Nobody downloaded yet

Immigration Wars - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Gaurav Sandhu Professor Lace May 19, 2011 English 101 Rhetorical Analysis Illegal immigration in America can be a heated and contentious topic in today’s political environment. Eduardo Proctor presents a rhetorical argument contesting economic claims levied against the illegal immigrants’ impact on California’s high school dropout workers…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
Immigration Wars
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Immigration Wars"

Download file to see previous pages However, the under utilization of pathos can be a highly effective tool in delivery of an argument when seeking to avoid an overly emotive response in politically charged subject matter. It is well known in the written rhetorical argument the writer is wise to embrace the concepts of logos, ethos, and pathos. The more difficult the subject matter, the more critical it is to master these rhetorical elements. Eduardo Proctor tackled a difficult topic in an aspect of illegal immigration. In Proctor’s lack of pathos, he successfully demonstrates the effectiveness of coupling logos and ethos as standalone tools of the rhetorical argument. Eduardo Proctor’s primary argumentative focus in the “Cost of Illegal Immigration May Be Less Than Meets the Eye” was logos. Proctor not only established credibility with his apt usage of statistics, he used them to maintain his credibility throughout the article. The best application of logos is found be in the statistical comparison of wage loss percentages between that of California and Ohio during the years of illegal immigration surges. He clearly identified that while illegal immigration critics cited wage declines in California, Proctor competently demonstrated Ohio, which has little to no illegal immigration saw nearly three times the low-income wage loss in the same period. By doing this early in the write, Proctor effectively attracted attention by using factual data that many may not have been aware. This effective use of logos literally forced the reader to continue hearing his argument. While starting the argument with statistics, Proctor was hardly done with logos. He continually reinforced credibility by repeatedly referring to the dates and time line in question. Why was this effective? This hit the mark for Proctor because he was referring to a period of spanning some 25 years. An important aspect of this article is the fact that the period in question is not a snapshot. This was originally introduced in the second sentence of the article because Proctor identified this as the key element of his argument. Proctor effectively applied the statistical date reference by referring to it no less than six times. He further built his credibility with this statistic by subtly referring to it in varying manners. By stating it as “quarter decade” and “since the 1980’s” allowed the reader to grasp the scope of time without losing interest through redundancy. Proctor was also effective in his use of quotes to build credibility. He quoted well-identified, credible sources. To establish his sources, he listed them by name, profession as it pertained to his argument, and organization. Proctor utilized appropriate quotes to support his argument without belaboring the quotes with inappropriate or off topic information. The quotes were precise, direct, and factually based. To achieve success in this, Proctor identified the individuals he cited, as “economists” to establish they were on the same level of those from which he was dissenting. In quoting one of the economists he cited, "’Illegal immigration had a little bit of a role reinforcing adverse trends for the least advantaged, he said, but there are much stronger forces operating over the last 25 years.’" This was an ideal quote because it both builds credibility and solidifies Proctor’s use of statistics. The element of logos has been highly effective in this article. However, Proctor did not ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Immigration Wars Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422746-immigration-wars
(Immigration Wars Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422746-immigration-wars.
“Immigration Wars Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1422746-immigration-wars.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Immigration Wars

Immigration

...Immigration In the book, Crossing Over, Ruben Martinez tells us a story of a poor Mexican family that undertakes a journey to find hope, better future and prosperous lives; a journey on a migrant trail. The story is all about crossing or not crossing. It relates to a physical journey of a family in search of a fulfilling future, however, it can also be said that Crossing Over is about their mental journey as well, as they travel through different geographical routes. Ruben Martinez, a Mexican-American news correspondent and a journalist, was devastated to hear the tragic incident that involved three of the Mexican brothers who lost their lives when the truck, carrying 26 undocumented migrants, including them, turned over...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper

Persian Wars

...? Persian Wars (499-479 BC) Two main factors led to the Persian Wars. First, in Persia’s pursuit for gold, Persia expanded their territory into Western Asia Minor and into Thrace on the European side of the Aegean causing the Ionian Greeks to be under their control, as documented by a web article entitled FC23A: the Persian Wars. Second, Solon's reforms and Peisistratus’ seizing control of Sigeum had made Athens especially sensitive to any threats to its grain route from the Black Sea. Further complicating this was the fact that several Athenian nobles held lands in the North Aegean. However, the spark igniting this into war with the Persians was a revolt of the Ionian...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

