Google's e-library - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Fair use is an "affirmative defense to what would otherwise be an infringing act, such as reproducing a copyright work 17 U.S.C & 107 (200); Campbell. Acuff-rose Music, Inc (1985). People think Google should be punished for scanning these books without authors’ permission,…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Google's e-library
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Google's e-library"

Four fair use factors affiliation Fair use factors Fair use is an "affirmative defense to what would otherwise be an infringing act,such as reproducing a copyright work 17 U.S.C & 107 (200); Campbell. Acuff-rose Music, Inc (1985). People think Google should be punished for scanning these books without authors’ permission, while others believe that it should consider the law of fair use as Crews (1993) points out "fair use doctrine helps to prevent the copyright owners exclusive right from interfering with the frames stated purpose of the promotion of learning" as cited in Cohen, 2001, p. 170). Google has to satisfy each criteria of the fair use four factors test. There are four factors to scanning or copying books according to the fair use principle.
Fair use is the most significant limitation on the copyright holders exclusive rights (United States Copyright Office, 2010, para. 1). “The four factors are: the purpose and character of the use, the nature of the copyrighted work, the amount and substantiality of the portion used and the effect to the use on the potential market Value of the Work (Hanratty, 2005).”
The first factor is about the purpose of copying commercial or educational purpose. Google says that it is not making profit from scanning; therefore, it is not commercial making profit by advertising. "Google also gave a copy to the library and allows authors to chose if they want their books scanned or not. For example Google also has this option policy where by the copyright holder can select not to get his/her book digitized" (Prasad and Agarwala. 2008.258). In order not to cause any effect or harm in commercial benefit therefore Google project will provide snippets only Moreover, Google will share the digitals copies for all libraries. Merely "coping a book into a digital format would not be deemed transformative because all that Google is changing in the medium print to digital see Kirkwood, 150 F.3d at 108, n.2."
The law states that whether the use is for non-profitable or commercial nature, this analysis should be taken into consideration. In circumstances where the analysis is for business purposes, presumption deliberates in contradiction to fair use. Practically, the court has found that commerciality is of no significant use to determine fair use. This can be attributed to the commercialization of secondary sources of copyright materials inclusive of the legal preamble. The root of this inquiry is to note whether the users profit by exploiting the copyrighted material devoid of customary price payment.
The offset of the commercial aspect of the use character is determined by whether or not the use is transformative. This transformative use changes or adds the copyrighted work to give it a new meaning, message, and expression. For this reason, the more the work is transformative, the more there will be a shift in the balance to fair use, and something new must be created from the transformation. Thus in this analysis the commercial factor deliberates against Google due to its nature of copying books to enhance its service value to their customers and selling of advertisement space that is similar to the copyrighted work (HANRATTY, 2005).
The second factor is the nature of the copyrighted bookwork. There are two types, which are factual work and creative work "the more creative the expression embodied in a work, the more likely a copy will not be fair use" cabbell. Acuff-rose Music, Inc. 510 U.S. 569,586 (1994). Google does not allow users to copy or scan the entire book; it only displays the bibliographic information that makes finding books easier for people. On the other hand "copyright office is preparing recommendation to Congress on how to address the orphan works problem- how to enable uses of works whose owners cannot be identified and/or located" (Band, 2006).
In this analysis, the more the manifestation of creativeness undergoes personification in the work, the higher the chances that the copy of the work will not be fair use. Additionally, the copyright system is meant to provide monopoly to authors thus providing an encouragement to create. Congruently, by replicating the facts, as well as the factual elements of creative works, there is a more likelihood of it being fair use. Additionally, whether work is published is also an important characteristic. Additionally, in the parody, even pure original uses can be fair. In this analysis, Google creates exact duplicates of works, some of which will blend unique fact and expression while others will be pure original expression. As a result, Google fails to show some accepted fair use reason and thus this factor will weigh against Google.
The third factor refers to the quantity and the quality, how much scanning can harm the market. Google only scan the entire books that depending of the type of the book and just displays part of it. "in the context of internet searching engines, there are two cases in which reproduction and archiving of the entirety of copyrighted content found on web sites have been deemed a fair use" (Kelly v. Arriba soft, 336 f.3d 816, 822 (2003).
Making of duplicates that are not significant in their dimensions might prevent fair use if the copy captures the work’s essence substantively. On one end of the spectrum, copying the whole work might prevent the finding of fair use. Typically, when an individual replicates the whole work and uses it for its creative purpose with no added benefits to the public, the fair use policy is inapplicable. As well, a copy of a completely original work can be still fair use in the right conditions. In Google case, investigations of sustainability and amount appear to deliberate besides a fair use finding. Google is replicating books in their totality thus preventing fair use unless justifying factors are found. For this reason, by observing Google in this light, this analysis weighs in favor of fair use.
Last but the least the fourth factor is the effect of copyright project in the market “it encompasses within its fold not only the existing and potential market of the work but also its derivatives" (Sony Corp. of America v. Universal City Studios, Inc. 464 U.S 417 (1984). The above-mentioned factors are most important and critical for Google’s e-library project, because with the help or understand of the mentioned factor Google will be able to identify whether this project goes under fair use or not.
In the analysis of fair use, this factor is considered to be the single most significant. It relates to the result that the possibly infringing use has on the prospective market for, or the importance of, the copyrighted work. Markets considered are the existing ones and any potential market for the derivative or original works creators might license others to develop or improve themselves.
Furthermore, usage that substitutes for original is not considered as fair use since it affects the market for the original. Thus, making consumers turn away from the original. This factor does not comprise only the loss of value: even though the use makes the proprietor of the copyright gain, this factor can still weigh against fair use. For this reason, the appropriate query is not on the effect of Google’s project in the market but also the impact on the market if there were myriad websites carrying out the same service. Lastly, due to the grouping of incredible grasp of Google’s project and the amount of copyright holders harmed by the project. Moreover, with the fact that Google is a for-profit company that generates revenue from this venture, it appears the project is commercial and affects the copyright holder’s potential licensing rights. As a result, this factor would deliberate against a finding of fair use.
Hanratty, E. (2005). Google Library: Beyond Fair Use? Duke Law & Technology Review, 1- 18. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Google's e-library Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Google's e-library Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from
(Google'S E-Library Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Google'S E-Library Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words.
“Google'S E-Library Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Google's e-library

