Transition from Stage to Screen: Advantages and Disadvantages of Artifice and Realism - Essay Example

Comments (1) Cite this document
The paper is regarding the adapting Broadway musicals for the cinema, when filmmakers have tended to either champion artifice or champion realism. The author is going to analyze this transition. …
Download full paperFile format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Transition from Stage to Screen: Advantages and Disadvantages of Artifice and Realism
Read TextPreview

Extract of sample "Transition from Stage to Screen: Advantages and Disadvantages of Artifice and Realism"

Download file to see previous pages In Zinnemann’s Oklahoma!, realism is remarkably apparent. From stage to screen, realism in Oklahoma! is attributed to the film’s setting and characterisation. Zinnemann’s chosen setting, for one, is evidently a departure from the Broadway type of background and props wherein objects and images are created by a man/artist. In fact, the director of the movie adaptation entitled Oklahoma! placed the location for his film in the actual world. The scenery is obviously in the field of a particular county perhaps in the West. In the scene wherein the two lovers serenade each other with the song “People Will Say We’re In-Love,” the rustic backdrop is utterly real and beautiful to the eyes especially that the film is in full color. Nevertheless, color technology and other “technological development” are different from the measure of realism in the realm of art (Durovicova, 1992, p.160). Zinnemann and several crew members of the movie had taken a serious advantage to the beauty, grandeur, and existence of the physical environment. On one hand, the positive side of making the film outside the Broadway stage and into the “stage” of the natural environment is that it makes the movie more real and appealing to the audience. The viewers can arguably identify and probably relate to the “message” of the film when it depicts its spatial dimension in a more realistic way. For the film-maker, on the other hand, the advantage of shooting the film in the field is that the director becomes freer in choosing what angle he or she desires -- namely, the film-maker frees him or her from the limitations inherent in props. And the open field offers the film-maker the vast array of areas or spaces wherein he or she can shoot a specific scene or episode in the movie that best suits him or her. Furthermore, Oklahoma! adds a certain level of reality through the portrayal of characters played by its actors. The way actors play their part is likely convincing. When Curly (played by Gordon MacRae) sings a lullaby entitled “The Surrey with the Fringe on Top” to his beloved Ado Anne (played by Gloria Grahame), the viewers are drawn to sleep not only by its mellow-dramatic music but also by how Grahame acted her character role. Grahame, among other actors, had played her role in a natural manner as if she was real and part of the world of the audience. In comparison to the realism characterised in Oklahoma!, the realism in Donen and Kelly’s On the Town is peculiarly distinct. The setting and the characterisation notable in On the Town are less far from real. The setting, in particular, marked in Donen and Kelly’s film is apparently transitory; it changes from artifice to real and vice versa. In the taxi scene wherein Chip (played by Frank Sinatra) and Brunhilde Esterhazy (played by Betty Garrett) sing the song “Come Up to My Place,” the background visible in this episode strikingly alters from artifice to realism. Inside the moving taxi, for instance, the images seen as a backdrop are merely pictures (or moving pictures) taken from the real world; that is, this particular scene was shot far from the actual city environment but rather from or within the studio or stage-like milieu. At the end of the singing act, however, the setting dramatically shifts from the artificial environment into the actual downtown area. Here, the advantage of realism is its ability to entirely transform the ...Download file to see next pagesRead More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
(“Transition from Stage to Screen: Advantages and Disadvantages of Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de
(Transition from Stage to Screen: Advantages and Disadvantages of Essay)
“Transition from Stage to Screen: Advantages and Disadvantages of Essay”, n.d.
  • Cited: 0 times
Comments (1)
Click to create a comment or rate a document
lindsayrice added comment 4 months ago
Student rated this paper as
I never thought 2000 words essay could be written in such a free manner. I loved the content of this essay. Will definitely use it for my own work!

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Transition from Stage to Screen: Advantages and Disadvantages of Artifice and Realism

Advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing

...?Advantages and Disadvantages of Outsourcing Table of Contents Introduction 3 2.Growing Importance of Outsourcing 4 3.Influence of Outsourcing 6 4.Benefits of Outsourcing 9 5.Risk and Disadvantages of Outsourcing 11 6.Conclusion 13 Reference 14 1. Introduction Outsourcing has become a major business in today’s world. Most of the big companies outsource their work which is not their core operation. To understand outsourcing one has to know what does outsourcing means. Outsourcing can be defined as contracting out a work which is not the core function of the business. Various functions of the business can be outsourced. The function which are most popular in outsourcing are IT functions,...
9 Pages(2250 words)Essay

Assistive Technology: Advantages and Disadvantages

...? Assistive Technologies- Advantages and Disadvantage Research Study Assistive Technologies- Advantages andDisadvantage Research Study 1. Introduction Technology has intervened in every walk of life and has introduced revolutionary changes in the lifestyles of humans. The field of education is no different; innovative technologies have made their way into the classrooms and other modes of education that are being followed by the academicians in the prevailing times. Assistive technologies are also counted amongst these inventions of the modern era since they facilitate the acquisition of education by students who have disabilities. This field is an emerging one and is attaining the...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Recommendation: its advantages and disadvantages