CULTURE WARS

...? 10 May Culture wars: Humans have always been quite vigilant when it comes to promoting and protecting the ancient cultural and moral values that shape any society or form the bedrock of a particular culture. In the eastern civilization, some major worth mentioning values are bravery, possessiveness, perseverance, and aggressiveness that are all male-oriented values. Some distinguished female-oriented values are sensitivity, watchfulness, and observing purdah. Men and women of the eastern culture have always been extremely careful about protecting these values. Historically, the cultural values that are male-oriented come from the many historical wars that were fought for protecting Islam and expanding...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Cola Wars

...? Cola Wars Task Coca-Cola and Pepsi cola are the leading organizations in the global carbonated soft drinks market. Powerful competition between Pepsi and Coca-Cola has been in the soft-drink industry for a long time, over a century. In this chess game of colossal firms, Coca-Cola was at the top and in power of the carbonated soft-drink industry in the 1950s to the 1970s. It had outsold Pepsi two to one, eventually this war moved geared to another level, global level that ended up being a “soft drink world war”. This war has been fought from different angles - in advertising, challenges of taste and with prices. The global bottle warring companies, despite their differences, have managed to remain the principal players... in the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Napoleonic Wars

...Why was France ultimately defeated between 1812 and 1815 There are a number of reasons for the defeat of France between 1812 and 1815, Some were internal to France, such as the nature of Napoleon, and others were external such as the campaigns and the war in Russia, the campaigns in Germany and the ultimate defeat at Waterloo. Maybe Napoleon's personality is the major factor- he never wanted to give up and did not listen to his commanders. Perception is as important as reality within many political relations and within conflicts between countries. In 1812 Napoleon enjoyed a mythology as being almost invincible, even if he might have at least temporary setbacks. By the end of 1813 that mythology of invincibility had...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

States Make Wars, but Wars Make States

...History Running head: MAKES WARS, BUT WARS MAKE S s make wars, but wars make s Write here Write the of theinstitution here The essence of human society will always be intricately connected to the nature of one of the most astonishing human sociological creations, the state. In order to understand the correlation between state and war, one must define the term "state". Many philosophers and sociologist throughout human history have given their own point of view on what a state really is. In Max Weber's influential definition, it is that organization that has a "monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory". Thomas...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Wars

...Wars The aim of the work is to discuss the arguments against war. It should be admitted, that despite the recent campaigns for leading wars in different parts of the world, war itself is absolutely negative phenomenon, though in order to prove its negativity the arguments should be discussed in the more details. It is not always possible to know which of the sides of the conflict is guiltier The present world has become the witness of the fact, when wars were started as soon as any suspicion in the wrong actions has been held or supported. We have become the witnesses of the war between US and Iraq; the recent events show us the intervention of the US to Somali, though there is no clear evidence of the fact that the terrorist... ...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Cola Wars

...Conclusion The analysis of Cola Wars covers four major aspects of the companies ly strategic analysis, financial analysis, human resources analysis, and marketing analysis. Threat of new entrants in the soft drink industry is low. Bottlers have low to moderate buyer power and have limited bargaining power. Suppliers have high bargaining power. Cola’s substitutes are from outside the soft drink industry. There is significant rivalry between the competitors, though the industry is generally dominated by Coca Cola and Pepsi. Coke and PepsiCo have both experienced an increase in ROE over the decades. While the Equity/Assets ratio of PepsiCo has increased over the decades, it has remained nearly the same for Coke. Coke has...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

STAR WARS

...and pump in water. The principle of contraction and expansion works best here. When cold water comes in contact with the hot rocks, fractures develop on the rocks thus giving room for water to horizontally move towards the already drilled second hole. Steam escapes through this second hole to reach the earth’s surface. Depending on what has been set up, the steam can be used in turning turbines or steam engines (World Nuclear Association, 2013). Permanent disposal of war nuclear waste is increasingly becoming a problem because it takes a very long time for the waste isotopes to decay into safe levels. Even though waste management specialists’ advice users to bury such wastes deep below the ground; it is easy for...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment

Star Wars

...Star Wars: Sci-fi or Fantasy? Introduction Star Wars is a series of films that revolve around aliens and space battles. The films also depict eventsrelated to ghosts and mystical powers. This paper will attempt to explore Star Wars as science fiction, but it does not only rely on a scientific viewpoint, but also a religious one to develop its mythical elements. However, there is much debate on the subject of difference between sci-fi and fantasy. While sci-fi deals with scientific technologies that are considered probable in the future, fantasy talks about stories and events that exist only in the realm of imagination. While it is no doubt Star Wars deals with advanced...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Immigration Wars for FREE!

Contact Us