StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Trompenaars. Leading Change and Organizational Culture - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Trompenaars, in the interview with Craven, provides an insight into the need for identifying and incorporating diversity in organisations. According to Trompenaars, it is surprising to see how lethargic many organisations are to accept the need for intercultural interaction in the modern business world, and how reluctant they are to tackle the issues associated to it…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Trompenaars. Leading Change and Organizational Culture
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Trompenaars. Leading Change and Organizational Culture"

? (Assignment) Leading Change and Organizational Culture Trompenaars, in the interview with Craven, provides an insight into the need for identifying and incorporating diversity in organisations. According to Trompenaars, it is surprising to see how lethargic many organisations are to accept the need for intercultural interaction in the modern business world, and how reluctant they are to tackle the issues associated to it. Thereafter, Trompenaars points out the common mistakes that are made by managers while dealing with culturally diverse workforces. The first one, according to him, is that most organisations still consider cultural issues secondary, and give them less priority on the belief that culture has nothing to do with the main business transaction (Craven). According to Trompenaars, if cultural issues are to be tackled, it is necessary to identify the origin of cultural values. Then only the organisations can develop effective norms and values. In other words, simply learning the norms and values of a culture will not help solve the issue. The second mistake, according to Trompenaars, is that organisations do not identify culture as a compliance issue. However, he reminds the fact that if cultural issues are not identified and solved, it can even lead to legal disputes. In the opinion of Trompenaars, in the 21st century, it is necessary for organisations to develop transcultural competence, which means the competence to reconcile dilemmas or to integrate opposites (Craven). At this point is wise to see what Levine, Phipps, and Blythe prefer to say about cultural differences. According to Levine, Phipps, and Blythe (16), linguistic and cultural pluralism is more than the mere coexistence of different languages; and it is about transcultural circulation of values across borders, the negotiation of identities, the inversions, even inventions of meaning, often concealed by a common illusion of effective communication. Trompenaars points out the fact that the currently available leadership literature is regionally biased. He gives the example of English, French, and Chinese literatures. It is pointed out that there is the need for more works on multi-cultural teams. In other words, the new leadership should transcend culture. According to Trompenaars, to effectively handle cross-cultural diversity, it is necessary to adopt reconciliation. According to Trompenaars, the first step of reconciliation is to let others be themselves. In simple terms, reconciliation is the understanding of how the perspectives of other cultures can help ones own culture. In others words, reconciliation calls for the fusion of two extremes; considering and accommodating the other culture. Trompenaars point out the fact that there are different ways of dealing with other cultures; ignoring other cultures, abandoning ones own culture, and reconciliation. In his words, in the modern world of business, an important factor for success of organisations is their ability to ‘celebrate differences’. In the opinion of Trompenaars, cultural is not a secondary entity, but is the contextual environment around all transactions in an organisation; financial, market, political, and technological. According to him, the success or future performance of an organisation is no more identified based on its financial performance, but on its ability to handle local cultures. So, he proposes Process Principle Optimization based on five major principles instead of the usual ROI. The five principles, according to him, are corporate effectiveness, the client, the employee, the shareholder, and societal responsibility. So, according to him, the modern businesses should seek ways to improve their local learning so that they can increase their global access. In other words, in the modern business world, integration of values helps organisations ensure sustainable business performance for the long term. 2. According to Trompenaars, the modern leadership and management, to be effective, should have transcultural competence. Transcultural competence is the ability to incorporate various cultures successfully, or, in the words of Trompenaars, to ‘celebrate differences’. A similar opinion is expressed by Laroche, and Rutherford (163) who point out that for culturally different employees, to stay in an organisation that hired them, it is necessary for them to work effectively with their managers. The authors continue that if their managers consider them poor workers, they are unlikely to survive. According to him, instead of neglecting other cultures or abandoning ones own, it is necessary to adopt the path of reconciliation to ensure transcultural competence. Reconciliation, in the words of Trompenaars, is the fusion of cultures by understanding how the other culture can be utilised to enrich ones own. It is pointed out that if the management and leadership fail to address the cross-cultural issues in the organisation, it will face problems in business as in the modern business world, to increase ones global offerings, it is necessary to understand and incorporate local cultures. 3. The first point that Trompenaars puts forward is that many managements and leaderships do not consider culture as an issue that can directly affect business transactions. The second point is that businesses, to succeed, should show transcultural competence. The third point is that presently, business literature does not address the issue of multi-culture workplace. The next point he puts forward is that reconciliation of culture is the best way to achieve transcultural competence. The last point he suggests is that culture can directly affect the financial performance of a company, and hence is an indicator of a company’s future performance. However, it is worth looking into what Abdulla Al Zamil, the chief operating officer of Industrial Investment Company, wants to say. According to Zamil, it is necessary for people to prevent a loss of their cultural identity too. He also points out the fact that in many countries, people are losing their traditional ways of life, and it should be stopped. 4. The first recommendation that can be seen in the interview with Trompenaars is that organisations should identify culture as a factor that has a direct influence on the business transactions of an organisation. The second suggestion is that companies should become transcultural competent. To become transculturally competent, it is necessary to identify other cultures and accept them as they are. Thereafter, it is advised that organisations should adopt reconciliation instead of neglect as the way to ensure transcultural competence. Horn and Faulkner (257) pointed out that a shared culture encourages people to accept common goals and to identify with each other; in addition, according to them, it facilitates the act of coordination and control in an organisation. Thus, it promotes cross-border consistency, both internally and externally. Works Cited “Cultural Identity must be Protected in the Wake of Globalisation, Says Al Zamil”. AME Info.com, Sep 2005. Web 25 May 2011 Craven, Alistair. “An Interview with Fons Trompenaars”. Emerald Management First. Levine, Glenn S., Phipps, Alison and Blythe, Carl. Aausc 2010: Critical and Intercultural Theory and Language Pedagogy. Boston, MA: Cengage Learning, 2011. Print. Laroche, Lionel., Rutherford, Don. Recruiting, Retaining, and Promoting Culturally Different Employees. US: Butterworth Heinemann, 2007. Print. Segal-Horn, Susan and Faulkner, David. Understanding Global Strategy. US: Cengage Learning, 2010. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Trompenaars. Leading Change and Organizational Culture Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1421953-trompenaars-leading-change-and-organizational-culture
(Trompenaars. Leading Change and Organizational Culture Essay)
https://studentshare.org/business/1421953-trompenaars-leading-change-and-organizational-culture.
“Trompenaars. Leading Change and Organizational Culture Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1421953-trompenaars-leading-change-and-organizational-culture.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Trompenaars. Leading Change and Organizational Culture