...for provision for depreciation would help to reduce the likely uncertainties of the company. Though the company still subtracts the accumulated provisions, it will benefit by reducing any possible losses (Bebbington, Gray & Laughlin, 2001, P. 187). Advantages and Disadvantages of the Recommendations Every accounting principle applied in any business unit has its own advantages and disadvantages, and depreciation is no exception. However, most companies have realized that the advantages indeed outdo the disadvantages. Advantages Increased accuracy in accounting for business assets; though depreciation is mostly termed as...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Risky Internet for Children

...; hence, children encounter such sites effortlessly. Regardless of all of the horrible disadvantages of the Net, there seems to be numerous advantages as well. Actually, the advantages even prevail over the disadvantages. The most frequent thing the Internet is employed for is research. Kids as well as students are amongst the top individuals who make use of the Internet for research. Nowadays, it is almost necessary that students apply the Internet for their research. Entertainment happens to be another popular motive why many kids surf in to the Internet. Now we are able to communicate in a few seconds with a person who happens to be sitting or even working in the other section of the world. There are numerous messenger services...
1 Pages(250 words)Essay


...Advantages and Disadvantages of Homosexuals Homosexuality is a lifestyle that entails sexual or romantic attraction among persons of the same gender. Over decades, homosexuality has raised debate concerning its appropriateness and effects to the society. In such debates, proponents and opponents of each side illustrate the pros and cons respectively while demonstrating their positions, this paper seeks to highlight the advantages and disadvantages of homosexuality. Pros Statistics have shown that same-sex couples who are legally married have lower divorce rates compared to opposite-sex pairs. This can be attributed to the low number of same-sex marriages officiated...
3 Pages(750 words)Essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of Globalization developing countries, which led the introduction of multinational companies (Asmussen, 2011). Advantages of globalization David, et al, (2005) identified that globalization developed international trade and companies. Due to increased interaction among nationalities, countries traded with one another with goods and services they have a comparative advantage (David, et al, 2005). In this perspective, a country sell commodities it have comparative advantage and import commodities it has comparative disadvantage. This led to the growth of home and foreign industries propelled by availability of vital inputs, which are cost effective, and increase in market for the...
6 Pages(1500 words)Literature review

Advantages & Disadvantages of JavaScript

... Advantages & Disadvantages of JavaScript Introduction: JavaScript is a dynamic form of computer language which is used in the purpose of programming. JavaScript has emerged as a leading language that has been used frequently because of its feasibility to target audience. JavaScript had reached a new level of popularity after its adoption from Microsoft as a diverse language for scripting on client side. Due to increment in programming presently, deeper effects of JavaScript has been highlighted regarding its advantages and disadvantages (Quigley, 2004, p. 1). Advantages & Disadvantages of JavaScript: In order to enhance the...
2 Pages(500 words)Essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of EU

...ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF EU European Union is a strong economic integration that brings various nations in Europe together. It is has gained much success but equally faces significant administration huddles. Some of the evident success that has come with EU is common currency. This means most of the member countries can transact across border in this currency. However, there has been divided opinion on the socio-economic gains of this economic integration entity. This can be addressed more easily by drawing the comparative analysis of the advantages and disadvantages. AdvantagesDisadvantages EU has facilitated efficient business...
3 Pages(750 words)Research Paper

Advantages & Disadvantages of Monsters

... humans to suffer. Their disadvantages in people’s lives are reputations preceding them. For example, the article asserts that these monsters cause insanity among other forms of misery. An evaluation of the abovementioned opinions that are considered as representative of several other positions, one might observe that most individuals do not still understand this kind of monster. Actually, several atheists might not perceive the actuality that spiritual monsters, also known as demons, are real. Thus, the perfect evaluation for the disadvantages and advantages of this kind of monsters can merely be advanced through the religious prism. Christianity indicates that there is no good thing that demons are able to bring into the life... down on...
4 Pages(1000 words)Essay

Psychoanalytic therapy advantages and disadvantages

...Global Warming Vs. Global Dimming Global Warming Vs. Global Dimming In most of the instances, people believe that aerosols with a global dimming effect are the solution needed to help in the regulation of global warming attributes. However, many view this with much skepticism because of the increase of cooling effects rather than the reduction in warming effects. This is something that people continually overlook as they continue to advocate for these dimming aerosols across the world. The fact remains that the aerosols provide a global dimming effect where lesser radiation levels reach the earth, but the trend reversed in the 1990s. Essentially, the growth of the global dimming phenomenon only worked between 1950 and 1985, only... Warming...
1 Pages(250 words)Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.

Let us find you another Essay on topic Transition from Stage to Screen: Advantages and Disadvantages of Artifice and Realism for FREE!

Contact Us