We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Does Jessica Cohen, in her Grade A: The market for a Yale Woman's eggs, meet the requirements for a person of integrity as defined by Stephen L. Carter in his , The rules about rules - Essay Example

Comments (0)
The first step is the discernment of what is wrong from what is right. The second step involves acting on the basis of that discernment, and consistent with the discernment, regardless basically of consequences, and…
Download full paper

Extract of sample
Does Jessica Cohen, in her Grade A: The market for a Yale Woman's eggs, meet the requirements for a person of integrity as defined by Stephen L. Carter in his , The rules about rules

Download file to see previous pages... This paper examines whether Cohen’s actions in her essay passes the three-step test for integrity prescribed by Carter, and argues that in fact, by discerning that egg donation is wrong, and by acting on that discernment and making it known through her published piece that he intends to shun egg donation, that he passes Carter’s integrity test (Cohen; Carter).
First it is important to note that Carter differentiates between honesty and integrity. One can say with little argument that Cohen was being honest, by writing about her thoughts in such a public way, about her experiences dealing with a couple who was looking for an egg donor for financial considerations, and to whose ad she responded. She was forthright in saying what she thought eventually of the whole thing. On the other hand, Carter says that integrity is more than just honesty. As embodied in his three steps, first there has to be discernment. Second, a person of integrity has to have the courage to act on what he or she has discerned. A person for instance may be against slavery, but unless that person also acts to end slavery, or free slaves, then that person has no integrity, even if he or she professes with honesty that he or she is against slavery. There has to be the three elements or three steps present to be able to say that a person has integrity. Say Cohen is honest, and the article seems very honest, but that does not necessarily make Cohen a person of integrity by the standards of Carter (Carter; Cohen).
So if Cohen was not a person of integrity for being honest about her thoughts and feelings about being an egg donor to a couple, then more must be done to examine whether in effect Cohen followed the three steps that Carter prescribed in his text on integrity. Looking at Cohen’s piece, one gets the sense that at the end she made a decision not be part of the whole thing. But then again towards the end the decision was made for her too. She was rejected by the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
The Cider ahouse Rules
The movie is of special relevance to American audiences, for it deals with the subject of abortion which has been a politically and culturally contentious issue for a long time. The plot is centered on the life of Homer Wells, an orphan, who grows up in an orphanage after being returned twice by his foster parents.
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Discovery rules
Likewise, guidelines and regulation enforcement is encountered with a rapidly growing amount of cybercrime problems which include hacking and malware. Therefore, efficient systems specifically aimed for the forensic examiners need to be implemented so as to keep up with the forever-changing competition in the industry.
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper
The Rules Governing the Insanity Defence in Order to Determine When a Person Should Not Be Criminally Liable
The court found him insane whom in an assassination attempt to Robert Peel the British Prime Minister, mistakenly killed his secretary. This led to the formation of strictures whereby it was avowed that a defendant was required to have a mental condition or illness and even retardation that was required to be severe to an extent that the defendant had no insight as to the quality and nature of the act committed without the knowledge that the act was wrong.
14 Pages(3500 words)Essay
The French New Wave is about Breaking the Rules
The French New Wave is a term used to express displeasure with the French film makers of the 1950s and 1960s. This movement was never organized formally. According to Bazin (1985, 248-259), this group of film makers deliberately rejected the traditional classical cinematic form.
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay
Rotterdam Rules Essay
The paper deals with the major changes in the rules in the Rotterdam Rules in comparison with the other laws. It discusses the major changes and their impact on the various parties involved, namely carrier, performing parties and the insurer. The paper tries to explain the impact with respect to each of the changes.
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
The Hague Rules
In England, these considerations led to the promotion of model bills of lading and to unsuccessful demands for legislation. Numerous efforts were made to secure a uniform international approach; as a result, The Hague Rules1 was finally drafted by the Maritime Law Commission of the International Law Association at meeting held at Hague in 1921, after considerable discussions among the representatives of either side.
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
A project is defined set of rules or functions that meet the pre-defined set of objectives
A project is defined set of rules or functions that meet the pre-defined set of objectives. The objective can be the goals for getting or accomplish that project. The project is created it need some resources like communication, space, energy, materials, people, money, etc.
9 Pages(2250 words)Assignment
Sociology: According to Becker, deviance is not a quality of the act the person commits, but rather a consequence of the application by others of rules and san
e we can understand how it was that Becker created a theory in which the labeling of a person who has committed deviant acts as being detrimental to the future of the person as well as the society in which the person is in as they will be morally judged and thus pushing them
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Write a paper about Michael Pollan's Food Rules
Processed foods have flooded the market and every brand claims to be more beneficial and nutritious than other. On the contrary, obese people have grown in number manifolds in recent years owing to bad eating habits and excessive consumption of food rich in fats and
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
Ask an old person about his or her life ( assignment )
Past generation fought hard for their survival and therefore they have more life experiences than the present generation. Learning from the past will help current people to manage tougher life situations at present. Because of the above awareness, I decided to
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
Let us find you another Essay on topic Does Jessica Cohen, in her Grade A: The market for a Yale Woman's eggs, meet the requirements for a person of integrity as defined by Stephen L. Carter in his essay, The rules about rules for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us