Nobody downloaded yet

Relativism vs. Objectivism in Aesthetic Evaluation - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Summary
Relativism vs. Objectivism in Aesthetic Evaluation The criteria on which personal views on objects or events are based are usually differentiated, being influenced by the beliefs of each individual. Under certain terms, subjective views, i.e. those views based on objects or events that can be evaluated differently are not accepted as valid…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.7% of users find it useful
Relativism vs. Objectivism in Aesthetic Evaluation
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample
"Relativism vs. Objectivism in Aesthetic Evaluation"

Download file to see previous pages In accordance with Young (2003) ‘the aesthetic value can be objective or subjective, being influenced by the criteria used for evaluating a specific event/ object’ (Young 2003 p.117). On the other hand, it should be made clear that a work of art is considered as having no value when the specific work of art has no effect on people. Moreover, the evaluation of a work of art should be primarily based on the potential benefits that the specific piece would secure for the public (Young 2003). In any case, when no reference is made to the pleasure that a particular work of art can offer to the public, then the evaluation of the specific work of art can be characterized as invalid. The identification of the influence of objectivism and relativism on the aesthetic evaluation is a difficult task. In terms of its nature, aesthetic value is a concept used for explaining the value of an object based on its characteristics. In accordance with Bunnin and Yu (2004) the aesthetic value can be described as ‘the properties rendering a work of art good or successful, such as balance, charm and elegance’ (Bunnin and Yu 17). Aesthetic value, in the above sense, can be focus on different characteristics of a work of art, such as its colour or its significance for the society’ (Bunnin and Yu 17). ...
Then, their role in aesthetic evaluation would be made clear. It should be noted that the existing theory on relativism and objectivism, especially regarding the aesthetic evaluation, is based on different approaches, mostly because of the extensive use of these concepts in explaining the response of individuals to their external environment. It should be noted that the relevant views will be presented and analyzed, as possible, especially in regard to their relation to aesthetic evaluation. In accordance with Baghramian (2004) relativism can have three different forms; it can be characterized as subjective, social and conceptual (Baghramian 7). Subjective relativism is based on the view that ‘aesthetic evaluations are depended on the beliefs of individual thinkers’ (Baghramian 7). The above type of relativism is differentiated from social relativism, which highlights the importance of social conditions as a criterion for the development of aesthetic evaluation. Moreover, conceptual relativism is highly based on ‘ontology and scientific paradigms’ (Baghramian 7), which can be used every time that an object or an event has to be evaluated in terms of its aesthetic status or quality (Baghramian 7). Among the three forms of relativism presented above, the one that most reflects the role of relativism in aesthetic evaluation is the first one, the subjective relativism. This form of relativism is clearly opposed to objectivism, as a concept also reviewed in this paper, especially as of its use in aesthetic evaluation. At the same time, relativism can result to the different evaluation of aesthetic properties. More specifically, in the context ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Relativism vs. Objectivism in Aesthetic Evaluation Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1440079-relativism-vs-objectivism-in-aesthetic-evaluation
(Relativism Vs. Objectivism in Aesthetic Evaluation Essay)
https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1440079-relativism-vs-objectivism-in-aesthetic-evaluation.
“Relativism Vs. Objectivism in Aesthetic Evaluation Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1440079-relativism-vs-objectivism-in-aesthetic-evaluation.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
CHECK THESE SAMPLES - THEY ALSO FIT YOUR TOPIC
Website evaluation- gizmodo.com vs. engadget.com
...Website evaluation- gizmodo.com vs. engadget.com Technology gadgets remain as one of the most intriguing topics that pull people's interest. Whether it on a new iPhone in the Market or a wireless charger for use in electric cars, people find technology news to be exciting and informative. Because of increased popularity of technology news, there many technology blogs that have come up, to provide blogs to thirsty technology savvy users. Today, there are many technology blogs in operations, with each one of them trying to meet the needs of its audience. Gizmodo.com and engadget.com are some of the technology blogs that people use to learn of any valuable technological news for their consumptions. After a...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Existentialism vs. Relativism
...? Existentialism vs. Relativism Philosophy Existentialism vs. Relativism Introduction Existentialism has its roots in the20th century philosophy from the writings of Heidegger, Kierkegaard, Sartre and Camus, and entails an analysis of the way human beings find themselves existing in the world. This is philosophy that is concerned with enabling individuals to find self and attach meaning to life through choice, will and personal responsibility. This philosophy is embarked on the belief that individuals try to attach meaning to their life experiences, on the basis of their outlook, experiences and beliefs. Existentialists believe that personal choices are unique and do not...
