StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
Summary
Numerous teachers all over the globe are conversant with the familiarity of presenting student with dialogues that hold an artificiality quality about them.Artificiality is not bad since the whole point of linguistics learning tasks is to contrive learning…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.6% of users find it useful
A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT"

Download file to see previous pages Authentic texts are defined as a text made to realize a social function within the language community. Pedagogic texts such as text dialogues like those found in English as a Foreign Language teaching materials differ largely from authentic texts across a variety of discourse features (Stubbs 2009) and (Widdowson 2008). These features include turn-taking and length patterns, the number of repetitions and false starts, lexical density, pausing, terminal latching or overlap frequency as well as usage of back-channelling and hesitation devices. This paper will compare and contrast an actual dialogue with a text book dialogue using a hotel booking telephone dialogue as an illustration. Conversations’ length Generally, an authentic telephone conversation on hotel booking would be longer than a telephone dialogue in a textbook (See Appedix 1 and 2). This can be explained by the fact that the turns taken by the information givers are virtually twice lengthy as those undertaken by the information receivers (Carter 2008) and (Sacks, Schegloff & Jefferson 2010). Authentic telephone dialogues would have a more intricate arrangement, with the straightforward question-answer pattern interrupted by several factors (McCarthy & Carter 2004). For example, problems arise in ‘Booking a hotel by phone’, there are unavailable rooms on ground floor, plus on top of that a discussion concerning elevators as well as standard rooms versus executive rooms may arise (Cunningham & Moore 2005). Further information is regularly entreated by the giver of information. For instance, in a conversation ‘concerning hotel booking’, the assistant may enquire whether the client would prefer a room with twin beds or single beds. Answers to queries are longer within authentic texts, where the information giver offers more than one option (Stubbs 2009) (Widdowson 2008). For instance, in ‘hotel booking’ the receptionist may suggest a room with an ocean view. Clearly, real-life is not as straightforward and simple as compared to dialogues found in text books. Text book dialogues are precise since they cannot capture a real-life scenario and perhaps because the text books writers’ tend to present them that way (Carter & McCarthy 2007) and (Myers-Scotton & Bernstein 2008). Unlike in real dialogues, the language of text book dialogues represents a ‘can do’ community where interaction is generally problem-free and smooth (See appendix 2). The speakers collaborate with one another courteously; the dialogue is neat, predictable and tidy. The queries and responses sequenced somewhat in the style of a court-room interrogation or quiz show (Cunningham & Moore 2005). This is, certainly, intentional and is executed for several reasons. Principally, if the core objective of text book dialogue is to exhibit novel functional and structural language through text simplification, this enables learners to focus upon target language exhibited, to spot it, as well as hopefully obtain the structures rapidly accordingly (Carter 2008). Another reason for text simplification is to render comprehension tasks simpler. If a dialogue runs along expected lines, in which the author expect the learner to be aware of what may be uttered next as well as utilize top-down procedure to decrypt the message (Carter & McCarthy 2007), (Stubbs 2009) and (Widdowson 2008). The more random a dialogue is, the more acquirers have to depend upon ‘bottom up’ processing, for instance, taking note of individual words as well as developing them up to reach at the implication (Sacks, Schegloff & Jefferson 2010). Nevertheless, if the dialogues are only made predictable, learners may be denied the chance to build up their ‘ ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT Essay”, n.d.)
A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1478866-a-comparison-of-an-authentic-text-with-a-pedagogic
(A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT Essay)
A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT Essay. https://studentshare.org/education/1478866-a-comparison-of-an-authentic-text-with-a-pedagogic.
“A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1478866-a-comparison-of-an-authentic-text-with-a-pedagogic.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
ma
mackenzie27 added comment 8 months ago
Student rated this paper as
This essay was always my weak point. I could never finish it successfully. Still, after I found this particular paper, I understood how it should be completed. So, I performed my research afterward and completed the essay in several hours, instead of days as it was previously.

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT

Comparison of Constructive Trust with the Remedy of Restitution under the Common Law

When trying to locate the property loss because of a transfer made under a breach of trust, there are certain issues that need to be taken into account. At the first level, the remedies available by the relevant legal texts tend to differentiate not only regarding their requirements but also their level of protection provided. On the other hand, the application of the rules of common law instead of the ones of equity has to be considered thoroughly and the party that suffered the damage has to evaluate all the parameters regarding his choice as each of the above legal paths has its own advantages. From a general point of view, it has been stated that ‘a person who confers a benefit, normally a money payment, under a mistake,...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Faith and Works - Comparison of James 2:14 and Romans 4

While the apostles James and Paul agree that Faith connotes belief in God and Works connotes good actions, James contends that faith and works are both essential for salvation, while Paul asserts that faith is the only requisite.

James is unequivocal in his declaration that “faith by itself if it has no works, is dead” (2:17). However, he does not discount the importance of faith. His contention is that both are essential and one, without the other, is futile. He is addressing Christians, who, we may assume, are already among the congregation of the faithful, by virtue of their professed belief “that God is one” (2:19). Therefore, James accepts that faith is a precondition for salvation but asser...
7 Pages(1750 words)Assignment

Towards the Comparison of Specialized Courts in USA and India

Without specialized courts, resolution of complex matters would have been stalled and progress dampened.

