Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Go to advanced search...

Debunking the myth of NGOs (non-government organizations) - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
It is the struggle by the aborigines in colonial nations like Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and the U.S for the right to self-determination. Admittedly, many Canadians have the…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Debunking the myth of NGOs (non-government organizations)
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Debunking the myth of NGOs (non-government organizations)"

Article Review "Whats Left? Canadas global justice movement and the colonial amnesia" Aziz Choudry has introduceda matter that has global repercussions and is widely discussed. It is the struggle by the aborigines in colonial nations like Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and the U.S for the right to self-determination. Admittedly, many Canadians have the latent sense that all is not well with relations between Canadian government and its indigenous peoples, especially when it comes to the latter’s claim for self-determination. Now, in support of these sensibilities, Choudry (2010) reveals in his article “What’s Left? Canada’s global justice movement and colonial amnesia” the role of NGOs in Canada, even the Left-leaning ones, is in acknowledging and supporting the indigenous struggles.
The NGOs have failed to acknowledge the link between colonialism and neoliberalism though they have acknowledged the latter as their enemy. According to Choudry, the Left-leaning NGOs in Canada do not acknowledge or support the struggles by indigenous people against neoliberalism. In order to substantiate this claim, Choudry points out that the issues of Indigenous people in Canada gained international attention as is evident from the fact that the 2008 UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women urged Canada to conduct special inquiry into the atrocities against the indigenous women in Canada. Still, it is surprising to note that none of the so-called Left-leaning NGOs showed any interest or supported the struggles of the indigenous people.
The reason for this is found by Choudry in the fact that even the Left NGOs are unable to acknowledge the existing element of colonialism in Canada, and hence, they adopt a ‘White progressive economic nationalist’ position. Thus, the NGOs fail to acknowledge the negative consequences of neoliberalism which surrounds them in various forms. While promoting baseless claims of nation-building, they fail to look into, or understand, the importance of the indigenous struggles.
Choudry turns the eyes of the reader towards a factor that often goes unnoticed. That is nations like Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and the U.S are all colonies in nature, and in all these nations, the indigenous people are in the struggle to preserve their land and sovereignty. However, the NGOs, and the Left in general, think that the struggle by the indigenous peoples for the right to self-determination has nothing to do with the global justice movement. Thus, the NGOs in Canada tend to identify the transnational corporations, powerful governments and political elites as responsible for the neoliberalism. As a result, the solutions they seek are social democratic governance, restrictions on foreign investors, and greater transparency in policy-making.
However, they forget to address the fact that there are no universal and shared Canadian values which can be rebuilt to develop a fairer society because the nation is a ‘stolen land’, as alleged by the indigenous. Thus, the point put forward by Choudry (2010) in the article is that capitalism and colonialism are interlinked; at least in nations like Canada, Australia, and the U.S. The fights by the indigenous people in these nations are, in fact, the fight against neoliberal capitalism too. This is so because the indigenous people are committed to confronting colonialism, which, in fact, is closely linked to neoliberal globalization.
Admittedly, Choudry (2010) has written on a subject which is globally important. Even in nations which are not victims of colonization at present, one can see struggles from the part of indigenous people against nationalization. A perfect example is India where people of many northern and eastern states are in constant struggle to gain freedom on the basis of their cultural and linguistic identity. Though it is possible for Choudry to claim that the fights of indigenous people are to be supported, the mere fact is that no one likes to surrender his or her freedom. People in the civilized world have compromised their personal freedom to make a nation or a society. So, the indigenous people do not deserve any special consideration regarding self-determination.
In total, Choudry (2010) points out the fact that the modern neoliberal globalization is just another form of colonization. Though the indigenous people recognize the same and fight against it, the Left-leaning NGOs have miserably failed to identify the relation and to react in time. As a result, even these NGOs hold the false belief that nation-building is the way to stop neo-liberalism. However, the scope of this claim is limited to such nations which are still colonized, though the indigenous in other nations too are in constant conflict with the national governments.
Choudry, A. (2010). "Whats Left? Canadas global justice movement and the colonial amnesia" . Sage Journals: Race and Class, 52 (1): 97-102. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Debunking the myth of NGOs (non-government organizations) Essay”, n.d.)
Debunking the myth of NGOs (non-government organizations) Essay. Retrieved from
(Debunking the Myth of NGOs (non-Government Organizations) Essay)
Debunking the Myth of NGOs (non-Government Organizations) Essay.
“Debunking the Myth of NGOs (non-Government Organizations) Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Debunking the myth of NGOs (non-government organizations)

Government and Non-governmental Organizations

... Comparing & Contrasting the World Response of Government and Non-governmental Organizations Comparing & Contrasting the World Response of Government and Non-governmental Organizations For comparing and contrasting the world and non-governmental response to the Holocaust and similar mass killings in our recent histories, we would first have to understand the prevalent policies of the countries in which such genocides happen. The roles on the other hand of other nation states through their governments and non-governmental organizations such as Amnesty International, United Nation, the Red Cross and the United Nations differ as different nations most of the time consider their national interests and thereafter intervene in the internal...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

The Organizations Requirement for Employees

The Employment Rights Act also provides for redundancy as one of the fair reasons for dismissal. Therefore Border Builders has the right to legally dismiss its employees on grounds of redundancy and it is possible that Margaret’s dismissal may qualify as a legal dismissal under the Employment Rights Act.
The test for redundancy was first set out by the Courts in the case of Safeway v Burrell3, wherein a three-stage procedure was set out as follows: (a) was the employee dismissed? (b) whether the organization’s requirement for employees to carry out such work has diminished? and (c) whether such diminution of work is the reason for dismissal? Therefore, this case laid out a simple factual analysis as the correct ap...
11 Pages(2750 words)Case Study

Business Management Framework in Educational Organizations

The organizational structure should be present to guarantee clear divisions of authority, responsibility, communication, and control. The second component is the generation of the organization situations for successful implementation such as culture, communications, reward and incentives systems, training, and control (Fonseca 2002).

