StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Other Side of Homeschooling - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Homeschooling is becoming a popular alternative to traditional schooling by a growing number of families. This essay will discuss how home schooling causes a disconnection between kids and their community, negatively affecting the social and communication skills of children…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
The Other Side of Homeschooling
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Other Side of Homeschooling"

?The Other Side of Homeschooling Homeschooling is becoming a popular alternative to traditional schooling by a growing number of families. This is when parents decide that they will educate their children themselves at home instead of letting them attend school. On their own, they plan out the children’s curriculum in accordance to the information they need to know at the particular age and grade level of the child should he be attending school. This essay will discuss how home schooling causes a disconnection between kids and their community, negatively affecting the social and communication skills of children. Homeschooling has its roots several decades ago from some groups who were not satisfied with the way schools were educating children. Stevens (2001) explained that it was upon the efforts of two vastly different groups, the religious fundamentalists and the’unschoolers’ who advocated for homeschooling. The religious fundamentalists pushed for homeschooling in order to ensure that children were kept exposed to their religious teachings so that a structured method of homeschooling was designed with the basic knowledge children should learn and promoted the authority of the family. On the other hand, John Holt, an activist, author and educator, encouraged parents to try teaching their children themselves because he believed that public schools may harm children by subjecting them to “technocracy” and wanted to protect them from such. Known as the ‘unschoolers’, their version of homeschooling was aimed at teaching children to enjoy life. They are against the regimentation being forced by authorities on children in terms of standardized tests and intensified curricula (Aurini & Davies, 2005). Homeschooling has been tagged as an offspring of older pedagogical movements which value individualism, non-conformity and empowerment, which most schools do not encourage (Aurini & Davies, 2005). Proponents of homeschooling were former supporters of ‘free schools’ which were considered left-wing (Miller, 2002) and detest conformity and ‘rat-race’ status-seeking that is usually associated with schools (Priesnitz, 2000). Since homeschooled children are isolated from school and are expected to be educated from home, they are likewise not conforming to any norm dictated by the school environment. Being so, they are thought of as being deprived of social contact with their peers and other adults. Bowditch (2000) argues: “Home education is not a reasonable choice for most children, as they need to spend time with peer groups to fulfill social needs. While home-schooled students may succeed academically, they may also fail to achieve that sense of independence generally acquired when attending public school. Additionally, home-schooled children may not learn problem-solving skills that are normally acquired through everyday interaction in public school circumstances” (para. 1). This view acknowledges that home-schooled children may excel academically, and even outstrip their peers in academic tests. However, socially, they are deprived of experiencing normal peer interactions that bring about challenging situations that make them stronger as individuals. The social adjustment that goes with being with other young people or situations that make them struggle to survive on their own build character and develop coping skills they would need as grown-ups in the real world. Being shielded from differing personalities of people leaves them unable to interact appropriately especially with those with difficult temperaments. They also miss out on exposure to students with differing backgrounds, and those who may think differently from them. Among these are teachers who adopt different teaching styles. Teachers who encourage an “open classroom climate”, push their students to air divergent viewpoints to stimulate their thinking and test their faithfulness to their long-held beliefs. When students hear different perspectives, it helps them understand an issue better and become less likely to feel threatened by views opposed to theirs. Being in an environment with these existing variety helps them learn tolerance and respect for others (Loving-Attachment Parenting.com, 2012). These life lessons are as important as academic skills they may pride themselves in being very good at, considering they learn these under the exclusive tutelage of their eagerly supportive parents. When a child attends school, he realizes that the world does not revolve around him, and therefore, learns to adapt accordingly. He establishes friendships with people outside his family and these experiences cannot be replicated at home even with a creative education designed by his parents. When they do not have enough contact with people their age, they may be considered outdated in their manner of dressing or talking that reflects their peer group’s style at that specific period of time. Hence, when they communicate with peers who go to school, it is inevitable that there are communication gaps between them (Merry & Karsten, 2010). Angela Pollard is a teacher who decided to homeschool her twin 13 year old daughters for six months until they begged to be enrolled back in school. Sure, their academic knowledge grew tremendously, but Pollard admits they are not happy. Pollard overlooked their basic need to be with their peers and that this was vital to their personal growth as the academic lessons they are imbibing from home (Bowditch, 2002). Coming from a teacher, this evidence from experience is credible since she is a representative of school-based education who tried out homeschooling herself, and realized that having her children enrolled back in a more socially- rich setting is best for them instead of for her own benefit. Merry & Karsten (2010) contend that there should be a balance between parental control and customization of children’s education and children’s choices in what to learn. Reich (2002) agrees that ‘total customization . . . threatens to insulate students from exposure to diverse ideas and people and thereby to shield them from the vibrancy of a pluralistic democracy’ (p. 56). Home-schooling parents design their own learning activities such as field trips to factories or writing essays on certain political issues. However, if children miss out on socialization and communication with people outside their home and family and this adversely affects them, then the state’s role as protector of children’s interests will trump that of the parents. It will not tolerate the liberty of the parents to manage the children’s education if the children themselves are not at liberty to grow with other children and adults. Parents who choose homeschooling for their children argue that it accomplishes what current educational philosophy advocates, that of helping students to learn at their own pace, integration of disciplines for a more holistic education, and the provision of individual attention and assessment for each student. Homeschooled students have more opportunities to pursue their natural interests balanced with the attention they need to develop ways of thinking which may be more difficult for them. Pat Farenga says, "Children, like adults, need time to be alone to think, to muse, to read freely, to daydream, to be creative, to form a self independent of the barrage of mass culture" (Jeub, 1994, para 19). Due to the flexibility of the home environment, this is easier achieved than in more restrictive, traditional classrooms. Homeschooling parents may have various reasons in reaching their final decision, however, what must be of primary consideration is the child himself. He or she must have a say in this. Would the child benefit more in a social school setting, or would he thrive in an environment of one to one instruction? His personality, ability and overall skills will determine where he would be of best fit. Children who attend school definitely derive advantages in their communication and social development whether they have positive or negative experiences with others. It only goes to strengthen their character without the constant support of their parents. They learn to be independent. Homeschooled children may not have enough social interactions with other children and adults, but they do get to establish strong bonds with their parents and are not deprived of social interactions not only with peers, but also get exposed to people of various backgrounds if their parents design a curriculum with a lot of hands-on experiences and field trips. Parents and children who are in the crossroads have to thoroughly evaluate which option provides more benefits which one is able to maximize the student’s potentials and prepare him to survive future challenges. References Are There Negative Aspects Of Homeschooling? (2012) Retrieved from http://www.loving-attachment-parenting.com/negative-aspects-of-homeschooling.html Aurini, J. & Davies, S. (2005) Choice without markets: homeschooling in the Context of private education, British Journal of Sociology of Education Vol. 26, No. 4, pp. 461–474 Bowditch, G. (2002) "Home Education Deprives Children of Real Lessons”, Sunday Times (London), January 6, 2002. Jeub, C. (1994) Why Parents Choose Home Schooling, Education Leadership, September 1994. Merry, M.S. & Karsten, S. (2010) Restricted Liberty, Parental Choice and Homeschooling, Journal of Philosophy of Education, Vol. 44, No. 4, 2010 Miller, R. (2002) Free schools, free people: education and democracy after the 1960s, Albany, State University of New York Press. Priesnitz, W. (2000) Challenging assumptions in education, St George, ON: The Alternate Press. Reich, R. (2002) The Civic Perils of Homeschooling, Educational Leadership, April, pp. 56–59. Stevens, M. (2001) Kingdom of children: culture and controversy in the homeschooling movement, (NJ, Princeton University Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Other Side of Homeschooling Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
The Other Side of Homeschooling Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/education/1449783-the-other-side-of-homeschooling
(The Other Side of Homeschooling Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
The Other Side of Homeschooling Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/education/1449783-the-other-side-of-homeschooling.
“The Other Side of Homeschooling Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/education/1449783-the-other-side-of-homeschooling.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Other Side of Homeschooling

