Nobody downloaded yet

John Berger's Comparison of Fine Art to Commercial Art - Essay Example

Comments (0) Cite this document
Introduction There is an inherent conflict between the meaning of fine art, such as art that would be found in a museum, and commercial art, which his art that might be found in an advertisement. Specifically, the writer and art critic John Berger believes that commercial art is limited in what it can tell the audience, because the commercial art is not the product of a lived experience…
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.9% of users find it useful
John Bergers Comparison of Fine Art to Commercial Art
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "John Berger's Comparison of Fine Art to Commercial Art"

Download file to see previous pages This is because fine art is often esoteric and ultimately meaningless. Art critics might be able to find meaning in certain works of art, but they would be the only ones. The common man would have great difficulty understanding the meaning of a man's urinal used as artwork. On the other hand, commercial art is supposed to be understandable and accessible or, at the very least, evoke powerful emotions. For this reason, commercial art is more successful in conveying messages to mass audiences then is fine art. Discussion John Berger states that abstract art has been adopted by corporate capitalism, which is causing these aesthetics to become emblems of economic power. He says that, through this process of reducing the aesthetics of fine art into something that is used to increase economic power for the entity that uses this art, the lived experience inherent in the art work is eliminated from the image of the art. This results, in his view, in a reduced area of experience, even though it claims to be universal (Berger, 2001, p. 296). This process of commercializing fine art, and the subsequent way that this transformation has robbed the art work of meaning is particularly anathema to Berger, as he feels that art comes from a primitive part of the artist, and that it comes from the lived experience of the artist (Berger, 2001, p. 296). For Berger, drawing and art is about discovery within the artist himself (Berger, 2001, p. 10). The power of the art comes from this lived experience, the faith that this experience can produce the art, and this is typically coupled with a skepticism of the society in which the artist finds oneself (Berger, 2001, p. 297). Thus, in transforming art in commercialism, it robs the art of this lived experience which is the essence, the very heart of the artwork. The meaning of the artwork is dead, at least the meaning that the artist intended, and the meaning is instead transformed into whatever the particular advertisement is attempting to sell. Berger was also highly critical of the fact that paintings have become so commodified. He states that no work of art may survive without becoming a valuable piece of property, and that this spells the death of the painting and sculpture, as “property, as once it was not, is now inevitably opposed to all other values. People believe in property, but in essence they only believe in the illusion of protection which property gives. All works of fine art, whatever their content, whatever the sensibility of an individual spectator, must now be reckoned as no more than props for the confidence of the world spirit of conservatism” (Berger, 2001, p. 215). Thus, the fact that paintings and sculptures must be commodified to survive in the long term spells the end of the art as we know it, in Berger's eyes. According to Papastergiadis (1993), Berger's issue with the commercialization of art would stem from the fact that Berger contends that art must give meaning to human experiences. In particular, art works to increase our understanding of the gap between freedom and alienation in everyday life. He also states that Berger is a combination of a Marxist, in which the art is integrated with the political, thus is an ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“John Berger's Comparison of Fine Art to Commercial Art Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from
(John Berger'S Comparison of Fine Art to Commercial Art Essay)
“John Berger'S Comparison of Fine Art to Commercial Art Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (0)
Click to create a comment or rate a document

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF John Berger's Comparison of Fine Art to Commercial Art

Fine and popular art

...hundred years a strict division between the fine arts and the popular arts. In this paper, that division will be considered in detail in order to determine whether there remains, in fact, a legitimate difference between fine art and the popular arts, or whether any attempt to describe such a division is ultimately false and misleading. Before one begins to formulate judgments about the distinctions between fine art and the popular arts, it is necessary to define both the type and scope of materials, ideas, and processes by which each is characterized. In what would certainly be called a...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Fine art Portfolio

...Thomas, one of the American naissance fathers and the third leader of the United States. The architect Russell J. P designed the neoclassical building and lay down by the Philadelphia service provider McShain John. Construction began in 1938 and was finished in 1943. Thomas bronze effigy added in 1947 to the existing structure. The cenotaph managed by the national park service beneath its nationwide mall and cenotaph parks partition. It became evident that the place showed suit for another high profile monument since it sat in a straight line south of the white house. The monument possibility came in 1934 when leader Roosevelt, a lover of Thomas inquired to the commission of fine arts...
8 Pages(2000 words)Essay

Research Paper ( Fine Art)

