Nobody downloaded yet

Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
In the essay “Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold” the author discusses the land ethic, which plays the role of establishing the correlation between the land and biotic community. The land ethic has changed humans to members of the biotic community with an aim of protecting the land…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold"

Download file to see previous pages However, Callicott criticizes Leopold's view by contending that the "professional neglect, confusion, and (in some cases) contempt" for Leopold's writing on the land ethic may be attributed to three things. The three things referred to by Callicott include Leopold’s reference to the writings of Hume, Smith, and Darwin (Callicott, 2012). Notably, Hume and Smith argued that ethics depends on feelings and not reason. Leopold relies on Darwin's theory of evolution of ethics where human beings are members of the "biotic community” which is the land. According to Callicott (1987/2012), Leopold argues, “the development of morality is grounded in evolutionary ideas and the development of moral sentiments predates the development of rational capacities.” Callicott dismisses the interpretation that land ethic requires the sacrifice of humans that interfere with the biotic community as inconsistent with the entirety of Leopold’s land ethic (Callicott, 2012). Callicott argues that Leopold’s land ethic is holistic and not dependent on previous accretions in the evolutionary layers that established the biotic community and pyramid (Callicott, 2012).
We have examples with Leopold's writing that support or refute each of Callicott's arguments. In agreeing with Callicott, that Leopold’s land ethic is holistic and animal liberation is not a criterion to measure the extent to which it is or is not of the environmental sort because animal liberation and conventional anthropocentric ethics are almost identical and have fewer similarities with environmental or land ethics (Jamieson, 1997). For example, “some bacteria and other inanimate entities such as oceans and lakes, mountains, forests, and wetlands have a greater value than individual animals” (Jamieson, 1997). I refute Callicott’s assumption that humans are natural.  ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1650827-environmental-ethics-assignment-4
(Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1650827-environmental-ethics-assignment-4.
“Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1650827-environmental-ethics-assignment-4.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold

Ethics

...?Computer Ethics The “Ten Commandments of Computer Ethics” were put forward by the Computer Ethics institute in 1992 and acts as a starting point in specifying the general principles one must follow when one uses computers. These ‘Commandments’ are very wide and lay out absolute directions without specifying exceptional circumstances when it is permissible not to follow them. In relation to some of these ‘Commandments’, it is understandable that the rule set out is absolute. However, in relation to others, it is not practical and perhaps in some cases not even ethical, to follow such ‘Commandment’ absolutely and to the letter in all circumstances. In my view, the 1st...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethics

...?JUST WAR THEORY: APPLICATION IN LIBYA Recent military actions by the US and NATO in Libya have stirred controversy among Western nations, s, and people in asking whether the approach is necessary, effective, and most of all just. Previous engagements in Iraq and Afghanistan have cast a shadow of doubt across the justification behind foreign intervention in corrupt nations, due to the damage caused by expanding the scope of the war. In Libya, however, there is a clearly stated goal of protecting civilian lives. The controversy still remains, however, as world leaders including presidents Barack Obama and Nikolas Sarkozy insist that Libyan autocrat Muammar al-Gadhafi must go. Many see this as a call for military action against... WAR THEORY:...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Ethics

...ETHICS Professionals undergo ethical dilemmas during the of performing their services. They have to face grave ethical trauma where on the one side they have commitment with their work place and organization, and on the other side they have moral obligation towards the clients and customers. It is particularly the case in medical department, where the nurses have to combat with the conflict between the job responsibilities and the call of conscience while experiencing ethical dilemma. The same is the situation with Deborah in the case under examination. Since Deborah is working as nursing practitioner at a private hospital, she forgets the very reality that private...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Ethics

...? Ethics can broadly be defined as parameters of human interaction that determine what is good or bad. They promote guideline for social interaction so that people can lead a peaceful life. Ethical considerations become complex because people have different perspectives on issues and things. The complex nature of differentiating ethical conduct has promoted various theories. Non consequentialist asserts that acts are good or bad according to their consequences. Thus, rational approach encourages ethical behavior. Again, theory of utilitarianism believes that acts which result in maximum happiness to maximum number of people are ethically right. These are...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Land Ethics and Land Aesthetics

...human beings, perceive the environment as an intricate part of the society, they will realise that its destruction leads to the entire suffering of the human force. The Amazon may not be in America and many assume that its destruction will only affect the communities around it. However, effects of environmental destruction are adverse and universal (Callicott 38). According to Aldo Leopold, the first western environmentalist, nature, politics and economy depend on each other. In addition, Leopold considered the community as a structure not made up of the humans only but other aspects of nature like soil, plants, animals and water (Budd 60). Land ethics focuses on fusing...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Ethics

...?Essay on Ethics My general ethical philosophy is that everyone has the freedom and right to make whatever decisions they deem acceptable. Ethical choices are based on a whole host of different factors, such as personal opinion, societal attitudes, and the circumstances of a given situation. Broader ethical issues are determined by society rather than the individual. For example, most people would agree that it is wrong to steal. There is really no way that someone can justify that, even though they might be in an extreme situation. On the other hand, a personal ethical decision is based on one's own experiences and thoughts. For example, I believe that it would be wrong to cheat on an exam, but there may be others that differ... from that...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Ethics

...? Ethical Dilemma Ethical dilemma is also termed as moral dilemma. Philosophers have discussed ethical dilemma as a situation/condition in which a victim faces a conflict and all possible solutions for the conflict seem morally intolerable. The concept of ethical dilemma has been further elaborated as a dilemma (condition) in which moral principles that could guide the victim to recovery may not be efficient enough to suggest the correct path. The phenomenon of ethical dilemma and approaches that lead to best solutions to resolve conflicting situations can be better understood through different case studies. This paper aims to present a case study related...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Ethics

...? Ethical Systems number: PHI208 Megan McLaughlin submitted: 6/27/13 ETHICAL SYSTEMS Introduction In order to explain morality and ethics, about five or more systems of ethics have been developed. Ethical relativism is one such ethical system, which contends that there are no universally valid principles (Wundt, 2010). With regards to this particular theory, every principle is valid according to specific cultural practices and beliefs. Another theory of ethics is the theory of divine command. This theory makes the argument that God alone is the one who makes decisions on moral standards since he knows everything. A third...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Ethics

...? Healthcare Ethics Practicing nurses are required to abide by stringent ethical and legal regulations due to sensitivity and complexity of nature of their professions. From maintaining privacy to ensuring autonomy of patients, healthcare professionals must take reasonable steps to stimulate change and support transition process. Changes, necessary to promote professional ethics, can be brought about by demonstrating leadership and keeping close coordination with other professionals within and outside clinical settings. Nurses must work within ethical, professional and legal boundaries and report immediately to authorities if they witness any negligence or lack of...
3 Pages(750 words)Coursework

Ethics

...? Defining “Ethically Bad Life” Philosophically of and Number Introduction In all generations, there is the need for society to define what is good and what is bad. This forms the basis for regulating conduct and ensuring that there are no tensions between an individual and other relevant stakeholders. There are many views and ideas that can be used to define what is bad and what is good. One school of thought defines what is what is bad on the basis of a set of universal and absolute laws. Another group define what is bad on the basis of relativist principles that are applied to the circumstances at hand to define what is good and what is bad. This paper evaluates the two approaches to defining “ethically bad life”: deontology... and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Ecocentric Ethics: The Land Ethics by Leopold for FREE!

Contact Us