Nobody downloaded yet

Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Animals - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Animals
According to Immanuel Kant, humans have duties to be kind to animals because these “duties towards animals…are indirect duties towards mankind” ( 64 ). …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Animals
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Animals"

Download file to see previous pages This means that despite them being non-human animals that “are not rational, self-conscious beings capable of grasping the moral law” ( 63 ), they still have intrinsic moral worth. According to Kant, animals are not included in the human territory because only humans are capable of creating and understanding moral laws. This also means that while a human, being an “end in itself” ( 64 ) are not indebted to animals, kindness towards animals “will help develop good character in us and help us treat our fellow human beings with greater consideration” ( 63 ). Aside from making humans less likely to be cruel to other humans, kindness to animals makes human beings fulfill the indirect duties to humanity, which is a categorical imperative. Kant provides good examples of this claim. A dog, for example, may not have rights like humans do, but letting the dog suffer is a reflection of lack of humanity. Kind treatment of the dog, especially one that has been faithful over time, in not necessarily a human being’s duty towards the animal, but a human being’s duty of “humanity which it is his duty to show towards mankind” ( 64 ). Cruelty to animals, according to Kant, reflects in humans an immoral tendency that might be inflicted to fellow humans. However, despite the need to be kind to animals, they should not be treated as ends in themselves. Human beings “serve(s) the will as the objective ground for its self-determination” ( 63 ), yet this is not the same with non-human animals. Animals are a means to an end, and that end is man. This means that while man does not have the right to use other people in ways to serve another human’s end, the case is not the same with animals. Still, one must consider that kindness towards animals is an imperative that will ultimately serve the end purpose that is humanity. Human beings require respect because they are sovereign and have freedom. Such autonomy is important and a creature can only have it by having free will. Since animals do not have the capacity for reason and are not guided by consciousness, they do not really have free will, and are thus not autonomous. Kant has a strong point when he says that one can ask, “Why do animals exist?” ( 64 ). However, the question “Why does man exist?” is meaningless ( 64 ). It seems the argument is that animals exist for a specific purpose, and one of those purposes is to serve the goals of man. Kant’s arguments make strong points. However, some amendments may be done according to some principles of consideration. While animals do not have the capacity for reason, are not guided by consciousness, do not really have free will, and are not autonomous, humans should act with “consideration in satisfying (their) needs and interests” ( 76 ). Singer quotes Bentham: “The day may come when the rest of the animal creation may acquire those rights which never could have been withholden from them but by the hand of tyranny” ( 76 ). Does this mean that consideration of one’s needs and interests apply to animals as well, and that giving animals rights is utterly necessary to reach this goal? To answer this requires not only a slight reconstruction of Kant’s views, but of Singer’s as well. What is required here is to determine if animals have morally significant needs and interests. The emphasis on moral significance means that withholding such could inflict unnecessary harm and suffering to non-human animals. Do animals have welfare or well-being that could benefit or be harmed by the non-existence of animal rights? It could be possible. However, saying this about a creature lacking logic, consciousness, and free will is tantamount to saying the same regarding a, say, car. Do animals have needs and interes ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1482706-you-can-make-a-topic
(Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Essay)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1482706-you-can-make-a-topic.
“Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1482706-you-can-make-a-topic.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Animals

Theories of Human Behavior

...Paradigm Theories of Human Behavior Much of behavior that different individuals portray in the society is highly predictable. Most people always try to conform to behaviors that their society approves to be worthy. The behaviors that are depicted by people are directly influenced by some factors such as the society, environment, and cultural backgrounds. A simple thing like a male and a female holding hand can be perceived in different ways within different cultures, depending on their norms, values, beliefs and ethics. This paper describes the three key theoretical paradigms that dominated the research and study of sociological behavior in the 20th and 21st Centuries. These theories include functionalism, conflict and symbolic... ...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Non-Human Animals

... of the of the Non-Human Animals Rene Descartes (1596-1650) every so often d “the father of modern philosophy” designed the opinion that human being is conspicuously dissimilar from other creatures and the rest of the usual all God's creatures. In Descartes' view, the urge to reason with everyone and almost at everything and the verbal communication are the characteristics that set humans separately from all other kinds. Using the belief of parsimony, wherein one always necessarily begins with the unpretentious details of pragmatic events, Descartes reasons that the perceived actions of all nonhuman living beings can be explained without crediting minds and understanding. He finishes it off with the fact that nonhuman wildlife can... on God...
4 Pages(1000 words)Term Paper