5 Pages(1250 words)Essay
Objectivism and Collectivism
...Objectivism and Collectivism It is within man’s nature to think and reason and thus one of the main topics that have been discussed in philosophy consists of the question which is the best way to live the life that an individual has. This has brought about the two philosophies of collectivism and objectivism which can be said to be direct opposites of one another when it comes to the beliefs and practices they promote (Mayhew 56). They do however also maintain a few similarities in certain aspects as well and it is by comparing and contrasting that one is able to identify both the differences and similarities that objectivism and collectivism bring to the table in the discussion of a...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Aesthetic relativism versus aesthetic objectivism
...of aesthetic descends from the notion of taste. The reason why the notion of taste commanded a lot of philosophical attention in the eighteenth century was due to the theory of taste that had emerged of which was a corrective measure to the upraise of objectivism in regard to beauty. With this rise especially applied to virtue. While objectivism was against beauty, the judgment of beauty in the eighteenth century idea of taste was to be immediate, against self-absorption of virtue and held the desire of beauty to be disinterested (“Relativism vs. Objectivism” 1). In any given debate, arguments especially to do with...
6 Pages(1500 words)Essay
Critical Evaluation: Dorian vs. Fishman
...Critical Evaluation: Dorian vs. Fishman The heritage of our language and culture ified our past, molds our present and structures our future. Conflict develops when society at large overlooks the needs and desires of all its members. With a move towards modernisation and the ever shrinking world, cultures are bound to clash. This however does not need to foretell the demise of a language or dialect but merely its progression to its next level - or does it In discussing two divergent opinions regarding the decline of languages and their cultural underpinning an evaluation of this debate will be investigated. Fishman in his 1990 article discusses the implications of reverse language...
10 Pages(2500 words)Essay
Aesthetic Essay
...as it had been popularly coined by the phrase “beauty is in the eye of the beholder” (Martin 2009). Film, which is an art of making motion pictures, encompasses different criteria or qualities by which its aesthetic quality can be evaluated depending on the person viewing it. Thereby, its classification as a beautiful film depends on the subjective nature of the person who viewed it. It is in this regard that this essay is written to determine the qualities of a good (and beautiful) film as hereby defined. Qualities of a Good Film The most critical factors that qualify a film or movie as good are as follows: (1) a good plot (or the content of the story), (2) the quality and choice of casts, (3) genre,...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay
Bsolutism vs. Relativism
...Absolutism vs. Relativism In todays world ethical relativism dominates so it is important to have s that are carefully written down and that are exhaustive and detailed. What is ethical relativism? This is a position believes that no universal standard exists to assess the truth of the world around us. Relativists often see morals as applying only within certain cultures. These people would say that female genital mutilation is okay because it is a cultural practice and an important to a particular culture. They believe there is no standard on which to base your opinion and they live their life under the precept: To each his own. This is obviously pretty useless for...
1 Pages(250 words)Book Report/Review
Relativism and Objectivism as Two Different Moral Principles Theory
..., which relies heavily in core principles of education; it becomes apparent that a moral truth can be no doubt achieved. It is safe to say that objectivism views do not change; the universality pertaining to each issue applies everywhere. Works Cited "Moral Relativism vs. Moral Objectivism." University of Colorado Boulder. N.p., n.d. Web. 22 June 2011. . Peikoff, Dr. Leonard. "The Ayn Rand Institute: The Philosophy of Objectivism: A Brief Summary." The Ayn Rand Institute: News and Highlights. N.p., n.d. Web. 22 June 2011. Relativism and Objectivism are two different moral principles theory. Relativism is a perspective that discusses the aspect that moral principles are valid. Each...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
Ethical objectivism and Kantian Ethics ar arguments to ethical relativism
...Ethical Objectivism and Kantian Ethics The nature of cultural understanding is strongly rooted in notions of ethics. Prominent researchers and anthropologists have advanced notions regarding ethnocentrism wherein morality must be judged within the specific cultural context. These notions of ethical relativism have received significant criticism from a variety of perspectives and ethical theorists. One considers one of the most prominent example the cultural actions of the Nazi’s in carrying out the Holocaust in World War II; few would condone such an action based on cultural relativism. Implementing Kantian ethics, this essay argues against ethical relativism. Even in...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay
Relativism
...Relativism It is undeniable that one of the most highly valued virtues is forgiveness. Many societies and cultures across the world consider forgiveness among the virtues that hold the society together. People are expected to forgive and forget the wrong done to them by others. Most of the cultures that are primarily based on Christianity uphold forgiveness as one of the top virtues. This is not surprising considering the fact that Christianity is based on forgiveness of sin. Likewise, Christian societies and cultures built on Christian grounds become a forgiving society. However, this is quite different from cultures based on Islam. Although Islamic religion upholds forgiveness as a virtue, there is an appreciable deviation... from this...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Let us find you another Essay on topic Relativism vs. Objectivism in Aesthetic Evaluation for FREE!
Contact Us