Behavior of Jack in Ethical Situation - Essay Example

Therefore, Jack was right to take the pill if this decision does not affect other classmates’ decisions.

Although the libertarian's view seems appropriate for Jack’s situation, there are a couple of negative implications that can be associated with the decision (Clarke, 15). For instance, if Jack chooses to take the pill, it could get his friend in trouble. This is because individuals are not allowed to share prescription drugs as they may hurt the health of other individuals. If Jack decided to take the pill and got a negative reaction, his friend could have gotten in trouble. This shows how the libertarian view could have had a negative implication for both parties.

Jack’s decision to take the pill could have given him an unfair advantage over his classmates. Taking the pill could have enabled him to study for longer hours and concentrate more (Clarke, 20). This is not only unethical but unfair to the other students. Competition is said to be fair if the students have equal opportunities to study and focus. It can therefore be concluded that taking the pill could have given Jack an unfair advantage over his classmates. Jack is therefore advised not to take the pill.

Jack’s decision to take the pill compromised the reputation of the class and the institution. This is because if his actions were reported to the appropriate authorities, this could have cast a shadow of doubt on the learning process in the class and the institution. Jack’s decision could have also influenced their overall performance in class (Clarke, 36). The performance of the class is characterized by a normal curve. If Jack takes the pill and it impacts his performance, there will be a disruption in the normal distribution curve. He is thereby advised not to take the pill from his classmate.

In summary, the above discussion shows the ethical concerns that are associated with Jack’s decision to take the pill. The implications that are linked to his decision include putting his friend in trouble, giving him an unfair advantage over his classmates, jeopardizing the reputation of the university and the class, and impacts on the normal curve of the class. It can therefore be concluded that Jack should avoid taking the pill together contrary to the libertarian view.