Socio-economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
This essay "Socio-economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies" describes what status women have in Minangakabau tribe. The peculiarity is that women are of immense social importance for this tribe and the male adult caregiver for a child in this tribe would be mother’s brother instead of child’s father. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
Socio-economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Socio-economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies"

Socio-economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies
Kinship patterns affect the social alliance of individuals in all society along with providing identity to them. It is the kinship which further acts as a criteria of social and economic status of an individual in their respective social groups. Raymond Scupin argues that kinship plays an important role in modifying position of women and women have a higher social status in societies with kinship systems that emphasize matrilocality (i.e. living with the wife’s family) and matrilineal descent (i.e. determining inheritance and descent through the female line) compared to societies with kinship systems that emphasize patrilocality and patrilineal descent. In order to analyze Scupin’s hypothesis, the Minangkabau of Indonesia and the Yanomamo of Amazon region, South America are examined. The reason for selecting these two social groups is that Minangkabau follow matrilineal system of descent whereas the Yanomamo follows patrilineal system of kinship.
Minangakabau tribe is known for its matrilineal social system despite being an Islamic tribe. It is important to note that in Muslim culture, men are given more dominance as a head of the family and main decision maker. Furthermore, Muslim societies usually have chain of decent traced back to fathers. In Minangkabau, the mother decides social status of the child and men are considered as a weaker part of the spousal relationship. In addition to that, men are pledged by mothers to their wives which makes them live at the wives’ homes after marriage (Sanday 81). However, this arrangement works only at nights and men return to their mothers during the day. Hence, men tend to belong to their mothers and have their loyalty towards them while bearing their responsibilities as well. On the contrary, the Yanomamo of Amazon follows the patrilineal system of descent. Marriages take place among allied lineage groups where members of the families are consulted for the final decision (Chagnon 121-126). After marriage, women move to their husband’s house. It is important to note that marriages are also decided by the elder male members of the clan.
Women are of immense social importance for this tribe and the male adult caregiver for a child in this tribe would be mother’s brother instead of child’s father (Sanday 94; Taylor n.p). Secondly, a child is known by his mother’s name and is expected to add to her wealth by playing his role as a part of the family (Sanday 37). On the contrary, children tend to belong to their fathers’ kinship in Yanomamo tribal system however names of the kinships do not follow any specific pattern.
Another important aspect of this tribal arrangement is presence of male head in a corporate descent groups making this tribe patriarchic while staying matrilineal (Sanday n.p; Taylor n.p). Women of the clan choose one of their uncles or older brothers to be the head of the clan who is responsible for negotiations, economic decisions and conflict resolution. However, these decisions often reflect the will of female members as well. Secondly, properties in such corporate structures especially immoveable are not owned by individuals i.e. neither men nor women, but groups. Usage rights are assigned by the groups to specific individuals. Outside clan, men and women both can own individual properties. Unlike, Minangkabau, Yanomamo does not follow the system of joint property (Early and Peters n.p). Furthermore, this tribe does not have named kinship groups (Chagnon 133-137). Exchange of women as a result of marriage leads to strong relationship among brothers-in-laws however relationships among cousins are often reserved. Polygamy is also evident in this group (Early and Peters n.p; “Marriage and Family” n.p).
Minangkabau further follows a duo-local residential system (Sanday 83-95). Husbands work on the ground of their wives and help them in cultivation however the produce will remain the property of the wife. On the other hand, if a man owns any form of property, it is inherited by its sisters’ children and not by his owns or his brothers’. Fathers are considered as outsiders or guests in this matrilineal system whereas the main decision maker is maternal uncle (Sanday n.p). Interestingly, if a man does not find employment in the local markets, he works on his wife’s descent’s property but for no major gains. However, if he decides to do the same on his mother’s property, he shares some profits with rest of the profits going either to his mother or sister. Young boys are also made to leave the house after the age of ten and make the place available for their sisters and their husbands. They tend to return only for meals (Sanday 47). However, the system changes after their marriage and they are required to move back to their mothers but are also required to make themselves scarce when their sisters’ husband visit.
A critical analysis of these two tribal groups helps in understanding that patterns of kinship and descent play a major role in deciding socio-economic status of women in different societies. It was found that women tend to have more rights and respect in matrilineal society in Minangkabau however this partially proves Scupin’s hypothesis. Despite having ownership of the property, major decisions of the family are taken by the male head of the clan (irrespective of mutual consent among men and women). Furthermore, existence of male heads is mandatory for every social group in Minangkabau. Therefore, having title to property and entitlement to income still does not eliminate a complete need for men in this culture. However, Yanomamo is a tribe with dense social authority given to men. In such structures, men are given more importance however with whom their daughters and sisters have been married acts as criteria for social bonding among men. Therefore, it can be said that Scupin’s hypothesis is partially correct however kinship of women does not act as the only criterion for their socio-economic status in matrilineal and patriarchal groups.

Works Cited
Chagnon, Napoleon. Yanomamo: The Fierce People. New York: Holt McDougal, 1968. Print.
Early, John D. and Peters, John F. The Xilixana Yanomami of the Amazon. Gainesville: University of Florida, 2000. Print.
Sanday, Peggy Reeves. Women at the Center: Life in a Modern Matriarchy. Cornell University Press, 2004. Print.
Taylor, Jacob. Matrilineal Descent Patterns in Contemporary Cultures. N.p, 2012. Web.