World's religions

... due: World’s religions The article on world’s religions talks about ways which the religious people seek ways of transforming their lives to walk in the light. The writer tries to explain these concepts using yoga. Yoga is derived from the word yoke; it is an exercise designed to lead to integration or union. He looks at Hinduism and Christianity. Unlike the west, Indians use yoga to gain control of the body functioning. Both religions agree the end goal is to do what God pleases and align all our ways to God’s ways. Hinduism has sought different ways to please God that work for different people. While Christianity uses specific ways that may not necessarily work for everyone. It looks at four paths to the goal. The first one... due: World’s ...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Mill's Utilitarianism

... Mill’s Utilitarianism It would not be an exaggeration to suggest that one of the characteristic features of the humansociety lies in the fact that actions of the people who belong to it are often viewed through the prism of Ethics. John Stuart Mill was one of the philosophers who contributed an ethical theory titled Utilitarianism, explaining what actions should be considered to be right. This paper will analyze in details one of its quotes about justice. To begin with, one should not that Mill pays particular attention to the above mentioned notion since it, according to him, it is often seen as the greatest obstacle on the way of accepting the doctrine that he developed (41). That is why he tries to show that justice... Mill’s...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Women' s right

... Grace Chang: Disposable domestics The book offers a broad of how immigrant women go to the extent of taking low-wage job and getting into numerous collusion path with the U.S government as well as the hiring organizations. The author seek to offer a detailed account of the challenges that the immigrant women must endure in order to survive and provide for their families. Together with Miriam Louie, they sought offer a voice to the many immigrant women who are constantly under threats and intimidations. Chang writes a compelling and disturbing account of the complicity between the U.S. government, private employers and corporations to control welfare and immigrant policies to the detriment of poor women. Chapter by chapter... Grace Chang:...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review

