Is Whistle Blowing Ethical or not - Research Paper Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
There have been several attempts to define the concept of whistle blowing over the years. One of the most comprehensive of these is the definition provided by Peter Jubb, who defined whistle blowing as a voluntary disclose by an individual who possesses privileged access to certain information about the entity in question, which becomes is put under records (Jubb)…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
Is Whistle Blowing Ethical or not
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Is Whistle Blowing Ethical or not"

Download file to see previous pages The morality comes into question when there is a conflict between the individual’s duty to staying loyal to the firm and the freedom to speak out against what is wrong. The dilemma is severe because of the fact that individuals/employees are legally and morally bound to show their loyalty to their employers as well as ascertain the fact that one does not, directly or indirectly, get involved in any wrongdoing (Beauchamp and Bowie). It has become a common practice to link whistle blowing to loyalty with ones employer, such that several literature surrounds topics such as “whistle blowing versus organizational loyalty” or “whistle blowing and loyalty” (Lindblom). In his book, Robert Duska offers an interesting insight- that loyalty to the firm is an impossible event. According to Duska, employees have a contractual obligation to perform their duties responsibly in return for the compensation that they get (Larmer). However, according to him, the concept of personal responsibility to the company is void and that no loyalty issues should arise when discussing the notion of whistle blowing. According to him, one must engage in whistle blowing only for the collective good of the society (Larmer). The conflict of whistle blowing with loyalty is more intricate than suggested. ...
Hence, in this context, loyalty would mean that the individual must show concern towards the potential harm and loss of reputation, goodwill, sales etc. that the organization would suffer as a result of him/her blowing the whistle. However, there is another view by Ronald Duska, which states that organizations should not be recipients of loyalty simply because only “humans” can be objects of loyalty and not the organization as an entity in itself (Lindblom). Also, according to Bok, whistle blowing almost always pertains to the personal level since it involves unveiling the wrongdoings of someone else. The whistle blower may face tremendous moral and ethical conflict when it comes to the same because of several reasons. One of the reasons is the uncertainty whether or not the act is going to result in the general welfare of the public. Furthermore, the whistle blower is faced with moral dilemma when he/she has to weigh his/her moral responsibility to protect the interests of his co-workers versus his/her responsibility to protect the interests of the public. In any case, the latter is considered more important. A final reason for the dilemma, according to Bok, is the potential threat of loss of job, social circle, reputation, or even violence that could result from blowing the whistle. On the contrary, however, whistle blowers often receive strong support and appreciation from the society since they perform a vital job. The job is indispensable because, if it weren’t for the whistle blower the truth of the moment would lay hidden from the public forever and would result in injustice. Furthermore, Bok has emphasized three main elements that lead to whistle blowing becoming a problem. First ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Is Whistle Blowing Ethical or not Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(Is Whistle Blowing Ethical or Not Research Paper)
“Is Whistle Blowing Ethical or Not Research Paper”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
Issiue surronding whistle blowing
...' Sherron Watkins ." Time Magazine Online, CNN. N.p., 2002. Web. 26 Apr 2011.,8599,194927,00.html Ravishankar, L. "Encouraging Internal Whistleblowing in Organizations." Santa Clara University, Jesuite University of Silicone Valley. N.p., 2003. Web. 26 Apr 2011. Ripley, A. "Q&A: Whistle-Blower Cynthia Cooper." Time Magazine Online, CNN. N.p., 2008. Web. 26 Apr 2011.,8599,1709695,00.html Whistleblower,. "Definition of whistleblower." The Free Dictionary, by FARLAX, N.p., 2011. Web. 26 Apr 2011. ?Whistleblowing and its effects on private and...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Whistle-Blowing. Interest in Public Administration, Policy and Ethical Analysis
...Whistle-Blowing Introduction Interest in Public Administration, Policy and Ethical Analysis By prancing managers and appealing straightly to politicians, whistleblowers can play crucial role in unleashing organizational information. Nonetheless, the security of whistleblowers can affect managers' capabilities to regulate employees. Politicians must, as a result, maintain equilibrium between information exposure and the preservation of the incentives of the bureaucrats in order to exert efforts. The tradeoffs can easily be explored with the help of a model of agency decision-making under partial information. It involves an employee's effort which determines... reporting ...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay
Whistle Blowing.Internal And External Whistle Blowing