...?Research Paper (Fine Art) Topic one The Metropolitan Museum of Art in the of New York is a facility that stocks an assortment of artifacts from diverse cultures. The museum of arts, just as its name suggests preserves artifacts from different cultures ranging from paintings to sculptures among other most common forms of products of arts (Sporre 20). Art provides an effective platform for the portrayal of the society; artists therefore produce artifacts that are of relevance to their cultures and the economic practices in either their societies or those of their audiences. This way, their works earn familiarity with the target audience...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Fine art ba

...MODERN ART AND ARCHITECTURE: A SYNTHETIC AND CRITICAL APPROACH Submitted by: Submitted TABLE OF CONTENTS I. II. INTRODUCTION III. CHAPTER 1: Innovations of Lego Architecture a. Lego Art b. Lego Architecture c. Cargo Ship Architecture IV. CHAPTER 2: The Modern Architect Frank Lloyd Wright a. Architectural Concept b. Stonehenge and the Modular Approach V. CHAPTER 3: Mondrian Architecture VI. SYNTHESIS a. Form b. Style c. Context VII. CONCLUSION VIII. REFERENCES I. ABSTRACT This study is originally inspired by the idea of Lego and of Modular Construction. Fine artists and architects often used units and modules to construct their work. This dissertation investigates the possible relations...
32 Pages(8000 words)Essay

Photography - Photojournalism to Fine Art

...1051306 - PHOTOJOURNALISM TO FINE ART 1940s to the present Culture may be defined as the way of life of a group of people (quote). There are several components of culture, of which the type of food eaten by a group of people plays very significant role. In the photograph below, Retlaw Snellac (2014) exemplifies the important role that food plays in the culture of the people of China, particularly South Yunnan. The picture shows different food staples that are unique and identifiable with the people of China and more importantly the people of South Yunnan. One significant characteristic of food as a component of culture is that food does not only differentiate between cultures of different countries but cultures of intra-countries... -...
3 Pages(750 words)PowerPoint Presentation

My understanding of fine art

...and figures within a photographic image also increase its visual appeal, as a fine art form, so does the framing or presentation of the photo. The second most significant feature of photography, as fine art, is the technique and skill depicted by the image. It is possible to determine the skillfulness and technical proficiency of the photographer, through intent observation and further comparison of the art work with others that adopt a similar medium and technique. Clarke (183) suggests that, skillfulness and technical proficiency showcased in a photographic image can be determined from the artist’s concern with light and form, which...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Fine Art

...Fine art Over the history the mankind has created a considerable number of different works of art that used various mediums. Cinema should be regarded as one of the most modern of them. This paper will analyze the movie The Matrix from the point of view elements and principles of art, proving that it is a work of art. The first element that will be discussed is form which mostly corresponds to the perceived volume. Thus, in spite of the fact that the movie is shown in two dimensions, it reflects the real three dimensional life. Speaking of the value, more specifically light and darkness in the art work, one would make no mistake that the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Fine Art

...Connection between Art and other s/Disciplines Arts, especially fine arts, are a crucial discipline that mosteducationists value because of its intrinsic value. Not only are fine arts relevant to the students, but they are also a primary component of the society’s development in terms of reasoning, creative, analytic, and communication skills. In this respect, art has a connection with a number of discipline/subjects. It implies that the world of education revolves around art. Indeed, every discipline, be it mathematics or science, incorporates some aspects of art in its...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Relationship between fine art and commercial art

... Relationship between popular art and commercial art Most of the Pop artists began their careers in commercial art. Andy Warhol, an American artist, was a main figure in the Pop Art movement, short for Popular Artists. Andy produced more than 100,000 pieces of art in paint, prints, photographs, films and other media. After a thriving profession in 1950s as a commercial illustrator in New York, Warhol became prominent globally for his work as a fine artist, a futuristic filmmaker, a painter, an author, a record producer, and a public figure. He is as well known for his presence in frantically various social circles that entailed Bohemian street individuals, eminent intellectuals, Hollywood celebs and rich aristocrats. One time Andy... was...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay

Fine art

... that would best resemble and represent the clouds. The cliché however is only in paintings but is limited or even absent in installations. I would use combination of cottons and mashed papers to hold the cloud in installation which have not yet been done before making it an original artwork. 3. My projects intends to have a soothing, relaxing, healing in addition to the usual visual effects of artworks. I want my intended audience not only to marvel at the beauty of the installation but also to feel good about it. I want them to revisit or to regress to their pleasant memories during their childhood when they my installation so that when people think of my art works, they will associate it with happiness.... Teacher My work of making...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic John Berger's Comparison of Fine Art to Commercial Art for FREE!

Contact Us