We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Nobody downloaded yet

Compare and contrast the two stories - Essay Example

Comments (0)
The following analysis is based upon two stories written by Kate Chopin. Ms Chopin was a nineteenth century writer, whose work shot to fame, sadly, after her death. Kate Chopin, known best known for her short stories covered all genres for both genders of all ages…
Download full paper

Extract of sample
Compare and contrast the two stories

Download file to see previous pages... Both these stories have tragic, heart breaking endings and they come across with a vital teaching. In the stories, the protagonists have made decisions that have made the readers regret the (character’s) decision. What led them to such choices and why was it wrong for them is discussed in great detail below. The story “Desiree’s Baby” revolves around a young adopted girl called Desiree. She lives with her foster parents; the Valmonde’s until she gets married to a man, Armand Aubigny, who loves her enough to sideline the anonymity of her origin. Soon after, the couple is blessed with a baby boy and Desiree is extremely satisfied with her life. She claims that Armand had changed for the better after marriage and after his son was born, he seldom gets angry and does not mistreat his Negro servants like before. However, after a few months, the horrifying truth dawns upon Desiree as her child greatly looked like the servants of the house in matters of color. This finding answers her questions to Armand’s cold and indifferent attitude. Armand claimed that Desiree was not white and that she was responsible for the way their child was. Disappointed and struck by grief, Desiree leaves her husband and disappears with her child. In the end of the story, Armand finds out in a letter written by his mother to his father thanking God that her son doesn’t know that his mother “belongs to the race that is cursed with the brand of slavery.” The other story is about a young woman, Louise Mallard, whose husband, Brently Mallard, dies in a train accident. She is informed about his death by her sister Josephine, who in turn was informed by Mr Mallard’s friend Richards. After knowing that she is a widow, she locks herself in the room and waits for the grief to take over her. While sitting in the chair, looking out the window, Louise starts to think about what awaits in her life. While assessing the tough, lonely, journey ahead, she instead finds out that she has finally been freed. Even though she loved her husband, she was now independent and the shackles of being under constant check were gone. She accepts this new thought of freedom and it fills her inner self with newly found joy. When she goes downstairs with her sister, she finds her husband standing there unscathed, unaware of the train accident that took place. Mrs. Mallard dies and the doctors claim that she died out of happiness. Both stories reflect on some serious misunderstandings and highly inappropriate decisions that caused regret in the end. In the “Desiree’s Baby”, we notice that Armand’s character lacks strength and wisdom. He is deluded with one-minded ferocity and he fails to weigh his decisions before implementing them. When he proposed to Desiree, Mr. Valmonde made it very clear that Armand should think about how nobody knows the origin of Desiree, on the account of her being adopted. Instead, Armand got carried away with how much he loved her and it did not matter whether she had a surname or not, hence we see that being extremely emotional is a trait of Armand’s character. On the other hand, in the story of one hour, we see that Louise Mallard is faced by sudden tragic news of the demise of her husband. In the given scenario, a person is most likely to lose rational train of thought and does or thinks absurd stuff. As surprising as her conclusions were to finding independence and freedom, Louise’s character can be given the benefit of the doubt, ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment
Compare or Contrast two buildings
4. Brain Storm List I. Massive Architecture. A. U.S General Services Administration Building’s E-shaped configuration. B. Ariel Rios Federal Building Semi-circular facade. II. Uncluttered Appearance. A. U.S General Services Administration Building’s organized flat and long facade.
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Peter pan and mary poppins
Both stories also share at the core several common themes, but that is not to go as far as to say these stories are similar in any way shape or form. Both of the stories teach valuable lessons that can be applied to real life; not only the fantasy settings they are taught in.
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
A good author will use setting to help define their character, especially in the short story, as it provides a succinct method of description that cannot be
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Compare and contrast two works
The characters present their stories as a means of entertainment during the long ride with the object being the one with the best tale wins a free dinner at the next hostel stop. The original plan was to have each character tell two stories
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay
Compare and Contrast the theme of Good verse Evil in the two short stories Barn Burning by William Faulkner and good Old Country People by Flannery O'Connor
In the short story Barn Burning, the protagonist, Sartoris Snopes represents good while his violent father symbolizes evil. The short story Good Country People depicts good through its women characters while evil is portrayed by the male character, Manley
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Compare and contrast the two stories, Black Men in Public Space by Brent Staples and Where are you Going, Where have you Been by Joyce Carol Oates
Once the first impression is made, it is virtually irreversible” (Sterling, 2002). However, this process is not limited to just the business world and is not limited to just those times when you’re trying to make an impression. Every time two people come into
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Compare and contrast their attitudes towards motherhood, proposing why the differences and the similarities that is identified exist in the two stories The mother by Gwendolyn brooks and Giving Birth by Margaret Atwood
Previously, she considered abortions not as a crime but later on, she felt that she was wrong and aborting children is a crime. In the poem, the poet’s shows the woman who aborted her children showing positivity towards
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
English take home final
Tone: The tone used in the poem can be described as Elegant, Creepy and Funny. The poet describes the heaps of bones and fetor of human remains so elegantly. This almost sounds lovely. The humorous but creepy tone also builds on the reader’s engagement in the
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Compare and Contrast two stories
On the other hand, Desiree, the heroine of Chopin’s eponymous tale, is a woman of the traditional southern plantations. Both the narratives depict a crisis in the relationships: Jig’s abortion and Desiree’s mulatto baby.
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Compare and Contrast two pieces or two authors using three literary critics. The stories used are How I Got That Name by Marilyn Chin and White Trash Primer by Lacy M. Johnson
They display her unwilling and resolved nature of not letting go off her heritage while at the same time having the urge to integrate into the American society (Cucinella 155). She experiences Chinese
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Let us find you another Essay on topic Compare and contrast the two stories for FREE!
Contact us:
Contact Us Now
FREE Mobile Apps:
  • About StudentShare
  • Testimonials
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Free Essays
  • New Essays
  • Essays
  • The Newest Essay Topics
  • Index samples by all dates
Join us:
Contact Us