...Introduction In increasingly ethical organizations, whistle blowing is considered as a task which anyone undertakes to expose the organization's illegitimate and immoral acts which may be harmful to the public at large. Whistle blowing may be considered as threatening to some of the managers or co-workers however, it may serve as a tool to improve the long term effectiveness of the organizations. (Miceli and Near). Thus the process of whistle blowing has both the short term as well as long term implications for almost all the stakeholders in the organization therefore if the process is taken positively and corrective measures are taken properly, it may increase the trust of society in modern day organizations. However, despite its... ...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Paradoxes of Whistle-blowing
... ups in the organization as he/she was specifically contracted to do, and yet no action is being done to stop the practice. 6. Are there any aspects of whistle-blowing that Davis' theory neglects or fails to do full justice to Considering the point by point discussion which Davis conducted, there seems to be no aspect of whistle-blowing left unaddressed. References Davis, M. (1996). Some paradoxes of whistleblowing. Business and Professional Ethics Journal 15.... 1. What makes whistle-blowing morally problematic - that is, why does it need to be justified According to Davis, why isn't the police officer, the criminal informant, or the clerk who happens upon evidence of wrongdoing in another department, a...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Whistle blowing
...of the seniors, there by being named as whistle blowers. The practice of whistle blowing is necessary for professional organizations to maintain professional ethics and protect the public. Whistle blowing can be both good and bad for the society. William De Maria (2005) comments that whistle blowing can be a complex social phenomenon. It is good because it exposes corruption and malpractices, which could harm the society; it is bad because it amounts to breach of trust. Moreover, at the time of employment, the employees also have to sign a ‘non-disclosure agreement’. At the same time, freedom of...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay
Whistle Blowing
... of the firm’s trust. In his seminal book, Boatright argues (quite correctly) that whistle blowing should be treated in an integrative manner; combining legal, economic and moral viewpoints (Boatright 2002). Reference List Boatright, J. R. (2002). Ethics and the Conduct of Business. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. DeGeorge, R. T. (1982). Business Ethics. New York, NY: MacMillan Company. Hall, R. T. (2000). An Introduction to Healthcare Organizational Ethics. New York, NY: Oxford University Press US. Miceli, M. P., Dworkin, T. M. & Near, J. (2008). Whistle-blowing in Organizations. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.... Whistle Blowing 25 October 2009 Introduction...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Qui tam and whistle blowing
...fraudulently through whistleblowers that get a portion of the recovered money. The private sector in particular should incorporate it into their systems as it could save a firm from collapse or save shareholder losses as happened for instance at Enron. An anonymous fraud reporting system should be incorporated as part of a firms risk management program References Johnson, R. (2003). Whistle blowing: when it works--and why. (pp. 28-30). Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers Inc. Ravishankar, L. (2003). Encouraging internal whistle blowing in organizations Informally published manuscript, Markkula center for Applied Ethics, Santa Clara University, Santa...
2 Pages(500 words)Assignment
... Business, Research Paper   July 27, Whistle-blowing Characteristics of Watkins, Cooper and Rowley. These three courageous women were honored by the Time magazine as Persons of the year in 2002 because of their determination to seek the truth and their desire to protect their own organizations, in particular, and the public in general. They chose to put their professions and personal welfare in jeopardy and came forward with the truth. Are they whistle blowers or just doing their jobs well and with open eyes? All of them had no desire to become whistle blowers and were just employees doing their jobs well with open eyes because they followed the code of ethics in reporting it to their superiors first and to the right persons... , Ken Lay, she...
1 Pages(250 words)Research Paper
Whistle Blowing
.... According to Johnson (2003), whistle blowing helps in building a safe working place, protects the name, and earnings of the organization. At times, an employee may desist from reporting potentially harmful practices in the organization as it often raises differences in the organization. It is important to note that whistle blowing may lead to division among various parties in an organization (Johnson, 2003). The other people who are affected by whistle blowing tend to dehumanize the whistle blower in various ways. In the long run the whistleblower may desist from the act (Johnson, 2003). Ethics hotlines...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
Whistle blowing
...Whistle blowing Introduction Whistle blowing comes about when an employee reports suspected wrongdoing in an organization. This action is same as making a disclosure in the interest of the public. Certainly, this action is justifiable since it has assisted many organizations in eliminating the factors or employees that threaten to cause an organization’s decline (Arszułowicz and Wojciech, 152). This essay provides information about whistle blowing, some of the critiques concerning the issue and application of act-utilitarianism ethical theory in whistle blowing. Summary Generally,...
6 Pages(1250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Research Paper on topic Is Whistle Blowing Ethical or not for FREE!
Contact Us