“Marriage and Family”. University of Wisconsin Milwaukee. N.p, 2008. Web. 27 Oct. 2013. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Socio-economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de
(Socio-Economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies Essay)
“Socio-Economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
Argentinas economic status January 2006 (Sullivan). IMF even questions Argentina’s accounting measures and credibility of data especially the one concerned with inflation. Keeping this at backdrop the paper intends to present a study of Argentina’s economic status by looking upon its past history of economic crisis and also examining the extent of recovery from such a crisis currently. Motivation of paper The country of Argentina situated in Latin America had been going through a political turmoil for many years along with disastrous economic conditions. Economic crisis followed by debt crisis has been piling up one after another. Currently the country is facing the problems...
13 Pages(2250 words)Essay
Changing Women status
...discourses. In the colonial period, the family laws were considered as inherently part of the Korean tradition. Therefore, family laws were considered as an essential component of building the nation as it could be based on the Korean tradition. According to Shin, “[s]ince its inception during the colonial period, the portion of the Civil Code covering Korean family law had institutionalized a strict patriarchal and patrilineal family, subordinating the rights and the status of women to the family head” (94). From there, it is important to note that how the gender discourse changed along with the demands of national reconstruction. By 1970s, economic development was the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Status of Women
...? Status of Women Status of Women Mary Wollstonecraft’ book ‘vindication of the rights of woman’ had considerable impact on political thoughts of women rights’ advocates in America in the nineteenth century. The book established Wollstonecraft as preeminent defender of controversial yet visionary views that women could realize same levels of moral, political and intellectual excellence as men if same education and civil rights were offered to both sexes. Her view, paved way for public discourse regarding women’s rights and once the book ‘Rights of Woman’ was published in 1792; she became the famous and infamous proto-feminist in European enlightenment; as well, in America her works received wide readership from both men and women... in the...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Socio-economic Status and Job Opportunities
...complaint to the EEOC so that they are provided justice in the prevailing society. Analysis of the study Through this study, various factors of socio-economic status effecting individuals have been analyzed that are causing hindrances to achieve equal job opportunities in United States. The socio-economic statuses have an impact on job opportunities, but it is necessary to have awareness of these issues so that the best suitable candidates can be shortlisted in the organization to provide good productivity and people can have a quality life in the society as well. In order to hire applicants without prejudice the...
7 Pages(1750 words)Research Paper
Socio-economic status of a population
...affecting the whole planet and disrupting earth's life-supporting mechanisms, but the extent to which this affects human well-being and health varies substantially in different parts of the world' (Sari Kovats, Kristie L Ebi and Bettina Menne 2003). Assessing the socio-economic status of a population based on health will require all the factors that contribute to disparities in health among humans, such as access to health care, nutritional factors, environmental exposure and social support. The health related behaviors of people in a society can be based on the individual position of its people most of the time (Kirby L. Jackson, Jennifer L. Waller, Carol Z. Garrison...
13 Pages(3250 words)Essay
The Status of Women
...and high schools), suggests that society still perceives their role to be that of nurturing the children, and when it comes to higher education, the numbers drop dramatically. Again, their roles exist within social services, home economics and the like, 'woman's work' with very few women college and university teachers in physical sciences, law and engineering. By 1989, women made up 45% of the workforce, but few in any important role, such as decision-makers. Rather, they are employed in service industries, clerical posts, machine operators, hairdressers, waitresses, book-keepers and so forth. An appalling inequality is the fact that, in 1970, despite the Equal...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay
Women in a patriarchal society
...We all are living in the patriarchal society. This is the world created by men and for men. Women are often left little space for freedom and independence here. The situation is not new. The history of patriarchal society takes its origin in the ancient world. Women of the Ancient Greece and Rome had little rights. They could not make arrangements of their lives and possessions. They were to marry men chosen by their families and were considered belonging first to their fathers and then to their husbands. They could not determine the destiny of their children, all the decision being made by males. In the epoch of Christianity the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Global Socio-Economic Inequalities
...States and other countries around the world. This helps the reader understand the relative effectiveness of American social policy. In Life at the Top is Longer, Scott starts by describing how people of different social status experience heart attacks. It shows how in society people get different healthcare depending on their status. In Health, Income and Inequality, Mulahy, Robert and Wolfe describe how inequality might affect health and vice versa. It also describes as to whether economic inequality predicts the size of health disparities between educational or economic groups. In Unequal Childhoods, Lareau describes how social class shapes parenting...
1 Pages(250 words)Assignment
Women status in islam
...(PBUH) brought Islam to the people of Mecca, he improved on the position of women and gave them their much needed respect. But this status is not enough for the modern world. The purpose of this paper is to explore the status of women in Islam with respect to their rights and duties. Status of Women in Islam Before the advent of Islam, women were treated in a derogatory manner. They were considered mainly as possessions that could be transferred from father to son as inheritance. There was also a prevalent custom where women were burned alive as infants since every family wanted a man rather than a...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
The Status of Women in the Hebrew and Greek Societies
...The Status of Women in the Hebrew and Greek Societies In different societies, one might observe a different attitude towards women. Analyzing ancient societies, in particular represented by Jews and Greeks, one can see that ancient women lived within a patriarchal system. It suggested that women had their specific responsibilities. The main role of women was to be a good mother and wife who was subordinated to her husband. Moreover, women demonstrated dependence on men. Compared with women, men had much more rights and opportunities....
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Socio-economic Status of Women in Patriarchal Societies for FREE!
Contact Us