Aristotle's Theory

... Aristotle against Epiphenomenalism In the modern scientific knowledge, epiphenomenalism is a teaching, considering the mind and consciousness as phenomena, which only accompany physiological processes (Robinson). Epiphenomenalism suggests that mental processes do not play an active role in a causal link defining various physiological states. The mind-body problem is being examined through the denial of the significance of mental processes in the physiological functioning of the body. Analyzing the philosophy of Aristotle, one can argue that he does not support epiphenomenalism. Despite the fact that Aristotle believes that the soul exists until there is a body, the philosopher recognizes activity of the mental processes... Aristotle against...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

LBJ's Wars

...thus the dilemma why US Troops had to go to Vietnam. Truman Doctrine was an attempt to go save the Middle East and Asian countries (Herring and Redford 124) Was the Vietnam War a "necessary war"? Why or why not? It was necessary because of the conflict between the United States and the Soviet Union regarding who was the superpower. It was like a world war where the future governance of the international system was the one at stake (Herring and Redford 130). The great nations that were opposing the United States and their allies were like the German Nazis during the world war. Works Cited Johnson, S.M. Emotionally Focused Couple Therapy with Trauma Survivors: Strengthening Attachment Bonds. New York: The Guilford Press. 2005....
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework

Girl's Eucation

...immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and AIDS, but all this deprive the girls of being educated. Poverty: when families fail to provide basic needs for their members, something has to fill up that gap. It leads to lack of control and prevailing over teaching of the young ones. On the other hand, education comes at a cost and the girl child might never enter the doors providing education when brought up in a poor family (Feeney, 2013). The associated emotional aspects of poverty, as illustrated in the movie, include distress, psychiatric problems and may lead to suicidal actions. References Feeney, M. (2013, June 3). Girls Rising. Retrieved April 27, 2015, from Boston Globe:...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Google's case study

...Culture and Leadership Google Inc. is among the largest corporations in the global information technology industry. The company is responsible for some notable innovations like Gmail, Android, and Google Nexus among other services and products. Based on the case study, Google started from a humble and grew rapidly because of its innovative structure. The following three statements can summarize the culture in Google. Teamwork fosters creativity and a sense of belonging that allows employees to thrive. Innovation and creativity are essential to growth and development. Everything worth doing should be done in the best possible way. The needs of the consumer are the most...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Alzheimer's Disease

...been proposed to be a part of the aging process forming a part of the logic of evolution. The disease could be an aspect of a genetically programmed death which forces old generation to give space to new generations. Work cited Kokjohn, Tyler A., and Kimbal E. Cooper. "The Outlook for Alzheimers Disease." The Futurist 39.5 (2005): 34-7. ProQuest.Web. 28 Apr. 2015. Open the attachment below Abstract of the cited paper. The rise of Alzheimers disease in recent decades is a tragic side effect of a great success story: the increase in human longevity. The modern emergence of Alzheimers may represent a confluence of several separate...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment

Women's issue

...Gender Wage Gap Women are the primary breadwinners in six out of ten families in America. Apart from this, it is apparent that they earn 75% of every dollar earned by men. Additionally, it is evident that the majority of the women are disproportionately piled in lowest-paying fields in addition to being poorly represented in well-paying fields (Covert, 2015). The issue of gender wage gap can be addressed with much ease through observing a simple plan like the one I will outline below: First, it is crucial for the US government to enforce all organizations as well as offices to treat women 100% in pay, opportunity as well as advancement through coming up with a rule that protects working women. The success of this, however... Wage Gap Women...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment


...McDonald’s YourFirst YourLast Political Trends According to the Economist , McDonald’s has set its base in over 95 states, so its political coverage is spread everywhere. Normally, McDonald’s, like any other fast food restaurant, has to observe government’s guidelines in relation to health cleanliness and sanitation. Some régimes have been compelling the fast food sector, for the reason that fast food has been regarded as junk food, resulting to obesity, circulatory problems and high levels of cholesterol. For example, McDonalds has been unable to invest heavily in Scandinavian countries as it has done in other countries because of tough rules that those countries have imposed the fast food industry. Economic Trends Being... YourFirst...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Google's e-library for FREE!

Contact Us