Human nature is not cruel - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
On the basis of Milgram’s experiment and the Kitty Genovese event, (Catherine Kitty Genovese was a young woman,28 years of age, who was brutally murdered by a man, Winston Moseley, who attacked and stabbed her…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.2% of users find it useful
Human nature is not cruel
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Human nature is not cruel"

Tianjiao Zhang Kuehner English 151RW
Oct 23, 2014
Human nature is not cruel
Several terrible things take place every single minute nowadays. On the basis of Milgram’s experiment and the Kitty Genovese event, (Catherine Kitty Genovese was a young woman,28 years of age, who was brutally murdered by a man, Winston Moseley, who attacked and stabbed her on Friday of 13th March,1964 outside her home in Queens as she was coming home from work .All this took place while 38 witnesses observed and did nothing to save her),the “bystander effect” refers to the fact that people are less likely to help other people in distress, while in crowd.
Whereas, Kitty’s case has been subjected to several inaccuracies and misrepresentations, many other similar cases have been reported recently. Clearly, then, the “bystander effect” can have a strong impact, especially on social behavior, leaving people asking why exactly does it occur? And why do people not assist others when they are part of a crowd?
More and more people are starting to pay attention and consider such kind of events as these. What leads people to become more apathetic, immoral or even cruel? Is human nature cruel? Human beings are not born cruel. A baby is always naïve and pure, they are not intentionally cruel to others. I believe that humans are not always cruel depending on certain circumstances surrounding an individual.
Furthermore, Milgram’s experiment is all about obedience to authority. It found that 65 percent of participants deferred to the authority of the experimenter and administered the final 450 volt "shock”. The other 35 percent refused to continue with the experiment. This experiment tells us that people always obey authority. I don’t believe the 65 percent of subjects were cruel just because they completed the experiment. They wanted to stop the experiment, but the experimenter kept emphasizing things such as “the experiment requires that you continue, go on please, the shocks are painful but they are not harmful.” It made participants very nervous and confused, meaning that the experimenter’s authority pushed them to be cruel and even hurt innocent people.
In brief, Milgram’s experiment is not enough proof that human nature is cruel, but people will be cruel under certain circumstances. Any normal person, usually, will not easily hurt others just for the sake of it. And if they do hurt someone they will definitely feel guilty. Someone however could be wondering that, if human nature is not cruel, then why are there so many murderers in the world? I believe murdering someone is cruel, but they are not always cruel. “People are likely to do anything to anyone if instructed to do so.” If they feel threatened or instructed by authorities, they are bound to do something cruel.
When Kitty Genovese event happened, people felt sad about the whole episode, and may easily end up condemning the 38 witnesses, as to why they never did anything to save her inspite of her pleas and screams for help. Assuming you were one of the witnesses, would you have dared come out, on hearing Kitty screams and pleas for help at that unearthly hour (3.20 am)? Would you have rushed out to help her? I am of the opinion that majority of the people will uphold justice, and claim that they would have come out and helped the young lady, but when people are indeed in real danger, I don’t think all of them will act as they claim.
Why do I say so? Because I have been to New York before and I am aware of all the hustle and bustle present in that city. Just like Kitty Genovese event happened, someone may absolutely fail to assist a person in distress. New York is an extremely, fast-paced large populated city, bustling with activity. New York urbanites lack a true show of humanity and everyone is busy, hurrying to accomplish their many and varied chores. This is one of the reasons which lead people to being indifferent to others as well as events taking place things around them. However, this also is not adequate proof that human nature is cruel.
In some occasions, people become indifferent because of the environment. However, under such a circumstance, people turn out to be selfish and indifferent, but not cruel. In addition, 38 witnesses is just a small account of number, in a big society and environment and thus cannot entirely be used as an argument for people being cruel. The murderer who killed Kitty Genovese is the real cruel person. There are several factors that could have contributed to the 38 witnesses behaving the way they did. One of them is what is known as responsibility diffusion, which possibly could have been contributed by the other witnesses. Since there were other people in the neighborhood, the witnesses did not feel compelled or pressurized enough to act, because the responsibility to act is believed to be shared amongst everyone present.
In conclusion, therefore, human nature, generally, is not cruel, but people will be cruel under certain circumstances. Many different kinds of situations and temptations will push people to become cruel. No one wants to be a loser, and it is no doubt that everyone craves success. But reality is cruel; it’s impossible for everyone to become successful. People may, thus, become cruel not because of their human nature but due to their present surrounding circumstances. Psychologist also argue that one can reduce the “bystander effect” is by being aware of it themselves and actually, this is the best manner to break the cycle. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Human nature is not cruel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words”, n.d.)
Human nature is not cruel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words. Retrieved from
(Human Nature Is Not Cruel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words)
Human Nature Is Not Cruel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words.
“Human Nature Is Not Cruel Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 Words”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Human nature is not cruel