Two basic theoretical paradigms to business management framework could be identified. The first puts considerable emphasis on structural frameworks to change and involves an issue with organizational design as well as the linkage between organization and environment. This point of view puts less importance upon human activity and the way individuals try to understand or make sense of the wo...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Non-Scientists, Scientists and Hiroshima and Nagasaki

Even so, we particularly think of scientists as the ones responsible for the destruction caused during World War II. In spite of the uses of atomic physics in improving our daily life most usually associate it with Hiroshima and Nagasaki and the atomic bombings that changed the way, people think about science.
Rhodes describes that the development of atomic physics began with Rutherford’s experiment on gold sheets which lead to the idea of what an atom is like. This model of the atom was not perfect but even so, it did provide a basic idea about the arrangement of sub-atomic particles within an atom. Rutherford’s model was supported by the discovery of the neutron by Chadwick. This model was further improved later...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Strategies of the South African Government

Maslow has argued that security and safety are required by all human beings (Boeree 2006). According to the Federation Internationale de Football Association (2009), Uruguay was the first nation to host the Fifa World Cup. In 2010, South Africa would be the first African nation to host the next World Cup. But Euromonitor (2009) considers that South Africa is a country with a significant rate of insecurity that would influence the trip to South Africa. Various security strategies will have to be reviewed by the South African Government in order to implement security and safety during this big event (Republic of South Africa, 2008). To accomplish the safety of the tourists during the World Cup 2010, many South African cities have in...
17 Pages(4250 words)Research Proposal

Benefit of Partnership to Company, Trade Union and Government

The John Lewis model of partnership states that the ultimate purpose of business is the happiness of all its members. Hence, when partners “share the responsibilities of ownership as well as its rewards of profit, knowledge, and power”, it is mutually beneficial to all members of the organization (ILO, 1996). The partnership can be a part of the commitment to pluralism and also a part of the non-union agenda (Bacon & Storey, 2000). The national agreement Partnership 2000 defines workplace partnership as “an active relationship based on recognition of common interest to secure the competitiveness, viability, and prosperity of the enterprise” (Doherty, 2008). The interest in the partnership has arisen due...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

The Relationship Between Citizen and Government

There are arguments between the advocates of universal and abstract principles and, the proponents of virtuous living. Onora ONeill traces this stalemate to faults in fundamental notions of reasoning about action. She recommends and builds a linked explanation of the principles that are fundamental for moving in the direction of just institutions and virtuous lives based on ethical thinking. (O’Neill, 1996)

The work of John Rawls mainly concentrates on the social institutions and virtues of the society namely, social justice, political liberty, and equality. In his work, Rawls’ has called justice as the “basic structure of the society” (Rawls, 1999, p. 7). Each individual enjoys a basic level of...
7 Pages(1750 words)Essay

Independence and the Provision of Other Non-Assurance Services

Given the overall importance of auditor independence for the quality of audit and non-audit services, and taking into account the growing role of non-audit services in business, it is essential that businesses realize the impact, which their policies may produce on auditor independence and that authorities shift the balance of their professional priorities toward promoting and preserving auditor independence in assurance and other services.

In the current state of the auditing profession, the meaning of auditor independence is gaining additional importance. Under the influence of the recent business and auditing trends, auditor independence stands out as the critical measure of the auditor’s quality and profession...
6 Pages(1500 words)Case Study

Promoting Creativity in Organizations

Under normal circumstances, no organization can successfully survive without communication which involves dissemination or exchange of information between the employees and the management. From the above assertion, it can be noted that communication in particular forms the backbone of activities involved in an organization that is intended to achieve the organizational goals set. Indeed, managers have the task of overseeing the operations of the employees and they can greatly influence their interpersonal behavior if they properly harness interpersonal communication in an organization where face to face communication would be advocated. In this particular case, communication has to be effective in order to convince and persuade th...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Role of HR Planning in Assisting Organizations in Reducing Uncertainty in an Unpredictable Labor Market

HR planning is fairly regarded as an essential instrument of forecasting, assessing, and meeting the demand for qualified labor. However, as labor markets are changing, so is the meaning of HR planning and its effects on labor efficiency in organizations. Globalization and integration of markets turn diversity and inclusion into the principal prerequisites of continuous business success. HR planning helps organizations to address and reduce uncertainty in unpredictable labor markets by forecasting, assessing, and meeting the demand for diverse employees and matching their skills and knowledge in each job category.

HR planning has already become a distinctive feature of contemporary business reality. Organizations are wi...
7 Pages(1750 words)Coursework

How Successfully Has the British Government in Running the British Economy over the Last Two Years

There were several issues confronting the British government since the time of the financial crisis, which had lead to the collapse of some of the largest banks in the nation. Government deficits had also increased considerably during that time and the situation of employment was worse than ever. The project tries to make an analysis of the steps taken by the British government in combating such serious issues. It also tries to gauge the extent to which the programs have been effective in mobilizing the British economy.

One of the major policies undertaken by the British Government in the last two years was fiscal decentralization. The government has taken steps to ensure that improvement is made in the country’s...
7 Pages(1750 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Debunking the myth of NGOs (non-government organizations) for FREE!

Contact Us