Educational Philosophies

The most recent method is homeschooling, introduced by parents who want to play a role in their children's educational development.... Therefore such issues led to some parents considering homeschooling as alternative.... homeschooling separated children from their peers which made them antisocial in nature.... People have reevaluated the old ways of typical class rooms and some have introduced other models.... This would affect them in their future relations with other people....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

What can the study of the history of learning tell us about learning today

In the past, greater focus is given to the artistic side of living, which can explain why in ancient learning there has been a bigger emphasis on the rhetoric, grammar, styles, as well as oratorical prowess of students, with particular mention of the upper and middle classes, while skills related to craftsmanship are passed down to the working classes.... On the other hand, due to the development of various fields, not only do students have greater choices in careers, they are also given other options in what to learn, which is very different from the concept of learning during ancient times....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Home Schooling

This paper descusses homeschooling which is not a rare phenomena and it is all about teaching children at home without them attending schools.... Homes schooling more than teaching children is a way of life.... It is a socialization process where the parents get chance to learn with children....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Education: the Key to Success

The aim of this work is to analyze education, particularly homeschooling Education is one of the most valuable experiences, which person can achieve in his life.... homeschooling is a method of education, which involves the study of general subjects outside school.... homeschooling is the oldest form of education, which appeared long before the first schools.... For many centuries, homeschooling was the only way to get an education....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Should Regulations for Home Schools Be Changed

Regulations need not target when, where and how a child should be educated as the whole point of homeschooling is to teach outside the classroom.... Before getting into the debate about whether the regulations for homeschooling should be changed let us see the origin of homeschooling the US.... This paper "Should Regulations for Home Schools Be Changed" discusses homeschooling that was once seen as a costly option reserved for kids involved in sports, modeling, and acting....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Traditional Classroom Model

The negative side of peer groups is a bad influence and trying to fit in, which results in immoral behaviors and issues of drug abuse.... The most recent method is homeschooling, introduced by parents who want to play a role in their children's educational development.... Therefore such issues led to some parents considering homeschooling as an alternative.... homeschooling separated children from their peers which made them antisocial in nature....
3 Pages (750 words) Term Paper

Bullying in the Junior Highs

The paper 'Bullying in the Junior Highs' presents children who need quality education and positive learning environments, bullying makes that impossible and separatist educations at home or online may be detrimental to certain children's development.... hellip; Bullying in the junior highs can be reduced by embracing a combination of approaches, that include inclusive involvement between parents and faculty of these Los Angeles and Riverside districts, a greater focus on the 5A Model introduced, and, finally, prevention measures introduced at the earliest ages of education....
7 Pages (1750 words) Term Paper

Effect of Homeschooling on Social Development

… The paper "Effect of homeschooling on Social Development"  is a good example of a term paper on education.... The paper "Effect of homeschooling on Social Development"  is a good example of a term paper on education.... Effect of homeschooling on Social Development Introduction It is a norm for parents and guardians to consider a number of factors before sending their child to school.... Opponents of homeschooling argue that children going through home schools are often socially deprived and backward....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us