Human Nature

...?Human Nature The theories of human nature are still on the process of development. These theories on how people are acting, thinking, and reacting on its environment undergoes this process of development for as long as human is existing. Humans, being there on everyday life, must choose what thing to do or what path to walk. For his everyday and lifetime realization of his dreams, a person must then choose his actions and reactions for his environment. Every action he takes or he misses to take will be a great deal for his future and a barricade for what he wishes to be. The idea that human beings have an inherent sense...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

The Dammed Human Race

...vast amount of food but none of the animals stored food. He states that these animals do not store food because they are not avaricious and miserly. However, animals do not store food like men because wild animals obtain food from the nature and tame animals are fed by humans. They do not need to store food. If animals cultivated their own food, they would have responded differently. In the competitive human life, if men do not store enough food and money, the chance of their survival decreases in case of any mishap. They have to be prepared to any face natural disaster or life changing event such as loss of a job. There are numerous examples that show that men are not...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Cooper Union Building

16 Pages(4000 words)Essay

Human nature

...Is it Human Nature to be Cruel to other? According to the Concise Oxford Dictionary, being cruel to others is defined by having pleasure at other people’s suffering, or simply put, enjoying other people’s suffering. There are people who believe that cruelty or being cruel to others is part of human nature with most of them trying to explain their position by arguing that it is because on cruelty that subjects in the Stanley Milgram’s experiment acted as they did, and why none of the 38 people who witnessed and heard Kitty Genovese call for help did not respond to help or even call the police. Yes, I agree with their...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Human Nature

...Task: Give a critical analysis of one philosophical view on human nature. How close do you think it comes to the 'truth' Excerpt: This paper investigates the human tendency to indulge in criminal acts, whether biological factors play vital role in instigating the desire in the instinctive demand or social norms have significant characteristics to mould the habit of individuals in the society. Order#: 198872 Deadline: 2007-12-22 18:57 Style: General Language Style: English UK Pages: 6 Sources: 6 Writer ID: 6746 INTRODUCTION: THE RATIONALISTIC APPROACH OF HUMAN NATURE 'Every human is indeed a slave of circumstances.' An honest man...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

The State of Human Nature Auschwitz' reinforces Hobbes' thesis and proves once again that pain and suffering, as well as the urge, in Levi's case, to survive, and here we talk about simple feeling and desire to survive not attached to any other need, represent the true nature of humanity. Humanity can be taken away by the artificial bodies such as governments and humans do lose their nature and fail under the influence of the circumstances, especially if these prove to be the cause of terrible pain. As cruel as it sounds, and this is what Levi admits, some survived the Holocaust because their humanity was washed away and survival became...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Human nature

...struggle between the classes with the aim of laying the foundation of a just and classless society. Consequently, the strife and struggle observed by the members of every social establishment mirror one of the most distinguished traits of human nature, i.e. having passion for and making efforts to obtain everything that is necessary for the fulfillment of human needs. History is replete with countless examples of exploitations made by the social classes, groups and nations, with the aim of earning superior and dominant position in comparison with their fellow-beings, where both fair and cruel as well as just and iniquitous measures have been observed by the people and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Human Nature

...Human nature Different views exist on the nature of human beings and offers insights into possible relationships, the need for governance, and the most suitable form of governance. My view of human nature identifies a society of self-centered individuals whose life is devoid of things and this establishes motivation into acquisition of different aspects of life. Actions and decisions that people make, therefore aim at meeting their self centered needs, and even though the actions and decision may at times benefit other people, such benefits are secondary or may be means to an end or secondary objectives. Maslow’s hierarchy of need theory,...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Human Nature

...Human natureHuman nature is an intangible idea and no one seems to agree on what it consist, yet several people do agree it is in existence. Some of the philosophers do agree that human nature is inherently good whereas others see it as evil. With all the concepts constituting human nature, I believe there are several flaws in the determination of the core of all human beings. The sole characteristics of what I tend to believe in the consists of human nature; I personally believe are part of what is making it improbable to determine if there exist any...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Human Nature

...Question One Psychological egoism purports that all human beings are inherently born with the urge to pursue interests that are beneficial to themselves. It argues that, the motivations of every human being are motivated by the pursuit of self-interests, whether knowingly or unknowingly. Simply, human beings are only interested in pursuing things that serve their specific end goals, all the time. The concept is related to ethical egoism in that, both suggest that human beings act out of self-interest. However, under ethical egoism, self-interest is desirable if in some instances, human beings restrain themselves from pursuing their interest if it results...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Human nature is not cruel for FREE!

Contact Us