Of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace - Case Study Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
The writer’s position was that the corporation has the obligation of knowing and taking into account the traditional and customary laws that apply to the patent of the Neem plant. Consultations with the indigenous people are crucial and important to avoid patent issues. The…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Case study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace"

Case Study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace affiliation Introduction The position was thatthe corporation has the obligation of knowing and taking into account the traditional and customary laws that apply to the patent of the Neem plant. Consultations with the indigenous people are crucial and important to avoid patent issues. The Indian indigenous people had to be consulted since it helps in preventing issues that arise after obtaining a patent.
Ascertaining cultural and legal tenure of the community affected is crucial. The impact of the product should be analyzed and assessed both to people and to the environment, and if found to be negative it should be addressed. This plan must help reduce the effects of the environment or ensure the impact is of an acceptable standard. Assessing the impact of the product on the cultural traditions and practices of the Indigenous people is important. The writer views that such assessment should include active involvement of the Indigenous Indians who have spoken on behalf of their cultural practices.
I would agree with the writer that the Indigenous people play a big role in the discovery of the product and, therefore, the company should demonstrate financial return that is equitable for the people who are the true owners of the plant. The people should be compensated for their knowledge of the plants use.
From the Grace’s case, the company should understand that the patent does not deny the farmers’ access to the plant due to lack of finances. The patent allows the company to modify the plant to produce a product that benefits the people and is less harmful to the environment. The company should make the peasant as their first priority before other opportunities.
From the case study, the peasant represents the Indigenous Indians farmers who had knowledge about the plant and stated that they discovered it. From this case study, it is clear that it was unethical for the company to manufacture the plant quickly that would only benefit a few. It is seen as a medicinal product that would be costly, and most farmers would not be able to afford it
Compensating the farmers would be a step to ensure that both parties benefit from the plant. The company in manufacturing the plant must ensure that it does better than harm and must benefit all customers. With all ethical and practical guideline considerations associated with the plant, the company can apply for the patent. Clearly, the plant has positive effects in improving the well-being of the community and general health of the people.
Presuppositions observed is that the Neem plant is seen as the village pharmacy because it has a variety of healing benefits. The plant has been used for a very long time because of its medicinal properties. Farmers from India claim that the corporations of America what they call new discoveries is actually theft as they are stealing and pirating indigenous practices of its people (Weissbrodt, 2007). Most Indians fully oppose the idea of the Neem plant being pirated and owning the rights to living organisms since they believe the rights of farmers will be harmed especially in developing countries
In conclusion, the writer’s view is that corporations need to establish ethical issues before they rush to manufacture the medicinal plant. This means that they should acknowledge that the Indigenous Indians discovered the Neem plant and, therefore, must compensate them. I agree with this view of the writer because it will ensure that both the corporations and the Indigenous Indian farmers benefit. The Neem plant has both health and environmental benefit and, therefore, the corporations should ensure that the manufacturer of the plant is beneficial to all parties involved.
Top of Form
Weissbrodt, D. S., & Vega, C. . (2007). International human rights law: An introduction. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Bottom of Form
Top of Form
Bottom of Form Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Case study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace”, n.d.)
Case study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace. Retrieved from
(Case Study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace)
Case Study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace.
“Case Study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace

Case Study on Toys R US Japan

...?Case Study on Toys “R” US Japan Introduction Background of the case The fate of Toys “R” US Japan is encompassed by issues such as leadership, understanding cultural diversity and implementing effective communication across varying cultures. Toys “R” US is a market leader in its industry particularly in the United States. Due to this advantage, its potential to expand can be possible across other economies with varying cultural backgrounds. Toys “R” US eventually made its way in Europe. Amidst contradiction from the start among local counterparts, Toys “R” US was able to grow and continue to exist in the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

R v Adomako, Law case

...?The case of R. v Adamako case was decided in the House of Lords by a bench composed of Lords Clashfern, Keith of Kinkel, Goff of Chieveley, Browne-Wilkinson and Woolf. This case discussed the offence of involuntary manslaughter whereby a medical practitioner who was supposed to administer anaesthesia to a patient was accused of being negligent in his duties. The appellant while in his duties in treating a patient with an eye ailment failed to notice that an oxygen pipe he had connected during an eye operation had been disconnected resulting in the death of the patient. The jury found him guilty of the offence of manslaughter after which he appealed and the Court of...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

American Grace

...(American Grace). More than 5,000 adolescents between the ages of 15 and 24 commit suicide every year. Nearly 30 percent of those deaths are attributed to emotional turmoil regarding sexual orientation.(Hillier & Harrison, 2004). With that, risk factors and reasons for suicide among young people have been studied very carefully. The suicide rate among young people rose 300 percent between 1960 and 1980. By the mid-80's, suicide was the second leading cause of death among young people ages 15-19. Inner city youth teenagers are more likely to commit suicide than their peers. However, very little research concerning this demographic has been completed (Proctor & Grove, 1994). "One of the greatest...
6 Pages(1500 words)Book Report/Review

