Free

Losing Isaiah - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Luckily, little Isaiah, freezing and starving, was found and taken to the hospital, where one of the social workers became interested with him…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Losing Isaiah
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Losing Isaiah"

Ethical dilemma in “Losing Isaiah” College Ethical Dilemma in “Losing Isaiah” “Losing Isaiah” is a story of a drug addict, who, being under strong drug intoxication, abandoned her new-born son at the dump. Luckily, little Isaiah, freezing and starving, was found and taken to the hospital, where one of the social workers became interested with him. Margaret, the social worker, adopted African-American Isaiah, who was no longer dependent on drugs. The boy grew up in the atmosphere of love in his “white” family; although, he was nervous, hyperactive, and distracted from his ethnical roots. The family idyll would go on, if not the fact that Isaiah’s biological mother began to torment Margaret’s good conscience. When Isaiah’s biological mother went out of the prison and escaped from the iron clutch of drug addiction, she decided to get Isaiah back. Here the controversy began. In the courtroom the parties of the “conflict” raised questions of ethnical difference between Isaiah and his foster family and wisdom of bringing up the boy in the environment, where nobody is like him. After the heated argument in the court, the judge brought in a verdict to give Isaiah back to his biological mother. That was right decision from the point of common sense, but it did not work in the end. The arguments against the verdict are the following: Isaiah’s biological mother did not know anything about bringing up this child; the boy had psychology problems and radical change of the family could do harm to him; there was a possibility of compromise that would be acceptable for both mothers and the child.
Firstly, despite the fact that Isaiah was brought up in the “white” environment and did not receive enough information about his roots, he was brought up in the atmosphere of love in Margaret’s family. His foster mother was with him from the very childhood. She helped him to overcome the drug addiction and kept him safe from the hunger and poverty. Margaret Lewin was right when she said that Khaila was not inherently his mother. Margaret said that Khaila wouldn’t even know what to do when Isaiah got sick. She really loved the boy, and on the trial she told Khiala’s lawyer that the skin color does not matter when it goes about love, and they are capable to bring up Isaiah as a decent person.
Secondly, Isaiah was rather troubled child. He was born from drug addict and during his first days of life he did not receive a proper care. Moreover, his biological mother gave him drugs as a sort of “lullaby”. The new born baby was drug addicted. All these facts could not but influence his mind. There are several accents on that in the film. The boy could suddenly go into dramatics in the most unsuitable situation (scene with Margaret’s daughter performance in the theatre). For such complicated boy as Isaiah, the radical change of his familiar environment could do much harm; no matter that it was his ethnical environment. The problems caused by the change of family became evident in the final scenes of the film, when living with his biological mother was a significant trauma for the boy. He began to show autistic behavior.
Thirdly, there initially was an obvious possibility for the compromise between two Isaiah’s mothers. It was presented in the end of the movie. Khaila, boy’s biological mother, saw the sufferings of her son when she got him back. She remembered, when being a child, she was disturbed by the constant change of the foster families and the troubles it caused to her childish mind. Finally, she decided to give the boy back to the Lewins. Isaiah was happy. Crying “Mommy!” he rushed into the embraces of his foster mother. His both mothers decided to bring him up together, and, in this respect, without violating the boy’s mind to keep him attached to his roots.
To conclude with, the movie raises a very controversial question, because everybody was right in the situation occurred. Isaiah’s biological mother did not give up her child and had a right to get him back. On the other hand, she appeared from nowhere and knew nothing about bringing up the boy with some psychological problems. It substantially complicated the problem. The only solution was a compromise between two boy’s mothers. In finally was reached, overcoming the racial and social controversies.
References
Gylenhaal, N. F., Koch H. (Producers) & Gyllenhaal, S. (Director). (1995). Losing Isaiah [Motion picture]. United States: Paramount Pictures. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Losing Isaiah Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Losing Isaiah Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1608854-losing-isaiah
(Losing Isaiah Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Losing Isaiah Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1608854-losing-isaiah.
“Losing Isaiah Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1608854-losing-isaiah.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Losing Isaiah

Losing weight

...? Losing Weight From eating unbalanced diets to quitting smoking, and from losing the temper to drinking, many people possess such a long list of behaviors which they are compelled to change or may want to change willingly. They consult numerous doctors and physicians, and while doing so, some of them succeed in giving up their bad and unhealthy habits while others are unable to control them. While, many of them are even successful in changing the bad habits, but may revert to their pervious behaviors in the long term. In order to change these complex behaviors, two of the psychologists named Prochaska and DiClemente have worked upon the Stages of Change Model. Through this five-step change model, we...
2 Pages(500 words)Research Paper

Losing Weight Research Paper

...Losing Weight Introduction There have been remarkable intent and focus instigated by health organizations globally on people who have reported to exceed the normal body mass index (BMI), an indicator of maintaining a healthy weight. According to the Centers for Disease Prevention and Control (CDC), the BMI “provides a reliable indicator of body fatness for most people and is used to screen for weight categories that may lead to health problems” (par. 1). Due to the enhanced attention being acknowledged for the need to adhere to a prescribed BMI, people who have exceeded to average BMI have increasingly resorted to using a variety of approaches and techniques to lose those unwanted weight. Are weight loss...
4 Pages(1000 words)Research Paper

