s plan of carrying out an abortion, she will also be putting the interests of her brother at risk. On the other hand, Sue’s moral stake involves telling the truth that she has been sexually active and taking responsibility of her actions by keeping the baby. Sue also needs to identify the real father of her unborn child. It is Sue’s right to expect her phone call conversations to be entirely private (Fink, 2008). Assuming you are a deontologist like W.D. Ross, how would you weigh the different moral stakes, interests, or duties against each other? That is, are some moral stakes “weightier” than others? Are some moral considerations or interests or stakes...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic The Moral Rightness Of The Suggestion To Sterilize Women for FREE!

Contact Us