The Moderating Effect of Culture on the Information Systems Projects

Universiteit van Amsterdam Roetersstraat 11 1018 WB Amsterdam The Netherlands Faculty of Economics and Business (FEB) Master Thesis "The Moderating Effect of culture on the Success Factors of Information Systems Projects" Abstract Information Systems has become a core concept in contemporary organizations.... A potential underestimation of factors such as culture may play a role of importance, leading to these problems.... This study provides an understanding of cultural impacts from the national level, based on Hofstede's and Trompenaars models of culture....
39 Pages (9750 words) Essay

Relevance of Cultural Theories to the Study of International HRM

?? culture theories emerge from the study of viewing cultures; hence, cultures are systems that relate individual communities to their ecological settings.... There are several theories that relate to culture including globe theory, Hofstede theory and Trompenaar theory.... If a culture is willing to work for the long-term goals, then the culture has long-term orientation (Torun, 2007 pp 10)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Assignment

Cross Culture Management: An Impact of Academic Literature on National Culture

This paper "Cross culture Management: An Impact of Academic Literature on National culture" examines the importance of the academic literature in the culture of the nation.... It can be said that national culture impacts on the cross-border business much more compared to national business.... hellip; The differences of natural culture are vital; along with it impacts on the expansion of company, industry as well as economy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Managing Challenges of Cross Cultural Differences in International Business

The paper comprises and thus will discuss the following main sections: Overview of National culture & Cross Cultural Differences; Overview of the Countries in Context; Analysis of Cross Cultural Similarities & Differences; Main Differences in Management Styles; Recomendations.... Overview of National culture & Cross Cultural Differences culture is a key factor in gaining an insight in to how people behave in different countries, their preferences, attitudes, values and beliefs (Cundiff & Hilger 1988)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Hofstede and Trompenaars Frameworks for Estimation of Coffee Consumption in China

The culture of a country plays a key role in consumers' behavior, and this is more evident in China's consumption of coffee.... nbsp;… Though it, is projected that China may become one of the leading consumers of coffee, it is taking time because of the Chinese value their national culture.... The word culture is a Latin word closely related to cultus which means cult or worship.... Therefore, culture may be considered as the result of human action....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Cross Cultural Negotiation and Management

Due to this, the French who exercise high resistance to change and patriotism did not take this well and thus only a few visited the park during its first year of operation in which it realized a huge loss.... This paper is an evaluation of the influence of culture on management across various cultural diversities.... culture refers to the unique characteristics of behaviors and norms that are identified with a certain community (Luthans 2008 p 45)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

The Moderating Effect of Culture on the Success Factors of Information Systems Projects

This study provides an understanding of cultural impacts from the national level, based on Hofstede's and Trompenaars models of culture.... hellip; The research design is situated within the theoretical constructs of Trompenaars and Hofstede who both advanced sociological notions of culture as contextually related to international business interactions.... In these regards, four individuals from Greek and four individuals four Dutch culture will be interviewed as they cultural distinctions represent the significant diversity of thought and perspective....
38 Pages (9500 words) Coursework

Strengths and Weakness for Culture Theories

In the paper, a comparative analysis was made of the three cultural theories namely Hofstede's cultural dimension, Swartz's cultural values, and Thompenaar's culture theories.... eert Hofstede's cultural dimension theory is based on how the culture of a society or a workplace influences an individual's culture in the same society or organization.... Lastly, masculinity versus femininity is when the emotional roles are assessed within a society or a culture....
18 Pages (4500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us