Isaiah

...? Interpretive essay Introduction In this excerpt, Isaiah indirectly revisits earlier God’s covenant to hispeople concerning what will befall them if they fail to hearken His statutes. Numerous desolations featured in Isaiah 24: 1–5 comprise penalties, which God through his messengers stated will characterize their daily lives because of disobedience1. This is contrary to what they would have enjoyed if they kept God’s ordinances from the great to the small. However, certain scholars despite holding onto the idea of “everlasting covenant” argue chapters 24 to 27 their content is about a period, which is still in the “undefined future.” “Undefined future” relayed in these chapters according to some...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay

ISAIAH BIBLE LESSON TOPIC Isaiah 11:1:9

...?The Lesson of Isaiah 11 9 Meaning of the Passage The lesson that will be examined will be Isaiah 11 9. This is a passage of glorious hope. This passage addresses the Assyrian threat, yet gives hope of a fulfillment that is in the future.1 The passage begins with the imagery of a felled tree. The significance of this tree is that, although it has been destroyed, its roots still remain. This is what Isaiah references when he speaks about the stem of Jesse, and the branch that shall grow out of its roots. In this passage, according to Motyer (1993), Isaiah was speaking about a prophecy that he was forewarned about in earlier passages, that there would be deported people and...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Losing Accents

...Losing Accents I used to agree that getting the chance to migrate was a fancy privilege. It suggested a fresh start, the chance of experiencing twoentirely different cultures first hand, and greater opportunities would now be available when they once were not in your country of origin. True that this may be the case for some immigrants, but does the tongue really twist better on the other side of the hemisphere Julia Alvarez's How the Garcia Girls Lost their Accents provides us with a perspective as what we might have overlooked about the lives of immigrants, and the issues they deal with as we become acquainted with the De la Torre-Garcia family struggles with assimilation. Moreover, the book just as intently defines the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Losing Community

...Essay Question 1) Respond to following quotation below. Losing Community “We should become suspicious of the retrospective consciousness of thelost community and its identity ... the thought of community or the desire for it might well be nothing other than a belated invention that tried to respond to the harsh reality of modern experience” Jean-Luc Nancy points to the Western preoccupation with some lost archaic community as an argument that we should be wary about. Here, there is supposedly an Occidental nostalgia that deplores the loss of familiarity, fraternity and conviviality as the world evolved. (p. 10) Such nostalgia implies an earlier, perhaps even primal concept of communion that came with the emergence of...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Isaiah

...Justice in Isaiah “Maintain justice and do what is right” (Isaiah, 56 Justice, the most fundamental aspect of every theological and political concern is too complex to understand and apply in practical life without any chance of a flaw. Justice is one of the significant aspects that have been discussed throughout the Holy Bible in order to purport the cause of divine intervention in the history of Judaism. It has been argued that there is no unanimous opinion or consistency regarding the concept of justice among its advocates/prophets. However, close reading would help us understand that the Scriptures have been interpreting the various facets of the same issue based on the same solid...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Losing Matt Shepard

...Losing Matt Shepard Loffreda is talking about the lesbian and gay. She stresses for alteration is in politics and lifefollowing the Anti-gay murder. In the story, she describes how the inhabitants of Wyoming responded when Shepard, a youthful gay student studying at a university in Laramie was viciously beaten, tied up to the hedge and abandoned to die by the road side. On 14th Wednesday, October, the countrywide organization of gay and the Human Rights Campaign participated in a candlelight vigil on the stair of the United States capital. Worth mentioning, if for the absurdity of an incident that brought together the likes of Ellen DeGeneres and Ted Kennedy (Beth 167). When the writer refers to what seemed like a...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Isaiah verse 1.1-2.1

...Commentary: The Book of Isaiah Assignment 2 Stephen Major Theo 201 Dr. Harvie May 25th, Background The first two chapters of the book of Isaiahreveal God’s displeasure in the doings of the people of Judea, where they had turned away from God and towards evil, without caring about their relationship with God. The first chapter presents God’s accusations and appeals to the people of Judah. In the accusations, God speaks through his prophet Isaiah expressing his displeasure in the alliances that the rulers of Judah had established with nations that worshiped pagan God’s (Young & Isaiah, 1965). He also expresses the injustices in the land, where the rulers and the powerful oppress the poor...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay

Isaiah verse 1.1-2.1

...Isaiah Verse 1-2 Introduction Isaiah was one of the greatest prophets who had his unique contribution developed through his teachings in the regions of Jerusalem and Judah. Like all other prophets, Isaiah even developed his prophecies to draw the attention of people towards the correct path and develop a better understanding towards the stated facts conversing the true meaning of Christianity. In the initial phases, the writing published by Isaiah depicts about the betrayals by human race towards God (Andreasen, 2001). As per the words of the book - “Hear, O heavens, and give ear, O earth; for the Lord has spoken”. The book and the verses even depicts about the different displays of cruelty and wickedness practiced by the kings... prominent...
10 Pages(2500 words)Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Losing Isaiah for FREE!

Contact Us