Cognitive and Moral Developmental Theories

...? Examining Cognitive and Moral Developmental Theories: Their Strengths and Limits In psychology there are two general developmental theories that seek to bring understanding of human development. These are classical and contemporary developmental theories. Under each, different theorists have analyzed different constructs, for example, intelligence, morals and cognition. Of particular interest to this paper are the classical cognitive and moral development theories. According to Piaget, knowledge grows with time as individuals make more logic out of reality. This implies that how children think and their...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Theories of Human Behavior

...Theories of Human Behavior ''''''During the early ages, there was a common conception among people that human nature essentially carries either of the two features that is good or bad. Literature has been a great medium that contained reflection of such basic behavioral traits of a person but with the development of human civilization we started to witness that human nature is not the solely either good or bad but it is actually a fusion of both kinds of traits. Looking at the ancient Greek and Roman literature we see that people are classified into two parts that either they are essentially good in nature or they are completely evil...
18 Pages(4500 words)Essay

Human Computer Interaction Theories

...of applications they had previously developed. On the other hand, innovation translation would concentrate on issues of network formation. It would investigate the alliances and networks built up by the consulting company, their programmers, Java, the potential users, and other actors involved in the implementation. It would concentrate on the negotiations that allow the network to be configured by the enrolment of both human and non-human allies, and would consider Java's characteristics only as network effects resulting from association. Actor-network theory would suggest that it is not any innate properties of Java that are important, but rather network associations...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Ethics and Moral Theories

...universal, impartial and rational knowledge is, the more it is a reflection of reality. Status Oriented feminist approaches ask questions about power, before moving on to questions about good versus evil, justice versus care and maternal versus paternal thinking. Nonconsequentalism:- The nonconsequential school of ethical theorists believes that consequences should not enter into our moral judgments and decisions. The actual criterion of judging actions are not consequences, rather we judge actions according to intuitions, intentions, drive and command, etc. It also argues that we cannot generalize from rules or principles because each situation has a different context and can have different...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

Human Devoloped Theories

...and relationships to adaptive human development throughout the lifespan, it describes characteristic crisis, experienced predictably at different stages of the life (Wadsworth, 2004). In comparison, the similarities of the two theories portrayed that some ideas of cognitive theory were imported into the research on the psychosocial theory like emphasis on the role of culture in guiding social and cognitive development. Although, this seems to pose a challenge to social cognition models, the two approaches are not necessary incompatible, especially if the idea is extended to automatic activation of earlier formed intentions. Finally, the vast of majority of studies are...
8 Pages(2000 words)Research Paper

Theories Concerning Human Development

...psychosexual aspects which incorporate five major stages such as oral stage, anal stage, phallic stage, latency stage and genital stage (Sulloway, 135). Erik Erikson The basic tenets of the psychosocial theory of Erikson focus on eight major stages through which the development of individuals is experienced from infancy to late adulthood. These stages include Basic Trust v Mistrust; Autonomy v Shame, Initiative v Guilt; Industry v Inferiority; Identity v Confusion; Intimacy v Isolation; Generativity v Stagnation and Integrity v Despair (Papalia 493). Lawrence Kohlberg The psychosocial theory of Kohlberg constitutes six recognizable stages of human moral and ethical...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Reliance Theories and Moral Obligation

...Reliance Theories and Moral Obligation The fundamental western philosophy argues that human beings are to some extent self-reliant. Social institutions rely on the belief of autonomy where people have freedom to worship, marry, and work. There are various reasons that explain the use of the stakeholder’s theories. The coping strategy proposes that the chance of having a governmental intervention and regulations increases when decision making in business conflicts with the society’s expectations. The second reason involves self-interest. The goal of any business in a capitalistic society is to make a profit regardless of its effects to the society. Some scholars such as...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Moral theories

...Moral Theories Affiliation: There are two general types of moral theories Morality is relative and (2) Morality is universal. Which of these would best represent your own views? The concept of morality varies depending in the culture and this is the reason that even in hospitals when treating and caring for patients, a nurse has to consider the culture of the patient and factor it in the treatment plan. If morality was universal where it indicates that there is one moral solution of every ethical problem in society, it would mean that all individuals are similar and hence what applies to...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Indirect Theories and Moral Equality Theories on Kindness to Non-Human Animals for FREE!

Contact Us