Colours R Us' Case Study

...Colours R Us’ Case Study Design a process for recruiting and selecting the new employees for the “Magnificent Miniatures” line. The Human Resource(HR) planning process for the Magnificent Miniature lines should occur in three stages, according to Bateman and Snell (2007, p.322), who suggested that the HR process should start with planning, followed by programming, and evaluating. Planning is the stage when HR managers determine the business plans of a particular organization in order to plan its HR requirements. This involves the analysis of organizational goals viz a vis HR requirements and the resources that have to be made available in a given time in order to ensure the continuous and...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Marketing of Service- R Cubed Case Study

...Marketing of Service- R Cubed Case Study Question Using the framework: Human Resource Strategies for Delivering Service Quality through People evaluate R Cubed’s human resource management strategies The philosophy and operating strategy of R Cubed is based on providing a learning, creative and rewarding environment to the staff. The three internal “Rs” including Rewarding, Reflection and Recognition were defined for all staff. The human resource strategies defined by R Cubed shows that company was aiming to deliver quality services to its customers through its people. The diagram of Gaps Model of Service Quality shows that there are various points of service layout, where the gap can negatively impact service quality. Gaps Model... and...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay

Anderson V. WR Grace case study

...The Anderson V. WR Grace case study The landmark in this case is centered on the allegation on the contaminationof two wells supplied by municipal in Woburn, Massachusetts. Three industries were accused of the contamination. The plaintiffs of the case included a group of eight families who lived in Woburn town that was supplied by these two municipal wells. Defendants of the case included UniFirst Corporation of Interstate Uniform Services, W.R. Grace & Co. of the Cryovac Plant, and Beatrice Foods, Inc. who owned the John Riley Tannery (Gerrard and Foster 644). Plaintiffs argued that the accused these companies used an...
1 Pages(250 words)Case Study

W 4 Case Marketing

... that in every facility with health information system, the focus will be to ensure integrated and coordinated efforts from all internal stakeholders who will work together to ensure speed and effectiveness. References Gagliardi, P. (2006), The creation and change of healthcare organizational cultures: Conceptual framework, Organization Studies, 7(2), pp. 117-134 Garvin, D. A. (2013), Building a Learning Health Organization, Harvard Business Review, 4(5), pp. 78-91 Zawacki W. L., C. H. Bell & French R. (2005), Organization development and transformation: managing effective change (6th ed.). Irwin: Mc-Grew Hill... W 4 CASE MARKETING Lecturer: W 4 CASE MARKETING Researching on...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Computer R us case study

...Assignment, Statistics Computer R us case study of Assignment, Statistics Computer R us case study Background Computer R Us (a manufacturer and retailer) has recently established Complete Care, a service and repair division. This division is responsible to provide rapid response to the customer technical enquiries and warranty repairs. The division is facing some issues that lead to the customer dissatisfaction. Problem Statement The launch was successful but there are some issues with the operations of Complete Care. The issues are explained below: 1) There is a shortage of technical operators that can operate in the telephone centre. 2) The courier (who picks up the machines and also delivers the repaired items to the customers... in the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Assignment

Screening the Project with R-W-W

This satisfied our curiosity on whether people actually need the service. We will be mostly focusing on UBC campus area where our market ranges from students to faculty members to visitors. The market for Cargo exist and is pretty wide, Umbrella2go won’t focus on a specific segment, but rather all who use an umbrella during the day (Statista 2015). Demand for umbrella is highest in a rainy season. However, the umbrella is becoming an all-whether necessity with changing lifestyle and fashion needs. University students are reported to take Umbrellas in a big way (Scaria 2015). There is a market for about 96 lakh pieces of umbrella that is not adequately met (Krishnakumar 2015). U2Go will mostly be competing with all umbrella s...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Case Study Computers R Us

...a rapid response to customer’s technical enquiries and warranty repairs. However, the division has been experiencing some challenges that include: Shortage of trained technical operators in its telephone centre; Distribution problems; and Parts availability problems. As a result of this, Computers R Us has been receiving multiple complaints about CompleteCare at the Computers R Us call centre. To address these issues, a study was proposed and the research overseen by the management of Computers R Us. It was found that customer satisfaction was a contributing factor to the issues experienced in the CompleteCare division. Consequently, the management of Computer...
8 Pages(2000 words)Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Case Study on topic Case study of Severance/Shapiro/Warhane, W. R. Grace for FREE!

Contact Us