Both countries have high educational standards and believe in an informed judiciary who are experts in their fields and these courts are presided by such persons. Justice is speedy in both cases and both give their judges penal and punitive powers.

Although there are many similarities, yet there are some differences both in content and in approach. Whereas the US believes in a more liberal outlook, giving greater emphasis to Human Rights, India lags behind due to its colonial and cultural legacies. The redeeming feature is that lead by its own global status as a growing economic power, it is trying to shed...
12 Pages(3000 words)Case Study

Comparison of the Cold War International System to the Current International System

An example is that of the Korean War (1950-53) which is said to transform the nature of the Cold War, while its initial impact was to solidify the division of the world into political, military, and economic spheres. Take Germany for instance where imperialism was a victim challenged by the historians for the destruction of the German Government along with its supporters used to conduct (Keylor, 2001, p. 44). That indicates economic expansion and territorial acquisition has always been a problem promoted since the First World War. Even in the 1920s, it was fashionable to declare the German empire on the threshold of the ‘Great War’ (Keylor, 2001, p. 44).

Europe in the global context remained tense and divide...
8 Pages(2000 words)Article

Stop Animation and the Comparison to Newer Techniques in CGI

As with many films, a great creative license is taken with the story, although it retains the original thrills and spectacle.

The great Ray Harryhausen created some of the most advanced special effects of the time within this film. The scenes are exciting and thrilling, although by today’s standards it is easy to spot the differences between what is created and what is filmed from life. Still, the special effects in Jason and the Argonauts are some of the best examples of Ray Harryhausen’s stop-motion animation available. The movie is a mythological creature that is the eighth collaboration between producer Charles Schneer and Harryhausen. Ray Harryhausen’s contributions included those of co-producer,...
13 Pages(3250 words)Term Paper

Quality Use of Medicines - Pharmacy Comparison

The pharmacist is also the justice of the peace.

Comparing this pharmacy with the Campbell pharmacy, the Chandler pharmacy is located in a much busier area, hence there are more shops and more people in the vicinity. There are more medically related establishments in the Chandler pharmacy than in the Campbell pharmacy, hence there are more patients buying their medicines in the Chandler pharmacy. Both pharmacies have similar conveniences for their customers. They are located near a bus stop and taxi ranks, and a car park is available within the vicinity of both pharmacies.

The Chandler Kamart pharmacy is a very busy pharmacy with three full-time pharmacists and 8 pharmacy assistants working in one shift. With...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Comparison of Leading Womens Role in Portrait of Teresa and Salt of Sea

... Number] Comparison of leading Women’s role in Portrait of Teresa and Salt of Sea Every society has different values,traditions and perceptions regarding the role of women that fit within their historical, cultural and social contexts. The cinema being an important cultural institution and reflector of social values tends to depict the role of women in movies to refer their current status as well as to motivate them playing a non traditional role for some specified purposes. In the movies “Portrait of Teresa” and “Salt of the earth” also, the directors Pastor Vega and Herbert Biberman have presented the roles of women in quite encouraging manner to show the women’s potential of playing a revolutionary and defining role in setting up trends...
7 Pages(1750 words)Case Study

Juvenile Delinquency and Education: A Comparison of Public and Private Education

...Juvenile Delinquency and Education Introduction and ment of the Problem The question of juvenile misbehaviour and crime was not taken seriously until modern times. It was till the eighteenth century that children were regarded as non persons. They were neither recognized nor received any special treatment from either the state or society. The concept of discipline was at most a violent treatment of reinforcing specific norms acceptable in society. Perhaps a reason for that was that child mortality rates were high. It was not considered feasible to form attachments with children. They were left up to nature and the survival of the fittest approach. However, at the end of the eighteenth century, the age of “The Enlightenment... Delinquency and ...
6 Pages(1500 words)Research Proposal

Comparison Of Two Books by Henry and Cox

The paper concludes by an evaluation of how the two books are useful with regards to public administration, particularly, the implication for the public administration.
Some of the most used texts in public administration are the book, Public Administration and Public Affairs by Henry (2009), and the book, Public administration in theory and practice by Cox, Buck, & Morgan (2005). These texts offer insightful history, introduction, and description of public administration practices and paradigms. They both focus on particular issues such as motivation or leadership. In both texts, there is a mention of key authors, most predominantly, Frank Goodnow and Wilson Woodrow (Cox et al., 2005 p. 5; Henry, 2009 p. 9, 13) have been...
9 Pages(2250 words)Coursework

Comparison of the Political Orientation of Trade Unions

Austria or you may call is the Republic of Austria in official terminology is located in Central Europe. Although the population figures do not touch the danger limit but the talent and resources are worthwhile there. Germany and Hungry are also near this region. Italy is in the south of Austria. Switzerland will be seen in the west. So, now you can realize the importance of this region clearly.
The GDP is also impressive here. You can say the economy is strong and it has much depth. The strong social market economy is the result of development and proper management by the government (DArt & Turner 2008). Traders find flexibility in business operations. Labor has a positive approach to work and jobs.
There was a tren...
9 Pages(2250 words)Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic A COMPARISON OF AN AUTHENTIC TEXT WITH A PEDAGOGIC TEXT for FREE!

Contact Us